Member Reviews

There’s a lot of Children’s/Middle Grade books out there that adults can enjoy as well as children, and with this being an offering from Jacqueline Wilson, one of my favourite authors when I was a teenager, I thought I’d really enjoy this. It was okay, and I think for it’s target audience it’s good, but there were some things that irked me about it, and it took me a fair while to actually get into it.

Okay, I’m going to start with the negatives. I’m partly disappointed about Wilson leaning so heavily on the Evil Stepmother trope. Maybe it’s used to give it a bit of a fairy-tale feel, and maybe it’s just me, but it feels like an overdone element in works for kids. I get there needed to be reasons for Lucy running away, but it would have been nice to not have it be “stepmother is cruel and parents are too distracted by New Baby”. It almost read like an AITA. It felt, too, like it maybe took a little too long to get to the part where Lucy and Kitty actually meet, and the way it got there was…a bit odd? Honestly, I think around the point just before they meet I would have DNF’d if I hadn’t DNF’d another book so recently.

Parts of the book do become a little repetitive, but as the story progresses it’s hard not to cheer Lucy and Kitty on and want things to work out well for them. One of Wilson’s strengths has always been to present dark topics, filtered through the eyes of children, in a way that children can understand. To kids, these are just part of the adventure, but some are kind of horrific from an adult’s perspective. There’s a reason her books are so beloved and widely read.

There are a few different ‘mother’ figures who pop up throughout the book, but none who are able to accept both girls as they are, and it’s sweet seeing the pair defend themselves and each other, and look out for one another. They travel across London, performing to earn themselves money, both pining for the parent figures in their lives, Lucy for her Nurse, sent away by New Mother, and Kitty for her Gaffer, a man who has “gone away”. Throughout, they argue and misunderstand, in the way kids do, and especially because of their different backgrounds, Lucy as the daughter of a fairly wealthy man, and Kitty as a child who grew up on the streets.

The ending felt very satisfying, and was a nice conclusion to what possibly looks like the first in a series. It’s an enjoyable enough book, if a little frustrating at points, but it was fine to revisit one of my favourite childhood authors, with something different than the books I read of hers when I was a kid. If you have younger readers in your life, I think this is definitely worth picking up.

Thank you to Doubleday Childrens for providing me a copy of this book via NetGalley. Views remain my own.

Was this review helpful?

One of my favourite authors from my childhood. I adored her books as a young girl. And my own daughter has now become a fan. It has been years since I read anything of Jacqueline Wilson so when I saw this one I just felt I needed to give it a go. I am glad I did. It was an enjoyable read and I loved the characters. I can't wait to pass it on to my little girl for her to read.

Was this review helpful?

Jacqueline Wilson was one of my favourite childhood authors & I couldn’t wait to see if I still enjoyed her writing style! I was not disappointed. I loved the history that was incorporated into it too & thoroughly loved it.

Was this review helpful?

Another classic gem from the hero that is Jacqueline Wilson. She certainly knows how to capture your imaginary and take you on an adventure. I enjoyed the characters and storyline of this book, as always, but did find the ending a little unsatisfactory compared to Wilson’s usual standards.

Thank you so much to NetGalley and Penguin Random House Children’s UK for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I have loved Jacqueline Wilson books since I was a child and grew up with them alongside all my favourite characters. Coming to this older I still really did enjoy the writing and the story. Jacqueline is the most incredible descriptive writer and her worlds and characters are so easy to imagine. This is a classic Wilson in that it takes a dark theme but through the eyes of a young girl who cannot see the dangers and views everything as an adventure. A lot happens in the relatively short book and you will not be disappointed.

Was this review helpful?

My 11 year old really enjoyed this latest Jacqueline Wilson book. Like many of Wilson’s other historical novels it is set in the Victorian era, but is standalone, so readers don’t need to be familiar with Hetty Feather etc to enjoy The Runaway Girls.

The girls, Lucy and Kitty share a city but are from entirely different worlds. They ‘run away’ through the streets of London, exploring the city and also finding out about themselves.

A great novel full of friendship and adventure.

Was this review helpful?

I adore Jacqueline Wilson. I find that she has a way of taking difficult subject matter and making it accessible to every reader, which I think is absolutely fantastic. THE RUNAWAY GIRLS is no exception, and this story has a way of nettling into your heart.

Was this review helpful?

