Member Reviews

This is my first book by Joseph Knox and I was lucky enough to get an ARC digital copy from Netgalley, however when Anne Cater of Random Things Tours asked if I wanted to take part in the blogtour I said YES, but can I please have the audio version as I am a recent convert to podcasts and true crime on audible.

First and most importantly do NOT do what I did after the first chapter which is GOOGLE the book, the author and the story, just be patient and go along for the journey because this book is one hell of a ride.

True Crime Story is a very clever book consisting of multiple narrators retracing the steps of young Zoe Nolan. A 19 year old Manchester University Student who literally disappeared into the night on 17th December (which is also my birthday). Author Joseph Knox and his friend Evelyn Mitchell slowly and painstakingly piece together the fragments of her life leading up to her disappearance interviewing her friends, family and University lecturers.

If you love podcasts and true crime then this is the next book for you. I couldn’t stop listening to this and hearing Zoe’s twin sister Kim’s tell the listener about living in the shadow of her more beautiful, more talented favoured sister was really heart-breaking.

Throughout the narrative, I was convinced I knew why and how Zoe disappeared, except after every other chapter I was changing my mind, which shows the ingenious talent of Joseph Knox and his complex plotting and storytelling.

This really is an enjoyable and addictive book which I thoroughly recommend.

Was this review helpful?

This is a work of fiction, presented in the format of an account of an investigation by an author, Evelyn, exploring the cold case of a missing student, Zoe, who vanished following a party in her student halls in Manchester. She investigates and interviews her friends and family to draw out the reasons why Zoe would have gone missing or anyone would have wished to harm her. This is a truly compelling and wholly uncomfortable read and the style really propels you along as all the character's secrets are revealed., it's written as journalist's notes and interviews and criss crossing the whole thing is a dialogue between the 'original' writer and researcher of the story and our author, who inserts himself into the narrative to clever effect. It's a startlingly original take on familiar tropes of investigating a pretty white girl going missing, with some genuinely surprising twists. The narrative laid out by Evelyn's investigations really unfurls and exposes everyone's layers of truths and lies , while at the same time it's hard to grasp the kernel of 'truth' at the centre of the mystery and there is a really horrific turn of events to conclude. Takes a bit of perserverance and suspension of disbelief but overall it's genuinely unputdownable.

Was this review helpful?

A bit of a complicated story… A bit of real life, mixed with fiction as further research in to the events would reveal.

Was this review helpful?

A bit of fact and a bit of fiction, all rolled into a slightly disappointing read. Difficult to get into, due to the format of snippets of interviews and the constant unfolding emails, but I persevered and was so pleased to reach the end. I failed to like any of the characters and I found the ending somewhat disappointing with unanswered questions, overall, a bit dull for me. Thanks to Net Galley for my ARC.

Was this review helpful?

This is a new author to me, but having heard a lot of good things about this book and with it being set in my hometown, I was excited to get stuck in.

In 2011, Manchester University student Zoe Nolan went missing after a party at her student accommodation. With year's passing and Zoe still not being found, the case grabs the attention of writer Evelyn Mitchell who seeks out Joseph Knox for advice on writing about the mystery.

The book is written by way of emails between the two and interviews conducted by Evelyn with the main players - Zoe's twin sister, parents, boyfriend and friends.

The accounts of each slowly weave the backstory before Zoe's disappearance, up to the event of the night she went missing and beyond, in the aftermath of her disappearance.

It is a complex case and although I loved the way it was told, it takes some concentration to keep up with who is who and what they have said before. I felt like making my own murder board at times just to keep track!

Well worth a read if you like true crime and mysteries.

Was this review helpful?

In the early hours of Saturday, December 17th, 2011, Zoe Nolan, a 19-year-old Manchester University student, walked out of a party taking place in the shared accommodation where she had been living for three months. She was never seen again.

This book It’s written like an interview of possible suspects, which have been spliced together to give one long picture of what may or may not have happened to Zoe Nolan. I genuinely never figured out what was going to happen, so the ending was also brilliantly done.

This is a first for me by the author and one I enjoyed and would read more of their work. The book cover is eye-catching and appealing and would spark my interest if in a bookshop. Thank you very much to the author, publisher and Netgalley for this ARC.

Was this review helpful?

