Member Reviews

I enjoyed reading the parts of the novel that related to military history. Silence in the Desert seems to have been quite well researched and covers a number of key WWII campaigns..
The counter-woven plots are fascinating and are well written. However, the main story-line of the interconnecting characters is fairly implausible, with some character vignettes not logical or particularly persuasive.
The book reminded me somewhat of a Jeffrey Archer novel, which will hopefully attract a number of Archer's followers.

Was this review helpful?

3.5 stars
I really enjoy reading about WW2 and this book deviates from the more common British and French angle with most of the action taking place in Europe and Africa. I really enjoyed the parts involving the people, although it was a bit coincidental how they all kept bumping into each other! However I got a bit lost on the military side of things, which is not the authors fault, just my lack of knowledge! I think the book was well researched, and showed different aspects of WW2 such as how the Catholic church was stuck between a rock and a hard place and how all Germans were not Nazi's. I would suggest that if you like WW2 fiction about the Resistance or life in Britain then this book is not for you, but if you know about the action in Africa, Italy etc then you would find it most interesting. I would read another of this author's books as he has a nice writing style that flowed well and kept me interested (just not the military parts!)

Was this review helpful?

Silence in the Desert is an excellent novel covering the battles in the Middle East, the Mediterranean, and Africa from 1941 into 1945 through the eyes of three students. Henri de Rochefort is the son of an English woman and a Frenchman, raised in France but being educated in England. Henri's dream is to become a member of the French Foreign Legion as his forefathers before him. Leo Beckendorf is the son of a German and an English woman, also taking some of his education in England but raised in Germany and feeling he is destined to fly for the German Luftwaffe. Bill Lomberg is British but was raised in Africa and his dream, too, is to fly. Adding their viewpoint we have Benedictine monk Dom Brendan Rooker OSB, or Rookie as the boys call him, who is house master at their English school, Saint Gregory's College. And Theresa Kruger, a renamed German Jewess, a trained nurse hiding in plain sight nursing the wounded for the Free French forces.

These earlier battles fought in WWII are not as extensively covered in fact or fiction as are those later battles in Europe. It is good to see them brought to our attention. We see the same names over and over - WWI, WWII, and over the last twenty years. Libya. Greece. Beirut. Egypt. Benghazi. Cairo. The Sinai. Gaza.

This is a story told very well. David Longridge is an author I will add to my list.

I received a free electronic copy of this historical novel from Netgalley, David Longridge, and Matador an imprint of Troubador Publishing Ltd. in exchange for an honest review. Thank you all for sharing your hard work with me.

Was this review helpful?

It is an evening in the 1930ties. A German, a French and a South African boy meet with their housemaster the last evening they are in boarding school. The boys want to join the military of their countries. The father insist they should not forget that in times of war nature's law is often forgotten. When weapons speak the law is silent. Years after the boys are men and fight as soldiers in different military operations during world war two.
An interesting book for someone who likes to get to know a bit more about World War Two. I thought it more a military book than a book about people. Because the writer switches between the different men and sometimes leaps in time happen it is difficult to bond with the individual men.
I have the feeling this book is part of a series as somewhere people were referring to earlier events and I had missed those. And as the story ends I had the feeling a part three was about to follow.

(Facebook and weblog review will follow but cannot get on that now as I am on a holiday trip)

Was this review helpful?