Member Reviews

Powiem wam, że z "The Birthday" Carol Wyer spędziłam bardzo przyjemny weekend. Książka jest szybka w czytaniu i ciekawa. Głowiłam się nad rozwiązaniem zagadki zniknięcia dziewczynek razem z Natalie Ward, bohaterką-detektywem i miałam podobne, silne przeczucie, że w miarę postępu śledztwa trzymamy w rękach wszystkie kawałki układani, tylko nie bardzo jeszcze wiemy jak je do siebie dopasować.

Główna bohaterka, Natalie Ward jest nie tylko detektywem, ale także żoną i mamą. Wraz z mężem, Davidem wychowują dwójkę nastolatków, chłopca i dziewczynkę, i Natalie bardzo się stara połączyć w jakąś funkcjonalną całość swoje życie prywatne z zawodowym. Długie godziny pracy nas śledztwem nie ułatwiają jednak stosunków z mężem i Natalie czuje się ciągle rozdarta pomiędzy misją odnalezienia zaginionych dziewczynek a potrzeba spędzania czasu z rodzina. Jest przy tym świetnym detektywem. Jest konkretna, rzeczowa i inteligentna i w taki tez sposób prowadzi swoje śledztwo. Praca jej zespołu jest metodyczna, przemyślana i konsekwentna i pomimo tego, że sprawca przewija się raz po raz przez ich dochodzenie i nie zostaje przez detektywów wychwycony, to ma to swoje dobre uzasadnienie. Jest logicznym działaniem zespołu a nie karygodnym zaniedbaniem. Akcja jest szybka, nie rozwleka się bezsensowanie w czasie i z każdym rozdziałem otrzymujemy kolejny ważny kawałek do naszej układanki.
Co do tożsamości samego przestępcy, to można się dość szybko domyślić kto nim będzie, co jednak wcale nie przeszkadza w czerpaniu przyjemności z czytania książki. Jest w niej wystraczająco dużo niewiadomych, aby trzymać nas w napięciu aż do ostatniej strony. Mnie historia wciągnęła tak bardzo, że przeczytałam ją w dwa dni.

"The Birthday" to bardzo fajna lektura, w sam raz na weekend. Polecam!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Bookouture and NetGalley for the chance to read and review this book.
A little girl disappears during a birthday party and the mystery begins. What happened to her? This book will keep you guessing until the end. This is a fast paced mystery with lots of twists and turns. I recommend to all mystery lovers. It is very well written and will grab you right from the beginning.

Was this review helpful?

I thought I’d never drag myself through to the end of this book. It wasn’t that it was particularly long, it just felt never-ending. The perpetrator was easy to guess and the fact the cops didn’t figure it out in such a long time made the climax take forever to begin to unfold. That fact paired with the redundant writing made for a long, dragging book. I’m sorry, maybe it was a one off bad job and in editing the final copy will be better. I received an advance copy of the book for my honest opinion.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely loved The Birthday by Carol Wyer. It’s the first in the Detective Natalie Ward series and I’m excited to see how this character progresses.

The Birthday starts with a hot summers afternoon. Five year old Ava Sawyer went to a birthday party at a garden centre but went missing and never came home. The police had no leads, however two years later, Ava’s body is found. Then Audrey Briggs goes missing. Audrey attended the same birthday party as Ava. Is there a connection? It’s down to Natalie to find out.

This book is a gripping and pacy read from the first page. I really liked the main character and thought the whole plot line flowed well.

A great read and I look forward to the next instalment. Thank you to NetGalley, Bookouture and the author for the chance to review.

Was this review helpful?

Ok, so its official--Carol Wyer is a must-read for me!! I love her DI Robyn Carter series, so I was thrilled to see that she started a new one. Judging by the first book, I know I'm going to love this series as well.

This one begins with a birthday party for kids when a young girl goes missing, she's never found. Flash forward two years and the bones of a child is discovered. This starts a new killing spree that sees children being killed. In comes a new detective in the area, Natalie Ward, that heads the investigation. Not only is she dealing with personal problems but, she also feels she has to prove to herself that she can solve this before more children are killed. I liked the character of Natalie. She's tough but isn't perfect. I really enjoy Carol's writing. Its feels like watching an episode of a crime series. Her books are solid as far as thrillers go. I can't wait to see more of Natalie in the future.

*Thank you to the publisher and Netgalley for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This is great read. There is a lot of suspense and a lot happening. The characters are good and the plot kept me reading. I have read some of Carol Wyers other books and enjoyed them all.

Thank you to Netgalley for my copy.

Was this review helpful?