I’ve never read anything quite like this! Like many other reviewers I googled Zoe Nolan to find out more about her. True Crime Story is highly original look at the disappearance of her using interviews with her closest friends. It reads like a true crime documentary although I must admit I found certain parts slightly repetitive however it’s definitely original and well written just not 100% sure I can sayI thoroughly enjoyed every single page. With thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for an advance copy.

Was this review helpful?

<!-- wp:paragraph -->
<p>Joseph Knox take a bow! This book is completely and utterly INCREDIBLE. I definitely haven’t been disappointed by this one. </p>
<!-- /wp:paragraph -->

<!-- wp:paragraph -->
<p>This is an extremely complex novel, we are told the story through the interviews and emails- which I can imagine was a nightmare to write. </p>
<!-- /wp:paragraph -->

<!-- wp:paragraph -->
<p>This has been so realistic, I found myself googling Zoe Nolan. This is a superb read which I have been unwilling to put down. I have loved that Zoe is the central focus of this one from the very beginning. </p>
<!-- /wp:paragraph -->

<!-- wp:paragraph -->
<p>The characters are an interesting bunch. I’ve been unsure about a few of them. This definitely hasn’t been a book that I’ve wanted to put down. </p>
<!-- /wp:paragraph -->

<!-- wp:paragraph -->
<p>I’m ashamed to say this is my first read by this author. But I will definitely be adding more to the TBR immediately. This is the book that has converted me as a fan of this author. </p>
<!-- /wp:paragraph -->

<!-- wp:paragraph -->
<p>There are a lot of twists present in this one and you are suspicious of everyone at some point or another. There are darker elements to this one and it is definitely a must read. </p>
<!-- /wp:paragraph -->

<!-- wp:paragraph -->
<p>This is definitely going to be one of my top reads of 2021. Absolutely outstanding, not one to be missed. </p>
<!-- /wp:paragraph -->

Was this review helpful?

This documentary style story is based around the disappearance of Zoe Nolan, a young twin who vanishes suddenly whist at flat sharing University. There are a group of main characters that we are introduced to very early on and as everything unravels, it is made clear that most of them have something to hide, secrets begin to become revealed.

I really enjoyed the flow of this, and just when I thought I had it all figured out, Joseph Knox flipped everything, and made me begin my own investigation once again. I read this with a notepad close by, to help me conclude what had happened to Zoe, and I am delighted to say the final twist was not foreseen at all. This is a thrilling and engaging read and is perfect for those readers who love to do a bit of detective work. .

Is this a True Crime Story as the title suggests? It certainly gives the impression of such in the style of writing, and I don't mind admitting that I was duped into thinking this was based on real events, but research proved me wrong!

This is a highly recommended read, which I predict will be a massive hit for all readers alike.

Was this review helpful?

WHEEEWW. I KNEW that this book was fiction, presented as true crime, and yet I still found myself googling Zoe after the first few chapters juuuuust in case I was mistaken. The author has written himself into the book and I think that is bloody brilliant. The book is all transcipts of interviews between Evelyn and the characters, and then email correspondence between Evelyn and Joseph, which made it an easy read, easy to plant red herrings and easy to say "go on then I'll just read one more entry"... and then you're up all night finishing it.

Really smart, really captivating and really fun to read.

Was this review helpful?

A good read if you like lots of dialogue.

I struggled with this book in places, it’s not the kind of book I usually go for due to the format it has been written.

It is interview based and paints a picture of Zoe’s life before her disappearance and puts a personality to her name rather than her being ‘just another victim’.

It seemed a little fragmented going from person to person, explaining the timeline.

It was very thoroughly researched and had a lot of information in it.

Probably much better for someone who likes this format of writing.

Many thanks to the author and NetGalley for gifting me this arc in exchange for an honest, unbiased review.

Was this review helpful?

Don't be deceived by the title of this book - it is not a true crime story at all. Pitched as a blending together of fact and fiction this is just the opposite and is instead entirely fictitious.

This is the story of Zoe Nolan, who in December of 2011 disappears from her student accommodation in Manchester. The police looked for her but could find no trace of either Zoe or foul play. In 2018 writer Evelyn starts investigating the disappearance and interviews the main players, from Zoe's jealous twin sister Kim, sleazy boyfriend Andrew, obsessive father Robert, and a bevvy of friends who all have their own opinions of what they experienced in the run up to Zoe's disappearance and what has happened to them in the intervening years.

