Member Reviews

Kate in Waiting is a charming tale of friendship, love and learning how to be yourself in the best light you can.
Many thanks to NetGalley and Penguin for allowing me an eARC in exchange for an honest review

Plot summary:
Kate and her best friend Anderson do everything together- musicals, summer camps, crushes. Everything always feels better when you can do it together though, right?

When Matt, a dreamy kid from summer camp starts at their school and joins the school musical, suddenly not everything is as fun. As Kate and Anderson begin to fight over the boy they both like, and musical auditions giving Kate the opportunity to be in the spotlight with Matt will they both come out of the year with their friendship and hearts intact?

Review:
Plot wise- It was honestly pleasantly surprising how much this book packed in to such a short story. Kate and Anderson from start to finish had some fantastic plot points and developments that kept me genuinely gripped to this story. Also the mass of pop culture references in this story was such a delight- particularly Tangled as it is also my favourite Disney movie.

I managed to finish it in less than a day and it is honestly some genuine light reading that everyone can get on board with.

In addition, gold stars for the LGBT representation in this story it was good to see.

On the flip side I did feel like some of the chapters where really short and could have had a little bit more in them, but overall I really enjoyed the plot and story set up
.
Pacing wise– It was a generally fast paced story which I thoroughly enjoyed and it kept me engaged throughout.

Character wise- Kate was an absolute delight to read and see develop throughout this story. As someone who grew up in a similar environment (Theatre kid with a love of musicals and some traits of anxiety) it was truly wonderful to relate to her and everything she went through as the story progressed.
Anderson is also wonderfully developed and is the gay best friend I wish I had- but without the jealousy as sometimes I did find it a tad too much.

All the secondary characters had some development however it did vary depending on the prominence to the story. I still feel like I don’t know Matt very well despite being a love interest but know quite a lot more about Kate’s brother Ryan. Overall though each character did have some development which is always a positive for me.

World building- Honestly the premise and set up were done expertly and I really enjoyed every moment.

Final Thoughts:
A sparkling coming-of-age romance for anyone who wants romance, friendship and so many pop culture references I was left in awe.

Was this review helpful?

This was a bit hit and miss for me. Whilst I enjoyed the background characters, Kate at times is insufferable and being in her head for the entire book detracts from the enjoyment of the overall plot.

Was this review helpful?

Becky Albertalli just manages to amaze me everytime. She always brings something so refreshing and new to the book community. I adored this book. Kate was an amazing character, I loved the dynamics between her and Anderson. Also, I enjoyed the sibling bond presented between Kate and Ryan, it was really lovely to see. I love authors showing off platonic soulmate friendships!! It's so important to show nowadays that you can be in love with your friends in a completely platonic way and Becky did this fabulously. The theatre aspect brings the whole book together for me, it's a perfect background for what is happening in this book and being a big theatre nerd myself, it made me feel warm and fuzzy. I was rooting for the romance between Noah and Kate from the outset, I love that Noah proved himself to not be like the other boys and was there for Kate and made her feel special. This book was outstanding and Becky Albertalli deserves all the love for it.

Was this review helpful?

The was seriously unexpected. I thought I had read my favourite BA book by far...but maybe this is it? This book has a giant piece of my heart and that comes from a place where I very rarely if ever read YA anymore.

Was this review helpful?

I'm afraid it is a DNF for me at 160 pages.
I'm not gelling with the character of Kate at all. The phrases she uses are getting to me, constant use of f-boy, f-girl, f-force, f-whatever you can think of is too much. It is like the author tried to see how many times they could fit that phrase in the book and totally detracts from everything else. It feels like a try-hard to be 'cool' with the teens that will read this book. Unfortunately, there isn't anything with the plot that can keep me hanging on at this point.
Just not for me, I'm afraid!

Was this review helpful?

Genre: Romance / YA

Release Date: Expected 20th April 2021



Kate and Anderson share the stage, and their lives with each other. They're the best friends you could ask for; even if some people might think they're a little co-dependant. They're even crushing on the same guy from afar, because a crush is much less crushing when you've got someone to share it with.

