Member Reviews
I had read mixed reviews about this and can understand how some people would find it unpalatable to read with some of the dark themes of the book but that is what made it interesting to me. I enjoyed the two different timelines between Julianne in the present day and Holly in the past and this kept the plot intriguing. It took me a while to work out what the files were all about but I think that’s coz I’ve got a newborn and I’m sleep deprived LOL. I always really enjoy reading books that are based in Oxford Uni with the upper class as I find that lifestyle intriguing. All in all a thoroughly engaging read and will definitely read more from this author. Thanks to the author, Netgalley and HarperCollins for an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.
The plot is structured across two time-frames, 1990 and 2019, and from two viewpoints; that of Holly who is in her first year at Oxford in 1990 and Julieanne in present day. Throughout the book we are drip-fed the action between the two time frames and the two characters.
Holly is a lonely, introspective girl with little or no social skills and what appears to be a less than supportive family. Her success at gaining entry to Oxford offers her an opportunity to form new relationships and blossom. However, the friendships she forms from the outset are not ideal and are far from inclusive. Within this group we meet James and then Julieanne his girlfriend. They later go on to marry and have one son. When we first meet Julieanne she is preparing for Christmas when her son shows her some disturbing data found on their i-pad.
This book is not for the faint-hearted as it covers strong, disturbing subjects, including racism, rape, abuse and homophobia wrapped in a web of elitism and evil. Although quite graphic, I think the way it was handled was well-thought through, the drip-feed of information left me feeling a creeping sense of unease as well as a fast developing loathing of the characters, coupled with a stunned realisation of just how bad people can be. There were no redeeming features for any character with the exception of Julieanne’s son, whose life had been peopled with these loathsome people.
I did enjoy this book and would recommend it but beware, if you are like my friend Mary (Agatha Christie is about her limit on thrillers) do not even chance it. For those of you with a stronger stomach, I am sure you will not be disappointed.
Thank you to the author, publishers and NetGalley for providing an ARC via my Kindle in return for an honest review.
Wow! Excellent psychological thriller. When Julianne finds potentially devastating information on her sons iPad her entire life is turned upside down. As Julianne finds out that the man she married and thought she knew is a totally different person, she must tread lightly to keep her son and herself safe. The story moves seamlessly between college and the present as Julianne learns the horrible truth about her husband and his close group of friends. Material is sometimes hard to get through as it deals with human trafficking and assault. Riveting, taught, suspenseful thriller.
After reading this book I am not sure if I really enjoyed it. Saying that I was gripped and could not put this book down. Be warned this book is very graphic in places and OMG so very dark. The story spans twenty-five years and dips into the past when the event actually happened. This book is full of twists and turns and did I mention so very vert dark.
Something is brought to light on the internet which they thought would never see the light of day again. Now a group of old friends are forced to answer some very uncomfortable questions. I could not find one character in this group that was likeable. I do not want to give too much away but I will say what does consent actually mean ?
I devoured this book and would like to read more from this author. Personally I think that this book is like marmite either you love or hate it. I like marmite say no more.
Not exactly the storyline I was expecting. Very harrowing to read in parts. Unlikeable characters. That said the novel had a way of drawing you in. The ending was quite abrupt. Just an average read not exceptional in any way. Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for the chance to review it
*3.5 Stars*
I suppose I was expecting this to be more of a psychological thriller, but it definitely wasn’t that. What I did find was a novel full of hypocritical, elitist characters who represent the most vile and narcissistic excuses for mankind that it’s possible to come across.
Julianne is preparing dinner when her son Stephen tells her that he’s found something really bad on the home computer among his dad’s files. What follows, when Julianne sees exactly what Stephen has discovered, is an unraveling of a marriage, an end to family life as she knows it, and an encounter with a dark and deviant underworld that’s truly shocking.
The narrative is told in dual timelines and flows effortlessly between 1991 and 2019. Julianne’s story is told alongside Holly’s who was a fellow student at Oxford University. Though they weren’t particularly good friends, they do share a secret - one that both of them would prefer to leave permanently in the past.
It’s really difficult to review this one, it’s a very dark and disturbing storyline, with graphic descriptions of gang rape, and some homophobic and racist undertones which I found unsettling, however, I have to be fair to the author, and give credit where it’s due, because though the subject matter is repulsive, he’s actually produced an addictive read, compelling the reader ever onwards in order to discover exactly what Julianne and Holly will do with the secrets of the past and also the present, and in that respect it did have me gripped - I guess I was hoping to see someone pay for their despicable acts, but I won’t reveal the outcome!
Spoilers within
A short way into this novel, I became convinced I had already read it, such were the similarities between it and what turned out to be - with a little help from Google- Sarah Vaughn's 'Anatomy of a Scandal'. Both stories are told via flashbacks from a working class girl named Holly who goes to Oxford University and has her head turned by arrogant, privileged upper class rapist whereupon Holly drops out of college, pregnant and devotes her life thereafter to justice. It transpired that this was indeed a different book but were I Ms Vaughn, I might be a tad miffed!
