Member Reviews

Firstly I’d like to thank Penguin UK for the ARC of this novel. Also thanks to NetGalley for facilitating. And of course thank you to Samantha Downing for writing another book!

So, as usual there will be no spoilers in this book review.

I was fascinated by Samantha’s first book, My Lovely Wife, so when I saw that she was releasing another book I knew I HAD to read it! Sadly, this book had no where near the same impact as the first but had a whole heap of potential!

The characters were complex and interesting. Every single one made me want to know their story and kept me turning the pages.

The story was also complex and full of twists and turns. This was certainly another book packed with the dark side of people. Plenty of secrets to uncover and they didn’t disappoint.

Much like with My Lovely Wife the twists were not obvious and so the book remained thrilling and a definite page turner that I couldn’t put down.

Now we come to the crux of it though, why the 3 stars when everything above is glowing... the ending. It was not good. At all. Such a let down and an anticlimax. The whole book had been building towards a moment that felt like it was over in a few short, lacklustre pages. There was no time to FEEL anything that was going on so the climax was very flat and emotionless as a reader. And it could have done with actually having a conclusion. It felt unfinished. All throughout the book I felt satisfied with the read, it was “filling me up” but after the book “finished” (or didn’t finish as it felt), I felt very deflated and “oh... that was it then...?” Not how it should have ended and felt like the anticlimax was a huge injustice to the amazing book that preceded it.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely loved My Lovely Wife and was so looking forward to this. However I found it hard to get into and the flashbacks were at times confusing. The family characters were interesting but the story itself I just lost interest in.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley for the chance to read this in exchange for an honest review.

This is the second book I have read by Samantha Downing I absolutely loved "My lovely Wife" and I would say it was one of my most memorial read so perhaps my expectations were simply too high but I am sad to say I didnt like this book at all. The book was very slow, too slow for me. I found I disliked all the characters so cared very little for what was going on and I was just wishing it would end. I did complete the book but I did skip quite a bit but even so I found it predictable and very uninteresting. This will not put me off reading more of Samantha's books but sadly for me this one missed the mark.

Was this review helpful?

When their grandfather dies, Eddie, Beth, and Portia are set to inherit a life-changing sum. There is one caveat to this inheritance. They must repeat a road trip they took with their grandfather as children with a few specific rules that they must complete it exactly as it was originally made, without any deviation and must not end up in jail and scatter his ashes at the end.

The three are selfish and manipulative and being cooped up together on a road trip that had sufficient bad memories from the first time is going to be difficult.

As we follow their present-day road trip, which includes visits to some more gruesome attractions such as the shootout whether Bonnie and Clyde met their fate, we are given flashbacks to the original trip and get some huge surprises along the way.

Very well written and an unpredictable plot.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed My Lovely Wife but I loved this, you couldn’t imagine a more messed up but seemingly functional family than feature in this book, and not just the siblings either to be fair. A road trip can be testing even for those families that get on well but when you’re retracing a memorable (and not in a good way) trip you took with your grandad in your youth for the purpose of ultimately scattering his ashes with siblings you neither trust not can be trusted with it’s never going to end well. Not one character is likeable but they’re all the more compelling for it, you have no idea what they might do, whether any can be trusted and you’re left wondering what twist is going to hit you next. This is a creepy page turner that I raced through in no time as I couldn’t wait to see what would happen next and just how it would all end.

Was this review helpful?

A good and solid suspense thriller. I did prefer the first half to the second I did think that it dipped towards the end however all in all an exciting book which maintains your attention.

Was this review helpful?

Eddie, Beth and Portia are not close siblings but when their grandfather dies they gather together, as he has left them an unusual request in the will, they all repeat the road trip that they went on with their granddad.

The will stipulates; “That anyone who ends up in jail, who does not complete the trip, or who deviates from the original trip in any way, will get nothing”

There is a large inheritance for them if they can complete the road trip and scatter his ashes. Sounds EASY but you know this will be the road trip from hell and with siblings like these who needs enemies!! They are vile, manipulative liars who are out for themselves. So maybe not such a jolly holiday after all!!

The story is told in two timelines in the present and back in 1999 when they all went on their road trip, which sees them visiting some strange and gruesome tourist places such as where Bonnie and Clyde died!!

I simply couldn’t read this book fast enough as I was completely hooked and wanted to know the ending. I finished this and was like WOW, I felt like I had just come off a rollercoaster, dizzy and not sure what the hell just happened!!! Took me a second or two to comprehend the ending.