But now, the object of their affections isn't so far away when he transfers to their school. Matt is perfect, and compared to the amount of fuckboys populating their classes he's looking even better. Gorgeous, kind, talented - Kate adores him. But so does Anderson. But now it isn't just some hypothetical crush, Kate and Anderson need to face the music or this could be curtains for their relationship.

From the first scene, I could feel the love Kate and Andy had for each other and I was dying to be their friend. They were sweet, charming and so beautifully real. They were also naive, impulsive and irrational - but of course they are, they're teenagers trying to navigate first loves. What did you expect?

I felt so many parts of my teenage self on the pages of this story - the confusion, the discovery, and oh god - the f-boys. I had such a visceral reaction that I physically cringed at them because I knew exactly who they were the second they stepped onto the page.

This was so much more than just a cute, easy love story - this was a story about growing up, and most of all the story about how not all soulmates are romantic.

Sweet, Sincere and so very sassy - this is another classic in the making from Albertalli that will leave you with a giant smile on your face.



RATING: ⭐⭐⭐⭐

Thank you to Becky Albertalli, NetGalley and Balzer + Bray for an Advance Readers Copy in return for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

A huge presence and the kind of book you’ll read with a big grin on your face, even when things aren’t going well.
Our main characters are Kate Garfield and her best friend Anderson Walker. Friends for years they are known for their strange rituals, and their shared crushes. During their recent summer camp they’ve both developed a crush on the same boy, Matt.
From the off we’re plunged into their little world and their shared fondness for drama. There’s the expected cute friend moments, a bit of drama and a general sense of expectation.
As they wait to audition for their annual theatre production, a proverbial spanner is thrown into the works...crush Matt has transferred to their school.
Cue problems.
Kate and Anderson vow not to let a crush derail their friendship. Sometimes the reality is quite different. Of course, though we see this from Kate’s view it is evident from fairly early on that she’s not the most observant of people and I was desperate to see if/when she’d open her eyes and see what was in front of her.
This is another Albertalli hit in the making, I’m sure, and I’m grateful I got the chance to read this before publication thanks to NetGalley. I’m not even that into theatre but still found myself captivated by this.

Was this review helpful?

I am a big fan of Becky Albertalli. Simon Vs is one of my favourite books - I have read it several times. So I was really excited to read this latest offering from one of my favourite YA authors. Honestly? It’s no Simon Vs. It’s sweet, but predictable. I certainly enjoyed it enough to read it in one sitting one night when insomnia was keeping me awake. But it lacks that X factor that we’ve come to expect from a Becky Albertalli story. All in all, it’s worth a read as long as you go into it knowing it’s not the authors’ best work. If I am completely honest, this isn’t one I’ll be re-reading in the future.

Was this review helpful?

This book was a beautiful love letter to the theatre, told via Becky Albertalli’s signature blend of cuteness and sincerity. It was just the book I wanted it to be.

I am a huge fan of Becky’s writing, Simon vs the Homo Sapiens Agenda is a comfort read of mine, so I had high expectations going into Kate In Waiting. Thankfully it did not disappoint. The characters are as likeable as you would expect. You’re rooting for all of the different love stories throughout. There’s drama, both on stage and off, and I genuinely understood where both sides were coming from in the conflict. A lot of YA and some adult romance I’ve read recently seems to add conflict just for the sake of conflict but with this I could really understand each characters point of view. The love triangle trope done well.

If you’re looking for a quick, lighthearted read that will leave you with a huge smile on your face at the end, maybe think about picking this one up!

Was this review helpful?

This was hilariously delightful, which is no surprise to anyone who has read Albertalli’s other books. It follows Kate and her best friend Anderson, who do and share everything together - they even have ‘communal crushes’. Which is fine, those crushes never get serious-they doesn’t notice them,or they never see them again after summer camp.

Except this time their ‘communal crush’ Matt has just moved to their town and is now attending their school. Emotions run high and Friendship is tested as both Kate and Anderson realise they can’t both win the guy.

