Member Reviews
I apprecitate the publisher allowing me to read this book. I found this a really interesting read and the characters are quite engaging. it kept me reading until the end. I highly recommend.
Initially, I found myself struggling to bond with the characters in Tania in China - the text seemed to be quite abrupt - it didn't flow.
However, the further I read, the more the text became enjoyable - it aligns itself well with the major topics - politics, love, and courage.
The main protagonist Tania is of Russian descent and we read about her forays into society, her relationships both in love and friendship. The book is set amongst a political backdrop of China and Foster writes with such clarity that the reader gains an insight into the China that never reveals itself to western eyes,
At +800 pages this is definitely a saga, so there is some rich details included, and readers will get to know a few of the characters very well. It's mostly engaging, and has some good dialog, nice descriptions, and drama. This will stick with anyone who tackles this impressive novel. Recommended.
Thanks very much to the publisher for the review copy!!
Tania in China by Ben Foster is an interesting book covering China from just before the formation of the communist party in Shanghai in 1921 through Mao’s death in 1976. Although it is fiction, the main characters of China’s history of this period are easily identifiable behind their fictious names.
I was looking for a book like this as I am an avid collector and reader of books by “Old China Hands.” These were mainly Americans many of whom were born in China around the beginning of the 20th century and went to America for college and then returned to China in the 20’s and 30’s. Others came to China to seek adventure, became journalists or wrote books as the 1st draft of history. Some of these writers are Pearl Buck, Edgar Snow, Agnes Smedley and Emily Hahn. There were professional historians such as Owen Lattimore and John Fairbanks as well as State Department officials like John Service and John Patton Davies. But these are all Americans and view the formation of China through their eyes. Where is a book in English as viewed by the Chinese? Mr. Foster does a very good job of telling this story mainly from the interactions of the Chinese leaders among themselves as well as Tania, a Russian who is supposed to guide them and inform the COMINTERN and Stalin.
I think the book succeeds in telling about the power struggles especially among the communists. My only complaint is the length of time going through all the battles between the KMT and the Communists.
What I also found interesting was the story of how Mao was able to hold onto power till his death by playing each of his rivals off each other. More or less replicating the power used by Stalin in the Soviet Union. All the while Mao being fearful of the 1st draft of history ruining his reputation as Khrushchev.
All in all, I would recommend this book to anyone wishing to learn more about how Mao’s Chinese Party came to rule China.