Member Reviews
Thank you very much for allowing me to read this title; I am trying to read as widely as possible ahead of the Carnegie/Greenaway nominations and awards for 2018 and your help is much appreciated.
As a Carnegie/Greenaway judge, I'm not allowed to comment about my opinions on specific titles so I can't offer an individual review on any title as I stated on my profile.
This book is about a young girl name Quinn, who finds out she is mysterious pregnant one day. Quinn cannot figure out how she got pregnant. Mean while, Quinn father is a politician running for Office again. Quinn goes to the doctor and finds out she is pregnant but She thinks it is a joke. In fact she thinks it such a joke, that she tells a lady at her father's Political campaign party, which leads to news reporters finding out. At the same time her parents find out which causes Quinn to go on a big search of how this impossible pregnancy came to be. Now if you wish to know how Quinn actually ends up pregnant, go buy the book right now and read it. There is a lot of heaviness to this book but a lot of beautiful surprises too.
Now I would like to add I was mad with Quinn parents at the beginning of this book. I felt like as a parent, they should not have doubt their daughter and her story. Someone who was lying would not continue with the same story over and over again. As for how Quinn ends up pregnant, that was so - so for me. I went into this book, thinking it was about Teenage pregnancy and YA romance but it ends up being a magical story about a pregnancy. I was lost by the writing a few times, and to be honest, if I had purchase this book, it would have taken me a while to finish it. I am going to try and reread again to understand it better, but right now it was not what I thought it was. I felt like it was a very heart heavy story line at the beginning with the pregnancy and then proceed to try to become more light by adding magical elements. I know some people will love this kind of story because it different then what is on the market right now in the way it was written. So to be honest, I think you would have to buy the book or even borrow it from the library to read, to see how you really like it.
I rate this book a 3.5 stars because I love and hated the pregnancy story line development in this book. The author did a great job in describing things of the book that where major points to the storyline. I feel like you need to be in the right mood to read this book though. Now with all of that being said, please do check out this book and see if you want to read it. I am going to re-read this book again just because of the premise of the story and how it is so different.
I have mixed feelings about this one. On one side, the plot, some characters and writing are amazing. But on the other hand, the main character is unlikeable for me and some characters are too stereotypical. If you like magical realism, along with “is it or is it not” type of book, I think this one should be on your TBR.
Craft level: expert.
The author was such a command over words and stylistic elements that reading this book is like falling into the "reading trance" I love to achieve but hardly ever do. Her words create the illusion of reality because they're not cliche, or distracting, worn or boring. I cared deeply about Quinn and her situation, and loved how the author is never preachy, but just shows what this situation (of being a pregnant virgin) would be like for a teen. Although I had the preconceived image of the TV show Jane the Virgin, but where JTV is awesome and funny, Quinn's story is poignant and sweet in a way that really touched me. I loved getting a peek into the other characters, and seeing how they experienced this situation, and how they saw Quinn. the end was sweet and full of hope, and I felt a bittersweet pang in that last scene. The magical realism aspect was absolutely spellbinding. I stayed up until the early morning because I just had to know what happened with Quinn and her baby. Fantastic.
I took a bit of time because I forgot the password to Net Galley. So... I read this book and... well, it's unique and interesting, but I felt that there was many gaps and the story's development was a bit lacking for me. Maybe it was not for me, so I can't recommend for anyone, BUT I believe that some people will like its uniqueness.
I was a little disappointed at how much I struggled with this book. The Inconceivable Life of Quinn tells the story of a 16-year-old high school student who finds herself pregnant. Quinn at first is adamant that she can’t be as she hasn’t had sex, but then has to face up to the reality that she is, along with the press presenting her as someone who thinks she’s the second Virgin Mary. The combination of political drama with the religious aspect grabbed my attention, and I was keen to see how well the author dealt with the religious aspect, I’m not particularly religious myself but I didn’t want to see the whole of Christianity painted as crazy fanatics, although I am well aware that like any religion you will find extremists.
