If you're at all familiar with The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy by Douglas Adams, you'll understand me when I say that the world desperately needs another book like it.Sometimes it's really good to read a book that doesn't take itself too seriously or that even successfully pulls off a joke, pun, or sarcastic comment. For that alone, I enjoyed Sherlock Mars.

If you like Sherlock Holmes and his stories and want to read something like that only funnier this is the book for you. I enjoyed reading it

The sci-fi twist on restaurants in this mystery was a welcome surprise. Well written whodunit.

This is basically a cosy mystery set in space. It has the classic ingredients – a victim that no one seems to care all that much about; a quirky, successful restaurant owner who inexplicably has sufficient time to shoot off here, there and everywhere to run down a number of clues; a friendly law enforcement officer who is happy to let Molly have crucial details of the ongoing case; lots of foodie details along the way.

I like Molly – the fact that she is happily married with adult children and is rushing around organising a wedding for one of them is a major plus point as far as I’m concerned. It’s nice to see women of a certain age confident in her ability and established in a stable relationship and career featuring as the main protagonist for a change. However, while she is crazily busy, I did feel her characterisation was a little thin – mostly because the continual stream of puns and gags around the future version of the past crowded out the opportunities for us to bond with her.

The worldbuilding is detailed and builds up a clear picture of exactly what life is like on Mars for Molly and her family. We get plenty of descriptions of the places they visit and in particular, the build-up to the wedding and the celebration, but again, the focus on the one-liners and wordplay inevitably skews some of the detail, as destinations and placenames are clearly only added for the sake of the gag. The situation regarding androids as political tensions rise around their status is nicely handled and I did enjoy Molly’s relationship with her friend Jersey, whose husband, Trenton, is an android. The only problem I did have, is that given the abilities Trenton displayed in manufacturing a range of goods for Jersey, it did occur to me that the fears of unmodified humans were very well founded – and that aspect simply wasn’t investigated. Perhaps it is being left for another book in the series, as although at no time is this book flagged as the second in a series, there is clearly a previous book somewhere about another case earlier in Molly’s life.

The solution to the case worked well, in that the murderer is someone who has a strong reason for killing the victim and is well placed to keep threatening Molly as she endeavours to track down the perpetrator. The various story arcs are nicely tied up and overall, it comes to a satisfactory conclusion – but I cannot help thinking that if there were a few less puns and wordplay jokes, the overall characterisation and scene setting could have been a lot stronger.
7/10

Cozy mystery in space

I enjoyed this book, more for the humor, character development, and world-building than for the mystery. The writing reminds me of the cartoon series “The Jetsons”, with corny puns and general silliness. Initially, I didn't like the first person, present tense writing, but I got used to it after a while. I also got to know the characters a little and when the book ended I realize that I would miss them. Overall, the book is a nice light read that blended two genres that I like.

A little bit of a slow start but built into a nicely funny cosy crime with a sci-fi theme. There were some terrible puns but they actually added to the fun and had me giggling - especially Mr Burton Ernie! I also enjoyed the way the author messed around with history, some brilliant jokes.
On the whole an entertaining read - I'd definitely recommend to anyone who enjoys their science with a side dish of laughter.

While the synopsis of the book sounded good, I had a great deal of trouble getting into the book and had a hard time finishing it.

My reference point of comparison for books about funny female detectives is always Janet Evanovich. Usually this means that I end up praising the plot and the general style but pointing out insufficiencies in the humour department. Sherlock Mars is kind of the reverse.
Jackie Kingon has crammed her story full of puns, jokes, and witty dialogue - so 10 points for that. However, the plot is very episodic, full of incident and character but not moving the plot along much. In the end, the perpetrator really just confesses without much actual detective work having been done. That said, I found it all very readable and amusing. If Ms Kingon can just strengthen her plots, I'm sure any sequel will be well worth reading.