Member Reviews

I expected to like this more than I did. The writing is a bit stilted in parts, and there's a lot of over-explaining going on. The most interesting characters are not actually the main characters, and I wished the book had been written from Parveneh's point of view - her story is far more gripping. I loved learning about an area of myth and fantasy I (shamefully) knew little about. I'd love to have had more from that angle.

Was this review helpful?

2.5 ⭐️

I’ll be honest, I struggled with this book. The cover is beautiful, it hooked me in, but the story didn’t match those expectations. The story is a fairy tale, Soraya has been cursed since she was a child, isolated in hiding because her touch is poisonous, she dreams of love and company and yet all she can do is watch her family, including her twin brother, rule the land. Then she catches Azad’s eye, a mysterious young man who wants to help make her dreams come true and unravel the truth of her curse.

My biggest issue with this book was Soraya - her circumstances are incredibly sad, her loneliness is the true poison in her blood and yet I had no sympathy for her because she was constantly the victim, even when her actions hurt (and kill) people. Other characters hurt her out of thoughtlessness, or rather too much thought, their intentions are routed in a misguided kindness, however her own actions would very clearly cause harm and even after that, she’s still complaining about people not looking at her or getting the right love. I found her quite insufferable in that way. I did like Parvaneh though, I would have actually preferred a lot more about her sisters and her. I found her sweet, determined and interesting in a way that made me wish she had a 1st person POV.
The romance as well - literally 1 character has 2 romances, 1 for each half and neither are developed to believability and she betrays both, it’s just instant love, there was even a 3rd character hinted about that they loved! Yes I get that a character isolated will have limited emotional maturity and a desperate need to be loved but that damage isn’t even explored.

To balance it out, I will say that the book is enjoyable, if you can get past the main character. It didn’t feel new but there’s something comforting in reading a book that takes you to a destination you know.

Thank you netgalley for the book in exchange of an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

"Stories always begin the same way: There was and there was not. There is possibility in those words, the chance for hope or despair."

Girl, Serpent, Thorn is based on Persian mythology. It centres around a princess who was cursed by a div to be deadly to anyone who touches her. She is kept a secret, locked away and confined to a life of loneliness and solitude.

This book drew me in from the first chapter and kept me wanting more. I really enjoyed the Persian mythology, I hadn’t heard the stories before, and I am interested in hearing/reading more of them.

This story isn’t clear cut good-evil. There is a moral ambiguity to the main character that makes her interesting. She is trying to navigate a world that she thought she knew. She’s trying to cope with lies that she has been told. Can anyone blame her for the steps she takes in this novel? Her internal conflicts and struggles are portrayed extremely well.

I would’ve like to have seen more of the Soraya beyond her curse and as a character who’d been locked away it would’ve been interesting to see her navigate and interact with the world more. To see her learning new things about it. I would’ve also liked to see more of the side characters and her relationships with them.
Shahmar, the main antagonist is a strangely interesting character. He is complicated, twisted and yet still human beneath his demonic façade. We got to hear about how he became the person that he is, through manipulation and destiny and it added layers to his character.

Parvaneh was another character I really enjoyed. She is flawed, she made a big mistake that she has spent her life trying to fix. Her story showed just how powerful words can be. Just with her words she caused a pretty major event to happen.

The budding romance that develops in this novel doesn’t detract from the overarching story, and I really liked that we got to see that develop alongside the main plot. The scenes where you see their blossoming relationship are beautiful and the girls really support and trust each other.

This story is intricate, enthralling and well-written. Bashardoust writing style flows well and is poetic. The characters are complex, and the question of what makes a monster runs throughout the novel. It reads like a fairy-tale and with each rising tension, she had me wanting more. I highly recommend the novel and look forward to seeing what she writes next.

Was this review helpful?

There was real potential for this fairy-tale based on Persian mythology to break new ground but while the marketing focuses on this an the thread of queer romance what the reader is actually presented with is a rather stale and derivative fantasy. Yes, there's a hint of queer feelings between Soraya and her twin's wife but this is largely overtaken by a very traditional fantasy love between Soraya and one of the male characters for much of the book. Neither relationship is convincing. Soroya, whose touch is poison to anyone she touches feels childish and self-pitying throughout, she can never see why others might see or feel things differently to herself and lacks any depth or development that would keep this from being anything except extremely irritating.