Thank you to Netgalley for my copy in exchange for a review.

Was this review helpful?

Oh my goodness - what a twisted story this one is! I enjoyed the author's previous story immensely and this one certainly did not disappoint. It was shocking, hilarious in places and entirely un-putdownable and raced to a surprising conclusion. Highly recommended.

Was this review helpful?

I can't review this as the copy I was sent to review is unreadable, with random numbers in every second line of text. I would be happy to read if a new download becomes available, however. It sounds like my kind of novel.

Was this review helpful?

Love Samantha ! Like her deliciously awfull characters
Dark twisty tales , unsympathetic characters never quite sure wat the truth is
I did have a confusing time at times as I strangely thought the twist way at the start ...then half way through thought ahhh it's that person and actually I'd been right from the off
This was down to slightly confusing journel. It was almost too ambiguous who's voice we meant to think it is so I thought it was the characters I thought it was right from the start not through being clever just um muddled
Then with the reveal I thought it I thought that from the v begining
However doesn't ruin it just pay attention
Great intrigue
Lots of dubious characters
Lots of untruths
Enjoy the road trip and u will crave another
one
Ty netgalley and publishers for this advanced copy

Was this review helpful?

I was a huge fan of My Lovely Wife so was very excited to read Samantha Downing's latest book. While this doesn't initially strike as a typical thriller, I'd struggle to label it as any other genre. When this group of siblings were children, their grandfather took them on a very unusual road trip. In his will he declares that his significant inheritance will be left to them only on the condition they complete the same trip again and scatter his ashes in a designated spot. I found this book totally gripping and I genuinely could not put it down- I finished it in just over a day. It's so unlike anything else I've read recently and I wholeheartedly recommend it!

Was this review helpful?

Sophmore slump, unfortunately.

A road trip does not lend itself to a thriller. You shoot yourself in the foot almost immediately because you slow down the pace. From the first couple of chapters, you lose the tension, you lose the tight pacing that makes a thriller something you want to gobble up in a handful of sittings. Downing's first book 'My Lovely Wife' had that in spades - but it's missing here. Sadly, I just didn't enjoy this one as much as her debut - and I definitely didn't get the same kind of feeling reading it as I did before.

Also a small thing, but the formatting on this was really weird - there was numbers and stuff all over it, which made it really hard to read.

Was this review helpful?

Downing can write. She manages to put suspense into a ten-day road trip across the country.

The solution was a teeny-tiny bit predictable, but that's basically what kept me reading, I wanted to know whether I was right.

Was this review helpful?

Downing excels at writing unsympathetic characters in a deeply entertaining way. How much you like the book may well depend on how much you enjoy a literal journey with horrible people.

Onto the plot:

Three adult siblings, Beth, Eddie and Portia are on a road trip across America - out of necessity, not affection. Their grandfather has died and they must replicate the same journey they completed as children if they want to take his inheritance. Two partners are along for the ride as well.

The journey starts off okay - there's bickering and awful museums to visit, but that's par for the course. Then they start being followed, tensions rise, and is that paranoia or are people really out to get them?

Beth warns you in the opening pages that she's not a heroine. That she's done bad things, that she'll probably keep on making bad choices. She soon alludes to family secrets, long-buried since their first trip with Grandpa, that start teasing their way out.

There's a lot she holds back from the reader and that both makes for a compelling page-turnery sort of read (and I read this in one day), but occasional irritation too. You're not reading to find out whodunnit, but what did he start (as per the title), and what does it mean? When you start to suspect that your main character has all the answers from the beginning, it can feel a tad frustrating when she keeps you hanging on for dear life.

Oh and don't start kidding yourself that Beth might transform into an underdog/good person heroine after all. Downing doesn't lie. And Beth doesn't transform.

It took me a little while to get into He Started It, purely because it took a while for Beth to actually tell me what the main plot was, but once she did I had to keep on reading.

3.5 stars rounded up to 4 for the moment, which means I liked it but didn't love it. Downing kept my attention and I'd certainly read her again, but I don't think I'd particularly want to spend any more time with this set of characters.

Was this review helpful?

