Member Reviews

Wow. A simple act has terrible repercussions for a woman who has found herself in a situation many can relate to.
A dark alley,being followed by a man after sexual hareassment in a club,failing signal and crippling fear lead to misidentification and and accident.
Post accident,the story splits in 2,Reveal and Conceal so in effect there are 2 books in one.
Reveal is where she calls for emergency help and finds herself arrested,Conceal where she fless the accident yet cannot flee her guilt.
Both are equally plausible storylines and equally humane.
The switching between narratives could have been annoying or poorly realised in less skillful hands but added to the friction and the pace of the novel.
I thoroughly enjoyed and would recommend this to anyone, the characters are so relatable and the situation so well drawn.
Many thanks to the publishers and Netgalley for letting me read this in return for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This story deals with something that has probably crossed all of our minds at some point with either speculatively or in a real moment of potential danger. Our protagonist Joanna has a different ending to the one you might suspect after walking down a canal path alone, and it is this turn of events that leads us deeper into the story and the words “anything you do say …”

Was this review helpful?

WOW, wow, wow! I loved this book! I have tried to write a review but I just can't do this book justice. It has a superb plot, starring me as the main character (if not me, then my twin)! Seriously I felt I was being quoted at some points in the book. The 'sliding doors' concept had me from the first Reveal/Conceal chapters. I felt it could have been anyone of us...just a simple mistake. how we deal with outcome of our decisions and how those decisions affect others. It would make an excellent choice for a Book Club, due to the moral dilemma and has great debate/conversation potential. Enjoy! I am now off to find a romance, light heated chick lit, as I have no finger nails left and my hair has turned grey. But it was worth it!

Was this review helpful?

This book started off great guns: I started the book one night before bed "just to see how it is..." and found myself flipping the pages furiously and unwilling to put it down. It was less than halfway through that I then noticed my interest waning and by three quarters I could happily have abandoned it and moved on... but I still liked the idea of the plot and really wanted to see how it would all resolve itself.

Set in a sliding-doors fashion, the first chapter follows Joanna on her night out with friend Laura, from her selfie with a stranger through to unwanted attention from a man that leads to them leaving the club early. Walking back along the canal side, and still upset from her earlier ordeal, Joanna hears quickening footsteps behind her and a split second decision makes her do something that will have long-term consequences for so many. The following chapters are then alternate between reveal (she confesses) and conceal (she runs away).

Such a great idea for a book and one I was looking forward to enormously to see how the consequences of our actions can affect us so utterly. It should have been great. But I got bored: bored of Joanna, whom I found it was difficult to empathise with, bored of the plot which didn't seem to go anywhere for a huge chunk of the book and bored of waiting to find out how it would all pull together. If in fact, if it had pulled nicely together at the end (by way of a twist or something jaw-dropping) it would quite possibly have redeemed itself but I found the ending to not only be convenient in an attempt to wrap it all up but a bit of a damp squib.

I feel my main issue is that I couldn't connect with Joanna or any other members of the cast, at all. It wasn't simply that I didn't like her; I couldn't "get" her in either the reveal or conceal stories. That made it difficult to invest in the book overall as I was not engaged.

Verdict:

Not a bad book, just not a great one. I haven't read Everything But The Truth (McAllister's first book) yet but I do have a copy and I have heard great things so I wouldn't be put off reading this at all. 

Great concept, not so great execution.

Was this review helpful?

I fijndbtgia book rather confusing and slow. Loved the concept but unfortunately it was not for me

Was this review helpful?

Anything you do say Actually London doesn’t get smog any more - only heavy pollution on a still summer day unless it comes across the channel - or sometimes we Saharan sand... The last know smog was in 2016 in December and was caused by pollution, to get black feet - and I well remember getting them myself, in my hippy phase, when I walked London streets barefoot (!), you need coal or wood fires, which have been banned for a very long time. However, that very picky point aside, I liked this book. I liked the alternative universes where different things happened according to her behaviour at the crucial moment. How long did she hesitate? Did she try to help or not? And what did say when asked? So truly two books in one which can be tricky to both write and read as you need to keep two plots in your head at the same time. So kudos to the author for trying this style of writing.

Was this review helpful?

Around this time of year I start to consider my Top Ten Books Published in 2017 along with many other bloggers, this year the list has been thrown into disarray with so many late entrants, including this novel. Anything You Do Say encompasses so many of the aspects that I enjoy: a moral dilemma, ‘sliding doors’ scenario, great characters who behave realistically and superb plotting all coming together to give a fresh feel despite the elements appearing in other novels.

Two friends meet for their regular Friday night out at a bar in London and meet a man who is slightly too pushy, deciding to leave they part ways and Joanna walks home taking the route by the canal when she hears someone following her. Now ladies, we’ve all been there – unable to tell whether the threat running through your head is real or imagined. What happens next will change Joanna’s life forever.

What do you do, I find myself thinking, when you think somebody is following you down a deserted strip of canal? When you could become a statistic, a news piece, a tragedy? Nothing. That’s the answer. You carry on. You hope.