So why did I struggle with it, there were a couple of reasons. One small fact that bugged me was her parents were referred to consistently by their given names and it took me a while to work out they actually were her parents, that and the fact her father really just didn’t come across as very likeable, I understand he was under the pressure of running for congress, and a story about his teenage daughter being pregnant would certainly complicate the campaign, without the additional reporting of Quinn’s virginity, but I just didn’t like the way he treated his daughter, there was a secondary plot relating to his mother and her suicide, and it was clear he was keeping things from Quinn, at one point I actually suspected that he’d been abusing her and that he was the father. I wasn’t particularly keen on Quinn’s mother either but I felt as though she redeemed herself a little more towards the end of the book.
My primary reason is the supernatural element that hit right towards the end of the story. This is partly my fault for not reading right to the end of the blurb, the idea of political scandal grabbed my attention and I was sold, so for me it really came out of the left field, up until this point in the story it’s played fairly straight and explores various possibilities including that fact she’s lying, or that she has suppressed memories of an attack due to trauma, it looks at the impacts that the press reporting has on all the family, from her father’s campaign to her younger sister’s guilt. The consequences for Quinn with the lack of support from friends at school and the stress that having religious fanatics camped outside the house has on everyone. This part of the book I really enjoyed and I was looking forward to finally getting an explanation when the local myth surrounding the island she grew up on and it’s connections to her grandmother were suddenly thrown into the mix – and the worst part we don’t actually ever get a firm conclusion it’s just left a bit in the air and you’re left to assume that this myth is true and was the reason she became pregnant. Now for some that might be enough, but I’m the sort of person, who if I’ve invested time in something, likes to find out an answer once and for all. I know life isn’t always so neat which is probably why I like the stories I read to be.
In terms of positives I quite enjoyed reading the different viewpoints – the story is told primarily from Quinn’s viewpoint but there are chapters throughout the book that pick up different viewpoints – These chapters are easily identified as they give the character’s name as a chapter heading. I thought this worked really well to bring in other viewpoints to the story, even, or perhaps especially, when the character involved really had quite a small role overall.
Would I recommend it?
I’m sure others may love this, the reviews on Goodreads are a bit of a mixed bunch but there are certainly a number of positive reviews on there. This book just wasn’t for me, I don’t mind a good fantasy book if I know that’s what I’m going into but this was so straight leading into the final act of the book it just completely threw me.
A sense of magic in an otherwise normal world was... strange. Especially since it arrived at a fairly late part of the book. Although I enjoy fantasy books filled with magic, this book didn't seem to need it. I think The Inconceivable Life of Quinn is much more about our society than anything else. The magic seemed to remove the credibility and the substance of what the book was really about.
There were religious undertones shown in both a good and bad light. Baer hasn't shown any bias towards or against the Christian faith here, she's just wrote about different types of people within the faith. She also talked about the media a lot, and that there's a lot of rumours and word twisting which can, to an extent, demonize people. I really liked that the book had a strong point to the story being told.
The book was slow, and the one question of 'Who's the father?' was the one thing that kept my interest. But, this answer was never given, which I'm assuming is one of the points of the book. The abrupt ending was also extremely odd as you dont quite know what to think. I'm also assuming that this is to again, link it towards the points the story is trying to make. You dont always know what to think when reading something.
Also, I personally disliked the different POV chapters. Although it was useful to find out more about the outside world, it didn't particularly help the story. The one I particular disliked, was Sam, the male religious fanatic. He had no actual bearing on the story, and removing his POV wouldn't have affected anything.
I would say The Inconceivable Life of Quinn is definitely worth reading, but it does take some time to really get into the story.
I wasn't expecting a supernatural book when I sat down to read this. If I had known that, I might have skipped it...
A cutesy story about a girl stuck in an impossible situation. I would have liked to have learned more about her grandmother and her grandmother's experience. I guess just in general I found the secondary characters to not be as fleshed out as they could be.
For Those Who Enjoyed: Juno, Jane the Virgin, Asking For It, The Unbecoming of Mara Dyer, Lost Girls, To the Lighthouse, Chopin’s The Awakening
I was given an ARC copy of this book by the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
Don’t ask me why, but I’ve always been fascinated by pregnancy plots. Anyone who’s familiar with my fiction writing knows I sneak it into my narratives at least once. So I was instantly interested in checking this book out. Given how taboo teen pregnancy is, I’ve seen very few books on the topic in the young adult market, so I was shocked when a chick lit type fluffy novel showed up. Why would a lighthearted book about teen pregnancy be out there in the world? I had a lot of questions about it and I needed the answer.
