Member Reviews
This book was one of the highlights of my recent reads on Russian history. Despite being quite knowledgable about this topic I still felt that I got quite a bit from this book and would recommend it.
An interesting perspective on the Russian revolution, a historical encounter that still has a lot to offer in terms of new approaches.
Exactly what it says it is – a short history of the Russian Revolution. In my opinion Swain has done a good job in summarising some very complex events in relatively few pages, and although it’s a fairly dry account, if an introduction is what you need then this is a comprehensive and accessible book that will fit the bill.
I wanted to start off by saying that I received an ebook copy of this book via netgalley in exchange for my honest review.
A Short History of the Russian Revolution discusses the Russian Revolution that ended the Tsarist monarchy and ushers in the communist regime in Russia during 1917. Now I will 30897399say that someone can easily write a 1000 page book on this topic so when I requested this I knew that some things would be missing. When I did finally get to reading it I laughed a bit when the author himself said, "much has to be left out" because this is such a complex period of history.
I will say that Geoffrey Swain did a good job summing up such a complex event(s). For someone who does not know a lot about the Russian Revolution they will benefit a lot from reading this. Swain knows his topic well, he discusses a wide range of related events and organizations which I find important. A historical event did not happen in a vacuum, society prior to the event let to the Russian Revolution and it impacted a lot of events, policies, and individuals following it as well. I will say that this book is very academic, since this is a short history it is jammed packed with facts. So if you are looking for a non-fiction account that reads like a novel this is not for you. This is more of something you would read if you are interested in learning about the event or need a good resources for research. I wish I had read something like this years ago when I took a class dealing with this topic. On another note I really enjoyed was the short timeline in the beginning of the book. It really showed a quick summary before getting into details.
Overall, I think that this is a good book. I ended up giving it a 3.5/5 stars. This is a great book for those who are studying the Russian Revolution, have a serious interest, an introduction to the topic, and a good resource for research, but it is not something I feel many individuals will pick up a read "for the fun of it". But, to restate what I have said, this really is a well written "short" history of the Russian Revolution.
Book Information
Publisher: I. B. Tauris & Company
Publication Date: March 30th 2017
List Price: Varies - $10.60 on Kindle $29.00 on Nook
ISBN: 9781780767925
Pages: 256 pages
This was a random read for me- having no particular interest in the topic! It's very readable and I found it very informative! In fact this book has made want to read more about it! A really interesting and informative read!
I didn’t enjoy this book, but I am convinced that the problem lies with me. For starters, Geoffrey Swain, a University of Glasgow Professor Emeritus, has likely forgotten more about Russian History than I will ever know. Second, the Russian Revolution is not one of my historical interests, it is merely something I wished to know a bit more about. Finally, while the book is titled “A Short History of the Russian Revolution”, “Short” evidently has a vastly different meaning to a distinguished professor than to a casual reader.
=== The Good Stuff ===
* Swain knows what he is talking about. He has a remarkable fluency and grasp of the causes, background and tactics of the Russian Revolution, and the work is impeccably footnoted and referenced.
* The book tackles a broad range of material. The book examines the growth of labor unions, the increased power of the “reformers”, and finally the specific political and paramilitary tactics of the revolution.
* The author is not afraid to mix in his own opinions. His major theme of the book is that the Russian Revolution was not a natural progression from turn-of-the-century events in Russia. Rather it was more of a clean break, and much more of a revolution in political thinking than evolution. He makes a convincing case, and I would never consider myself able to challenge Swain’s mastery of the subject.
* Swain is able to use his knowledge to highlight issues that I never would have considered. For example, there were two types of labor unions in pre-Revolutionary Russia, those organized geographically and those organized by industry. I would have never picked up on it, but the author points out that the geographically organized labor unions had some very different implications in terms of political power and organizing…something that would have not gone unnoticed in Russia.
=== The Not-So-Good Stuff ===
* The entire book is somewhat like drinking from a firehose. The text bristles with facts, and is fatiguing to read. My knowledge of Russian history is not sufficient to sort out the significant facts from the more mundane. And while I could feel the author making subtle points and comparisons, I worry that most of the slipped right by me.
* Swain’s writing style is what I would call “academic”. Long paragraphs abound, and complicated and wordy sentences are the rule. In short, it is written in the type of English that few of us (especially on this side of the pond) rarely read. I found the book to be a slow read, and it took me several days to work my way through the book- a rarity for me.
=== Summary ===
I really can not fault the book. It is very well written, impeccably referenced, and the authors command of the subject is masterful. But I didn’t enjoy it. From the title, I was expecting an “easy-read”, with fast-flowing text and opinions and observations laid out for me so I didn’t have to work too hard.
The book would probably be a hit with more serious amateur historians, or those with an “academic” expectation. Casual readers such as myself will probably not make it through the book.
As a history graduate I have read a variety of books. My biggest passion is Russian history and I had been looking for a nice concise guide to the Revolution, especially with the 100th anniversary of it coming up.
This was well written, accessible (which can be incredibly hard for History books) and interesting.
I would definitely recommend this to someone who has an interest in the topic but does not want a bulky, heavy read.