Member Reviews

Due to a technical issue with the Netgalley App, I no longer have access to this audiobook and am unable to review. If I can find a way around this, I will post a complete review.

Was this review helpful?

This is the fifth In the Vinyl detectives series and I enjoyed it immensely.
Cartmel.
The Vinyl Detective and his sidekicks return for another adventure and whodunnit mystery with old and new cast members.
I always have a grin on my face when reading these books and this one did not disappoint!
If you haven’t read any then I recommend you get started.

Was this review helpful?

What a discovery! It's a highly enjoyable and engrossing story that kept me hooked.
I had a lot of fun and want to read the other stories in this series.
The music part was a fascinating addition and I liked to read about punk and the age of Sex Pistols.
The narrator did an excellent job in telling the story.
Highly recommended.
Many thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for this ARC all opinions are mine.

Was this review helpful?

This is another excellent addition to the Vinyl Detective series, the fifth. The series focuses on the Vinyl Detective of the title and his girlfriend, Nevada. The title character spends his time searching for obscure old records for his clients (hence "Vinyl Detective") and looking after his cat but keeps accidentally becoming involved in exciting escapades. This book - as with all the others in the series - exudes humour, cats and excitement - and Eric Make Loud is back. Although relationships between characters develop over time, each of the books is a stand alone novel and they can be read in any order. I have no hesitation at all in recommending this book, and all the rest of the series. It's an easy, enjoyable read (or listen) and spending time reading it is something that you won't regret.

Was this review helpful?

Punk was a short-lived musical genre and if you have listened to some of it you can probably tell why. It was raw, edgy and loud, but most of the songs were not that great and it was more about attitude than being able to sing. The songs that you may like from that genre may be post-Punk or New Wave, when some of the musicians from Punk went on to make some great songs. I am no fan of Punk but that does not mean that I want to kill any of the artists that made it. Someone hates The Blue Tits enough to want their former lead guitarist dead. What was her biggest sin? Maybe it was the fact that she could play.

To look at her now and you can tell that Helene Hilditch is an artist of some kind from the way that she carries herself but you would not imagine that she was once known as Howlin’ Hellbitch, the lead guitarist from the ephemeral Punk band, The Blue Tits. Years later and it seems that Helen’s past is catching up with her, three failed attempts at her life has led her to The Vinyl Detective. He is tasked with finding a copy of the rare first pressing of their debut album but really this is an excuse to meet all the old crew and see who has murder in mind.

The Vinyl Detective is now an established series and you can tell by Low Action, Andrew Cartmel is getting a great tune out of the characters. The basic premise of the series has been that when he is searching for a record, he gets embroiled in a murder plot. Making an amateur discover this type of case becomes less organic over time but thankfully Cartmel has decided that at this time people in the know visit the Vinyl Detective knowing that he actually investigates murder. The Detective reluctantly realises that to supplement his income this has to be the norm.

With this in mind enter Helene Hilditch. Her story leads directly into a Punk story of a young group of privately educated girls setting up a band and making a success for themselves after a rather fruity live interview on TV. Anyone who knows their Punk history will be aware that this story chimes with real events. Cartmel does a great job of interweaving the fictionalised Blue Tits with the real Punk scene. I am not sure that the era of Punk works with the timeline of The Vinyl Detective, but I can forgo that for a fun book.

And Low Action is just that, fun. This book is part of that strange genre that the Brits do so well – the cosy murder mystery. The stakes could not be higher, yet this book feels light and fun. The interaction between the characters is very amusing and this is certainly enhanced by the audio work of Finlay Robertson. There is a slow build to the story as we are introduced to the various suspects. This gives the listener the chance to develop their own opinions who may be behind the crimes. Like any good mystery there are also a few twists and action scenes that will keep you on your toes.

Low Action is a traditional crime story told well in an amusing manner both in Cartmel’s written word and Robertson’s narration. The audio book is a great option as Robertson has a clear presentation and uses various voices to distinguish the different characters. He has also noted the tempo of some of the scenes as the humour and timing comes across from the page. This book will have you chuckling out loud.

Was this review helpful?