Of course the title are known to all of us although I hope few of us have had them directed towards us:

The words are familiar, but it takes me a moment to place them. It’s not a hymn or a song lyric or a phrase. No. It’s a caution. The caution.

Joanna is a great character, you probably know someone like her. She works on the mobile library while she decides what she wants to do with her life. She avoids the nastier aspects of life by ignoring them; bills, decisions, babies are all put in a box to be dealt with later… or never. Her friend, Laura, has plans, big ones, she wants to be an artist and is far surer of herself by far than Joanna, not uncommon in a friendship pairing. In both scenarios that are presented following the late night encounter we see not only what the consequences of her decision has on Joanna but Laura and her partner Rueben and brother Wilf too but also Laura’s partner Jonty in a perfect example of the ripple effect.

With sparkling dialogue which is entertaining yet realistic I was drawn into the story before I’d finished the first page. I loved the friends, that pre-Christmas setting with Christmas trees sparkling inside the houses that Joanna passes as she walks home at the opening of the book is followed up with the changing seasons as we follow the two different outcomes of that night.

As much as I enjoy books with the ‘sliding doors’ aspect I won’t lie, it can sometimes be complicated keeping the two strands straight in your mind. Fear not, Gillian McAllister has a clear system for marking the two stories by using a heading and since the stories diverge from the start I didn’t have a moment’s confusion. What I did have, was compassion for Joanna, maybe that says something about my morals, but there was one particular moment when I had my heart in my mouth as things took a drastic turn for the worse and despite actually needing to be doing something else I wasn’t putting the book aside until my heart-rate settled.

I really enjoyed Gillian McAllister’s debut novel Everything But The Truth which I read earlier this year but this novel even surpasses that one. Usually when I read a book that I want my friends to read, I wait until I have posted my review – not this time – I have been urging many of my bookish friends to go get this book, now – especially as it is at an absolutely bargain price at the moment for the kindle. The paperback will be published on 25 January 2018. Whatever format you read, I urge you not to miss out but do beware, once started, you will not want to stop reading!

I am extremely grateful to the publishers Penguin UK who have provided me with a great selection of books this year, including Anything You Do Say, and Gillian McAllister who I sincerely hope is furiously writing another book for me to enjoy, this unbiased yet unashamedly gushing review is my thanks to them.

Was this review helpful?

It's every woman's worst nightmare. Alone on a dark street, footsteps getting quicker behind you. Fight or flight? Joanna picks fight and finds herself staring at a broken figure of a man. So what does she do? Call an ambulance and face the consequences or walk away....after all no one has seen. This is the story of what happens in both cases. Think Sliding Doors if it had been a psychological thriller.

I tried to stop reading this book. It was going to quick. I wanted to know what was going to happen so much that I'd find myself skimming and then going back because it's too good a book to skim! No matter how much I wanted to know the outcome. Even with going back I finished it in a few hours. Now I feel like I've been stuffing Maltesers and reaching in the box can find nothing.....happy with a satisfying experience but kind of sad there's no more. It's a compelling and tense thriller, brilliantly written. An easy 5 stars.

Was this review helpful?

I loved Gillian McAllisters first novel so was really looking forward to reading this. I literally couldn't put this new gripping thriller down, reading it in two sittings. An engrossing story superbly written with believable characters and plenty of action and intrigue. Alternate chapters tell Joanna’s story and the path her life would take depending on her decision. This is a great read, and I was sorry when it finished.
I will be recommending this book everywhere I go.

Thank you!

Was this review helpful?

Firstly thank you to Net Galley & the publishers for an ARC in exchange for a fair review.
This book makes an interesting read. What would you do in a life changing situation? Fight or flight? Help or walk away? This story poses those questions and takes us along both paths.
The narrative is written from the perspective of Joanna whose decisions we follow after an incident where she pushes a man down a flight of stairs in fear.
Overall, this is a well written, thought provoking book about the consequences of our actions and is certainly like nothing I have read before.

Was this review helpful?

This did take me a while to get into it with the reveal/conceal sections but once I did I was gripped. It's totally different to the other psychological thrillers I've read this year so would definitely recommend.

Was this review helpful?

This book was ok I found it a little confusing when it went from reveal to conceal.

Was this review helpful?

Joanna and Laura are enjoying a Friday night out in their usual bar when a man approaches them and is very pushy in his sexual overtures to them, especially Joanna. On her way home, after she's parted company from Laura, Joanna senses this man is following her. She is very scared and calls her boyfriend but the line is bad and she loses the signal after telling Reuben of her fears. Shortly after the man catches up with her and in her terror she shoves him. He falls down some steps and lands in a puddle motionless. Joanna is now in a dilemma - help or run? The rest of the book is dealing with the two possible scenarios in chapters headed 'Reveal' or 'Conceal'.

It's easy to follow the dialogue in each scenario but I did find it a little long winded and it took me ages to finish. It was all a little depressing really as I didn't care much for Joanna in either scenario and both were equally gloomy to read. Joanna is an Oxford graduate but works in a mobile library and has no career ambitions. She is still trying to find her 'thing'. I wasn't at all convinced by Joanna's character and couldn't warm to her. Her parents were quite overbearing and derogatory towards Joanna but this didn't amount to anything in the story which I surprised about.

