Member Reviews

Thank you to NetGalley, Marianne Holmes and Agora books for the chance to read an ARC of this novel.

From the description - Besides, if you were one half evil, wouldn’t you want to know about the other half?

Review - It’s the summer of 1976. A heat wave means perfect weather for swimming at the Lido for 9 year old Robyn (Little Bird) and her brother Christopher (Kit). The only things spoiling their perfect summer is their Mum bringing home women in tears and the town gossip about it, the bullies that mercilessly tease her, the mysterious appearance of The Man in the Cowboy Hat. Then something happens that summer. Something that changes the course of Robyn and Kit’s lives forever. Something Robyn feels she must atone for before it’s too late…..

The story switched between 1976 and 1988, when Robyn and Kit return to the village to solve the mysteries surrounding what happened and so Robyn can right her perceived wrongs. In ‘76 she is a child on the cusp of adolescence, trying to figure out adult secrets and behaviours while also learning who she is. Her sense of frustration and mistakes she makes as a result of childish naivete often left me wanting to shout at Robyn "don't tell him that" or clue her in but it was great for the story and you felt your heart break with hers as the adult Robyn is filled with deep regret for what those mistakes now mean.

The bond between Kit and Robyn and the intricacies of sibling relationships, are pivotal to this story and are well written. The author weaves the layers of the story elegantly and reveals its secrets in piecemeal; teasing you with the promise of a revelation then ending prematurely so you're left trying to decipher it's meaning.

I was so excited to be approved for this book. The premise was intriguing and I loved the fact that it was the chance to read a debut novel. There’s a thrill of the unknown, the possibility of finding a hidden gem of a story and a new voice who you just know you’ll follow the rest of their career. Just reading the introduction to the author started the book with a smile and the sense I was about to read something special. The letter from the publisher solidified those feelings and I wasn’t disappointed in hoping I’d find all those things. I will definitely be reading any future novels by this author. A wonderful book.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley for sharing this book.

I loved the book. Will recommend this to anyone.

I was unable to put down this book. I loved all the characters (except 2).

After reading I was bit confused on the ending. At times I feel it's incomplete. But in fact, it was a beautiful way to end the book.

Sometimes, its better not to know what had happened in the past and its better to let go. I would have preferred not to know what happened. Its so terrible. But Robyn was so brave to face it and find a solution.

I enjoyed reading this book. I might modify the feedback later once my mind is settled with all the thoughts about Jemima, Robyn and Ray.

Was this review helpful?

A very confused and muddled tale which was, despite all, well written with good descriptions. The book covers the summer of 1976 when the actual story happened and the main characters (Kit and Robyn) were children and also jumped forward to 1988 when they were young adults. The plot was good but executed rather poorly and I found the main character Robyn rather exasperating and weak, she always seemed to be wanting 'to tell the truth' as an adult, but didn't, and as a child kept wanting to know the truth, probably no one told her as she was a bit of a loose cannon.

I'm afraid I didn't really take to it as a book as it was slow to start, gathered pace to be all rather unbelievable ending. There are a lot of irrelevancies that crop up and never fully explained and a number of loose ends.

I find I'm only giving it three stars and that really is more for the descriptive writing than the actual book.

Was this review helpful?

Robyn and her brother, Kit return to their old home after twelve years away. It has stood empty for all those years after a long hot summer, when there was a tension not only in the house but within the town. Who knows what happened that summer, who is not telling the truth and can Robyn lay rest to everything that has haunted her since the day they left.

Was this review helpful?

This was a very good read. It was intriguing as the author told the story of Robyn and her brother and the circumstances of their lives and the town that didn't seem to be able to move on from past events. Robyn and her brother Kit always seemed to be running from danger and finding the secrets of their past and what a past that turned out to be. I liked how it moved from 1976 to 1988. It was only at the end after many twists and turns that the truth was revealed. I was captivated by the story Marianne Holmes presented us with. An excellent debut novel and a captivating read. I look forward to reading more from this author.

Was this review helpful?

A very enjoyable story told through the eyes of a little girl, and as an adult 12 years later. The author’s characterisation and descriptive language is superb and I loved the little ladybird appearances through the book. The present tense narrative took a little getting used to, but just meant I got swept up in the story almost as if I was a spectator at their kitchen table. I didn’t see the twist at the end happening, which is always good. I devoured the book in a couple of days and would recommend.

