Member Reviews
Annie Lang is introduced as a young girl whose mother has died when she was 6, and despite her strict religious (cult-like) upbringing, she does not see Jesus as one who loves the little children, since He doesn't seem to care very much about her. There are several things that just don't make much sense to little Annie and no one seems keen to let her in on it.
Years pass and when she returns from France from a school stint, she is struck by the strange occurrences that, again, no one seems ready to speak of. Her brother is in a mental hospital where her father will rarely visit, her father's "new" wife is just as horrid as before, and her sister Bea is mum. Annie is determined to find out what is going on and why her favorite Sunday School teacher is also missing. Her digging uncovers more than she could guess and the weight of it propels her into a quest to make it right. She finds unlikely allies as her world begins to unravel and she must figure out what path she will take to keep herself from falling down into the abyss.
This was a fairly slow burn historical mystery/family drama. I tend to enjoy the character development and world building that is done, but I could see how this one may take a bit to stay with it. I would encourage the reader/listener to stay with it! It felt at times that there were several confusing lines to follow, but as a good slow burn does, it brings it all together in the end. I did find myself frustrated that Annie couldn't find out more, but then I would remember that she was a child and naturally did not see it all in an adult perspective. This was a fascinating choice. There was a real heart-wrenching moment for Annie when she begins to lose her childlike naiveté, and those moments are such that cannot be taken back.
I really enjoyed getting into Annie's head and being able to watch her grow. I had such frustration alongside her and anger and confusion! I saw how she chose her moments carefully over time, and had to admit she may have better self-control than me.
I listened to the audio version of this story, and I do admit I had to replay a few sections. This wasn't a story that I could just gloss over. I wanted to understand what exactly was happening. I think the narrator, Joanna Ruiz was fantastic and gave Annie all the emotions and growth along the way.
I would recommend this story for those who are ready to enter the world and character building before the deeper darker drama unfolds. I finished the audio quickly; however, I don't know if I would speed through this one if I were to read the book. I definitely enjoyed all the underlying mystery, family drama, and suspense.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for the audio. I was transported and enveloped in the mystery all while I was supposed to be working. All opinions are voluntary and my own!
A very enjoyable book. It's a story of a young girls growing up in an atmosphere of religious fervour and hypocrisy in the 1920's and 30's. It is very much a period piece exploring the role and treatment of women in that period. The story is narrated by Annie, her understanding changing as she grows older.
I had the audio version, which was extremely well read and added a lot to the atmosphere of the story.
This is an honest review of a complementary ARC.
I really enjoyed this book. Well I enjoyed listening to the audiobook and thought the narrator was great. She really brought the book to life. I really loved reading about the young character coming of age story. Also the not so nice step mother that liked to control her every move. It was the depths of the characters that brought this to life and made it throughly enjoyable. The little details made the characters believable making it very easy to relate to them and love or hate them. The book created a great sense of atmosphere and tension for the period. I enjoyed the slightly slower pace of the novel but I lost concentration during the middle of the book and got a little confused. Whether that was my fault or the books is unknown. I really enjoyed the pace at the end of the book. The beginning and end really made this book for me. If it wasn't for the middle section I would of rated it higher as I actually gave it a 3.5 but rounded it up a little. This book would make a great genre hybrid book as it contains part historical fiction, part mystery and part young adult read.
Thanks to the author and publishers for allowing us to enjoy this great book. I'm happy I got to enjoy this book.
Posted reviews 11/11/21 on the following sites goodreads , amazon, Barnes&noble, waterstones, kobo, Google books and my blog https://ladyreading365.wixsite.com/website/post/the-dissent-of-annie-lang-by-ros-franey-saga-egmont-3-5-stars
*A big thank-you to Ros Franey, Saga Egmont Audio, and NetGalley for arc in exchange for my honest review.*
Ms Franey knows how to present the world seen through child's eyes. Annie, the youngest of three, as a child observes the world and does not comprehend fully what she sees. Her perception is limited by her age and by her siblings together with her father and step-mother. The family belong to a strict religious community founded by one of her ancestors and which has an impact on her ubringing.
The plot takes place in the mid-1920 and the early 1930, and we are offered a slow path towards Annie's full realisation of what she witnessed as a child.
This is a novel that uncovers hypocrisy swept under the rug and suffering of women who were abused and confined to an asylum in order to keep up appearances.