The biggest weakness is the painfully wooden writing. Every event and emotion is explained so that the reader has no input or investment. Everything is unambiguously telegraphed so that characters are utterly flat and the plot easy to predict. Almost impossible to finish.

Was this review helpful?

“𝐵𝑒𝒶𝓊𝓉𝒾𝒻𝓊𝓁 𝓎𝑒𝓉 𝒹𝑒𝒶𝒹𝓁𝓎, 𝒽𝑒 𝒽𝒶𝒹 𝒸𝒶𝓁𝓁𝑒𝒹 𝒽𝑒𝓇. 𝒮𝑜𝓂𝑒𝒽𝑜𝓌, 𝒽𝑒 𝓂𝒶𝒹𝑒 𝑜𝓃𝑒 𝓈𝑜𝓊𝓃𝒹 𝒶𝓈 𝓈𝓌𝑒𝑒𝓉 𝒶𝓈 𝓉𝒽𝑒 𝑜𝓉𝒽𝑒𝓇”

Girl, Serpent, Thorn is a book based on Persian mythology and is centered around a princess who was cursed by a demon (or Div as the book refers) to be poisonous so that anyone who touches her dies almost instantly. As a result of this, she is kept a secret, confined to a life of mostly solitude and loneliness.

Tempted by a demon lying below the palace she resides in that could hold all the answers she craves and a mysterious soldier who does not treat her a something to be feared she makes choices that lead to consequences she never could have expected. This leads her to question the type of person she really is; good or evil, princess or monster.

REVIEW
I was drawn in by the description of this book but I have to say It completely surprised me and was not at all what I expected. I expected some romance with some fantasy elements thrown in but what I got was an empowering tale with twists and turns that gripped me so much that I read most of the book (27 of the 30 chapters) in one day.

The book had a fast pace that kept me interested from the beginning, and even though I usually manage to guess big reveals in books this one managed to surprise me. The Persian mythology throughout was exciting and new to learn about as I’d never encountered it before and was extremely refreshing.

I loved the moral ambiguity and greyness of the main character as she tried to navigate what to do as the world she new quickly changed- Is it right to lash out against those who have wronged you? Or does that make you no better than them? The way her internal struggle was depicted was very believable.

Overall I really enjoyed this book, though at times I did feel that I didn’t know much about the main character, Soraya, besides her curse but that may be deliberate since being locked away as a secret meant she didn’t really have a chance to live. However, I would’ve enjoyed learning more about her as it would have added more depth to her overall character. The ending seemed a bit rushed however it was a satisfying conclusion to the book and I recommend reading it.



I received an eBook ARC from Netgalley of Girl, Serpent Thorn in return for an honest review, this does not affect my opinion or rating in any way.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely adored this book. Melissa Bashardoust's vivid and lush writing makes this read like an epic or fairytale. Right from the first few pages, I instantly connected with the characters, and the skillful writing made it easy to fully imagine them and understand their motives and actions. I tore through this and read it in just two days. I found the story to be mystical and compulsive and I honestly can't wait to read more from Bashardoust.

Was this review helpful?

A princess locked away for safety. Not her own safety, but the safety of her people, thanks to her curse. A mysterious boy who sees her for who she is, not the title she holds. Sounds like your average fairytale right? You would be completely wrong.

What can I say about this book? I knew it was going to really enjoy it by the time I got to chapter six, and fell in love by chapter twelve. The storyline was intriguing and kept me wanting more. Soraya's character development was a breath of fresh air, not the typical 'boy saves princess and releases her from her curse so she has no personality' trope.

The book was welll paced, and I didn't feel overloaded with unnessecary informationthat you needed to hold on to for 10 chapters ahead. My only complaint is that the story had to end!

Was this review helpful?

I’m always in for a good fantasy book, let alone DIVERSE fantasy books. Girl serpent thorn met almost all my expectations.
Beyond this gorgeous cover, we discover a story, a tale. Of a girl with a poisonous touch.
And what a story it was! Really fast paced, A page turner! I was surprised by some part of the plot and I had not seen coming some things and I enjoyed it!
The retelling of various tales made me want to read the original story!