This is told in part through a series of emails between Joseph Knox and Evelyn (an additional character within the book with her own story to tell) and interviews with everyone else. We cover and recover and recover parts of the story with each of the characters having their 'say' in a series of interviews which are spliced together so that all characters comment on the same event at the same part of the book. We are lead in every dizzying circles as the police do a sweep of the flat but miss a service hatch hidden in the wall. where the 'killer/kidnapper' watches Zoe through holes drilled in her wall - really??

The story is not thrilling, exciting or gripping - instead it is dull, monotonous and it takes an inordinate amount of time to make progress with the story. None of the characters are in anyway likeable - in fact I struggled to care about them at all. The 'reveal' of what happened is a disappointment as it isn't clear about what exactly occurred to Zoe, and I found that I didn't care about her either as we don't spend anytime getting to know her.

On the whole I found this to be a disappointing read.

Thanks to Netgalley and the publishers for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I expect that the length of time it took me to finish this book, almost 2 weeks, gives a true reflection on how I feel about it. I thought it would be a story I could really get into, but I found the way in which the interviews were set out were difficult to focus my attention, and had to reread at times.
The idea of the book is good, and had it been more cohesive, then the premise would have worked. For me I found it too lengthy and also childish at times. With some editing it would have worked better as a “teenager” book. Not one for me sadly.
Thank you NetGalley.

Was this review helpful?

It’s an intriguing premise. The ‘true crime story’ of the title - the disappearance of student Zoe Nolan - isn’t a true story at all.
However, it reads like documentary, told in the voices of the family and friends of Zoe. Their narratives intersect so it feels a bit like a conversation between them.
But the story is complex, and full of twists and turns that mean that no one person can be trusted or believed.
I haven’t read a book written in this way, and the effect is clever and builds up
a gradual picture of Zoe and what happened to her.
But it isn’t always the easiest to read; the plotting gets complicated, sometimes slightly at the expense of the characterisation.
Regardless, this is a self-assured and accomplished story, told in a credible way. Recommended.

Was this review helpful?

I really liked the concept of this book - a whodunnit, told in the style of a true crime, with the author written in to the storyline. It reminded me a bit of Paul Auster.

The execution is great as well - using mixed media, such as emails, Facebook posts and news articles; together with first hand accounts of the events surrounding Zoe’s disappearance, meant that you’re constantly seeing the story from different people’s views. There’s a whole host of unreliable narrators, not least Knox himself, who redacts parts of Evelyn’s research to suit his own version of the narrative.

My only criticism is that it felt a bit ‘teenage soap opera’ - I love Pretty Little Liars and shows like that, but this felt a little childish in parts.

I definitely recommend it, as the ‘story within a story’ is really intriguing.

Was this review helpful?

Told in true crime-style interview transcripts and emails between investigators--and with Joseph Knox as a character within his own novel--this playful and clever format elevates the story of a campus killer.

Was this review helpful?

I have picked up this book as I thought it was an actual true story.. Didn't take me long to understand that it wasn't, however the idea behind it is very interesting. To show events through the eyes of different people, who witnessed the same events..
In fact it's a brilliant idea! Execution wasn't as good in my opinion. It dragged and dragged and dragged.. for something that is supposed to look like a true story there were a bit too many "big" events and "not coincidences" in it.
Ending made me think that the author just ran out of ideas. Maybe it was supposed to leave way too many questions unanswered, way too many strange events, but it didn't sit well with me.
Not exactly the author's fault, but it was also very poorly edited for a kindle reader and I had to go back to my table to read certain parts of it. It was also interesting that parts that were supposed to be "edited out" of the emails etc. were all readable on kindle. Including phone number that was supposed to be couloured out.

Was this review helpful?

True Crime Story is the first stand-alone from Joseph Knox and it is a story told from the perspectives and recollections of a number of unreliable witnesses.

Does it work is the big question and I’m afraid that in my case I just couldn’t get into the style or engage with any of the characters which was a disappointment.

Was this review helpful?

This is a different take on a typical genre of book. I didn’t particularly enjoy it, but I can appreciate how well crafted and put together it was. I liked the writing style and I was interested in finding out what happened.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for my copy of this book.

Was this review helpful?

I unfortunately could not get into this book at all. I thought it would grip me from the first page but got no such luck at all

Was this review helpful?