Member Reviews
Starting in Belgium in 1939, this book is based on true events. Simone Lyon and Hava Daniels are best friends, and the stories about their life and adventures growing up together before 1939 are so beautiful; but the entire time you are reading, you know this story is not going to have a happy ending, because while Simone's father is a WW1 hero and goes on to do remarkable and brave deeds in WW2, Simone is Christian. Hava is Jewish.
'Ashes' tells the tale of two young girls fleeing Belgium and the invading Nazi army. Their friendship is told in such a touching way, most women remember a friendship they had while they were young, that they thought would last forever, while playing daft games and make-believe. I also really loved the ending, which made me absolutely sob my heart out.
Unfortunately, where this book lost for me, was the lack of terror the characters felt when they were running from overhead gunfire and bombs were dropping around them, or even when faced with the SS. Perhaps the girls had simply become numb in the face of fear, but this was not really shown well either. Additionally, how quickly Simone forgets her promise, and how long she takes to remember just does not wash with me. Considering the close bond between Simone and Hava, this promise should have been an obsession that she worked tirelessly at. The fact that she doesn't do this makes me feel like Simone values that relationship rather cheaply, and that makes me hate her a little.
'Ashes' is full of ordinary people with a focus on acts of kindness in the face of brutality and evil. I would happily recommend this book to teens and young adults who are looking to get into this sort of content. However, for people that have already read a lot of true stories based during this time or even non-fiction books about WW2, I would be more likely to recommend 'Night' by Elie Wiesel.
Beautifully written, another war story but told from a different perspective, I really enjoyed this book. Thanks for letting me review it.
I feel really bad rating a book on this subject with a low rating, and honestly I considered giving this book two stars, but ultimately I feel like this was the only rating I could give it.
I don't know what it was about this book but I just couldn't connect at all to the characters or the story; it almost felt like the writing was quite clinical and there were no real emotions pouring through. The events of the book should read as horrific and terrifying but the characters never seem to be portrayed in a way that shows their emotions or the impact of the events on them. Simone is the daughter of a General and can see in him the horrors of war and yet she spends the first half of the book in complete denial about what is going on, and then because she is his daughter she essentially gets free passage and food everywhere she goes.
I think part of the problem is the structure of the book; we get flashbacks throughout the events of the book but they tend to happen in line with events that are happening at the time so it's both jarring trying to figure our when we are, but also disrupts the flow of events that should horrify you. And then there are random quotes in the book from true events or world leaders which again takes you out of the flow of the writing. It almost felt like the author really skimmed the events of the book and focused almost entirely on the girls friendship; which yes came across as very deep, but it meant that the book felt almost superficial? I think it spent so much time setting up about the girl's lives in Brussels, then we get a quick few chapters on them fleeing, and then it's Simone's life afterwards; so I think it was the pacing and the structure of the book that took me out of it.
I do think this book portrayed their friendship well and you can see the love and affection they have for one another but ultimately I just felt no emotional connection to the book, which I am disappointed about.
Thank you NetGalley for allowing me to read an eARC of this book.
I was given an ARC from NetGalley in exchange for an independent review.
I enjoy reading books set against this period of time so from a historical point of view this was quite interesting.
But I found the writing a bit stilted and clinical which reduced the emotional impact for me. An ok read
3 stars
Thank you to NetGalley and HarperInspire for an advance reader copy in exchange for an honest review.
I'm not a huge reader of historical fiction, but I do tend to be drawn towards world war two era stories. Having read the Tattooist of Auschwitz I kind of expected this to be a rip off, of that. Bad of me, I know. Although I was really pleasantly surprised, going into this completely blind that this book is written from a Belgian perspective during the war. I'd never read a book about the war based on real events that was set from a Belgian perspective and I really enjoyed that this was something new and unique for me.
This book was equal parts enjoyable and heartbreaking, I absolutely adored the characters of Simone and Hava and the ending was incredibly bittersweet for these characters. I really liked the writing style of Christopher de Vinck, having never heard of this author before reading this book.
