Member Reviews
After a thriving debut, Lina Bengtsdotter returns with the second volume in the Charlie Lager series and the final result is an even better novel than the previous one, For the Missing. The Swedish author creates a captivating story featuring a protagonist who bears some of the characteristics that are reminiscent of some of the most fabled main characters in Nordic crime fiction such as Mia Kruger, Harry Hole, and Tuva Moodyson. Charlie has a difficulty in establishing meaningful social relationships, exhibits a tendency towards alcoholism, and she more than often gets so immersed in her cases that she forgets to rest and find some time for herself. For the Dead is set, chronologically, a few months after the events that took place in the previous installment and Charlie is still striving to get over some of the most haunting memories from the case of Annabelle Roos's disappearance in Gullspång, the little town where Charlie used to live as a kid along with her mercurial mother, Betty. Annabelle's case proved to be connected with people that Charlie used to know well and some of the persons involved meant a lot to her. The cost that she had to pay both professionally and personally was immense and the beginning of the book finds her scarred and trying to put her life in order once again. Her boss, Challe, insists that she has to take time some time off in order to come in terms with everything that happened back in her hometown, but Charlie isn't particularly keen to the idea.
Things change for our protagonist when one of her most valued childhood friends, Susanne, tells her that she is getting divorced and asks for Charlie's help to cope with family obligations as she is a mother of four children. Inevitably, Charlie decides to takes a leave from work and returns to Gullspång where Susanne lives in order to comfort her old friend. Her reappearance to the place where she had been brought up triggers a barrage of memories for Charlie who didn't have a particularly happy childhood due to her mother's erratic, unstable behavior that often made her feel embarrassed and stigmatized by the others. While being in Gullspång, Charlie becomes interested in a cold case involving the vanishing of a 16-year-old girl, Francesca Mild, who was gone without a trace more than 25 years earlier. She soon becomes obsessed with finding out what really happened to Francesca even though she is off duty and most of the locals seem to be unwilling to share what they know about the case. Johan, Charlie's journalist friend and old flame, will be on her side and he will help her in her inquiries using his experience as a reporter.
Francesca Mild was a rebellious, untamed teenage girl who was in love with Paul Bergman, one of her classmates in the Adamsberg boarding school. When Paul was found dead, drowned in Gullspång's lake, the authorities ruled his death a suicide, but Francesca never accepted that version of events and claimed that Paul was a victim of a crime, possibly committed by some of her peers in Adamsberg who enjoyed to bully and intimidate him. Unfortunately, nobody seemed to believe her and after a failed suicide attempt, Francesca moves, along with her parents, in a mansion where the family is supposed to rebuild the burnt bridges between them and try to forget the traumatic past. The readers follow the story which is narrated in alternating chapters between Charlie's rogue investigation and Francesca's first-person account of the events and feelings that took hold of her after Paul's untimely death. The pacing is even and the major part of the story unravels through the heavy use of dialogue parts that makes the novel easy to read, while the double timeline narrative is expertly handed by Bengtsdotter who reveals the critical plot points gradually and as the story progresses, Charlie's investigation and Francesca's narration merge into one.
Charlie has, once again, a personal stake in the story as it seems that her mother, Betty, was involved in some obscure way with the Mild family and as the plot evolves the memories from her childhood resurface and perplex her. She is a headstrong character, despite her many weaknesses and vices, and when she takes on a case, she won't rest until she solves it. As her investigation evolves she confronts many of the people that she had interrogated, in an official capacity, a few months back during the Annabelle case. Many of them treat her suspiciously and the largest part of Gullspång's closed-knit community seems not to be particularly inclined to help her find out what happened to a girl who was not a member of their closed club. Charlie will have to use all her cunning in order to overcome the people's reluctance and discern the truth from the lies.
For the Dead is a well-rounded Nordic crime novel featuring a gripping plotline, a lot of characters, and a satisfying conclusion. It will be much appreciated by the fans of Scandinavian crime fiction and especially those who enjoy reading about cold cases being reopened. Even though it's not necessary to have read the first book in the series, it would help you to be acquainted with many of the recurring characters and comprehend the special circumstances and bonds between them. So, I would urge you to read For the Missing first in order to be able to fully grasp even the tiniest detail of the story and sympathize with both the protagonist and some of the secondary characters. I would like to thank Netgalley and the publisher for providing a free ARC of this title in exchange for an honest review.
Unfortunately, I have not been able to read and review this book.
After losing and replacing my broken Kindle and getting a new phone I was unable to download the title again for review as it was no longer available on Netgalley.
I’m really sorry about this and hope that it won’t affect you allowing me to read and review your titles in the future.
Thank you so much for giving me this opportunity.
Natalie.