This is a grim read and anyone likely to be triggered by sexual violence should avoid like the plague as it's dark with almost no relief at all from increasingly twisted sexual exploitation scenes and very few foils to a set of bleakly compromised characters. I finished it. I don't think it was badly written. I didn't enjoy it and felt somewhat grimy afterwards.
Really frustrating, the precis sounded good but nothing really happened - it was all set up. We met the characters, followed the thread, had a reveal of sorts but there was no real connection, no sense of tension. I felt sorry for the "victims" for their choice in men, but we never met the real victims and there was a disconnected feel to the crimes.
There was so much potential for a thrilling read, unfortunately it wasn't.
Though it's still early into 2019, I can safely say that A Version of the Truth is by far the worst book I've read this year. It shocked me NOT AT ALL to see that BP Walter is a white man, as no other author I can think of would write such awful characters. I hated every one of them, save for Stephen.
Graphic descriptions of sex and rape, homophobic undertones, powerful men and their wives who just go along with their bad behavior, this book has all those. I would highly recommend skipping this one.
Thank you to Netgalley for the ARC.
I am sorry this was not the type of book I was expecting. If I had known what it was about I would not have requested it.
Thank you to Netgalley for my copy.
A Version of the Truth by B P Walter is a tough book to write a review for without giving too much away. This book will not be for everyone as it deals with some very dark and confronting issues. There are some very graphic scenes that I found hard to read. Still having mixed feeling about it all now - lets just say that it was not what I was expecting when I started this book.
The story is told in 2 storylines - that of Julianne in 2019 who is getting ready for Christmas when her son shows her something on the families dropbox that changes everything that she thought she knew about her husband. Then we learn about Holly in 1990. It is her first year at Oxford University and she is a bit of an outsider, until she becomes friends with a group of people who are very different to her. What happens in Oxford will change her life forever.
Thanks to Avon Books UK and Netgalley for my advanced copy of this book to read. All opinions are my own and are in no way biased.
A Version if The Truth was not exactly the psychological thriller I was hoping it would be, but it was a page turner. I just did not gravitate toward any of the characters and felt like elements of it were off putting rather than thrilling. However, it is a shocking read that has some twisty elements that many readers will love. If you enjoy books with imperfect characters, eye opening scenes, and shocking storylines then you will like this one.
This book was not at all what I expected, there was a lot of graphic sex, sexual violence and the characters were vile and obnoxious. It was not for me at all I didn't enjoy it in the slightest.
This book deals with very graphic sexual abuse content - I wasn't expecting that when I started reading it. I do think that the story could have been told without being quite as graphic. It was a compelling read, something drew me in and kept me reading. I enjoyed the flashbacks to tell the earlier story, but found that I didn't particularly like any of the characters. I was expecting the story to continue longer than it did, the ending felt quite sudden, despite the epilogue. I don't think I can describe the story as enjoyable due to the subject matter, but it was compelling.
Not sure, how I feel about this book. It wasnt what I was expecting yet I was gripped.
It is rather graphic in places and it was VERY dark.
I love books that hop back in time and to present day, you can piece the story together as you read and the ending was great!
The characters where hard to like too which makes it difficult. I suppose the only likeable character is Stephen.
Anyway a good book, but very very dark.
A book of twists and turns with lots of darkness and very little light. The story spans 25 years. Following a discovery on the internet a group of old friends are forced to answer previously unasked questions. Layer after layer of secrets are uncovered with surprising results, including a really good example of the meaning of 'consent'.. It's a great read if you like mystery, intrigue and to be kept hanging for answers. I really enjoyed and recommend it.
I have to be honest and say this book was not for me. I think the reason was the subject matter of rape, sexual violence and racism are hard subjects to enjoy.
I wasn't sure what to expect with this book, I liked the sound of it but looking at the other reviews it seemed like a marmite book, some people thought it was great, and others didn't seem to like it at all.I thought it was much better than I expected, and a very interesting,if some what disturbing story.I guess the sex scenes may have put some people off ,they didn't hold back but were very much integral to the story.I thought the characters were very well written and seemed realistic .I am not going to spoil the story for other readers but I will say if you are looking for a captivating and interesting story and not squeamish about the sex scenes and content you should enjoy this book .I found it to be an interesting read and I would like to thank the publishers and netgalley for an ARC.
Enjoyed this book, though I'm a sucker for a tale about posh aristocrats but this becomes a lot darker. I would say that some of the more graphic scenes seem a bit gratuitous but by the end, it all becomes a bit clearer. Would read more by the author
I have to be honest, this wasn't my favourite book, I just wasn't drawn in from the start which I love a book to, it did pick up and turned out after a roundabout way of getting there, to be a good storyline, gritty and dark but mixed feelings. Overall 3*
Many thanks to Netgalley and Avon Books UK for an advanced copy in exchange for my honest opinion.