The only thing I regret here is that it’s a bit to fast paced. I would’ve like the story to be longer even though it’s a one shot because at some point I felt like the author wrote in a hurry to finish the story and it’s too bad because the story had a lot to tell us!

I was sent a copy through netgalley in exchange of an honest review

Was this review helpful?

This book surprised me in all the best ways. I fell in love with the persian-inspired world, a type of fantasy which was new to me, and with the characters wirhin it.
Soraya is such an interesting main character to follow, as she was realistically naive due to her upbringing, but also had a much darker side which was really interesting to see explored. Her arc within the book is really enjoyable, as you watch her to come into her own. I wouldn't be doing the book justice if I didn't mention the inclusion of the female x female romance, which while not heavily focused on, was brilliant to see all the same.
Overall, I found this to be an easy and enjoyable read, which I would definitely recommend others to check out.

Was this review helpful?

this was such a great fantasy and something unique with our main character being poisonous with touch and really enjoyed the twist and turns this fantasy took us on, I really enjoyed the characters full of magic, royalty, political intrigue and some backstabbing all in the mix.

definitely recommend this one and can't wait to see more from this author

Was this review helpful?

Girl, Serpent, Thorn is a beautifully unique and whimsical fairy tale based on Persian mythology and I adored it! As soon as I heard about this novel I knew I needed a copy to read as soon as possible and I was not disappointed. This YA story is based around a princess who’s touch is deadly, cursed since birth, Soraya must forgo the touch of any other living creature or become a killer. I haven’t read anything similar to Girl, Serpent, Thorn before so reading about curses, demons and monsters from Persian mythology was absolutely fascinating.

The world building within this novel transported and immersed me within the scenes instantly, I could feel how isolated Soraya was within the walls of her rooms, I could envision the palace and structures of the world, the author has written a spectacular novel and included every small detail to create beautiful images within your imagination. I haven’t read a novel with a similar magical system to GST but it was explained so accurately that I understood every part of it perfectly, I am very impressed with how compact yet detailed this standalone novel is.

Not only does Girl, Serpent, Thorn fit the bill for fairy tales, castles, curses and monsters it also features a LGBTQ+ main character, the f/f romance within this novel is quite slow but enchanting. The scenes featuring the blossoming relationship between Parvaneh and Soraya were most definitely my favourites, although their initial kinship is built out of necessity their ensuing friendship and relationship is strengthened by their unwavering trust in each other, we love monster girls supporting each other!

Girl, Serpent, Thorn is an amazingly atmospheric fantasy world with morally grey characters and a queer romance neatly packed into about three hundred pages, I also loved the added detail within the Authors note where Melissa has included a glossary of the inspirations behind this novel. It is refreshing to read a novel based on a culture and mythology I am unaware of, everyone needs a new fairy tale to fall in love with and I would highly recommend Girl, Serpent, Thorn.

Was this review helpful?

Soraya is a princess cursed to be poisonous to the touch. Hidden away from the rest of her family, and the wider world, she must learn to step out of the shadows of her torment in order to protect her kingdom after she makes a terrible mistake. By her side is Azad, the handsome guardian who is unafraid of Soraya’s deadly touch, and whose eyes linger on her deadly potential. On her other side is the mysterious Pavenah, a demon with moth wings who may hold the answers to lifting her curse, but will pull her into the darkness to do so.

I really enjoyed the dynamics between the three main characters. Pavenah and Soraya have a great chemistry that simmers with heated looks and sensual touches. She’s the living embodiment of how Soraya sees herself – a monster like those depicted in the myths and legends told throughout her kingdom. But Pavenah is happy as she is – she’s strong, powerful and beautiful and it’s only when Soraya starts to see this in Pavenah that she starts to understand it in herself. By comparison, Azad is the stereotypical handsome hero who wants to protect and shield Soraya. Although he sees her inner fire, he nurtures this anger into his manipulation of her character. He tries to shape her into what she always wanted to be, rather than what she should be. The two are the light and dark of Soraya’s personality, and it was interesting to watch the dynamics between them shift continuously as the story progresses and Soraya struggles internally to decide on the right path.