Over the past few years we’ve seen a surge in translated works from the Scandinavian countries and English readers now have an overwhelming selection of outstanding crime novels to choose from. Unfortunately the flooding of the Scandi-noir mass market also means that predictable plots and one-dimensional characters do seep through the cracks. For The Dead is not one of them.
Full review is available here: https://wanderingwestswords.wordpress.com/2020/03/14/for-the-dead-lina-bengtsdotter/
I really enjoyed the first Charlie Lager book, For The Missing, so I was dead keen to read the follow up, For The Dead. This is a series where you will want to start from the beginning, so as not to miss anything about the character of Charline Lager. Charlie is a Detective Inspector with the Stockholm Police and right now she is struggling. Thanks to the events of For the Missing, she is drinking too much and over medicating on anti-depressants.
As with the first book, this series is character driven and Charlie is front and centre of what is going on. Drawn back to her home town of Gullspång, Charlie has become fascinated a cold case from 1989. Francesca Mild was only 17 when she disappeared from her home; police thought she may have been a runaway whilst others speculated that she was so distraught by the supposed suicide of her friend, Paul Bergstrom that she too may have taken her own life, though a body has never been found.
Journalist Johan Ro is also interested in this case and despite the fact that many in the police department think Charlie leaked information on a past case to him, the two decide to work together as Charlie takes time off to investigate outside of police auspices.
The story is told in a dual narrative, Charlie in the present day and Francesca in the past. Charlie becomes fascinated by Francesca, not least because she can’t remember anyone in Gullspång talking about this case when she was around investigating another missing girl case and she can’t understand why that would be.
Coming home to Gullspång causes emotional turmoil and the resurgence of many memories, not all of them pleasant for Charlie and as the book progresses it seems as if Charlie and Francesca’s lives have more than just Gullspång in common.
Not everyone is happy that Charlie and Johan are looking into Francesca’s death and those who are not are more than ready to show it. The original police investigation begins to look very sloppy indeed with Francesca’s mental health frequently cited as the reason for her behaviour and no-one looking behind her actions to try and understand why she would behave as she did.
This is the strength of Lina Bengtsdotter’s writing. She is all about the psychology and depth of her characters, wanting the reader to understand what motivates them and why they are driven to act as they do. In investigating Francesca’s death, Charlie is also learning a lot about herself and her own upbringing. Once more she is confronted with ghosts from her past and fragments of memories of her mother keep popping into her head and will not go away. These are often things she would rather forget. But this sleepy village does not make that easy; this is a small place where everyone knows a bit of her history.
In Gullspång, there is also someone for whom the past is still very much alive; someone who is prepared to keep the truth hidden whatever the cost.
Verdict: The second in the Lager series lets the reader in to more of Charlie’s past and contains some surprising and shocking revelations that will undoubtedly impact on future books. The case is beautifully plotted and the atmosphere is delightfully tense with the disparate fragments coming together to tell a sad and intense story. Terrific writing and brilliantly drawn characters make this a compelling read. I do wish the translator was credited though – could not find that information anywhere.
This is definitely a novel that needs to be read in sequence! Unfortunately I had not read the first in the series so found this one hard to get into because an awful lot of the story relates to the first in the series so I can't give the greatest review due to being utterly confused alot of the time.
On a positive note the story is written amazingly well and the atmosphere created is fantastic. The characters are likeable and relatable, showing the strength of friendship and gut instinct.
I will go back and read the first novel and then reread this one before giving a full and honest review, so for now I won't be star rating it fully. For now i give 3*
Huge thanks to netgalley and Orion Publishing for the ARC.
For the Dead is the second police procedural in the Detective Inspector Lager series and it reminds me exactly why I love Scandi noir with a passion. Stockholm Detective Charlie is drawn back to her hometown of Gullspång and becomes interested, thanks to journalist Johan bringing it to her attention, in a cold case from 1989 when seventeen-year-old Francesca Mild vanished from her home in a case which was never solved. Charlie decides she is going to investigate, ably assisted by friends, to try to bring the family some closure as to what happened to their daughter. As she begins to dig deeper she quickly comes to the realisation that the official investigation had been seriously flawed from the get-go. And when some of the townsfolk catch sight of her prying into the case many make their displeasure known. The original investigators appear to have assumed Francesca was a teen runaway and that her vanishing was precipitated by her friend Paul Bergman's apparent suicide. By all accounts, it seemed that the police couldn't close her case fast enough. But why? What is there to hide?
Francesca refused to believe that Paul committed suicide or drowned by accident; she thinks he was murdered and puts her investigative skills into action trying to uncover the truth. This possibly rubbed someone up the wrong way. Told from the perspective of Francesca in the past and Charlie’s investigation and what she uncovers in the present, I thoroughly enjoyed hearing from both the victim and the seeker of justice. It made me incredibly sad that her disappearance was not taken seriously and her poor mental health was frequently cited as a get-out clause for the police. The atmosphere created was one of the standout aspects of the book where the ominous weather adds to the overall tension. It's a slow-burn, character-driven thriller yet this doesn't stop you being glued to the pages. It is an intricately plotted, intense and beautifully written piece of fiction. I look forward to the third instalment and being reacquainted with Charlie. Highly recommended. Many thanks to Orion for an ARC.
