Member Reviews

I didn’t hate this book. But I didn’t love it and ended up DNF-ing which was unfortunate. It was nothing against the book, I actually really liked so many aspects of the story but I think it was very much I was not in the mood for the book and something didn’t click and so I ended up DNF-ing at the end of 2018.

This book seriously made me question at what point you should DNF. I found the story interesting and original. The exploration of Japanese mythology and folklore was fascinating and done well so that someone knows very little (like me) didn’t feel lost within the story but instead felt like they were being told but it also wasn’t too heavy handed so you feel overloaded with information either. It was gradually interspersed and that made me like it so much. I think my issue was very much I wasn’t in the mood for this book but also I didn’t connect with the characters. This may have been because there were multiple POV and we all know how I feel about those, or maybe my not being in the mood drive a wedge which stopped connecting, whatever the case it was very much a ‘it’s not you it’s me’ moment in DNF-ing. I felt so bad and questioned whether or not I should persist for the story but I knew how it would end. Me in a slump disliking the book when it really was a good story.

I did try and push through my mood and see if the characters would click for me but sadly that did not happen. If you are looking for a book with an interesting storyline with mythology and folklore you may be unfamiliar with then this is for you. There are plenty of far more positive reviews out there which shows it wasn’t the books fault.

Was this review helpful?

I loved this book!
The story follows Yumeko, a half kitsune who was raised by monks and grew up in a temple, and Kage Tatsumi, a samurai of the Shadow Clan. Brought together by fate, they have to go on a journey that revolves around the search for the ancient Scroll of a Thousand Prayers.

Reading this book felt just like watching an anime. The descriptions of the setting and of all the creatures Yumeko and Tatsumi encounter were incredibly vivid and the action scenes were great.
The lack of the YA typical instalove made this book even better.

I’m pretty sure that fans of anime and Japanese folklore will enjoy “Shadow of the Fox“ a lot. I certainly did.

- I received a free copy from the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. -

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley for giving me this ARC.

I absolutely LOVED this book! It's a Japanese mythical story about a girl who is half fox (Kitsune) and a legend about a dragon whose time to be summoned is coming soon. To summon the dragon, one must recite the prayers written on 3 scrolls - one of which the girl, Yumeko, has in her protection. On her quest to protect the scroll, she comes across a few samurai's, demons, kami's (gods), an emperor and more, some of whom become her companions along the way.
The story is told from the perspective of Yumeko and Tatsumi, a shadow samurai who possesses the Kamigoroshi sword, AKA the demon slayer sword.

I have never read a book from Japanese culture and I don't know much about the country's history and myths, so I absolutely LOVED this! I couldn't put it down! It held my attention the whole time I was reading it! I was so into the myths and characters and the story line as a whole, I just want more! Thankfully, the sequel is coming out in 6 months I think, but I can't wait!

Also, my obsession with foxes has multiplied by 1000, and it was pretty high to begin with! I highly recommend this book to anyone who loves a good journey, myths, Japanese folklore and adventure.

Was this review helpful?

I liked Kagawa's Talon series, but hated the other one so much that i can't even remember what it's called, and the cover is appealing! We get multi POVs in this book, and i listened to the audio, where they did have the money to hire a male and female narrator, always a good things. One MC is a orphan basically living among monks, who happens to be a fox, very strange. Another MC is a samurai who has this cool demon soul that could take over his body at any moment. World building was on point for this book, and the blood magic's and just the magic in general was explained well but not cumbersome. The ending was a cliff hanger for me for sure, i need to know who that stranger was and what the heck is happening next!

Was this review helpful?

Really enjoyed this sino-fantasy, full of thrills and peril. Each character with as much to hide as an Agatha Christie dinner party. Looking forward to the sequel.

Was this review helpful?

3,5 stars

Over the years I’ve tried to read a few Kagawa books. The original Iron Fey books and later even Talon. None could really satisfy me when it came to characters or story. Was Shadow of the Fox amazing? No. But it was better than anything I’ve read of this author before.