I definitely think this book is deserving of the four star rating, and I'd definitely recommend it for fans of historical fiction or world war two, holocaust era fiction.
Thank you to Netgalley and Harper Inspire for the arc of Ashes by Christopher de Vinck.
This is set in world war 2, historical fiction novel, which is actually based on true events!! which follows two young women, First is Simone whom is the daughter of World War I hero General Joseph Lyon, and Hana whom is Jewish. Germans invade belguim and are seperated from their families so they only have each other and they form a strong friendship. Until Hana is dragged away because she is Jewish, Simone is determined to find her after the war has ended. This is a heartwarming but emotional book about two girls who were inseperable then torn apart... i loved the story between these girls it is a rollercoaster of a book wow i loved it so much
5 stars! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Unfortunately I didn’t love this one as much as I was hoping to. I liked the idea behind it and the storyline, but it fell flat for me. I can see why some people love this one, but it just wasn’t for me.
Set in Belgium at the beginning of World
War II, this is the story of two friends. One the daughter of Belgian WW1 war hero, the other a Jewish girl. It's a slower book than many other books about the same period and similar subject but still a good read.
Very sad story to read, very harrowing. I didn’t know much about Belgium during WW2 and I’m glad I read this, even though it was upsetting and at times I had to put it down and read something else.
My thanks to Netgalley and the publishers for giving me the opportunity to read this book in return for an honest review.
A story about a friendship between two young women, one Christian and one Jewish, at around the time of the German invasion of Belgium during WWII and of the heartbreak, and terrible events that go hand in hand with war. A story of escape, separation, but always hope for a reconciliation.
Not my normal genre of reading material, however I found it well written and interesting...however, I found the ending rather abrupt, and in my mind, more could have been written about Hava's story. Many thank to Netgalley and the publisher for an advanced copy of this book.
A moving story of friendship between two young ladies born into different religions but just the same at heart. The more I read about war, the more I understand the suffering inflicted on millions of innocent people. The addition of facts before each chapter further drives it home. This book may be a little clunky in its writing style but it certainly gets the message across. It’s also been a while since I’ve liked a book cover but this one was very appealing. Thank you to NetGalley and HarperInspire for letting me read and review it.
An interesting story but lacking in the passion of some fairly similar themed books I have read recently e.g. The tattooist of Auschwitz and The cut out girl. It’s still worth the read though as the subject matter is important
Two girls, inseparable friends, one ghastly war but nothing will keep these two apart. This is a moving tale based on a true story around 1940s Belgium of friendship, the horrors and unfairness of war and the prejudices of ordinary people who get mixed up in surviving terrible conditions.
This is a very well written account of struggling in adversity and kept me hooked as to the outcome of the characters who I came to care for and for whom I wanted justice.
A highly recommended, gripping read.
Thanks to NetGalley and Harper Collins for the ARC
This book has everything that is needed for a really good story; finely drawn characters, action that moved along swiftly, pathos and an historically accurate background. The writing is excellent and I admire the skill of the author in producing such a special book. The story is so memorable that this book will stay with me for a long time to come. I do not hesitate to recommend it.
Ashes is a raw and moving story which illustrates just how powerful the bond of friendship between two people can be, as well as the adversity that can be overcome through having those we love close to us and despite the troubling times in which it’s set, de Vinck still infuses the tale with strength and dreams of one day again living in freedom once again. It's a heart-wrenching tale of hope, survival and friendship during World War Two by an award-winning essayist and is inspired by the author’s true and touching family history. It's July 1939 in Belgium, a mere few months before the start of the war, and Simone Lyon, the daughter of prominent and well regarded Major General Joseph Lyon, is inseparable from her close friend Hava Daniels, who hails from a devout Jewish family. When the war breaks out and the Germans begin their invasion of Belgium, both Simone and Hava devastatingly find themselves separated from their families and must rely on each other for support. When the Nazis start rounding up Jews, Hava is one of the unlucky ones and is taken away with very little idea of what awaits her. Simone vows to find her once the war is over. But will they ever be reunited?