I really loved the main characters and the brilliant plot. I read this book in one sitting and could not put it down. I would highly recommend this book to anyone.

Was this review helpful?

This story begins with every parent's biggest fear; a child goes missing from a birthday party & isn't found. Fast forward abt 2yrs and an excavation company find the body of the missing child, Ava. Her case is reopened and DI Natalie Ward is in charge. This case brings up a past failure for Natalie, along with current troubles from her home life. Without giving anything away, this definitely had me thinking. I had a few suspicions but did figure it out. This was a 3.75-4 stars for me. Look forward to more books involving DI Ward & her team.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley and Bookouture for allowing me to read this ARC book, The Birthday by Carol Wyer and giving my opinion.
**spoiler alert**
This is my 1st book from this author and I can say I was pretty happy with it. DI Natalie Ward is called in on a case of a childs body being uncovered on a construction site, as she is trying to find out the circumstances of how this child got there another little girl goes missing ...now Natalie needs to find out who is killing little girls and it all seems to stem from a little missing girl that disappeared from a birthday party just a few years back....
There are alot of good, well fleshed out characters to sink your teeth into, story moves along at a pretty good pace am looking forward to the next book.

Was this review helpful?

I have really enjoyed Carol Wyer’s books so far, so of course I knew I had to try out her new detective series as soon as I heard about it. And who can resist that cover and blurb?! I was looking forward to reading The Birthday and while not perfect, it was without doubt a good start of a new series. Of course the writing is just as strong as ever, with a quality I have become used to and a way to charm you into flipping page after page without putting the book down. The case in The Birthday is both intriguing and will chill you to the bone... Child kidnappings are always so hard to read about, especially if there are multiple lives on the line. The things that happen in this detective thriller will give any parent nightmares, and even childless readers will be emotionally invested. There is definitely a lot to love in The Birthday, so why didn't I rate it higher? Well, this mostly has to do with the new main character we meet. Sadly, I wasn't able to connect to the new detective or most of her team. Instead of refreshing and interesting, I found especially Natalie Ward to be mostly cliche and I really do hate cheating characters. There was nothing 'new' this team added to the genre for me, nothing original to cause a spark. I am willing to give detective Natalie Ward and her team a second chance though, mostly because the writing, plot development and suspense are spot on. And there are without doubt a few twists hidden in there that will manage to surprise you!

As I said before, there is a lot to love in The Birthday. The writing is solid and engaging, making you fly through the pages. The plot is interesting, suspenseful and has just the right amount of twists for me. I did guess part of the ending, but overall you are left in the dark most of the time. My only problem was with the new detective and her team; I simply wasn't able to warm up to her and found both her personal life and way of investigating to be mostly cliche or at least not that original. I'm still curious about the sequel though.

Was this review helpful?

Sadly, this book did nothing for me. Detective Natalie Ward is one of those characters that is flawed. She has personal issues that a little bit creep into her work life; yet she does try her hardest to find that balance. I wanted to point this out as I do like "flawed" characters. It shows they are vulnerable and can make them more relatable as well. Which Natalie was for me. Yet, my issue was not with her but more about the story as a whole package.

The story was uninteresting with most of the other characters being just as uninteresting. Even the voice of the killer was muted down. Thus the storyline dragged on and on. It was hard for me to keep finding interest in this book. However, I was determined to finish it as I wanted to see how it would end. Which, I was left unsatisfied by the ending. This is the worst. To read a whole book; only to come to the ending and be left unsatisfied. Plus, I can't really remember any of the other characters names in the story. I will not be continuing this series.

Was this review helpful?

Another stunning story from Carol Wyer. This is the first book in a new series featuring DI Natalie Ward and her team. This is a really good police procedural with great characters. Although I guessed the murderer, it was still gripping.

Was this review helpful?

I was very glad to be able to read this first in a new series by Carol Wyer. Unfortunately, I was not as enthousiastic about this as all the other reviewers. It must be me, because it was very well written. I just could not remember all the names and kept mixing everyone up. Must be the old age! I hope this will not keep people from reading it because the story line is really good

Was this review helpful?

Although I really wanted to love this book, it was just meh for me. The story drew me in very quickly but the ending failed to deliver the unexpected twist I so desire in a mystery/thriller type of book.

The story starts with a little girl named Ava disappearing from a birthday party. Two years later and her body has not been found. Then little girls who attended the same party start showing up dead in random places of the town wearing yellow dresses just like Ava had been wearing the day she disappeared. Enter Detective Natalie Ward, mother of two. Detective Ward does her best to ignore the distractions at home and dives into the case. Like, I said the story was very entertaining and had some great characters in it, both reliable and unreliable, but the ending just fell flat. There were several chapters in the book told from the point of view of the killer and it was clear he was very disturbed, but there were no clues to lead the reader to the aha moment in the end. 