I feel like this story shows in some writing that Kagawa did mature in her writing. I feel like the characters are less walking clichés and while the plot didn’t go entirely like I wanted to it also didn’t quite go the walked route either which I really enjoyed. So I am pleased with Shadow of the Fox on this front.

Shadow of the Fox is inspired by Japanese mythology and I really enjoyed that. There are so many familiarities that as a manga and anime fan I came across. In terms and used mythology. But there were also things that I hadn’t heard of before. So there were still new things to discover as well. I enjoyed the mythology aspects.

As for the story I liked the start. Initially it really grabbed me with Yumeko as a character. But as the plot really started it kind of dwindled. It stagnated as I didn’t get the sense of urgency from our characters as they traveled that the mission required. In the end however the story picked up tremendous speed and things really took off.

The combination of Yumeko with Tatsumi was also a factor in this. The story is told through dual first person point of view and while I mostly enjoyed Yumeko’s, Tatsumi’s was another matter. He was rather on the bland side to follow. And while I understand why that is, it didn’t make for a very interesting read. Normally I like characters like him, but I missed the interaction with the demon in his chapters. I missed the subtle influences the demon should be having on him. It made the ending a bit of a sudden emergence for me.

Yumeko was just a marvel. A wide-eyed, naïve but mischievous half Kitsune that suddenly gets thrown into having a task, a purpose, having lost everyone she’s known since birth. I loved how they picked up some strays along the way. The sarcastic rounin and our determined noble. It created an amusing group nearing the end. Something that the start missed.

Overal I think this is a good start to the series and if I have to rec anyone a Kagawa book, it certainly will be this one!

Was this review helpful?

Full of Kagawa's tropes this first installment in a series let me down; it not only was predictable and instalovey but also had the heroine surrounded by prominent male characters as if she couldn't have been strong on her own.

Was this review helpful?

Yumeko is just peasant girl to most peoples eyes, but some can see through the cloaking to her ears and tail, she is half fox. The monks received a note telling them that she would be the savior, so they took her in, trained her and then entrusted her with a secret.

Yumekos journey across the .lands makes her friends and enemies, and some find that the path they thought they were on isnt as simple as the mission should be.

If you like a little YA fantasy this is the book for you, personally I struggled with the amount of words that meant nothing to me, which isnt unusual as the first book in the series, but there were just so many, along with names I couldnt pronounce in my head I really had to pay attention. Theres a glossary at the back that is useful ( so Id suggest the 'real' version over the eBook) but I found it too late.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley for this opportunity to read and review this awesome book!!

Shadow of Fox synopsis:
One thousand years ago the great Kami Dragon was summoned to grant a single wish and the land of Iwagato was plunged into ago of darkness.

Now, whoever holds the scroll of thousand prayers, a new wish will be granted and a new age will be dawn.

And its up to Yumeko, a yokai, who must hide her identity, that she is half kitsune and that she has the sacred scroll and Kage Tatsumi, a samurai of Shadow Clan, who has a demon inside him, that is more deadly than demons or monsters after them and the scroll!!

This epic fantasy book is full of much color!!
Strong world building, unique, loveable, interesting characters, japanese mythology, action, adventure!! Everything you want in a book!! The description of monsters, demons and characters brought to live!! Cant rave enough, how I love this book!! Cant wait for next book in this series Soul of the Sword!!

Was this review helpful?

I was a little bit wary going in to this book as the hype around is was so big, however it was truly worth it.
This does have a lot of your typical YA tropes however as the setting and story itself is so unusual i found them to be a lot more bearable.
The characters in this story were also great, i liked both of the main characters and loved that i got to experience this story from both of their point of views.

Definitely worth a read if you fancy a "typical" YA story with a twist!

Was this review helpful?