The plot itself isn’t a particularly original one, given Jane the Virgin’s been doing the same schtick for three years now. But the magical realism element gave it its unique heft. Unlike Jane the Virgin’s hook of an artificial insemination gone wrong, Inconceivable doesn’t tie itself to a logical explanation for Quinn’s virgin pregnancy. Most of the novel is spent trying to make sense of it and the mystery is what keeps the narrative afloat. I could have easily set this one aside one chapter in, but something about the intrigue of it all kept me going. There are so many I need to know where this is going paths that just about excuses the almost mediocre writing style.
Baer addresses possibilities for how Quinn may have been impregnated without knowing in ways I haven’t seen YA authors address female sexuality before. Going into this novel, I didn’t think she would be touching up on drugs, rape, incest, and PTSD that might come with it as much as she did. And because this is supposed to be such a light fluffy novel, I found the tonal shifts very jarring. The assumption is that something horrible has happened to her to give her regressive memory, so much so that her parents are more willing to lie and convince her she’s been victimised than they are to believe something extraordinary has happened. There’s a really serious, intense, important message building there that Baer doesn’t quite drive home. As if she’s not fully committed to the severity of the situation.
Her use of multiple narratives throughout gives Quinn’s character development some interesting depth. Quinn takes on the majority of the narration, but the novel is peppered with outsider narratives that really challenge her reliability as a narrator. There is nothing I love more than an unreliable narrator, so I would have liked Baer to really go there and make the reader seriously question whether she really is suffering PTSD or if she did have a divine experience. It would have been a far darker story, but I think it would’ve been stronger and more meaningful for it, especially as a novel written to counteract slut shaming, rape culture, gossip media and religious extremism.
I really hope Abrams and Amulet market this with all those messages in mind, because this book is definitely trying to say more than it appears on the surface. It’s opening that dialogue, in however a fluffy way, and I think that’s important.
It took me quite a while to read this book andI can understand why! I'm still a bit perplexed as to the whole concept of the book.
It was very strange and wasn't what I expected at all.The Inconceivable life of Quinn includes a lot of magic realism and as much as I don't mind a bit of magic realism this one was very complicated!
I didn't really connect with many of the characters probably because the book was quite slow paced.
I adored this book so much. I wasn't sure at first how it would go, but I was happily surprised by how much of a discussion it was about believe and religion. It was really interesting to see Quinn and her friend consulting a priest and hearing about the different interpretations of the bible. It was also interesting seeing a character who was not at all Christian being the subject of the book.
It showed every side of the issue. The people who called Quinn names and accused her of lying; the people assuming that she has some psychological issue and endeavor to help her find out what happened; the family, desperate to find out who the father is so they can find a solution to the issue; and of course the true believers who caused so much trouble.
I also loved how much it was left open to the reader to believe what they wanted. It became such a beautiful book of magic realism and the ending was a nice satisfying ending while still leaving it up to the reader to decide what to believe.
Quinn was such a great character and I'm so happy I got the opportunity to read this book.
I thought the synopsis was incredibly interesting and I really, really wanted to know what happened and I really needed to know how Quinn became pregnant. I got a bit of a Unbecoming of Mara Dyer vibe from this book so if you loved Mara Dyer, you might love The Inconceivable Life of Quinn as well.
The Inconceivable Life of Quinn is an odd little book, but I mean that in the best way. It's just a little hard to describe. Filled with magical realism and gorgeous imagery. The ending is a complete surprise I can almost guarantee you won't see coming. The story is essentially about a sixteen year old virgin who finds herself pregnant. Quinn wants to solve the mystery of how she got pregnant while the press gets wind of her pregnancy amidst her father's run for congress. I was pleasantly surprised by the use of mythology woven into the story. The characters were quite fun to read about. If you enjoyed The Unbecoming of Mara Dyer or like books with magical realism, make sure to check out The Inconceivable Life of Quinn on April 4th!
