Member Reviews

This comic is about Natsumi after her younger sister and best friend that was engaged to Togo ideas and they started to date with the condition that Togo will take Natsumi to all the places he had to take her.
This is a really sad comic and I felt like the author was stepping into my heart all the time, both Natsumi and Togo have this guilt about going out after Haru death but at the same time, they have this feeling that always were there for each other.
Hary and Togo's relationship started as an arranged marriage what in my heat makes the thing more hurtful because Haru started to have a feeling for Togo and at the same time that he was trying to be a good boyfriend he was not in love with her.
I would highly recommend reading this comic if you want to understand the feeling that all the character have and make your own conclusions if they are wrong or not about their actions, in my opinion, they are not.

Was this review helpful?

Haru’s Curse is the story of Natsumi following the death of her sister, Haru. Natsumi believes that she will be cursed by Haru because following her funeral, she has started dating Haru’s fiancé, Togo. Natsumi agrees to date Togo on the condition that she wants him to only take her to places that he took Haru, so she can feel closer to Haru after her passing.

Though the manga starts with Haru’s funeral, there are a lot of flashbacks to events prior to the funeral which really help establish the relationships between Haru, Natsumi and Togo. I really liked the change between past and present day, and I felt it worked especially well to show the contrast between Togo and his relationship with each of the sisters.

Haru’s Curse is a very real and raw portrayal of death and grief. As a reader, you see a lot of Natsumi and Togo struggling with their own feelings about Haru’s death, as well as their extended families. Haru’s Curse doesn’t shy away from a serious subject matter, with many serious and often dark subject matters touched on, but in a very respectful way.

As expected, there are a lot of hurdles throughout Haru’s Curse. Not only do Natsumi and Togo have to wrestle with their own guilt and emotions surrounding Haru’s death, but there are also a lot of outside influences interfering in their relationship and

The characters of Natsumi and Togo feel incredibly nuanced, whilst also feeling very realistic. Natsumi is hardworking, excitable and cheerful, but to Togo she seems the total opposite. Togo, who comes from a prestigious family, has his whole life mapped out for him according to his family traditions and expectations. As Natsumi and Togo’s relationship develops, the reader beings to see the effect they each have on each other and how they each change as a result of their relationship.

What I really liked about Haru’s Curse is that characters actually talk to each other. I’ve read a lot of manga where miscommunication is key, or characters bottle things up, but in this there is none of that. This helps all of the characters feel a lot more like the adults they are meant to be, and also a lot more realistic – this is what real people do after all! Well… for the most part anyway.

There’s a lot to like about Haru’s Curse, and it poses really interesting questions about how to honour the dead and how to move on after the death of a loved one. Haru’s Curse does seem to go too far at times – I did feel like it could have been left that Natsumi and Haru’s relationship was just sisterly, but the manga edges slightly further this and Natsumi declares at points that she was in love with Haru. Fortunately, this isn’t really a main area of focus and you can easily move past it and focus on the many great parts of Haru’s Curse.

Was this review helpful?

DEEP. So very deep.
Usually the mangas that I read are light and fluffy but I really enjoyed how different this one was.
I feel so bad for Natsumi. Not only did her sister die but she is riddled with guilt.
I think if it was under different circumstaces, she would be in the wrong. But considering it was an arranged marriage and Natsumi has genuine feelings then she really can't be blamed for following her heart. Especially not after everything she did for Haru. I think in death Haru became very selfish. She should want her sister to be happy.
She also wanted Togo to be happy. What if Togo being with Natsumi is what makes him truly happy?
Haru didn't like being treated like a child but she acted like one.

Was this review helpful?

Natsumi and Haru are sisters and they are the closest family to each other after their parents divorce and the father remarries. When they are teenagers, Haru starts dating Togo as part of an engagement in an arranged marriage. They are together for two years when Haru dies from a non-specified cancer. Later Togo asks Natsumi to go out with him and she agrees on the condition they go to the places he went with Haru. Thus begins a sort of relationship between Natsumi and Togo that isn't all that straightforward.

This story probably falls under the josei genre of manga which is targeted at women. For the most part there's an aura of gloom over the story. Natsumi feels guilty for dating her sister's fiance and there's a similar feeling for Togo. Both characters have to move forward and this story tells how they both go about it. Although the subject is kind of complicated, the telling of the story is simple, with flashbacks to earlier times to help tell the story.

Overall, it's a nice story about two adults and is done without a lot of fuss.

I give this 3.5 stars.

Thank you to Netgalley and Kodansha Comics for sharing an advanced reader copy in exchange for a fair review.

Was this review helpful?

Haru's Curse is a bittersweet story of familial and romantic love. I have pulled away from romance manga for years now, but I was drawn to Haru's Curse based off the synopsis. It seemed different, to put it simply.