I’m gong to say that Shadow of the Fox is something pretty magical. From the incredible world building to the fantastic characters this ticked all the right boxes for me. Yumeko’s mischievous Kitsune is wonderful, she’s like that friend who always seems to get away with things no matter how much trouble they cause! She is the perfect antidote to the serious and sensible Kage. The story itself is set in 3 parts alternating between Yumeko and Kage for the main chapters. I really enjoy dual POV books and the additional insight they give in a first person narrative. What is a little different though, is that each part is opened by Suki, who we meet at the very start and her pages help to fill in the blanks whilst the main players are on their adventure and adventure is what this book is at its heart. Like your favourite anime series met Wizard of Oz, Yumeko is on a journey fraught with dangers but meets those on her way who help in ways she didn’t know she needed. Each place she finds herself she is met with a new test, a new boss battle of sorts with each being more terrible than the last. I loved the use of magics in the writing and how everything from forest spirits to angered ghosts make an appearance. Everything is described with such vivid beauty and the #ownvoice adds a depth and warmth to the pages where the Japanese flows seamlessly.

What was also refreshing is that any romance was kept to blushes and glances, yes there is a hint of inevitability as to where things are leaded (i’m pretty certain love will save the day eventually) but Yumeko is not to be distracted from her task and rightly so given the lives that were lost to set her on her path. Given her sheltered upbringing anything more would not have been authentic to the story. There was nothing I didn’t love about this story, and that includes a potentially inadvertent Monty Python moment (a knight, a bridge, non shall pass…) which may go over the heads of some, but tickled me none the less. Shadow of the Fox is a wonderful addition to the recent flurry of Asian mythology, with fantastic characters that you can’t help but cast in your head, gorgeous surroundings and heart in mouth set pieces. If you want a book to get truly lost in then this will certainly be the one to do it!

5*

Was this review helpful?

A touch slow to start and took a little time to get into, this is a great read. I am a fan of Julie kagawa and was not disappointed at all, I love the world she has created a mythical world where all the creatures from Japanese mythology come to life , all the nods to Japanese culture even etiquette are well done and I can't wait for the next in the series. 4 stars largely due to taking time to get into.

Was this review helpful?

2.75

I was really looking forward to reading "Shadow of the Fox" because I liked the idea of a novel based on Japanese mythology. Unfortunately, this book didn't meet my expectations.

The mythology was fine, but the characters just weren't all that well developed and acted and interacted in a rather forced and unrealistic fashion.

The female protagonist is presented in a painfully naive fashion, doesn't in any way react to the traumatic events she undergoes at the very start of the novel, and somehow has been raised by warrior monks without having picked up any notable combat skills.

The male protagonist's storyline was predictable but also confusing due to some inconsistencies in his backstory: he's introduced as an amazing assassin but constantly has to be saved by his magic sword, and he is a special kind of super secret assassin even though basically everyone he meets immediately knows who he is.

The supporting characters are all rather underdeveloped (even Okame is rather one-note) and the antagonist for some reason constantly talks to herself even though spirits are all around her and she knows they can hear her.

The plot itself was fine but it dragged in a lot places, spending time on countless subplots that don't really tie into the overall story and therefore feel rather underdeveloped and unnecessary.

Overall, I liked the idea of this novel more than the actual novel.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you so much again #Netgalley, the publisher & the author, for providing this book in exchange for an honest review.

Story: 4/5 When she flees from the demons who burned down the home she lived in, she walks into a member of
the Shadow Clan who is able to kill those demons. The decision that has been made to travel together, things work out fine
for the both of them right?

Characters: 4/5 We follow two main characters; Yumeko, who was raised by monks and was told to bring the scroll to
safety within another temple, so that the monks there will be able to protect it.
And Kage, from the Shadow Clan (I was/am not sure to actually trust..). He is looking for a scroll, not knowing that ever since
they met, Yumeko has that certain scroll strapped to her body. This is not he only thing he doesn't know about her...

Writing: 4/5 I personally like it when words in another language are thrown in, but only when they add to the story.
And they did! And I loved how they added another layer to the story.

Reread: Yes, I think I will. Also want to read the next book in this trilogy.

Was this review helpful?