This was for me a really strange book to review as I’m still not sure just how I feel about it, I enjoyed reading it but I just didn’t connect at all with the characters. Full of twists and a very unreliable narrator in Beth it’s the story of a road trip by three siblings to scatter their grandfathers ashes and recreate a road trip they had originally done with their grandfather when they were much younger.
The story is a compulsive one but I did find at times it stretched belief and was rather slow however I found that I still needed to continue reading just to find out what exactly had happened in that first road trip and how that was affecting this later one. So it was a read I enjoyed but did not love although I think maybe others will, it was an original story and very well written and with a whole heap of secrets it did keep my attention so a 3+ read rounded up to 4 just for the craziness!!
My thanks to NetGalley and Penguin UK - Michael Joseph for giving me the chance to read the ARC in exchange for my honest opinion.

Was this review helpful?

A wicked-fun read with razor-sharp wit and a killer twist, He Started It is compelling, captivating, and deliciously dark. Samantha Downing writes with a wry, sparse elegance that steadily entangles you until you’re utterly addicted.

In He Started It, we get three unapologetically sinister siblings heading out on a road trip to fulfil their wealthy grandfather’s final wish and secure their inheritance. But none of them are exactly who they seem.

Like My Lovely Wife, He Started It blurs the line between who is good and who is bad, expertly exploring the theme of how much ‘bad’ you can do if it’s in the name of love. A novel that should be high on everyone’s must-read list for 2020!

Was this review helpful?

From the author of "My Lovely Wife" comes this tale of twists, turns and power grabs. This tells the story of three siblings: Eddie, Beth and Portia who are dispatched on a road trip by their late grandfather. Their mission: to retrace the exact steps they took on the last road trip when they were kids. The rules: They must not deviate from the route, they must visit the same places, they must end in the same place, scatter his ashes and no one must get arrested. The Prize: A third share of his estate, estimated at around $8 million.

The action flicks backwards and forwards between the first road trip, taken when their grandfather took them away while their parents sorted out their problems, and this road trip. Haunted by the events of the past and a truck of heavies who appear to be following them, the tension ramps up between the siblings and for the reader too. This takes many twists and turns and the only thing that you can be sure of is that everyone is lying...

A great read that I just couldn't put down. I loved 'My Lovely Wife' but this is so much better!

Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This is a story of a road trip across America that Eddie Beth and Portia are obliged to take if they want to receive their inheritance from their very wealthy Grandfather .Twenty years before when they were all children their Grandfather decided to take them on the same road trip, only then there were 4 siblings ! It seems to me that the siblings and the Grandfather were all very nasty people in their own ways .This story is about greed lies and betrayal but it was very hard to put down full of twists and turns and the ending was wow just wow ! I have no words !! I loved My Lovely Wife but this book was even better .many thanks to the Publisher the Author and NetGalley for my preview copy in return for an honest review .

Was this review helpful?

Having read her first novel, ‘My Lovely Wife’, I felt that this couldn’t be as good, but it is. Another storming read from this author.

The story is about three siblings who do not get on – no real surprise there. When their grandfather dies, he leaves the huge amount of money to be shared between the three of them providing they repeat a road trip he took them on when they were children. There are certain criteria they must follow.

Eddie, Beth and Portia are the three siblings but Eddie’s wife and Beth’s husband are along for the ride as well. The narrator is Beth and there are tensions between everybody at different stages along with an underlying humour at certain points.

As the journey progresses the reader is taken around so many twists, turns and unknowns. The final chapter is a stunner.

Thank you to NetGalley, Penguin UK, Michael Joseph, and Samantha Downing for my ARC in return for my honest review.

Another brilliant read. Highly recommended.

Was this review helpful?

Wow what a ride.

Well more a road trip but it's still a ride & a half. Beth plus a brother and a sister have to complete a road trip they did with there Grandpa 20 years ago & were still living at home. Now they live well away from each other but to get their inheritance that's the deal in the will. (Pure poetry I know). They have to take their Grandpa's ashes to scatter them at the end of the trip.
The trip is across America heading towards the Pacific Ocean taking in all the sites they visited before. The 3 know what to expect Beth's husband and Eddies new wife ( he has recently dumped his long term live in girlfriend for his secretary !!!!!).
The trip starts off with being attached on the road by a black truck leaving a done in tyre the won't be the first time they have to change tyres but i will let you read about that yourself
I loved Samantha's previous book "My Lovely Wife" and if you haven't read it yet get that as well but I think this one is even better. It has great twists very believable characters with their own colour to brighten your read. Plus a ending that will blow your mind. So what I'm saying is this is a fantastic thriller I really loved it & hope you do too, it's well worth it buy some extra for friends if you want I'm sure some of them will treat you once they see how good it is

Was this review helpful?