The clean, simplistic art style contrasts starkly to the darker story. Haru's Curse is a complete 180 from the other romance manga I decided to pick up recently. And I must say, that despite the fact that I could feel my heart wrench a little with every chapter, I genuinely loved Haru's Curse.

With the ghost of a sister and lover constantly in the background, does the guilt ever really go away?

I highly recommend this book!

Was this review helpful?

NOTE: I received a free preliminary, and likely unedited copy of this book from Netgalley for the purposes of providing an honest, unbiased review of the material. Thank you to all involved.

"Natsumi’s little sister Haru was her whole world—and now she’s gone. After the funeral, Natsumi reluctantly agrees to date her sister’s fiancé Togo. But as their relationship develops with the passing seasons, Haru’s memory lingers over them like a curse. Asuka Konishi’s English-language debut is a nuanced and affecting portrait of the conflict between romantic and familial love, and of the hard choices that face us all in making our lives our own." -- Description

I usually stay clear of romance manga because its generally childish, basically pornography for men, or entirely comprised of slapstick comedy, usually taking place in high school, and is so far distanced from my life that its like me watching Disney Channel sitcoms meant for children. I gravitated towards reading Haru’s Curse for two reasons: I love atypical art styles in anime/manga, and the description sounded mature and somewhat thrilling for a romance manga.

The art style thing comes from my distaste of how most anime has looked for the last decade or so, I’ll likely upset people here, but I feel most of the Moe Manga boom from 2008 onwards looks the same and tells the same stories, and this style has infiltrated just about every non-shonen property. The tall, angular art style in Haru’s Curse reminds me of CLAMP or its derivatives upwards of 20 years ago. I love it when manga artists are willing to move away from the stylistic norm, even if it’s a throw-back of sorts. Usually, to me, its a sign of quality. and it definitely was.

Storyline-wise, the way Asuka Konishi writes is refreshing. Most romance manga follow the tried-and-true cliched plot of 1) girl lusts over dreamy and brooding guy 2)he has mysterious past 3) they go headlong into love 4) some obstruction gets in the way 4) they work through it and are together, or in some cases the main characters die etc. It gets tiresome and seems too formulaic. This story is somewhat flipped on its head as it jumps point of view a few times, even telling the story from the male protagonist’s POV a few times. The couple in question only start “dating” as some sort of mourning for Natsumi’s younger sister Haru, who has died of cancer. Once they meet a requirement of her proposal, that Togo takes her to all the places that he enjoyed with Haru, their relationship abruptly ends. Or at least, that’s what they think. I don’t plan to spoil everything, don’t worry!

All of the main characters are written as real people, none are “Mary-Sue” perfect people, and each has flaws. Seeing the story from all points of view was great, and gave depth to everyone. This comic deals with issues like arranged marriages, familiar pressure, and even Japanese societal norms that really leaves you on the edge of your seat like any good drama would. I don’t normally say this about this genre, but I think this has been my favorite manga of the year so far, and I will try to find a way to read the author’s previous work, Raise wa Tanin ga Ii (something like: I’d Prefer It If We’re Strangers in Our Next Life).

Was this review helpful?

Natsumi’s little sister Haru means the world to her. However, after Haru tragically passes away from cancer, Natsumi begins dating her sister’s fiancé Togo on one condition: that he takes her to every place he visited with Haru.

However, as the seasons pass, both of them remain haunted by the shadow of Haru’s death.

Haru’s Curse by Asuka Konishi isn't a sugar-coated romance. It’s an emotionally-driven story about reconciling love, guilt, and loss. It navigates both romantic and family relationships with heartbreaking honesty and skill. There’s an incredible rawness to it. The characters are messy, flawed, believable.

I’m going to be honest though. The art is also more simplistic than I’m used to and it took a while to grow on me. However, by the end, I found the art style charming and the sheer earnestness in the dialogue is enough to carry the emotional weight of the story.

Lastly, one of my nitpicky issues with the manga actually boils down to the typesetting. It's the same issue I had with Go with the Clouds, North-by-Northwest since both manga are published under the same imprint of Kodansha: Vertical Comics. The font can be small at times—especially for sounds effects—making it more difficult to read in certain parts.

Overall though, Haru’s Curse is a tragically poignant and bittersweet josei romance about two souls coping with the death of a loved one while coming to terms with their own feelings for each other. I cannot recommend it enough.

Was this review helpful?

This was such an interesting reading. The manga is about this girl called Natsumi who starts dating her dead-sister Haru's fiance (and they're both well-aware of that detail).

What I liked about this story was the complexity of it. Natsumi and Haru were so close because their mother left and their father married shortly after that, leaving their with the feeling of being no longer wanted. But they grew too close Natsumi keeps thinking if that wasn't she being in love with her sister. She makes up her mind after hanging out with Togo (Haru's ex).