Finally, I get the feudal Japan-inspired story full of mythology. I was hoping for just that in an earlier release this year, and was sadly disappointed. But my faith has been rewarded with Shadow of the Fox! It was very well done. The setting felt so familiar – having seen a lot of period drama’s from Japan – and there were so many mythological beings, some known and also a few unfamiliar ones. I liked seeing both the temple life, rural villages, as well as the larger cities with their splendour. The world is very much Japan-inspired, with similar names, language, culture and mythology, but a different history, leading to different type of clans and structure to society. It feels like a very natural version, like this is what it might have looked like, had youkai existed. We get all the staples of feudal Japan, even ninjas which are called shinobi which I like much better, ‘ninja’ just sounds so cringy to me.

I ended up really liking the group of characters that come together in this story. We only get two main perspectives, which is for the best I think. They sound and feel very different, and each get enough time to tell their side of the story. Yumeko got on my nerves a little bit at the start. She was very naïve, and while it made sense with her upbringing at the temple, at a certain point her not understanding sarcasm or jokes wasn’t believable anymore. Luckily the naiveté didn’t extend to dangerous situations, so in the end I came to like what she brought to the story. Tatsumi is our typical stoic male lead, with an interesting backstory which creates some believable tension. What was very refreshing was that there is actual communication between our leads. While of course not all secrets are shared, there is very little of the usual ‘mysterious male being frustratingly vague about why he’s dangerous’. Tatsumi tells her fairly quickly, and is as open as he can be, and I love him for it. It lets their connection build in a very believable way between them, and it’s a nice change from the usual scenarios in these stories. The supporting characters are all varied and cover a variety of backgrounds and motivations. Okame delivers some much need criticism of the honour system of the samurai, and society in general, and his sarcasm is a nice change from both Yumeko and Tatsumi’s tone. I love that we have now a noble, a miko and a priest along for the next leg of the journey, such a varied group. When it’s just the two of them you are kind of waiting for romance to develop – I liked that it wasn’t instantaneous, and that even near the end of the book we’re still just at the level of interest and a connection, enough to help the story, but not so much that it becomes unrealistic. I do wish that Tatsumi’s initial reaction to her was more due the fact that he could sense her half-youkai-ness rather than attraction – and who knows, maybe it was?

Now this is going to sound like a criticism, but it really isn’t. When I first started reading, the story reminded me very much of an anime I used to watch back in the day – one of the first ones I ever watched actually. Featuring a group of unlikely companions travelling through feudal Japan with youkai (demons) and yurei (ghosts), with one of them being a hanyou (their name for half-demons), hunting for parts of a magical object that can grant immense power – You can see how it sounds the same on paper. This is not a gripe though! I felt such nostalgia, and the characters and elements added to the story are different enough that it does its own thing. I adore this set up, and will always be there to read more of it. There was a nice variety in pacing between action scenes and more character-driven moments. My main and only gripe is that, for me, the writing had a tendency to be repetitive when it came to motivations – after a certain amount of time spent reading about characters I would hope that we know the character well enough to understand a certain motivation, when it has already been mentioned about ten times. I don’t need an explanation every time a characters makes a decision based on that motivation. There was also some over-explanation, where less would have been more, not to mention it made certain twists less surprising. Examples of the former would be Tatsumi constantly mentioning why he couldn’t have feelings every time he suppressed them. At some point we get it. An example of the latter would be Okame when the gang leader ordered them killed. Him saying out loud that he had promised they would be left alive, sounded not only naïve, but also made it quite obvious that he was going to switch sides. A disgruntled look, and perhaps an comment AFTER he double-crosses the gang, would have left at least some uncertainty as to what he was going to do. And this is really my only gripe with the story, over-explanation and too much emphasis where it didn’t need it for me. Maybe other people appreciated that more. It wasn’t enough to annoy me, it just made me start skimming those lines. There were plenty of things to make up for it.

This was a very enjoyable read, as my review already showed. It took me a minute to get the mood and pace of the story, and once I did, I was hooked. I flew through the book, coming back to it. I will definitely be picking up the next one, as I want to know where this story is going to go. It’s also really making me want to rewatch that anime!

Was this review helpful?

I was a little wary going into this book because I'd tried to read another book by this author earlier in the year and I really didn't get along with it. Thankfully, I loved this one!