Soraya’s character is definitely a highlight to this novel. I found her very well developed, with a lot of internal conversations about what the right thing to do is. She has grown up her whole life isolated from everyone and everything, living her life through the people she sees from her palace rooftop, and as a result she’s a very lonely woman at the start of the story. She’s also envious, jealous of her brother’s soon to be bride who will remain in the limelight with her brother while she’ll be forced back into the shadows. She wants to prove herself, prove her worth and there’s a lot of philosophical discussions about whether the hunt for a cure for Soraya’s curse is actually turning her into more of a monster than the actual curse itself because of a few rather ‘choice’ decisions she makes. She’s an extremely interesting character.

I also loved the rich descriptions of the lush settings and the small hints we get at the wider world and its mythology were utterly captivating. It’s based on Persian mythology, and I loved the inclusion of old heroic stories told by Soraya to help shape the story and I liked the way these stories eventually intertwine with Soraya’s tale. However, I do wish that more time had been spent expanding this world. We get far too few glimpses into the various demons (known as divs) who live in the world, and we’re never really given an explanation into any sort of social constructs or hierarchy between them, except that the group Pavenah belongs too may be classed as intelligent winged spies. Some groups appear to be merely grunts, with a few well known individuals with given names and ‘specialities’ (such as a zombie type div who specialises in the dead), and I would have liked to have seen more of the history behind this.

I also found the pacing a bit off. The first 100 pages are rather slow and meandering, with very little in the way of plot development. However, after this point there’s a major plot twist and the action just keeps coming – to the point where the ending feels rushed and a little bit too neatly tied up, too quickly. Soraya seems to be able to overcome her many difficulties rather too conveniently.

That said, I found the characters and setting for this to be truly magical and unique. Soraya is a complex, well thought out protagonist and there are some interesting dynamics between her, Azad and Pavenah that I haven’t really seen before. If you enjoy YA fantasy, I would highly recommend this for an interesting new take on the genre that includes some wonderful Persian mythology.

Was this review helpful?

Characters
I will be completely honest and say that the first 30% of this book didn't have me hooked. I didn't believe the interactions between Azad and Soraya, but boy was I wrong. I'm really going to try to keep this one spoiler-free, but DAMN.

Soraya, Azad and Parvaneh are all so beautifully morally grey. Soraya is our main character, but both Azad and Parvaneh are equally fleshed out and the intricacies of their personalities are just amazing.

Azad and Soraya are the same in many aspects, and THAT is what makes this book so GOOD. They're my ideal her0/villain combo and I am thriving for it. I don't have the words to describe how layered and well-written this book is.

Atmosphere
I am a big fan of worldbuilding done by the characters interacting with the world, not through info dumps or unnecessary dialogue. This book just does it so well. It's truly like reading a fairytale. It is SO atmospheric and I was eating it all up. I felt like I was in the world and part of the world.

The stories and the lore are just...I don't have the words.

Writing
I read Melissa Bashardoust's debut novel, Girls Made of Snow and Glass at the beginning of the year and it was pretty mediocre. This book was way above that. You can clearly see how much Bashardoust grew in her writing and how much it improved. It's absolutely phenomenal.

I love how to the point her writing is, and yet it's so layered and perfect. I am here for it.

Plot
The plot is where I completely lose all of my shit. IT IS DONE SO WELL. Everything that's set up at the start of the book pays off, everything that's even just mentioned in passing pays off. The story is so well set up and I'm still reeling from it.

It is so intricate and the fairytale aspect plays so well into the overall story. I already spoke about Soraya being a morally grey character and her character arc is just so amazing. She really toes the line between what is perceived as good and bad. All of her reasons are so believable and I would have rooted for her no matter the choices she made.

Intrigue
I think it's safe to say that this book is intriguing. I'm honestly a little bit sad that I haven't seen more hype for it. A story doesn't have to be part of a seven-book series or feature mediocre faerie dick to be hyped up.

Girl, Serpent, Thorn has an intriguing plot, excellent writing, great characters and believable romance. It deserves more love.

Logic
The magic system and the entire world is inspired by Persian fairytales and it is so beautiful. The magic made sense and played such an important part in this story.

Honestly, I'll probably never stop gushing about this.

Enjoyment
Obviously it's very clear that I love this book a LOT. It needs more hype and I will forever stan it.

Was this review helpful?