The story not only focuses on Natsumi's pov, as Togo also has his chapters so the reader fully knows how those two felt while Haru was still alive. We even get Haru's pov throughout the manga. So we've got the feelings of guilt as these two characters weren't supposed to fall for each other.

Was this review helpful?

Absolutely adored this story. I found the themes of grief and healing to be extremely engaging.
Haru's Curse really surprised me at the end of the day because I did not expect to feel so emotional reading it.

I found the artwork to also be stunning.

Was this review helpful?

C/W: Grief, cancer and talk of suicide,

This manga was a mesmerising exploration of love and filial duty. The art-style is crisp and unsurprising. I loved that this volume contained the entire story and the special chapters.

The story follows Togo and Natsumi who decide to date each other after Haru's death. However, the memory of Haru is a cloud over their relationship as Haru was Natsumi's younger sister and engaged to Togo.

In all honesty, this is a really gentle, somewhat dark, story that asks the question "Who should we live our lives for?". While romance plays a central role it does not overshadow the other themes or concepts presented in "Haru's Curse". The translator, Hannah Airriess did a wonderful job with this series and this is probably why "Haru's Curse" is definitely a new favourite. I can't wait to explore more of Asuka Konishi's work.

Thank you to NetGalley and Kodansha Comics for access to an e-arc of "Haru's Curse" in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley, Kodansha Comics, Vertical Comics, and Asuka Konishi for the opportunity to read this book in exchange for an honest review.

This is a very wholesome slice-of-life manga complete in one 360 page volume. The English translation was very well done. The story was pristine and the art was nice too.

The story starts off with the death of Natsumi's sister, Haru, who was engaged to a man named Togo. Even while dating Haru, Togo had feelings for Natsumi, and Natsumi only had love for her sister. After Haru's death, Natsumi and Togo begin to date with certain terms, though Togo took it seriously while Natsumi did not. How can someone date the same person her dead sister dated? Both are wracked with guilt, but also come to terms with the reality of death and what it means to move forward in life.

This was an all-around excellent manga that really dealt with realistic hardships and explored the different forms of love and what they mean to the living. A wonderful manga I would recommend to somewhat older readers, but anyone can enjoy this story and take it to heart.

Was this review helpful?

Big shout out too NetGalley for an advanced copy!

I read this in one go straight through and I am looking forward to continuing to support the author in future volumes. The art style is simple, but still manages to be charming and eye capturing. The full colored pages in this copy were astounding (always love some full colored art).

I genuinely loved each character and their interactions. I'm looking forward to seeing how this "cursed" relationship continues to bloom and what comes up for them next. I can only imagine the sets of struggles and hurdles they'll have to cross so I'm excited to see what Asuka Konishi puts out.

It was a little more somber than romances I'm used to reading, but nevertheless I enjoyed it and will be picking up this volume physically when it's released.

Was this review helpful?

Rating: 5 out of 5

Disclaimer: I received this book from Netgalley + in exchange for an honest opinion. Thank you Netgalley for the ARC

I read this in the morning and I'M FUCKING SOBBING IN THE VERY FIRST CHAPTER
This is what I like about comics or graphic novels that the romance in it has stakes and omg the slow-burn and the pain. Both Natsumi and Togo slowly fall for each other after Haru died and they feel guilty especially Natsumi. The way Togo just fall for Natsumi is such a fluff. The story is so gloomy and dark. I thought the ending will be a sad ending where Natsumi or Togo ended up dying.

Thank you so much Netgalley for the chance to read this comics.

Was this review helpful?

I already knew about Asuka Konishi’s other works and I enjoyed it thoroughly so when I got the opportunity to read their other work like this, I was very thankful. I already knew there was going to be some emotions flying about and complicated ones at that. Overall I enjoyed the journey we went through with Natsumi, a dedicated older sister who took care of her younger sister to the point of calling her overbearing, and Togo, the ex fiancé who cared, but heart wasn’t in the the marriage proposal.

If you want a short, but emotional ride, please go ahead and read this story. The art is pretty and the explanation overall is very much their with complexed human emotions that one reader can understand.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for this aRC in exchange for my honest review.

I have to say that this story started strong and got better by the end. It's a story about lost, grief but also about second chances in life, new starts and the discovery of oneself.
I loved everything about this book and I never loved mangas with tragedy but this book made me change my mind because it was so well written. Asuka Konishi is a discovery for me and after this story I want to read her other books.

Was this review helpful?