This is a fantasy featuring a Kitsune and lots of Japanese folklore that was action packed and I can't wait for the next one!

Was this review helpful?

Dear Julie Kagawa, publishers and netgalley, I am so grateful to you guys for allowing me to read this early because it was one hell of a ride. I mean, what more can I ask for? Dragons, it got ‘em. Adventure, it’s got it. It was simply a masterpiece. Let me start from the beginning.

Every thousand years, this sacred Dragon is able to grant the wish of anybody who goes to him. But in order to call upon Kami The Dragon, you must read a prayer to him. However, to stop the bad guys getting the wish, the prayer has been split into many parts. The Scroll, which holds the prayer, is hunted for generations and generations in order to get the wish. Enter Kumeko, as her local temple burns to the ground, she escapes with its treasure; a piece of the scroll. She then encounters many people who would kill in order to get the full scroll. She must keep the secret of the scroll or her life will be on the line.

Overall I would give this read 4 out of 5 stars.

Was this review helpful?

Shadow of the Fox Showed Flashes of Brilliance

*Received from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review*

Let’s jump right into this shall we? Because this book doesn’t waste any breath throwing you into the mysterious and immersive world of Japanese myths. With an ominous tone, which foreshadows some of the darker themes, the scene is set. As someone who is fascinated by legends of kitsune, I found this more than lived upto any conception I had of it. I adored how distinctive stories, imbedded in a rich culture, were threaded through the narrative to create an exquisite reading experience.

One of the most effective ways this was achieved was through the fantastic characterisation of the main character- the girl who is half human, half mythical fox. Her voice was strong and had a wonderful comedic edge, which made the mood feel as perfectly balanced as a sword in the hand of a Samarai. Yumeko’s way of talking had a unique sense of innocence, while maintaining a humorous edge. Though she felt reminiscent of Puck from Kagawa’s Iron Fey series, she was also entirely distinctive and it felt great to have such a joyful character in the starring role for a change.

In case that wasn’t enough, comic relief came through in many of the other characters and really bounced off the more serious figures in the story. Through this contrast, the more murky personalities had a greater chance to shine. There were times when it did feel a bit headhoppy for me, but I also appreciated how every character- from Okame to the Kage warrior- had such strong and individual voices that this didn’t matter.

In terms of the rest of the writing, there was plenty of stunning imagery to maintain the illusion of this fantastical world. I especially appreciated how some images were cast against others in dichotomous harmony. Some descriptions were a tad samey- particularly since I saw exact words and images repeated on the same page- which, may seem like a nitpicky point (cos it is), made some parts feel repetitive. All in all, though, there were some standout lines in the book and the prose had a life of its own.

Though at times the story felt somewhat generic, the tension did climb towards the end. As much as I liked the way it started, the conclusion was even better. In a sensational finale, the book both closed a lot of chapters, but also opened up a path for new adventures. I for one can’t wait for more!

I’ll admit, I’ve had my ups and downs with Kagawa over the years- but one can’t argue that any of her books are ever the same. Sure, she plays to some of her strengths here, and that works a charm. Yet what’s really remarkable here is what she does differently. For all the teeny tiny flaws, this was a definite return to form for an excellent author. So all that’s left to say is I WANT MORE!

Rating: 4/5 bananas

Was this review helpful?

Trigger Warning: This book features abuse, discussion of desire to rape.

I loved the sound of Shadow of the Fox by Julie Kagawa when I first heard about it, but was a little wary as I hadn't enjoyed the other book by Kagawa I'd read in the past. However, Shadow of the Fox was a really facinating story, and one I thoroughly enjoyed!

