Member Reviews

No, not one for me this one.

Man suffering from Alzheimer's takes his own life as he's concerned if he can only remember the events from 50 years ago he'll break his family's deepest darkest secrets.
And told in reverse we find out what those shocking secrets are.

Was this review helpful?

A story starting from the present day taking you back to 1962. A loving couple with immediate family surrounding them but there is a huge rift keeping them away from England and Emily's parents and sister with whom she had a wonderful childhood with. A secret kept for years that only a few know.

This is a beautifully written and mesmerising story as the secret is slowly revealed and wow what a story and ending!

Was this review helpful?

This is a love story told backwards, in the most beautiful manner, so that we know from the very beginning that Emily and Robert love each other enormously, and that he is about to break her heart in the most dreadful way in order to protect a secret that they've lived with for decades. Seeing their love unfold in reverse is beautiful. We get to know them once they have already gotten to know each other, and it makes for an unusual and interesting structure. The secret they hold is referred to throughout, but it isn't revealed until very late in the book. I'm guessing very few readers will figure it out. Even once you know, you want to go back and read the whole story again in the light of the information you now hold.

I always think Julie's characters are beautifully drawn, and this story is no exception. Emily and Robert will leap into your head, and heart, fully formed, breathing and speaking and living as you read more and more about them. Their story is compelling, experiencing these snapshots from throughout their lives, moments of choice and decision and, throughout, secrets and lies. They aren't perfect, not by any means, but of course that only makes them more empathetic. Their love story, also, is far from perfect. By times you want to ring a counsellor on their behalf because it surely cannot be healthy to withhold secrets for so very long! And yet, you understand...the more you get to know them, the more believable their flawed love story is.

The book moves around from, mainly, the East Coast of America to England. It's peopled with intriguing characters, family and friends, who creep into view and then disappear from sight as we slip back further in time. I sometimes wanted more, just a little more time, with a side character or a postscript to finish off their story and tell me how things worked out for them! That's the problem with the book going backwards...you already know there are no more future stories to come. Still, I loved that it never felt like a gimmick, and it flowed perfectly. I think my favourite part was reading towards the end when Emily and Robert first meet, that initial blossoming of romance between them, which you read already knowing their whole lives together afterwards which lends an entirely new outlook on the first moments of their love affair.

When it comes, the final reveal, it is a take-your-breath-away moment. I almost don't want to write that, because I don't want to set expectations too high, but there isn't really any other way of describing it. I need to add it to my reading group's list of books to read because it's definitely one of those books that you feel you immediately need to talk about, but you can only really talk about it with someone else who has finished the story already, so they've had that experience and you can dissect it together! It transforms everything, and everyone in the story, and I read the ending in a daze really, questioning everything that I had just read, and reeling from the weight of what they'd carried their whole lives. It leaves you thinking (and probably crying, if you get like that over books!) for a long, long time.

I think is is a darker and deeper novel than any of Julie's other books. There are moments of humour, but it isn't a humorous book. It's a love story, and yet it’s quite unlike other love stories. It will wring you out emotionally, and you will think long and hard afterwards about dear Emily and Robert, and the secret they held onto for so long, and why.

Was this review helpful?

Emily and Robbie are a couple who have been happily married for over 40 years, they have two sons, William and Adam, and grandchildren.
She is a retired obstetrician, and he was a boat builder.
Their only problem appears to be that they are ageing, and is that Robbie is starting to show signs of dementia.
At this point, I was thinking, “Oh no, not another book about someone’s slow decline”.
But it most certainly is not.
They have a secret, and it is a secret that has affected their whole of their life together.
Their story is told in reverse order, in a series of events, and the complexity of their life becomes clearer, until the secret is finally revealed, at the end of the book……………………… at which point, I immediately started to re-read the first chapters in a new light.
I did feel a little uncomfortable with the revelation of the secret, but not enough to stop me heartily recommending the book!
To say any more would spoil the plot.
Go read it!

Thanks to Netgalley and Orion Publishing Group for the opportunity to read this book.

Was this review helpful?

This is the story of Emily and Robert and a deep love that spans decades from the present day back to 1962. What is the secret they have kept for years? Why did the family disown them?

This is a well written, poignant, intriguing novel, and like all Julie Cohen's books the characterization is extraordinary.

I enjoyed this story and recommend you read it for yourself.

Was this review helpful?

Truly epic, Together begins with you asking how tragedy could hit such a nice, normal family. It unravels so beautifully to an agonising ending which will make you question the meaning of love.

Was this review helpful?

A very different story, unexpected twist. Love the characterisation and the family dynamics. I would really recommend this book to our customers.

Was this review helpful?

A beautiful heart-breaking story that pulls you in and swallows you whole. Robbie and Emily are complex and well-rounded characters with flaws that make them endearing, realistic and relatable.
I've never read such an intense love story and the ending left me completely stunned.
It'll take me a long time to get over this one.

Was this review helpful?