This book was received via Netgalley in return for an honest review.

Girl, Serpent, Thorn is a Persian mythology based retelling of Sleeping Beauty. Soraya is the sister of the Shah and has been poisonous to the touch since she was born, cursed by a div. As a result, she lives shielded away in a palace, far away from her family, but when they return, they bring a new guard who seems to see Soraya for who she really is.

And what is this about the div in the palace dungeons?

Girl, Serpent, Thorn is a brilliant retelling, entirely unique from the original fairy tale but still obviously inspired. Melissa Bashardoust crafts a interesting world, inspired by her own roots and family history. I enjoyed the details and it is clear the effort that went into its creating, from language to burial rights. All aspects work together to create a wonderfully immersive world that acts as a backdrop for this tale.

Soraya is an enjoyable character to read this story from the perspective of. She is a character kept isolated, who has feared and felt weak even in the face of her own terrible power. She is angry and jealous in a way that is completely human, even if she doesn’t want to be feeling those emotions. She takes an active role in her story, trying to fight for what she wants or needs, even if it doesn’t always work out. I also enjoyed her ending and the messaging of it - you may be thorny but you are allowed to be. I also enjoyed how her relationships developed and changed, both platonic and romantic.

(I won’t give too much away as it is connected to plot twists but I will confirm that this book has endgame girl love.)

The character of Shahmar, who acts as the main antagonist, is strangely interesting. He is complicated and twisted and yet obviously human through his demonic facade. Reading about how he became this person, how he was manipulated and had a form of destiny placed upon him, builds him as a enjoyable villain to the tale. His relationship with Soraya, wonderfully paralleling each other, also adds an extra layer to the story.

As mentioned above, I did enjoy the romance. At the beginning, there was some insta-love that I didn’t quite enjoy but, with the plot twist and Soraya’s situation at the beginning of the book, I can see how this trope has been turned into something else. The endgame romance is cute and fluffy and I did enjoy reading it.

Bashardoust’s writing style is poetic and easy. It reads a little like the fairy tale it was inspired by. I sped through the last 200 pages in a day because I was so eager to get to the end, to know what happens next, as tension built and built.

Girl, Serpent, Thorn is a unique twist on Sleeping Beauty, set in a world steeped in history that isn’t usually shared in YA, and has a decent message about self-acceptance - thorns and all. I look forward to seeing what Melissa Bashardoust writes next!

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this one more than the previous book I read by this author, though it did have some of the same problems with slow pacing and lack of character development. I did appreciate that it was a different take on a fairytale retelling and I loved the Persian mythology influences in this book.

Was this review helpful?

I have wanted a retelling of Sleeping Beauty for as long as I have been on bookstagram. Whether that be a loose one or one very close to the original. It is set beautifully and the main character becomes stronger as the novel progresses. However, she is fairly reliant on other characters and I felt that the romantic narrative was rushed. We slowly realised that she was bisexual and I would have liked to have seen that explored further.

I enjoyed this book but would have liked to have seen it stretched to 400+ pages to increase the character development.

Was this review helpful?

I just want to make absolutely clear that my 3 star rating for this book isn't a reflection of it being a bad or unbearable book at all - it's just that it could have a been a little slicker or, with a bit more padding, context and background, even better.

Our heroine is Soraya, however she's definitely not your typical princess. Soraya's skin and touch is poison to anyone around her, so she is kept safely away in one of the palaces of Atashar. She tends her rose garden and waits for her brother (the Shah), mother and the rest of the royal court to visit the palace each spring. She has been trying for years to keep her poisonous skin under control - to never touch anyone, to always be calm and demure, never rise to the bait as Soraya knows full well that she is the most dangerous person in the room. She puts up with so much from her family to keep them safe. But when a new young man, Azad, accompanies her brother and tries to talk to her, and when Soraya becomes aware that there is a div - one of the demon creatures that cursed her - locked up in the dungeon, she starts to think that there may actually be a way to break her poison-curse.

There are so many fairy tales and myths running through this story. The author does a great job of explaining her source material at the end, including the Persian mythic origins for her story (with some changes), which definitely encourages you to read more outside of western mythology. But, whether Bashardoust means to or not, there are moments of the story that feel a little bit Sleeping Beauty, and others that feel (gory) Beauty and the Beast. And quite a lot of Frozen too ... But, all of those stories had to be influenced by something originally too.