Yumeko is half human, half Kitsune - a fox yōkai. She was abandoned on the doorstep of the Silent Winds Temple as a baby, and has been raised by months ever since. A natural mischievous prankster, she's spent the years being a nuisance to some of the less patient monks, doing chores, and learning from Master Isao about her magic and how to keep it hidden. But the turn of the new millenium is almost at hand, and Master Isao reveals to Yumeko the true purpose of the Silent Winds Temple; to keep a piece of an ancient scroll safe. It's a piece from the Scroll of a Thousand Prayer, and whoever has all the pieces will be able to call the Kami Dragon from his watery home at the turn of the millenium, and have one wish granted. When a horde of demons appear at the temple one evening, Master Isao forces Yumeko to run with the scroll piece with the instructions to seek out a Master Jiro at the Hayate shrine in Kin Heigen Toshi, the capital city if Iwagoto, and find out from him the secret location of the Steel Feather temple. It's the only place the scroll piece will be safe. The demons raze the temple to the ground, killing everyone in it, but not before the monks combine their forces together to hold the demons at bay in order for Yumeko to get away. But when she is discovered by some minor demons as she makes her escape, she is saved only by the appearance of Kage Tatsumi. A samurai assassin whose job it is to kill yōkai, the dark Shadow clan has sent him on a mission to the Silent Winds temple to retrieve the scroll, but he gets there too late. Using her natural kitsune instincts to trick and deceive, Yumeko convinces Tatsumi that the scroll piece had been sent on to the Steel Feather temple days before for safety, the monks doing danger was coming, and that is where she is heading, and persuades him to accompany her on her way there, to keep her safe. It's the only way to make sure she doesn't die, to complete her mission, and see that the scroll is safe. Even though she is in the company of one who would kill her without a thought if he knew she was kitsune, and especially if he knew she has the scroll.

I really loved Shadow of the Fox! It's such an awesome character driven story! It's dual narrated by Yumeko and Tatsumi, two characters who couldn't be more different. Despite being half kitsune, and therefore it being her nature to be deceptive, Yumeko is also innocent and filled with a child-like sense of wonder. She's never been anywhere except at the temple, and so their journey towards Kin Heigen Toshi gives Yumeko experiences she's never had before. She is excited and joyful about everything, and it's so beautiful to see someone so in awe of what most would take for granted. Even though she is quite a prankster, and finds tricking people amusing, she has been raised by monks, and so she is so good and so kind.

Tatsumi is the Kage's demonslayer and wields a sword named Kamigoroshi - The Godslayer - a sword inside which a violent, bloodthirsty demon full of rage, Hakaimono, is trapped. The sword helps Tatsumi to be practically unbeatable, but the demon is still conscious, and a bond between demonslayer and sword is always formed. Hakaimono can reach inside Tatsumi's head, and Tatsumi always has to fight to stay in control of the sword and of himself. He has been raised since he was very young to be emotionless, to withstand the harshest of treatment and feel nothing. For emotion is the way Hakaimono can slip inside him completely and take over. Any emotion is forbidden - the Shadow clan will kill him if there is any sign that Hakaimono might be able to take control. So he's never experienced kindness, or been touched with any kind of warmth or gentleness - at all, ever. Yumeko is unlike anyone Tatsumi has ever met before, because being in the company of anyone other than those in the Shadow clan for any length of time is forbidden, in case of emotion, but he has no choice this time. And Yumeko is so baffling to him, how she treats him like a human. Because, to the Shadow clan, he is not. He is a tool with a purpose, and must remain so, lest Hakaimono takes over and all hell breaks loose. But Tatsumi has his mission, he must retrieve the scroll or be executed, and Yumeko is the only person who can lead him to it's whereabouts, or so he believes. He is always walking on a knife's edge, but being in Yumeko's presence for days on end has made that knife all the more sharper, and staying free of emotion and keeping Hakaimono out of his head is becoming even more. As you can probably guess, there is a hint of romance. It's not the kind of romance we normally see, considering if Tatsumi knew the truth he would kill Yumeko, and so she is constantly trying to keep her true self and the scroll hidden. And considering Tatsumi is not allowed to feel anything. So it's the slowest of slow burns, jus the beginnings of the two coming to care for each other, but it was still so beautiful. I adored it!