Was this review helpful?

The plot and characters in this psychological thriller were intriguing and I found it a quick and page-turning read. At the start of the novel Christopher (Kit) and his younger sister Robyn arrive by train to somewhere that featured significantly in their past although it is some time before we know exactly why they are there. It is apparent that Robyn wants to find someone who has disappeared and clues as to who this might be pop up and then are burst like bubbles. The narrative flits back and forwards between 1976 and 1988. I am not sure why the author chose these two years as it could just as easily have been 2006 and 2018. In 1976 the siblings' mother, Jemima, offers shelter and assistance to women who are victims of domestic abuse and this causes resentment amongst some of the townspeople. This is developed as a key to the 1988 narrative with threats and violence never being far from the surface. All the characters seem to be either bullies, victims or both and this is perhaps one of the main themes of the book. As I wrote above I found this an easy and enjoyable read but there were aspects of the plot I felt were neither fully explained or developed. This is Marianne Homes' first novel and I would look out for further titles from her.

Was this review helpful?

I wasn’t sure what to make of this book at the beginning but by the end I was hooked. I couldn’t turn the pages quick enough. I had a feeling what the relationship would be for Jemima but the book just drew you in. You really feel for Robyn and Kit and the impossible situation everyone is in where they’re all trying to protect each other but not really protecting anyone. An excellent read

Was this review helpful?

I found this book description intriguing but found it a bit slow & felt it could have been better. I did enjoy it though

Was this review helpful?

Intriguing and a very enjoyable mystery read, keeps you guessing until the end. I recommended this debut novel, a very interesting & well written book.

Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

The discription seemed very interesting, though after starting it, it was too slow and dint keep my interest; didn’t finish.

Was this review helpful?

I thought this was a great holiday read! Intriguing enough to keep me wanting to read more, but not too heavy going.
I will look out for further books from this author

Was this review helpful?

I neither loved or hated this book therefore award three stars. The story didn’t really grab me and I found the denouement a little contrived and unbelievable. I won’t be posting a review on social media as I feel it would be unfair to the author and to the many people who may not share my view.

Was this review helpful?

I received a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

If you were one half evil, would you want to know about the other half?

A beautifully laid out mystery taking place during the summers of 1976 and 1988 with varied pace and vivid imagery, it was only the knowledge that the baby would be awake soon that had me putting this novel down; I could have easily devoured it in one sitting.

A Little Bird Told Me centres around siblings Robyn and Kit, their encounter with a sinister stranger in 1976 and their prodigal return to put things right in 1988. That there was much intrigue was clear from the first chapter, and so I was hooked from the word go. Holmes’ ability to conjure up the heat and hues of the mid-70s using succinct descriptions made it easy to picture the scenes playing out before me, and she does not rely on continual cliffhangers to keep the reader engaged.

The relationship between Robyn and her older brother is strong, realistic and serves to explain why so many secrets were kept from her - he had always known the truth would be more harmful to her than the lie, and so we are taken along on the, often frustrating, journey of a 9-year-old slowly realising the truth of her beginnings.

Whilst I found this an enjoyable read with a twist I did not see coming - a rarity for someone as used to the well-worn tropes of mystery/thrillers - I did at times get frustrated with the pacing and how far into the novel we had to delve for any hint of the truth. I could have used a few more breadcrumbs along the way. I also feel the sense of Robyn as a town pariah upon her return in 1988 was never fully explained - as a child, she could not have been held responsible for anything that took place in the summer of 1976, surely?

As a page turner, this delivered beautifully and I would highly recommend for anyone who is more patient when it comes to finding out twists than I am!

Was this review helpful?

For a debut novel Marianne Holmes had set herself a very high standard to keep hitting but I feel (I know from one book) that she has a talent that will keep her publishers busy and rewarded for a long time. Plus her readers/fans on tender hooks for years to come
This is a story about Robyn (little bird) and her brother Christopher (Kit) who return to their childhood home in 1988 to find the truth of the awful events that took place in the Heatwave of 1976. The chairs alternate between the two years and the suspense build with each chapter and you will not want to put this book down. Kit wants to protect his younger sister who just wants the truth and the home town folk don't seem over I to see them again apart from Eva their Mums best friend but s she is pregnant surprised to see her even if well I let you read about that rather than spoil the story but this is not a big part but there is so much here that it needs to be read in order like all good novels. The bad guys are nasty the hero and her brother are characters you want to succeed and will love and grow to understand more and more. The years may change people but the truth remains all the same.
I'm grateful to Agora Books and NetGalley for this copy and hope you get this amazing book and enjoy it as much as I have our more even. Don't let the price fool you this is a top read and I'm sure you will have to pay a lot more for her next books.