Jacqueline Wilson has written enough books about Victorian waifs to rival Charles Dickens. This book is slightly different to Hetty, Clover and co. in that the protagonist was born into a life of relative privilege; after she is (unbelievably) mistaken for an urchin by her own father, she decides to take her chances in the 'underworld' along with her new sweet and street smart friend. Wealth and education are the themes here; while Wilson touches on women's rights and the lives of Black Victorians, this is a recognisable 'orphan's tale' rather than an 'own voices' novel for young people. There are plenty of familiar faces- it wouldn't be a Wilson book without a cameo from Hetty Feather- and Wilson relies heavily on staples like the simple, kindly country folk, the strict governess and the wicked orphanmaster. The book doesn't really sparkle until Wilson arrives at a specific historical event: the Crystal Palace exhibition. We see the exhibition through the eyes of ordinary people- some are trying to sneak behind the velvet ropes while others are looking to snatch some pennies from the rich folks in the long queues! The seedier side of travelling theatre and the horrors of industrial childrearing are both covered in more depth in the Hetty series, but the wonder that Hetty first felt on seeing the Tanglewoods Travelling Circus lasts longer, and feels stronger in The Runaway Girls. They are part of the action, rather than observers; when they aren't invited to take part in the show, they make their own, complete with songs, costumes and stories. I would love Wilson to write a book set somewhere else in the former British Empire, but I suspect this novel is the first of another circus-themed series (Hetty: The Next Generation) If you and your children like familiar Victorian stories with just a touch of magic, this book will be just fine.

Was this review helpful?

Lucy lives a financially privileged life in Victorian England but has little in the way of emotional comfort, so she runs away from home. Luckily for Lucy, she meets a street performer called Kitty, who has the wits to survive on the dangerous streets of London. The narrator does a skillful job of bringing an already engaging story to life. My 12 year old was hooked.

Was this review helpful?

As always, a well written and engaging book by Jacqueline Wilson.

I loved her books when I was younger and I was interested to see how they read as an adult. Still a good read.

Was this review helpful?

A story of sadness, adventure and happiness.
Sometimes having a new family can be so hard and you feel pushed out unloved and sometimes you can not see why adults do the things they do.
This is an adventure of growing up and learning to accept that somethings change and you grow with those.
Wilson writes such wonderful stories.

Was this review helpful?

I always admire the way in which Jacqueline Wilson deals with hard-hitting themes and topics, however this story fell a little flat for me.

For the most part, the writing was engaging and enjoyable. There were places where I felt it was slow and repetitive at times.

I also didn't feel the ending was as satisfying for the reader as it could have been, and feel as though not enough use was made of Gaffer.

Nevertheless, thank you very much for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

I used to love Jaqueline Wilson when I was younger and having recently got back into reading I wanted to read some of her newer works. I think this would be a great story for young readers as I myself enjoyed it. The main character was one very typical of Wilson’s writing which felt comforting. I enjoyed this read despite it not being aimed at my age group and would definitely recommend to the targeted age group and those who loved her growing up

Was this review helpful?

I have a huge soft spot for Jacqueline Wilson, my daughter loves her and has read most of her books. This one did not disappoint! A fabulous book set with all the great attributes we have come to expect from Jacqueline. Set in Victorian England, the book follows friends Lucy and Kitty - two girls from very different backgrounds who develop a strong friendship despite the odds. Fabulous.

Was this review helpful?

I have been a huge Jacqueline Wilson fan since I was around eight years old. I was absolutely ecstatic (not an exaggeration) when I got accepted by the wonderful people at Puffin for her latest release. It was simply glorious!

In 1851, Lucy Alice May Browning lives with her father, New Mother and her new baby sister Angelique in a nice house in London. Her governess Miss Groan forces her to read Bible passages and behave as a little lady should. Lucy misses her lovely, kind Nurse who moved to the country terribly. Then Lucy runs away and finds herself naked and helpless on the harsh streets of London. Until she is found by the boisterous, loveable Kitty who has made a life for herself on the streets since losing the protection of her beloved Gaffer. Now, it’s up to the girls to survive by befriending families, hiding from the police, avoiding the Workhouse and crafting an amazing performance to earn their money!

Like all Jacqueline Wilson books, The Runaway Girls is accompanied by gorgeous illustrations from Nick Sharratt. Located at the start of every chapter, they dropped hints as to what to expect from the chapter to come. Having visuals of the girls’ journey added another dimension to the story and they completely transported me to normal every day life in Victorian London.

Lucy’s life in her family home isn’t a happy one and she dreams of a life with loving parents. My heart broke for her and for most of the novel, I was desperate for her to find this. I know that this is how so many children feel in the place where they’re supposed to feel loved and safe and that it’s timeless. There are probably just as many children in 2021 who feel like this as there was in Lucy’s time. Wilson’s ability to speak directly to these kids never fails to amaze me.

Wilson is constantly praised for her ability to emulate children’s minds so expertly, even at her age. I think the little passage where Kitty says that she was born in a bush and Lucy believes this as she has heard it before demonstrates that perfectly. Lucy’s blind acceptance of such an absurd theory is something that only a sheltered nine-year-old could do. Spending time in Lucy’s head really took me back to being her age and it was exactly what I needed.

The Runaway Girls is written in such an immersive, vivid style that everything was so easy to picture. I saw everything through Lucy’s eyes and therefore I really felt everything that she did -the fear, the wonder, the anticipation of the Great Exhibition. I know Crystal Palace quite well as I grew up in South East London but of course, I didn’t know it when it was this new, glittering structure full of creativity and promise. It was a wonderful, magical experience to see it like this.

