Member Reviews

Much like Room, Only Child is a novel that takes place from the point of view of a young child. A shooter enters Zach's school and the book is about how he deals with his own trauma and how the incident affects those around him. I read this book in just a little over a day and found it really gripping. I like the way the book was written although frequently found myself frustrated with many of the characters as Zach's family pay little regard to what the boy has been through.

Was this review helpful?

A powerful emotional read from start to finish, a subject that is far to real and sad yet how this author has put it into words is truly beautiful.
I felt so many different things reading this book and for me is was very unique in the fact i have never read a book like it.
Narrated through the eyes and voice of 6 year old Zach, he tells the story of a shooting at his school that changes life for him and his family as they know it. Rhiannon Navin clever writing captures the innocents and perspective of a child so well. I did find part hard to read, especially the mother behaviour towards Zach at times, however I am very lucky to not have experience grief like she has and have no idea how you would cope with losing a child.
This truly is a brilliant debut novel and I look forward to see what emotional rollercoaster the author has in store for her next book.

Was this review helpful?

I don’t know what to write about this book without giving too much away. All I can say is what a wonderful child Zach is to deal with this the way he did. A very emotional heart wrenching story.

Was this review helpful?

Amazing book, very well written and grips the reader from the very first page. Absolutely brilliant read.

Was this review helpful?

Wow! Outstanding! Hard to believe this is a debut author. Without doubt this will be one of the best books of this year and will stay with me for a long time to come.

Was this review helpful?

A truly heartbreaking read, it tells the story of a family torn apart by a tragic shooting, it makes you think about the people left behind and how adults and children deal with loss and grief and what can happen when you deal with it separately and not together, a great read I would definitely recommend

Was this review helpful?

What an amazing book, very powerful and quite addictive reading. The story is written through the eyes of a young child who was involved in a school shooting in which his elder brother dies. What follows is an emotional roller coaster of how the family deal with the grief which they do in different ways and in the mother's case by going through anger and needing someone to blame, which impacts on Zack and his struggle to understand. This book should make us all think when there is a younger child within the grieving family and in today's blame society and in fact a child's understanding is often the way to go as it's honest and uncomplicated. Despite the fact this book is written through the eyes of a child, it is in no way a child's book and has a deep insight into feelings that abound after such a tragic event, happily, very rare this side of the Atlantic, and hope it stays so. An incredibly moving debut novel which will stay with you for a long time and I, for one, shall be keeping an eye on this author.

Was this review helpful?

Breathtakingly Beautiful

This is an outstanding debut, Zach really can tell a story! Before beginning I had heard comparisons with ‘Room’ and quite rightly so, I think there is something very harrowing about a tragic event when told through the eyes of a child, the innocence serving to add another layer of pathos to the story as it unfolds. Each word I read, each page I turned breathed life into Zach until he was right there with me, even as I went about my day to day life.

This is a beautiful narration of a horrific event and it’s aftermath, overwhelmingly sad yet also overflowing with hope.

Thank you so much to the Publisher and to NetGalley for the advance copy. I loved this book with my ‘Whole Self’

Was this review helpful?

Only Child sensitively explores the devastating impact of personal tragedy within the family unit. As narrator, Zach poignantly conspires to reveal the painful truth of victimisation, so often not as openly and selflessly acknowledged. I spent two nights crying whilst reading this book, mostly for the innocence and acquired worldliness of little Zach, but also for the very public misguided portioning of blame, earned or otherwise.

Was this review helpful?

Only Child is a heartbreaking read especially as it's told through a child's POV. To be honest as a mother I wouldn't have been able to read it from the mothers POV.
I read this book over the space of a few hours I just had to know the outcome.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you for the opportunity to read this book. It was very good right from the start. It sucks you in from the very first chapter. It is heartbreaking to think that these things happen in real life. This has happened to people in real life. It can still happen today. Definitely worth a read. I will be recommending this book. Very well written, great story, heartbreaking at times but very good. Definitely worth 5 stars.

Was this review helpful?

This is an accomplished debut. Zach Taylor is six years old when his ten year old brother Andy is shot dead alongside a number of his class mates and teachers. The novel follows Zach’s attempt to make sense of what has happened and the impact it has on him and his family.

Rhiannon Navin has captured beautifully the confusion within Zach. Everyone speaks kindly of Andy and what a wonderful child he was. Zach knows this isn’t strictly true and that Andy could be mean. He puzzles over the motives of the adults in the way only a child could. On occasions Zach sounds a little older than his six years but for the most part, and it isn’t easy for an author to accomplish, you hear a clear six year old voice.