It was so addictive I ended up finishing it in a day,it was that good. I loved all of the characters and thought the LGBTQ+ characters (Anderson specifically but also Raina,etc) were well written and relatable,more so than I’ve seen in other Contemporary YA novels.

As this is a romance, romantic relationships are a given but the importance of friendship, platonic love and the bond of siblings is also established. I enjoyed the scenes with Kate’s families’ dogs, Charles and Camilla - who are used to great comic effect and I couldn’t help but love Noah (f-boy or not).

Honestly, I can’t imagine any YA Romance or Contemporary teen romance lovers not liking this book, it’s got humour, romance and drama - what more could you ask for?

Also a huge thank you to Penguin Randomhouse and Net Galley for ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Having previously read and quite enjoyed Albertalli's Creekwood novels, I was excited to get my hands on her new novel in the form of 'Kate in Waiting'. I am also a huge theatre nerd so anything with a backdrop of putting on a show is already a winner in my eyes. Kate and her classmates are putting on a production of 'Once Upon a Mattress' which leads to all kinds of friendship and relationship drama behind the scenes.

Kate and her best friend Andy share many things, including intense crushes. The past summer, they fell in love with Matt at summer camp, having no idea whether their feelings were returned and leaving this behind them in another state. However, we have a Grease style surprise when Matt not only moves to Roswell Hill High but signs up to audition for the school musical. Unexpectedly, he is everywhere Kate and Andy turn! The pair's feelings towards Matt are definitely not sustainable long term and so their friendship is about to be tested to its limit.

The plot of 'Kate in Waiting' is completely predictable from the moment each main character is introduced. However, it is a very sweet story with a diverse representation of characters which will be loved by the teenage target audience. Personally, I love the emphasis on Kate and Andy's platonic connection and the love between friends often being the most powerful and enduring. There are also some brilliant supporting characters such as the goofy Noah, Kate's sweet brother Ryan and forthright friends Raina and Brandie. I only wish Albertalli would cease and desist with the use of the terms f-boy/ f-girl - every other sentence got wearing.

Overall, this is a sweet, if predictable, novel which will be widely enjoyed, especially those who are fans of the theatre and an adorable showmance! 4 stars.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher who provided an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I had a lot of fun reading this book! Becky Albertalli always manages to write incredibly cute YA romances and this was no exception. Whilst this book was very predictable, the love between Kate and Noah was very cute and fun. Their scenes together always made me smile and they were the best parts of the book. I enjoyed the theatre aspect but also loved that it didn't take over the entire plot of the story. The only reason I gave this a lower rating was because of the friendship aspect. The friendship between Kate and Anderson just didn't work as I found it to be quite toxic. I didn't like how Kate always had to apologise for spending time with Matt when Anderson was doing the same thing. I felt like Anderson was quite mean towards Kate and I didn't like how their friendship worked. However, I still really enjoyed this story and I would recommend it as a cute YA romance.

Was this review helpful?

Kate in Waiting is narrated by Kate, an awkward high school junior who is deeply committed to musical theatre and very reliant on her gay best friend Anderson. Kate and Andy have a history of 'sharing crushes', so they can discuss the same guys together, and when they meet Matt, it looks like business as usual. However, when they both find themselves developing genuine feelings for Matt as they all work together on the school's latest theatre production, Kate is afraid that this crush will ruin her friendship with Andy. How can Kate and Andy navigate this situation, and will Kate be able to gain in confidence and step into the limelight of her own life?

My lukewarm feelings about Kate in Waiting have led me to the conclusion that I just don't get on with Becky Albertalli books with straight protagonists (I thought this was a little bit better than The Upside of Unrequited, but nowhere near as good as Simon Vs The Homo Sapiens Agenda or Leah on the Offbeat). Unfortunately, they tend to become a little too sugary for my liking, and that was the case here - there was a lot to like about Kate's relationship with Andy, and also with her brother, Ryan, but in both cases, I thought Albertalli laid it on a little too thick. The plot was also incredibly predictable, which robbed the central section of the book of the tension it might otherwise have had. I think Albertalli fans will still enjoy this one, but for me, it needed a bit more bite. 3.5 stars.