Soraya is also perfectly and unpretentiously bisexual - it's never labelled on the page, she just is. And it's great to come across a teenage heroine that isn't agonising over who or what she is - she just is. (Plus, with that whole poison skin thing, she's got plenty of other problems). But there are references later on to in-depth conversations between Soraya and Parvaneh that I don't feel really happened early on - I would quite happily read a longer book if the padding then added to those kinds of relationships.

My main issue is that I have just read a few books recently that take elements of the story here and go through them in much greater and complex depth. If you want Persian-inspired fantasy, got to the Daevabad Trilogy (although, reading Bashardoust's explanation at the end has given me a greater understanding of S. A. Chakraborty's source material). And if you want a heroine that can't be touched, try The Obsidian Tower by Melissa Caruso (please please please don't be tempted to read Shatter Me on my account though. I can't take responsibility for that). The length of Caruso's novel means she can spend much more time on how the MC reacts to being physically untouchable, and what it means when it's taken away. And, that doesn't mean that Girl, Serpent, Thorn is in any way bad - it's just not as detailed.

As a story, it really picked up towards the end, but often falls into the trap of movement and time and location - it's hard to tell how long is passing, or how much the MC can actually achieve in the few hours she has. There's also a lot of convenience - Soraya just happening to come across something that can completely change the outcome - that kind of thing. Again, it doesn't make the story bad, just a little simplistic in places.

However, I did particularly like that Soraya had lots of opportunities to go one way or another with this story - her relationships with her mother, the rest of her family, what she finds out about her past - there are lots of opportunities to head towards a more villainous side, which makes her a much more interesting heroine.

I read Girls Made of Snow and Glass recently and I do really enjoy Bashardoust's writing of female characters. They are flawed, but they want to do what's right. She is also particularly good at writing characters that have the potential to be an absolute villain - and that's something I really enjoy. But, as with the previous novel, the men certainly aren't there to be admired. In fact, they all suffer from being weak, or arrogant or cowardly or prideful. It's not super heavy-handed, but it's there. And certainly by the end, this is very much a sorority.

Really it's a 3.5 star read, but I can't mark it up to 4 stars, so down to 3 it goes ...

Was this review helpful?

Short review:
I tried really hard to like this, I was enchanted by the premise of a Persian fairy-tale retelling featuring diverse rep and an MC that had a devastating gift, a deadly touch. This, however, felt like a 14 y.o. girl's story written for 14 year old girls. Nothing wrong with that of course, except it’s not what was promised.

My advice: I recommend this as an entry point for people who are dipping their toes into the Fantasy genre, this won’t bewilder you with overly complex magic systems, difficult names with apostrophes and 352 maps 😊.

Long review, no spoilers:
Plot:
The synopsis along with the (promised) Arabic inspiration were what drew me to this. A girl with a deadly touch, a tagline on the cover saying “sometimes the princess is the monster” ? Y_E_S!!!! This gave me Rogue (X-men) vibes – she is probably my favourite female character and her and Remy's relationship just tore at my heartstrings - so I was excited to see her story told with a twist. Unfortunately, this was neither complex, nor surprising. It was a mix of ACOMAF and DOSAB, but was lacking their cheeky humor, drama and worldbuilding (gasp, yes, I am praising SJM ! say what you will about her crappy recycled plots and cringy scenes, but the woman puts time into fleshing out her worlds).
It's also slow. Very slow. For a book that has 330 pages, it took me 3 weeks to finish. At the 25% mark does the story truly kick off with our Soraya going off on an adventure.

On one hand this is a very focused, personal story, lasering in on Soraya's journey, transformation and inner battles. On the other, it's too linear, only ever having the one plot, absolutely nothing else happens outside her bubble, which makes this dry and boring. I'm never hunting for clues to uncover other secrets or piece together people's intentions, everything is out in the open. It's a pity because the world the author built is quite interesting, but not explored or utilised. And the way information and history are introduced is lazy, there's not much ground work, pretty much every time we need to know something, Soraya asks and she is told. Or when needed to get out of a pickle, information is dropped only to be utilised 3 pages later to solve a conflict. :)

Characters:
Uncomplicated and unsophisticated, it is the story and journey of Soraya, her battle with morality, her need of belonging and her journey of acceptance. And it could have been something epic, but it felt like a very narrow thread of a story, with every beat predictable and straightforward. I tend to dislike single point of view stories because they bore me. There are exceptions, the Assassin's Apprentice is one that is a masterpiece, stripping me bare and leaving me sobbing every time I pick up a book in that series.