I loved this audiobook, and I was quite surprised by how much I enjoyed it. As it went on, I loved it more and more and I really liked Annie, the main character of the story. Annie is such a sweet soul, but she has a hard life. The story is told from the olden days, and life then was much different to how it is now, so sometimes it was hard to read about the type of things that Annie had to endure. I was quite surprised at what happened with her father, but I liked the way Annie handled it at the end! She is so strong and powerful and I just loved her! I highly recommend this book, as the narrator was great, the story was great and the characters were well portrayed, even if some of them were annoying. The book made me appreciate my life more and all the luxuries that myself and my family have, as well as us all having each other. Interesting and fantastic book!
Many thanks to the author, publisher and NetGalley for a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
A well executed dual timeline historical fiction with a dash of mystery.
We meet Annie Lang as a young woman just returned home to the UK from an extended stay in France. Upon her return she learns that her brother has been put into an asylum for undisclosed mental health issues and her former beloved Sunday school teacher has disappeared without a trace. Annie is suspicious of the claims her family makes and wants to get to the heart of the matter. In the course of her fact-finding mission, other family secrets emerge, leading to some unexpected turns.
The second timeline shows Annie's diary entries as a young child who loses her mother and then has to contend with a cold and oppressive stepmother who only sees her flaws. Growing up in a strict religious community, she is brought up to believe in the doctrines of her church, but struggles with her faith due to her mother's early death. This leads her to question other narratives her family tells and facilitates her development into an independent, slightly headstrong girl that tries hard to fulfill her own wishes within the confines of her position.
The characters are well drawn, if a bit stereotypical at times (looking at you, evil stepmother), the voice of Annie well realised, both as a child and a young woman. I enjoyed watching her grow into an independent thinker that keeps her own council.
The novel explores ideas of morality, faith, sexual abuse and the inherent misogyny that governs the ways society judges victims over perpetrators, a theme unfortunately still very timely, even though here it is explored within the 1920s in a religious community.
I listened to this on audio, and the narrator Joanna Ruiz deftly inhabits Annie at both ages with nuanced changes to her tone and inflections that distinguish between child and young woman.
Thanks to Saga Egmont Audio and NetGalley for providing me with an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
The dissent of Annie Lang - Ros Franey
I loved the narrator and narrative respectively. This lady’s voice reminded me very much of Victoria Wood and so I was imaging the story being told by her.
I’m not usually keen on stories where the narrative point is from a child. There are exceptions and The Dissent of Annie Lang is one. The narration is superb, with Joanna Ruiz capturing the flat Midland accent and the story is clearly set in and around Nottingham. The sense of location is strong and, for me, added to the detail making it even more immersive.
The pace is even throughout. It’s a slow burn of a tale as the listener is introduced to life in and members of Annie’s family. She’s shrewd, perceptive and humorous. She sees through many adult guile’s and in her own way, makes fools of some. Her father is widowed and suddenly a member of a religious sect becomes the stepmother from hell. She’s unkind, controlling and life is very different. Annie’s brother Fred is unwell and her sister Beatrice changes as secrets begging to emerge.
This isn’t dramatic, but there are moments where it’s intense and certainly Annie is a strongly drawn character with whom it’s easy to have empathy. Ros Frances succeeds in creating an emotional connection by the way she writes and overall, I really enjoyed this.
My thanks to the publisher for a review copy via Netgalley
Interesting though slow-moving story. I enjoy period stories. The historical background felt authentic. The characters felt lifelike and detailed. I enjoyed reading about Annie most of all.
The book takes place over three different years. Annie, her sister Beatrice, her brother Fred, stepmother Agnes and her father are the main characters. There are several others that are important to the story but most of the interaction is between Annie’s family
The Langs’ are very religious and the parents command obedience and respect at all times. Annie loses her mother at age 6 and her father remarries the housekeeper but this is no Mary Poppins story.
The second Mrs Lang was a character I strongly disliked . From her treatment of her stepchildren to the family dog, she seemed cold hearted and disagreeable. As the story continues we get an idea what has shaped her behavior and personality.
The ending was satisfying. I enjoyed the book but 3 stars for reasons of it being slow moving, and the heavy religious overtones.
The narrative was wonderful! Thank you NetGalley.