After the death of her sister Haru, Natsumi starts dating Haru's fiance Togo. They both have feelings for each other but they also feel an incredible amount of guilt. Will their love be enough for them to move on with their lives or will they get stuck in Haru's curse?
The synopsis was very interesting to me but I didn't know what to expect going in. And I ended up really liking this. Natsumi was adorable. Awkward, loud but ultimately very kind and caring. Her father is an idiot though, somehow her stepmother loves her more than her own dad. Togo is also quite interesting. His life has been planned for him from the very beginning and he always did what his parents wanted him to do. Togo's mother wanted him to marry Haru and Togo was going to and probably would have, but he found himself drawn more and more to Natsumi. Her personality is a polar opposite of his and they balance each other really well. It didn't take long for me to start rooting for this romance, I wanted these two characters to be happy. The arstyle was interesting, particularly in the way faces and bodies were drawn but I liked it a lot, it was unique.
My only criticism is that I wanted more character development. Natsumi mentioned once that she wasn't sure about her sexual orientation and that she might have been in love with her sister. And then it is not explored further. I mean, it definitely should have been a topic of some discussion, right? I think this book should have been a little longer so that more time could have been spent on the characters. But overall it is a good book and would definitely recommend.
Thank you to Netgalley for a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

3.5/5 stars (rounded up to 4)

I received an ARC of this manga in exchange for an honest review.

When Natsumi's younger sister dies, she's devastated. Haru was Natsumi's whole world, and her loss is hard to deal with. Haru had been dating Togo, a man from a wealthy family. In a strange twist of events, Natsumi reluctantly agrees to date him. As the two continue to see each other, the memory of Haru hangs over them, making them question if what they're doing is right.

I have mixed feelings about this manga. I liked the art style and I liked the way that grief, loss, and guilt were portrayed. I never really connected to the two main characters, and their relationship seemed a bit strange.

Ultimately, the art was beautiful and the story was okay. I'm not sure if I would recommend this--I guess it depends on the reader.

Was this review helpful?

After Natsumi's younger sister and best friend Haru dies at the age of 19, she begins dating Haru's fiancee Togo - on the condition that he take her only to places he had taken her sister. Their relationship deepens as the seasons pass, but Haru's curse lies between them...
Will there be happiness after Haru's curse is broken?- Goodreads

I thoroughly enjoyed this book and wish it was longer to see what happens.

The story is simple enough but it is the complex emotions that keeps me hanging on. The unfortunate and unexpected death of Haru keeps the book going but it isn't exactly the main story until the end. I liked it that way; it allowed Natsumi and Togo to grow on me as a reader and it made me feel for them.

The overall story gave a different perspective to some very hard choices. Moving on to the artwork, I thought I wouldn't like it but it fit the overall story perfectly. Although blocky, it was detailed and the artist showed a lot of intense emotions through the book.

I really wish there was another book as I really want to see what happens. This is not to say that the ending was crappy or that it keeps you on a cliff hanger; its to say that the I was so moved by the story and how it was written, how it was drawn that I want more of it.

Overall,

This manga isn't for the faint of heart in regards to emotions but overall, I loved it.

Was this review helpful?

Holy heck, this manga was quite a ride. I had just finished reading a cute shojo manga before starting this one, so it was quite a switch. The story is about a young woman named Natsumi who is super close to her younger sister Haru. After her sister falls ill and dies, Natsumi begins dating her sister's fiancé Togo in order to go on the dates they went on and try to cling to the memories of her. The art style is nice and the story was captivatingly sad. The only big downside to this read for me were the references to consanguineous dating/marriage, as Togo belongs to a prestigious family and is expected to keep the bloodline "pure." Other than that it was engaging and I enjoyed it.

Was this review helpful?

Rating: 3.5

I always enjoy finding new mangas to read and was excited to see this one on Netgalley. It also has both volumes included so I could finish it right away!

Haru’s Curse follows the life of Natsumi after her younger sister dies. The book is filled with grief and what people do to deal with it. It also follows her relationship with Togo (The fiancée of her younger sister), who she has agreed to date on one condition.

There are a couple times where the point-of-view switches as to better understand both characters, Natsumi and Togo as they find themselves in this weird relationship. There are also past tense scenes to help bridge the gap of how they all interacted with Haru (the sister). It all added to the plot and helped bridge the gap.

Natsumi is definitely a wreck as she doted on her sister who was the only one really there for her growing up. They didn’t have the best childhood and it was easy to understand why such a loss would cause her to spiral at times.

Togo has been living under his mother’s thumb since they day he was born. He hasn’t ever had to make any choices of his own but he does come out of his shell when he is around Natsumi. I did like seeing that side of him.

Both of them have a lot in common and it is easy to understand why they would find themselves in such a predicament. Although it isn’t easy on their conscious as they struggle to come to terms with grief and learning to move on when you don’t want to hurt the one who is no longer living.

Overall, I liked this one. The ending was a bit on the meh side as I don’t like open-ended but I still am happy I gave this one a chance.

Was this review helpful?