I do like Soraya, her many little battles with morality are certainly different. And her desperate need not to be an accidental villain is truly a unique perspective.
I could have excused Soraya’s many mistakes and gullibility as caused by her lack of social interactions, but she just was mind-blowingly naïve: Soraya, 10 minutes after meeting Azad: "Let Azad be the one to walk away, then, and let him do it now, before she got too attached." Child are you kidding me???? I know she has been starved for attention, but this is ridiculous.

This isn’t a spoiler, just my thoughts at page 100: The whole time I hoped Azad turned out to be a villain or spy or something INTERESTING because this was a snoozefest. Soraya's blind belief in his textbook romance lines was believable only because she'd scarcely had any social experience and no romantic interactions.
Th other 2 recurring characters are fine, but without much of a life outside of Soraya’s orbit.

Worldbuilding:
There was something….missing. I wasn’t enchanted and transported. It didn’t feel like a whole new world. The worldbuilding, while interesting, was superficial, we don't understand the ways of this world, how creatures are resurrected, the mythology isn't expanded upon. The magic system was vague and underutilised. I found the divs fascinating and wanted to know more about their origins or purpose or dynamics. I’m the first to complain when a book is 900 pages long and caked with descriptions and infodumps, but in this case there really should have been more mythology and politics included.

Overall, I was expecting so much more and this was absolutely and completely fine. In all honesty I’m probably not going to recommend it or reread it, but if you’re new to the fantasy genre, this will be easy-peasy to understand 😊.

Was this review helpful?

Content warnings: violence, murder, torture

Rep: Persian cast of characters, sapphic main character, sapphic side character

"Stories always begin the same way: There was and there was not. There is possibility in those words, the chance for hope or despair."

Girl, Serpent, Thorn is a Persian-inspired fairy tale that follows the story of a princess who resents, nurtures and then embraces her darkness.

"She had read enough stories to know that the princess and the monster were never the same. She had been alone long enough to know which one she was."

Throughout the story, Soraya, the protagonist, teeters on the edge of darkness, and watching her internal struggle was the main highlight for me. Initially, Soraya's poison is something that causes her great shame and so she hides herself away. When she finds that there might be a chance she could rid herself of this curse, she makes some choices that draw out the anger envy in her, which make her feel strong and powerful and free. I loved seeing these sparks of darkness within her explored. Not knowing which way she would go, or which decisions she would make made for a very exciting, twisted story. 

"I was always afraid the poison would make me a monster, but what if trying to get rid of it makes me more of a monster than I was before?"

I'm a sucker for overarching themes of 'good vs evil,' 'nature vs nurture' and 'what makes a monster.' I always love seeing these ideas explored and I enjoyed the conclusions the narrative came to and the focus on choices and acceptance. The way the narrative got to the conclusions was interesting and each potential answer was thoroughly explored within the story.

"You're my favourite story. I feel like I've know you for a long time."

The relationships Soraya had were very complicated and another highlight for me. My favourite relationship is a spoiler, so I won't go into detail, but it did keep my eyes glued to the screen reading. Everything I wanted to happen between them, good or bad, happened and I was addicted!

"What she needed tonight was another monster."

I also loved the slow-burn sapphic romance between Soraya and Parvaneh, a parik div, which is a kind of demon. It was quiet and romantic and made a great contrast to the other relationship. This relationship was focused on mutual respect, acceptance of 'inner demons' and building each other up. I liked how this all played out.

"Sometimes I feel like my thoughts are steeped in poison, and that it's only a matter of time before I lose control over them... or over myself."

The writing was also so beautiful and lyrical and the use of metaphors and similes in particular was very powerful. Take, for example, one of my favourite lines:

"Parvaneh seemed to be made of the night. She wore it like a gown, draped over skin that shimmered in the moonlight."