There are other characters in the story who end up joining the two along the way, and the duo does become a band of people, do to Yumeko's kindness, and honour, and need to get the scroll to safety - despite Tatsumi wishing he could just get the damn scroll on his own, and be away from people who may cause him to feel anything. My favourite has got to be the ronin Okame, a former samurai who is without honour. He's straight talking and uncouth, and just completely hilarious. In a world where honour is everything, and you must be seen to doing and saying the right thing, Okame's lack of honour allows him to do and say as he pleases, and he's a breath of fresh air! He is so funny, but he's also loyal to those he decides matter, and is just brilliant. I don't want to say too much about the others because of spoilers, but they're such an interesting group, and it felt really familiar to the quest-style Western-inspired high fantasies I grew up on.

Speaking of Western-inspired, Shadow of the Fox is not. It's an #OwnVoices Japanese inspired high fantasy. We might not see much of the various yōkai, but the story was saturated with Japanese folklore as well as Japanese culture, and it's so immersive and gorgeous! It was just so fascinating! However, there were moments that felt slightly clunky, where information needed to be given to the reader about the various kami - gods - for example, but it was done so in conversation between people who would already know it. For example, they would all know that Tamafuku is a the God of Luck, but because we readers won't necessarily know that, they would say things like, "Tamafuku, the God of Luck, ..." It happened a few times that aspects of the culture or folklore were explained to the reader through conversation, when those characters would already know those things. It felt almost shoehorned in? And just a little clunky. But it's only a small thing.

The only other issue I had with the story is that, of the couple of people that we know of in this part of the series, we don't know what they want all the pieces of the scroll for. Obviously, it's to make a wish at the turn of the millenium, but what that wish is, we never know. It kind of makes sense that we don't know what the Daiyo - the leader - of the Shadow clan wants to wish for, because Tatsumi isn't important enough to know such things. He doesn't even know what the scroll does. He's just been sent to retrieve it. But, without spoilers, we do occassionally get to see what's happening with the other person who wants the scroll, away from Yumeko and Tatsumi, and so it would make sense there for us to know what wish this person would want to make? I mean, they are pretty desperate, considering all the things they throw at the two on their way to the capital. And towards the end we kind of find out something, but I do think we could have found that out earlier in the story, but still have known of the plans? Sorry to be cryptic, I don't want to give spoilers so I can't explain properly. I just would have liked to have known what people wanted to wish for. I think it might have added to the stakes a bit. These people cannot get hold of the scroll pieces, because if they do, X is going to happen. But we don't get that.

But again, that's just another small thing. On the whole, Shadow of the Fox is awesome. It's not quite as exciting, despite all the action that takes place - it feels more of a quieter high fantasy that's more about the people than it is about the action, but I loved that. And the ending, oh my god! Such a cliffhanger! I'm really excited to see where things will go in the sequel, Soul of the Sword, when it comes out in June next year!

Thank you to HQ Young Adult via NetGalley for the eproof.

Was this review helpful?

I received a free ebook version of this book from Netgalley. Thankyou to both Netgalley and the publisher for allowing me to read this! My review is still honest.

This was a really good one! It's not perfect, and I'm not wowed, but it had a lot of great aspects. I really enjoyed it.
Shadow of the Fox is set in a fantasy world based on Japanese mythology, centred around Kumeko, a half-kitsune (fox spirit) and Tatsumi, the bearer of a demon sword. It's difficult to summarise, but it was really cool!
The Japanese culture and mythology aspects were by far my favourite thing. I can't attest to the accuracy of the portrayal, but it was definitely more mesmerising and interesting than your typical YA fantasy setting. It also had a really enticing romance, and some very vivid characters. Tatsumi's struggles were very resonant, and I really liked some of the friends Tasumi and Kumeko picked up along the way. The demons and evil creatures were sufficiently scary, and the ending really makes you want the sequel now!
My issues were essentially with lost potential. For a mischievous kitsune spirit, Kumeko is very meek. She could have been so much more, but instead she's kind of like the all-kind, all-innocent maiden that the others have to protect. She has her badass moments, but I want to see more of them! I also felt like this could be a little repetitive and predictable, and in certain parts of the book, not much seemed to happen.
Nevertheless, this was a good one, and I'm excited for Soul of the Sword.

Was this review helpful?