It was pretty clear from early on that something supernatural was going on in this book. THere isn't a lot of basis for the supernatural, no hints of magic or exploration of mythology. Part of the problem is that Quinn inventing this story to cover a trauma doesn't really work either. She doesn't come across as traumatized or delusional. I think there are two things that would have made this book work better for me. 1) More uncertainty. If I had ever really questioned Quinn's version of events, considered her unreliable. A little more back and forth. 2)If there had been more basis for the mythology, a clearer sense of the creatures involved.
Thanks for giving me the opportunity to read this. An intriguing idea. Sometimes the most obvious solutions provide the answers to our questions, but not in this case. When sixteen year old virgin Quinn discovers she is pregnant there's all sorts of rumours circulating. She sticks to her story, and we eventually come to be told about a mysterious connection she has to The Deeps, spirits of the ocean. Mystical, more than a little unusual and strangely entertaining.
I'm not sure how to start this. I'm going to just keep this short. I knew it was magical realism from the get so I did not mind that. I happen to like the genre. Something about this just wasn't for me.
Quinn was a bit annoying if i'm honest with myself. Her friends were gossiping always and showed very little support for her. I know teens are crappy to each other a lot but it seemed a bit much.
I didn't feel like we got much of a resolution in the end of this.
We never truly know about the supernatural aspect of it. It is also introduced late into the game as well so I never had time to get into that aspect of it.
I think that some people will for sure like this books. It was written well and the POV jumping made it interesting. This book just wasn't for me! I hope you all get out and give it try. Hopefully you like it better than me.
THE INCONCEIVABLE LIFE OF QUINN was a fascinating, readable story. Quinn finds herself unexpectedly pregnant at age sixteen. She has never had sex with her boyfriend Jesse. In fact, she doesn't remember ever having sex at all. As she tries to solve the mystery of how she became pregnant, things around her change. Her father is running for Congress in a district where he should be a shoe-in until Quinn's pregnancy raises questions about the family. She finds herself distanced from her friends because she can't tell them that she has no idea how she became pregnant.
Quinn's insistence to her doctor that she's never had sex and is a virgin is spread to the internet by someone in the lab at her doctor's which leads religious fanatics of all kinds to gather outside her home and trash her reputation on social media. In order to protect her, her parents take away all her access to her friends and social media which just leaves her feeling even more isolated.
Quinn dwells on the two weeks in May that she spent in Maine at a home once owned by the grandmother her father hates for abandoning him and who committed suicide by walking into the sea. Quinn remembers some strange things from her childhood from the time she nearly drowned to times when the sea seemed to welcome her. She remembers bits and pieces of an old children's story about the Deeps who live in the ocean.
A big theme in this one is the role that social media plays in our lives. The social media storm about Quinn's pregnancy causes her father to end his campaign for Congress. Rumors of sexual abuse spread rapidly but without any evidence. The role of social media in spreading rumors about Quinn makes her an internet sensation and destroys any sense of privacy. It doesn't help that Quinn is herself struggling to put together what really happened in May.
This was an engaging and thought-provoking story told from a variety of viewpoints - Quinn's, her boyfriend Jesse's, a woman who believes that Quinn might be carrying the new messiah, and others.
I really enjoyed this book and thought that the preimise was very interesting and unique. I have never read a book that dealt with an issue where someone is pregnant but they could not possibly be since they never had sex.
The first half of the book we see Quinn trying to figure out how she got pregnant and seeing how her pregnancy affects her family, especially her dad’s campaign. I did like Quinn but there were times where she was very annoying but to be fair if I was in her situation I would probably act the way she did. She knows she has not had sex, she does have a long term boyfriend but they never had gone that far. Her parents were very frustrating and did not help her situation at all. I knew that there was going to be a religious aspect to the book since the synopsis hinted to Quinn’s baby perhaps being the next messiah. That part was interesting and it was written really well. Media played a big part in this book; Baer did a great job showing how the media twists everything and do not care if they have correct sources, or any sources at all, and who they harm in the process.
I do recommend this book to others and think that it is a good book that deals with hard issues