Just. Beautiful! I have the author's debut, Girls Made of Snow and Glass, on my TBR, so I'll definitely be getting around to reading that one later this year.

There was nothing I really disliked in this novel. It was almost a 5 star read and it might end up being one if I continue to think about it some more. I would also recommend reading the author's note at the end, too. It really added something extra to the story and set out some of the context of Persian myths and legends that had inspired it.

"Soraya no longer had to choose between one piece of herself and another. She could be whole."

Overall, I loved Girl, Serpent, Thorn and highly recommend it. If you like rich, beautifully written fairy tales, inspired by existing myths and legends, with morally grey protagonists and themes of what makes a monster, I think you'll love this one, too.

Was this review helpful?

Girl, Serpent, Thorn

4 stars

Girl, Serpent, Thorn is a vividly painted fantasy novel that has a bisexual anti-hero as the protagonist. It’s no surprise that I liked this book a lot.

Soraya is cursed by the demons, aka Divs — anyone she touches dies — she’s poisonous. (Kind of like a deadly Midas touch.) She’s also the princess of Atashar, but that title is only a prison — her twin, the crown prince leads a life of freedom while she is kept an unwanted secret, hidden from public eye. Her family moves to different castles during the rest of the year, and the only time she gets to see them is during the summer.

Years of being the shame of her family and the untouchability; the inability to live a life like everyone else breaks her spirit, till she decides to take action — something that’ll go on to harm her entire family and kingdom.

Going in, I didn’t know that this book drew from Persian elements, but I picked up on it easily. My dad loves learning about other cultures, and I grew up learning about the Parsis of India. Being the morbidly curious child I was, I was fascinated by Zoroastrian funerals — they offer their dead up to the vultures. So when that turned up in the book, I just <I>knew</I>, and I was super chuffed.

(And later when I confirmed that it indeed was Parsi culture the author drew inspiration from in the author’s notes, it was such an ego boost.)

So for me, the masterful interweaving of fiction and culture made it all the more enjoyable.

Soraya is an interesting protagonist.

As I mentioned, she’s an <b>anti-heroine</b>. And she’s someone that you can get behind. Her descent into darkness is motivated by human emotions — the bitterness grows in her heart slowly through the events that occur prior to this book, till it reaches its peak in the chapters of this story. The narration, though linear, is well interspersed with Soraya’s thoughts and memories about the things that have led to her current state of mind, and it’s easy to want to support her, even though she’s taking a questionable path.

While the author says it’s inspired by Sleeping Beauty, I genuinely feel it’s very loosely based, and should be read as a completely original story with elements drawn from Zoroastrianism.

The <b>world building</b> isn’t something that the author goes into in detail, but the world is well established. Enough details are given for us to imagine the setting, but not too much time is spent on it. The focus is more on Soraya’s transformation and thoughts, and the consequences of her actions.

I liked the extent to which the other characters were developed, not too much in detail the way Soraya is, but enough so that none of them are two dimensional. The other important characters, in no particular order: Parvaneh (a parik), Azad (a boy who saves the crown prince’s life), Soroush (Soraya’s brother), Ramin (her childhood nemesis), Laleh (her brother’s bride who also used to be her first friend and crush), and Tahmineh (Soraya’s mother).

I particularly relished the depth and intensity of feelings that Soraya and Tahmineh had towards each other. The guilt, the shame, the love, the bitterness — if emotions were flavours, this would be dark chocolate and coffee, blended together.

The only reason why this book isn’t a 5 star read is because towards the end, the plot lost the pace that it developed over the first 70-80%. Maybe if the same pace had been maintained and the book had been about 50 pages shorter, it would have been a five star read. Somehow books which start out magnificently but end on a slightly less positive note feel more disappointing than they actually are. I’d even say I wanted to give it a 3 star rating.

But I’m reviewing objectively, and the majority of the book was truly enjoyable; something that I really liked. And thus, it’s a 4-star from me.

P.S. The cover is gorgeous; it characterises Soraya to a T!

I’d like to thank Hodder & Stoughton and NetGalley for giving me a chance to read and review this book. Hodder & Stoughton has published some of the best fantasy works I’ve read this year, and I’m going to be on the lookout for more fantasy titles from them. :)

Was this review helpful?