I will post the full version of this review to Goodreads and to my blog nearer the publication date.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Netgalley for letting me read this book in return for an honest review.

I was very excited when I saw this book as I am a huge fan of Becky Albertalli's. I managed to read this within one sitting and while I loved the complexities of friendships and highschool, I do have a few minor complaints.

For starters, the use of f-boy and f-girl. I don't care about swearing but the terms were used a little too much within the book. I wish there was more development between a few of the characters because even though I loved them all together, I personally feel like there could have been just a little more to make it perfect. My last complaint is that I could tell that it was about a girl who was 16/17 and I find that sometimes, I cannot connect with that as, currently, I am in the mood for a slightly more mature main character (this is not me saying that 16 and 17-year-olds are immature) and tone of the book.

Now that those small issues are out of the way, let's get to the good! I loved how open Kate and her family were about being Jewish and being a divorced family. Noah is an absolute cutie in my opinion and I seemed to smile whenever he was around, Andy is just pure passion with his rants and enthusiasm, Ryan is the standard mysterious brother but he really shone through at times, Matt is so brilliantly lovely and kind, Raina and Brandie are the mums of the group and Kate, the lady in waiting, is a sixteen-year-old who is just trying to figure out life.

Rating: 3.5/4⭐
Would I Read It Again? Yes
Would I Recommend it? Yes

Was this review helpful?

After spending the summer at camp and having a huge crush on Matt, Kate and her best friend Anderson are shocked to see him on the first day of school. How are they going to navigate the school year when they both have huge crushes on him.

Becky Albertalli is one of my favourite authors and I was thrilled be given an advanced copy of Kate In Waiting. It certainly did not disappoint. Becky has written yet another gorgeous novel about been a teenager and the struggles that come along with it. This story of young love and friendship is witty and tender and I devoured it in one sitting. I will certainly be recommending it to everyone I know!

Was this review helpful?

I've loved every one of Becky Albertalli's books so far, although I might be biased as Simon Vs. Was the book that helped me come out and What if its us is one of my favourite books ever. Saying that, I was worried this wouldn't live up to those so I tempered my expectations. I shouldn't have done, though, because it was every bit as special as the rest of her work. My absolute favorite part was how it clearly showed the importance and magnitude of platonic relationships - that's something more books definitely need to make a big deal out of. Oh, and the love interests? Absolutely swoon-worthy, of course. One of my favourite books of the year so far and such a comforting read.

Was this review helpful?

4 to 4.5 stars! I can't decide, uhh.

I love Becky's writing. Her books, this one included, are usually so delightful.

What I loved the most in this book was relationship between Kate and Anderson. Their friendship is beautiful, and I think it's really important to show that friendship is a relationship. A platonic one, but it's still a relationship. It's still important.

Kate and Anderson are not "just" friends. They are best friends. They live next to each other, they share their interests. And their crushes.

And it's all nice until one of their shared crushes becomes something more than just a crush. They both really, really, really like this boy.

This is the part of the book that I really liked, because it was so real? How to be happy for your best friend when it breaks your own heart? Is it even possible?

Relationship between Kate and Noah was so subtle. Sometimes it felt.. too subtle. I did like them together, tho!

The only part I didn't like/didn't really get/was a bit confusing, was the talk Anderson and Kate had after Kate's talk with Matt. I didn't understand Anderson's explanation at all. It didn't make sense to me. I expected something better.

I finished this book in one sitting, I couldn't stop reading it, because it was just... Nice. Even with the things I didn't really like. It left me with this warm feeling inside and a huge smile on my face.

Thanks to Netgalley for providing me with an ARC of this book.

Was this review helpful?

This is one of my favourite Becky Albertalli books. I loved the formatting of the book. I loved the short chapters. I loved that it was based around a theatre performance in high school. Solid book.

Was this review helpful?

I’m sad to say I didn’t like it very much. I hated the term f-boy with a burning passion and found the main character fairly self centred and annoying.

Was this review helpful?