Zach’s family begin to fall apart under the strain of their loss and his father’s infidelity. Zach is determined to make things right both for his family and that of the boy who did the shooting. The ending is a little bit simple but all things told this was a good read.

I received a complimentary copy of the book from NetGalley and publisher in exchange for an honest review. Thank you

Was this review helpful?

An absolutely heartbreaking book about a school shooting and its aftermath all from the point of view of a 6-year-old boy, Zach. Zach survives the shooting, huddled in a classroom cupboard with his classmates, but his older brother, Andy, does not. Zach struggles with a vast array of feelings, making feeling posters to try to separate out his complicated emotions and make sense of them. But while Zach tries to deal with his loss, his parents are rapidly unravelling, dealing with the tragedy in wildly conflicting ways.
This is a compellingly written book. Zach is a narrator for whom you feel great sympathy. His attempts to make sense of the motions and feelings of grief are hugely touching and the innocence of childhood sometimes gives him a wisdom his parents lack.
It was a huge surprise to discover that this is the author’s debut novel. Her writing style that adopts the personality and viewpoint of a six-year old is very accomplished. I look forward to reading whatever Navin produces next.

Was this review helpful?

WOW what an absolutely stunning 5 Star read from cover to cover. A very emotional tale of an elementary school shooting and the total devastation caused by such a terrible event. The total heartbreak for a family trying to recover from such events and the trauma caused to a child who managed to survive. Told from the young survivors point of view it will tug at your heartstrings. Absolutely recommend.

Was this review helpful?

This book was simply heart wrenching. Watching the devastation of a family from the eyes of the 7 year old son.
Zach is at school when someone starts shooting and nineteen lives mainly children are gone in minutes. Zach then has to make his way in this new world where everything seems scary. His parents don’t know how to deal with it together so they start breaking apart.
You understand things that Zach at 7 can’t comprehend.
This book didn’t just make me cry but several times as you desperately want one of his parents to identify how much Zach is hurting.
I can’t wait to see what the writer will release next.
Stunning can’t recommend it enough.

Was this review helpful?

Six year old Zach Taylor has just survived a shooting at his school only to realise that a bigger horror awaits him and his family. His older brother has been killed in the shooting.

A heartrending story told in Zach's words, the impact is magnified ten-fold through the little boy's innocent narrative. His terror during the shooting, sometimes sidelined by the mundane and brought immediately back to focus by the onging horror. It was heartbreaking to read how the family falls apart and how it impacted Zach, the innocent, helpless victim.

The author has done such a fabulous job, never once did the narrative seem fake or unrealistic. Zach's voice felt true and his observations apt for a child. The way he copes, tries to work things out.. I cried through the book. All I wanted to do was hold Zach and comfort him.
A book I'd heavily recommend. One I'm sure will stay with me for a while. And the author, I'll pick up any book she writes in a jiffy.

Thank you NetGalley and the publishers for the review copy of this book.

Was this review helpful?

Where do I even start? Such an amazing debut and written through the eyes of a seven year old. So thought provoking on such a difficult subject. The story of little Zach from the daughter lives changed forever. You go through every single emotion whilst reading this book which is pure brilliance by the author. I wish I could give this book more than 5 stars it truly is very special

Was this review helpful?

Prepare for tears, do not wear mascara! This was such a sad but heartwarming book about a school shooting in America with the story told from the perspective of a surviving boy whose brother was killed. It was so well written and uniquely told from a child’s perspective. Just loved it and couldn’t put it down

Was this review helpful?

This is the story of an amazing little boy caught up in terrible situation and how he and his very human parents deal with the aftermath. It is told by the child himself with quite a bit of poetic license because no seven year old could express himself quite as brilliantly. I read it in one day and evening, was enthralled, upset and humbled by the boy’s emotions and feelings. Extraordinary empathy from the author.

Was this review helpful?

Written from the perspective of a 7 year old boy, Only Child tells the heartbreaking story of what happens to a family after the unthinkable happens at school. The horrific shooting has far-reaching effects for the local community too. The simplicity of the voice of a child adds an extra layer to the book, as there are times you have to read between the lines and decide for yourself what is happening and what feelings characters are experiencing. A very well written book that makes you explore deep within yourself.

Was this review helpful?