Lucy and Kitty constantly have fantasies about what their lives will be like in the future. Their outlandish ideas and beautiful dreams thoroughly transport the reader into their wonderful child-like minds and I found that I was getting as carried away with these dreams as they were! I know that it’s these dreams that keep them warm amidst the frightening, hostile conditions that they’re living in and when you consider that, they take on a tragic tinge but Wilson never specifically frames them like that. There are so many layers that you can read her stories on and I love that you can see something different, depending on your mood or experiences.

There are also points where the stark differences between Kitty and Lucy show themselves. Kitty is very aware of these differences and she is actually saying so much in the line ‘Only you’re rich and I’m poor so we can’t really be friends, can we?’. Even at her tender age, she knows that the existence of the class system and the privileges that Lucy enjoys mean that Lucy can never have a true understanding of Kitty’s life. This translates directly into 2021 and I know a lot of working class people will connect with this viewpoint.

The Runaway Girls is a fantastic adventure powered by a beautiful friendship that survives real threats. I didn’t expect the ending to pan out the way it did but it fits perfectly. I finished it full of warmth and hope and that’s exactly the kind of read that my heart really needs right now.

Was this review helpful?

I loved, loved, loved Jacqueline Wilson’s books when I was a child and so I am delighted that my daughter has discovered the joy of reading her books too. When the opportunity to review the new book presented itself, we were both excited. My daughter became totally engaged in the story and there was plenty for us to discuss together. At just 8 years old, some of the vocabulary was a little advanced for her at time, but this presented the opportunity for her to learn too. This is her review in her own words...

“I think this book is about trust because they were always trusting each other like when Lucy and Kitty were at an orphvillage (sic), Lucy trusted Kitty when to run. It is about 2 girls Kitty and Lucy and Lucy ran away from her home , because she thought she had found her nurse but she hadn’t meeted (sic) her nurse it as someone else. Then Lucy met Kitty they kept on running away like from The Great Exhibition, the park and the orphvillage (sic). I like the bit when they performed at The Great Exhibition and the it where Kitty told Lucy about the fairies in the park, but really my favourite bit is ...all of it! I didn’t like the new mother, because it sounds like she was really mean to Lucy. I thought the ending was definitely a happy ending because they joined the circus. I wonder if Jacqueline Wilson will make another book about The Runaway girls when they are at the circus? I would recommend this to my brother, because he enjoys Jacqueline Wilson books”

Thank you to Netgalley, Jacqueline Wilson and Doubleday for the opportunity to review this book in exchange for an honest opinion.

Was this review helpful?

This is another great book by Jacqueline Wilson, my daughter loves her more historical tales and this was no exception. Lucy is struggling to adjust to her life with a new stepmother and baby but without the nurse who helped raise her, in her misery she runs away from home and fortunately for her befriends Kitty who helps her to survive on the streets and shows her the kindness she was missing. This is as thoughtfully written as you would expect and another great edition to my daughters library.

Was this review helpful?

This book follows Lucy - a young girl who’s got a new mother and new baby sister who she doesn’t particularly like. Her nurse has also been replaced with a mean woman and all Lucy wants is to have fun. Then after getting into trouble because of an accident, Lucy runs away and meets Kitty. Kitty lives on the streets and earns tin to support herself by performing. Kitty teaches Lucy how to survive on the streets and together they develop their performance in order to earn money for both of them. All is going well until they get accused and stealing and the threat of the workhouse becomes very real.

The way this book ends I would more than happily read a sequel that follows their adventure further. However Jacqueline Wilson’s books have always been something that I could happily read over and over.

I highly recommend this book to people of all ages who enjoy books following friendships and overcoming challenges.

Was this review helpful?

A carefully considered look at the experience of a Victorian childhood from multiple viewpoints. Lucy’s life is comfortable but lacks emotional support. Following a mistake she decides to leave home however life on the streets is not what she expected and help comes from an unexpected source, forcing her to reconsider her ideas of the poor. Set within Jacqueline Wilson’s Victorian world it can be read as a stand-alone and examines themes not looked at in her other novels. Sure to be popular with year 5 and above.

Was this review helpful?

A Jacqueline Wilson book never does disappoint. Runaway Girls was a historic light read that followed two girls who bonded to be more than sisters.
Lucy, a high society young girl, has run away from home when she accidentally melted her doll and has been punished. She meets Kitty and the two become the best of friends as time goes by. They have their differences and arguments but the series of incidents that follow make their friendship stronger.

The main theme of Runaway Girls was friendship. It was delivered in a sweet heartwarming way. The writing style was quite simple and readable.

I enjoyed Kitty and Lucy's characters. I thought that they were quite well rounded and their opposing personalities made it quite interesting.

What didn't quite work for me was the ending. I was hoping that Lucy would meet her father again and it would be bittersweet yet memorable but I got a happy unrealistic ending. It wasn't bad but it could have been better.

Overall a great read and highly recommended!

Thanks to netgalley and the publisher for the E-arc!

Was this review helpful?