Historical fiction set against the harsh and harrowing backdrop of WWII has really taken over the genre of late, however, what particularly drew me to Ashes was the fact that it revolves around a seemingly unbreakable friendship and platonic love rather than a relationship as in most of the others stories. It still tugs at the heartstrings just as much and I found myself moved almost to tears on some occasions and laughing out loud on others. You are taken on an emotional rollercoaster of ups and downs, peaks and troughs as you follow the meanderings and trials and tribulations they come face to face with. The two girls’ lives are brought vividly to life and you can't help but have your heart warmed by their enduring friendship. Set out in short chapters there are little sound bites, or epigraphs, from history at the beginning of each one which immerses you into the compassionate tale right from the start. The descriptions of incidents where they had to escape and evade the Nazi regime were terrifying even for me as merely a reader. It's clear extensive research has informed this narrative and the author has captured the zeitgeist of the time perfectly. Many thanks to Harper Inspire for an ARC.
A beautiful book about a friendship between Simone and Hava. Focused on the Nazi invasion of Belgium and the attempts of the two girls to escape the bombings and soldiers, I didn't want to put this book down. Highly recommended.
A beautifully written story about friendship, loss and love.
Set in Belgium, Hava and Simone meet as girls and become best friends. However, World War II tears their lives apart. Their innocence is obvious - Simone has no idea of the danger her friend is in as she hasn’t understood Hitler’s hatred for the Jewish community. This innocence left me afraid for both girls.
I know that some reviewers feel that this innocence in unrealistic, however, I can believe that many people truly believed that they would never be affected by the war and so would have been woefully unprepared for a Nazi invasion. Again, I know that there has been some criticism about the abrupt separation of Hava and Simone, however, I did not feel that it was rushed, I feel it was very realistic to what would have occurred - a blur of terror and confusion, and then, gone.
The start of each chapter has a quote in relation to WW2 and these add to the horrifying and upsetting background of the story, the hate and division spread by the Nazi party. Interestingly, reading it with the knowledge of recent events also shows that things are not that different in relation to the spread of hate and division, this time by the right wing political parties and their supporting media.
I really enjoyed this book and recommend it.
Belgium, July 1939: Simone Lyon is the daughter of a Belgian national hero, the famous General Joseph Lyon. Her best friend Hava Daniels, is the eldest daughter of a devout Jewish family. Despite growing up in different worlds, they are inseparable. In the spring of 1940, Nazi planes and tanks begin bombing Brussels, their resilience and strength are tested. Hava and Simone find themselves caught in the advancing onslaught and are forced to flee.
This is a touching and moving story about two women whose differences that once united them, will now be torn apart by Hitler's Nazi occupation. Of France and Belgium. Both women have strong bonds with their fathers. The story flows along at a decent pace through some horrific subject matter. The girls try to escape the Nazi but it all doesn't quite go to plan. I loved the authors writing style. The characters and plotline were complex. This is an emotional read. My only criticism is that I felt the ending was a bit rushed.
I would like to thank NetGalley, HarperInspire (HarperCollins Publishers UK) and the author Christopher de Vinck for my ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Wow what a truly fantastic read. Felt like I was there so well written and descriptive. Would highly recommend
This book is about two young women who live in Belgium in the Second World War. While they have very different characteristics, they are the best of friends. The war starts for them when Hitler invades Belgium and they are forced to grow up quickly when they witness many of the harsh realities of war.
It is certainly an interesting story and the fact that it is based on true events makes it even more touching. But I found the speech and thoughts of Simone (who is essentially the storyteller) as well as the other main character, Hava, to be a bit disjointed. She is supposed to be 18 and while I wouldn’t expect her to think or speak like someone who is twice their age, it just didn’t feel quite right. I would also like to have had more in the book about the real events that the story was based on.
Having said all of this, I did enjoy reading it and I’m glad that this story has been told. An absolutely heartbreaking account - one of too many from that period.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read this book and thank you to the author for bringing this story to light.