Was this review helpful?

Such a protracted and muddled telling of a story, that was not an enjoyable read. I persevered with completing reading, but it felt like an onerous task.

Was this review helpful?

A very well written story, however I found it really frustrating. The story is told in present day with flashbacks to things that happened in the past. You are never quite told all the details which is obviously to keep you guessing, but I just found it confusing. I could never quite tell who was who and if I was supposed to know something that we hadn't yet been told. I spent a lot of time going back to re-read chapters in case I'd missed something.
In the end the finale was a bit of an anticlimax. Bit disappointed by this read.

Was this review helpful?

This novel drew me in from start to finish. The sense of intrigue and evil wound it's way throughout, culminating in a finale that tied in the events in a sad albeit satisfactory manner. I would love to read a sequel, as I feel several of the characters have untold stories to tell.
A fantastic debut novel!
Many Thanks to the publishers and Netgalley for allowing me to read this in advance of publication.

Was this review helpful?

This was a beautifully written book with a great premise of a story. I love the way the authoress writes, and the story itself, I mean what actually happened (the mysterious events with mysterious background), was a very intriguing and exciting idea.
The actual execution is not so perfect, though. For the first couple of chapters, I was very interested in finding out what was happening, what is it all about, but with time I started to get bored because everything was going so slowly. I like the atmosphere of suspense, and it was nicely created, but I felt like I knew too little and too much at the same time. The reveal of the 'big things', of the actual happenings, is dragged out until like 60-70% in the novel, and by the half it felt very tiring, because I still didn't know what exactly we are dealing with. On the other hand, I figured out the very basics of it, the nature of what happened very early, and way long before the protagonist, Robyn did. So though it is a very well thought-out mystery, at the end of the day what happened to me was that I was getting tired of Robyn finding out about things I (and everyone else in the book) already knew, while I was frustrated for the majority of the book about not getting enough clues about things that I felt like would matter more and would be more interesting. So even though the information and clues were gradually unfolded, I felt like I only got to know everything in the last chapters.
I think this was because of the main character, Robyn. She was so clueless that it was crazy annoying! I get that she is a child (on one timeline in the story), and even on the other timeline she's only a young adult, but she simply can't add two plus two together. I like that we see the happenings through a child's eyes, this is a very interesting perspective, but many times I felt like her character's behavior is a little forced. She's not simply naive, innocent and confused, but seems like outright dumb, even for a 9 year-old. I don't dare to say the that she was a badly written character, because I'm not completely sure a child couldn't turn out this way, living the way she did, not being told about anything at all that's even a bit complicated. She was an annoying person nonetheless, though.
The last 30% saved this book for me. Though the proportions (of where/when in the novel the story is told) are a bit off, this is a very good story and a great mystery in the background. I guessed the major plot twist at the end (I basically guessed everything), but it was far from being obvious, and it didn't take away much from the enjoyment. It was a clever plot twist, and looking back, I see how cleverly the hints were hidden. I'm sure many, or probably the majority of the readers will not see everything coming. I'm just not easy to surprise. :)
The very ending (I'm thinking of the last page) left me a bit unfinished, I'm really keen to find out what happens next, and unfortunately, we don't find out about it, we only get to know everything that happened in the past.
All in all, I would say this is a good first novel based on a great idea. I'm not sure this book is for everyone, but I would read another book by this author, because I feel like she would write amazing novels, given the chance of publishing more.

Was this review helpful?

Absolutely loved this book. Unfortunately, I did have to put it down several times. This book keeps you guessing until the end. This book was not like any other story I have read before and the premise was very different. What I thought to be the truth was so far from it. Loved the characters and the fact that they were young when most of the incident took place and it is now them looking back as young adults. I also loved that it was the young adults that solved the mystery instead of the police. I would still love to know more of what happened to Wendy and Carol, along with Mickey. It was unclear if what happened to Mickey was a result of Ray. This is definitely a book I would recommend to my friends and family. Very quick read.

Was this review helpful?