In the 'Conceal' storyline Joanna got herself into deeper water by telling a lie about her brother. In the 'Reveal' storyline we found this wasn’t a lie after all but the lie/non-lie was never tied together in the two storylines which I found very curious.

It was a good premise but not gripping enough for me. And just relentlessly miserable.

With thanks to NetGalley and Penguin UK - Michael Joseph for a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Wow a thought provoking book .
Joanna is out with her friend. Experiencing sexual harassment and feeling she is being followed she rings her boyfriend for added protection as she tries to get to safety.Losing connection the person gets closer and a scuffle occurs and she is faced with a dilemma. Does she stay and check on her would be attacker? or does she leave him at the bottom of some steps?
Told from both perspectives ,what transpires in both lives not only has your imagination running wild but also has you feeling paranoid for Joanna,has you feeling frustrated at the the people who are surrounding her and has you feeling that Jo needs some serious relationship advice.
The characters are well written and you wonder at times why she is with Reuben.
As always Gillian McAllister takes a character,turns them inside out and rings them dry. You know every inch of them before you are done. Some are marmite(sorry if you don't know that saying you love or hate them) and in this book I have a number I feel that way about.
I have pondered this book since the moment I read the introduction and will do for days after.I am not convinced Joanna took the right path!
Thank you to the author ,the publisher and Netgalley for the opportunity to review.

Was this review helpful?

I loved the previous book by this author so was excited to read this one.
However I just could not get into it and struggled to read it, I ended up giving up after a few chapters.
Very disappointing as I was really looking forward to it.

Was this review helpful?

What a stunning cast of characters, well written and developed. I became completely absorbed in this plot and gripped by the unfolding drama, most of which was unpredictable which only added to the enjoyability of this novel.
The writing style is well executed and entertaining, though not entirely original. But don't let that put you off, This story is well worth the read.
It is a carefully woven plot which, although we find ourselves in two time frames, the characters stay true and are convincing to the last.
I found that a third of the way through the story lost a little of the urgent momentum that was building up but the pace picks up again after what seemed like a bit of a lull for me and a bit repetitive. I also found the ending was a little drawn out. See what you think because I urge you to pick this one up. Pretty sure you won't regret it.

Was this review helpful?

This was a good book with dilemma as it’s theme. Would you stay or would you go after accidentally injuring someone you suspected was about to attack you?!? This book follows the conceal or reveal the truth with Joanna, an avoider, as it’s central character. Following a night out Joanna is faced with a dilemma and we see what happens from both sides.
Excellent reading and raised a few questions about myself, I’m still not sure what I’d do!!
Thanks for allowing me to read this book, it was very enjoyable.

Was this review helpful?

An ingeniously clever book.

Joanne is an avoider, she hides her problems, and is easily overwhelmed. She is like most of us. She's also just an ordinary young woman who finds herself in quite an ordinary situation for women these days: she is being followed while on her way home. The situation escalates, her choice of reaction will seal her fate. Will she hide herself from the truth or face it unflinchingly? What would you do? How long can you keep a secret? It's scary isn't it, that one mistake can potentially alter your life's course?

The structure of this book was completely new to me: I loved it. It was extraordinarily inventive! Usually I'm the one predicting alternate paths for characters. I'm like Joanna except I daydream about characters which, unlike Joanna's daydreaming about the lives of real people in real time, can be pretty useless. I liked Joanna, and her husband as well. I'm quite a neat freak too. The endearing characters, also were one of the book's many high points. I was completely invested in their story.

This book was impressive, and it illustrated the ever-poignant issues of sexual harassment, and prejudice. With the recent explosive Harvey Weinstein case, you really do hear the horrors everywhere. Joanna's story could be anyone's. I really felt for her, I felt I was her at points: my life just as royally screwed up. In other words, this story was very much alive. I've never read anything like it. Anything You Do Say will be an unflattering mirror in your face, daring you to look away by forcing you to clinically examine your moral values. Will you pass the test unscathed?

From the beginning, I was telling Joanna what to do through the page. By the end, I was quite happy with my thinking and the way it panned out. This is the book that readers will truly engage with, and talk about, with anyone willing to listen. You just have to. You can't get enough of its brilliance. I loved the writing which offered the promise of anticipation and unpredictability and I especially enjoyed the witty, swoony dialogue between Reuben and Joanna. All their rituals.

Having also read Gillian McAllister's Everything But The Truth, I can tell you her books are too good to be missed out on.

I received this book through NetGalley.

Was this review helpful?

What a dilemma to be in..........
a simple mistake, is cleverly interpreted in a reveal/conceal concept. What makes the plot compelling is the impact and consequences each decision the main character makes has not only on the victim, but on her Husband, Family and Friends.. With plenty of twists and turns this I'd definitely a recommended read that leaves you with plenty to think about.

Thank you netgalley, penguin and Gillian McAllister for the opportunity to read and review this book.

Was this review helpful?

This book held my attention from the first page. All the characters seemed so real with their foibles and idiosyncrasies. I was enthralled to find out how the two stories would unfold and wasn’t disappointed in the eventual outcome. A great read.

Was this review helpful?