I would like to thank Netgalley and Orion Publishing Group for an advance copy of For the Dead, the second novel to feature Stockholm detective Charlie Lager, set in her home town of Gullspång.
Journalist Johan Ro interests Charlie in a missing person’s case from 1989 where 17 year old Francesca Mild disappeared from her home near Gullspång, never heard from again. On holiday in Gullspång Charlie decides to investigate unofficially with help from Johan and meets a wall of silence.
I really enjoyed For the Dead which is more character driven than fast paced action and not my usual fare. It is told alternately from Francesca and Charlie’s point of view so the reader has more information than the investigator but rather than make it boring it makes it more interesting as both have an interest in events and a completely different angle.
Francesca is depressed after the death of her best friend, Paul, who drowned in the lake at their boarding school. An accident is the official explanation, suicide is the generally accepted solution and Francesca, alone, believes he was murdered and sets about investigating. Francesca, however, has a history of mental health issues so the reader never knows whether to believe what she says or not, her parents and doctor definitely don’t. She has a compelling story to tell and I found myself caught up in it, even though she wanders about her timeline over the course of her narrative. I guess it reinforces her fragility.
Charlie, on the other hand, is initially interested in the case because nobody mentioned Francesca when she was last in Gullspång looking for another missing teenager. She soon realises that her mother, Betty, has a role in Francesca’s story and that spurs her on. The novel is as much about her trying to reconcile her past and present to find some peace as it is about her investigation. I think she takes a few steps in the right direction in this novel but she’s still a troubled soul. I didn’t find her story as compelling as Francesca’s, perhaps because it’s mostly more mundane, but she’s certainly a more relatable character, making poor choices and trying to do better.
For the Dead is a good read that I have no hesitation in recommending.
I haven’t come across Lina Bengtsdotter before but I am now adding her previous DI Lager book on my list!
This books is about Francesca, a girl who disappeared at the same time her friend was found dead in a lake. Drawn back to Gullspäng DI Lager finds herself looking into this disappearance, finding the original investigation flawed. DI lager wants to know what happened years ago, but her investigation starts stirring up the town and resentments and forgotten memories are beginning to surface. What will happen if the truth is revealed?
Compelling writing with amazing descriptions, Lina Bengtsdotter really kept me hooked in this book.
This book is more focused on the problematic relationships and vulnerabilities of the characters, I personally am a bigger fan of fast paced mystery and thrillers but this book surprised me and I couldn’t put it down.
The author sets the scenes perfectly and you start learning more about DI Lager as you read along.
I am aware there is a third book in the pipeline and I can’t wait to read it! The first one is also definitely on my list!
Special thanks to #netgally and #orionbooks for the opportunity to read this book prior to its publishing date in exchange for an honest review.
For the Dead is the second book in the Charlie Larger series. Having been able to read the first book at the beginning of 2019 and thoroughly enjoying it, I was really pleased to be able to start 2020 by tucking into book 2. At the time I got hold of a copy of the book I had not read any of the blurb, so actually had no idea what it was about and if I am totally honest that didn’t bother me one bit.
Still reeling from the revelations from the case that took her back to her hometown of Gullspång, Charlie finds herself drawn back there and to the unsolved case of a missing girl. The original investigations had Francesca down as a runaway after her best friend Paul Bergman had drowned in an apparent suicide. Intrigued why the case had never been mentioned when she was last in town and by how quick the original case had been closed Charlie starts doing some digging, a fact that is not very popular with quite a few people.
The book is told in part from Francesca’s viewpoint in the past and via Charlie’s investigations in the present. Whilst it took me a little time to get used to this as with each change of viewpoint there was also a change of pace, it didn’t detract from my enjoyment of the book. The more I read about Francesca’s life before she disappeared, the more I felt her frustration with her family and her school about how none of them believed her and put her down as being troubled and disruptive. These days her behaviour would probably be put down to something like ADHD and would be managed differently.
This case also opens up more of Charlies past and she slowly starts to understand the dreams that have been plaguing her and she finds that she has links to the missing girl that will have repercussions in her future. You start to get a real insight into what makes her tick and the reasons behind some of her actions. The more she digs into the past the more she (along with me) has to find out why everyone is against her digging into the case.
Normally I would say that most books could be read out of sequence in a series however in this case I would recommend that you read For the Missing before reading For the Dead as otherwise some references may not make sense and you may be left a little confused. Overall I enjoyed this book and look forward to reading more about Charlie Lager in the future