Thank you to Netgalley, Carol Wyer, and Bookouture for my ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Reading this book gave me chills as I can only imagine what the family of a missing child goes through.

The story was absorbing and had a really great new lead is Natalie Ward. Let's just say that while I think she is a great detective I think she needs to learn to prioritize.

Her life is not easy and she made mistakes which could have ended her marriage and her family life.

I really enjoyed this character and can see her grow with each book that will be released. It is nice to really see a character that stands out from the beginning.

Wonderful book

Was this review helpful?

I was excited to read this new book from Carol Wyer as I love her Robyn Carter series so much. I thought I hope i won't be disappointed and boy I wasn't .Great story, love the detective I was hooked from the start. I thought i had worked out who the killer was but i was wrong lol Still love the other series as they are set where I live but can't wait to see what happens in the next in this series.

Was this review helpful?

This is the first in a series centred around DI Natalie Ward and her team.

2015. 5 year old Ava Sawyer goes missing at a birthday party. Two years later, her body is found, wearing a yellow dress. When two more girls are murdered and found wearing yellow dresses, it is up to DI Ward and her team to ascertain if the murders are copycat killings or if the girls are victims to the same killer.

I really enjoyed this book. We learn a little about the detectives throughout the story, but it is very skilfully done, with the main emphasis being on the murders.

The characters come across as very human and are well written. There are plenty of red herrings to keep you guessing - I couldn’t work out the murderer until near the end of the book

This is the first book I have read by this author, but it certainly won’t be my last. I certainly look forward to reading more about Natalie and her team.

Thank you to the author, Bookouture and Netgalley for giving me the opportunity to read this story in exchange for my unpaid, honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This is the first of Wyer's books that I have read. A detective is covering the disappearance of young girls, all who attended the same birthday party. What's the connection? I felt that the story was very well pieced together and well paced, and that the character development, especially for the main character--Detective Natalie Ward--is excellent. Development of the other detectives is not so fully fleshed out, but since this appears to be a series in the making, I am sure that will come with time for those who stick it out. I probably won't be one of them. The story was good enough, but not enough for me to come back to this author for another round. I felt like the ending was unsatisfactory, with no great twist or surprise to the conclusion.
Thank you very much to #NetGalley for an advance copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I started reading this book in bed at 10pm and said to myself I would only read for 30 minutes before catching some shut eye. But an hour and half later I was still up and reading. I found the book so gripping and intense that I didn’t want to stop reading.

I thought the book had a great plot and was very well written with many twists and turns as well as a few surprises in between which I weren’t expecting. The story is told mainly in the point of view of the main character, DI Natalie Ward. There were also a few chapters which were written with the thoughts from what sounds like a child, who is unnamed. From what I read I’m making a guess and saying that these are the thoughts of the killer when he/she was younger. (Don’t want to give the story away now)

While reading I feel Wyer portrayed the struggles of work life and personal life of the characters very well. I liked the character of DI Natalie ward and can’t wait to read the rest of the series to see how she develops both in her personal life and professional work life.

I really enjoyed the twist at the end of the book, I wasn’t expecting it, especially as I thought I had worked out what was going to happen.

I really enjoyed reading this first book in this series, and I think I will definitely be looking into reading her previous books while I wait for the next book to come out.

I definitely recommend this book for anyone who loves reading crime thrillers.

I would also like to thank NetGalley and Bookouture for my eARC in return for an honest and unbiased review.

Was this review helpful?

The Birthday is the start of a new detective series featuring DI Natalie Ward, a married mother of two. In 2015 Ava, attending a school friend's birthday party and wearing a yellow party dress, goes missing. Fast forward to 2018, Ava's body is found and very soon thereafter, other young girls who attended the party are also murdered and found wearing yellow party dresses. DI Natalie Ward is in a race against time to find the killer before they murder again, as not only is this case weighing heavily on her as a mother and a police officer, but also the fact that a previous case involving a teenage girl she was investigating didn't result in the outcome everyone had hoped for.

At just over 300 pages, it is a fast and pacy read. It is choc-full of suspects with dodgy alibis and motives as Natalie and her team try to unravel the truth and get to the perpetrator. A back story featuring flashbacks from the killer's point of view is also interesting and gives an insight into the question of why. Despite the difficult subject matter of missing and murdered children, as a mother myself I wasn't put off and enjoyed this book 3.5/5

Was this review helpful?