After the death of her mother, Annie struggles to find her place as the youngest child in a very strict and religious family. When Annie’s beloved Sunday school teacher goes missing, she starts to dig around. With both religious and historical constraints Annie dangerously begins to uncover disturbing things.
This book was a slow burn and did take a bit to get going but it was very enjoyable.
**huge thanks to NetGalley for the ARC
In a Nutshell: An interesting slow-burn historical lit-fic with a strong heroine, dark themes, and a multitude of points to ponder upon.
Story:
1920s Nottingham. Annie Lang is the youngest child of a strict religious family. Her grandfather is the founding patriarch of a rigid Christian sect. After her mother’s death, Annie finds herself saddled with a father who either doesn’t know or doesn’t care, and a stepmother who is draconian in her religious beliefs. She finds herself witness to many confusing and disturbing events, but she’s too young to understand exactly what’s happening.
Six years on, when she returns from France, she finds that her dear elder brother is locked away in a mental asylum and her loving Sunday school teacher, who was also her friend, has vanished without a trace. Using her childhood diary and her elder sister Beatrice, Annie becomes determined to discover the truth.
The story comes to us in the first person perspective of Annie over multiple timelines, with the present part of the story being set in 1932.
There are multiple Annie Langs in the book and each of them dissents in their own way, whether major or minor. But the title mainly refers to the narrator of the story, little Annie who seems to mature before our very eyes. Annie’s story begins and ends at a train station. And in between these two points is revealed her journey of self-realisation and gutsiness. Most of the remaining characters pale in comparison to this eponymous heroine. She is outspoken, curious, courageous, impusive, loyal, and determined. She also knows when to toe the line and when to speak her mind. Annie’s dissent isn’t necessarily bombastic; many times, her rebellion is subtle and passes unnoticed by everyone except us readers. I love a character who knows how to pick her battles because usually, we get stuck with female characters who are doormats for most of the story, or with those who are aggressive about every single thing. There’s no in-between.
This book provides an interesting glimpse into the religious repression of female voices and the predominant patriarchy in most sects that is never questioned. It’s a dark narrative even when voiced from a child’s perspective, and contains many hard-hitting themes throughout. I appreciate how the story questioned why men escape unscathed from scandal and gossip while women are castigated for the same offence. Such two-faced behaviour of religious zealots is hardly ever questioned in real life. It was hence gratifying to see it in writing.
I usually keep the genre and target age group of a book in mind to see if the book does justice to its intended readers’ expectations. But for this startling story, it is tough to categorise the genre; it has shades of psychological drama, mystery thriller, literary fiction, historical fiction, religious fiction, and bildungsroman. But whichever way I look at it, I find myself a mostly satisfied reader. Many might find the pace of the story slow, especially in the first half. But a literary fiction is usually as a slow-burn, and the content raised enough curiosity in me to persevere even through the unhurried tempo. (The fact that I heard this and didn’t read it helped a lot.)
There are some unanswered questions about the past events. And these are primarily because we hear of the past and present only through young Annie’s voice. So whatever she doesn’t know, we don’t know. While this makes writing sense, it leaves readers dissatisfied and wanting to learn more about what happened. I would have loved to get to know more about some of the other characters. I would also have loved to know what happened after the last scene. Then again, the title does tell us that the story is about the dissent of Annie Lang. And it reveals to us only whatever she is aware of. And it stops at her final act of dissent.
All in all, I enjoyed this book tremendously, even though it left me with almost as many questions as answers. Recommended mainly to lit-fic or psychological-historical fiction fans.
The audiobook clocks at a little more than 9 hrs and is narrated by Joanna Ruiz. And what a brilliant narration it was! Whether Annie was 8 or 16 or 24, her voice was portrayed with a timbre suitable to that age. Joanna brought the titular character to life in a way that never leaves you in doubt about her feelings. Of course, there are two timelines to follow in the book. So if you get confused easily between audio timelines, it might suit you to read it than listen to it. But keeping in mind the fabulous narration and the slower pace of the story, I would certainly recommend the audio version as a better choice for this book.
My thanks to Saga Egmont Audio and NetGalley for the ALC of “The Dissent of Annie Lang”. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion about the audiobook.
I really enjoyed The Dissent of Annie Lang. It was a bit of a slow burn at first but just the right amount of tension throughout. I think the book really struck a chord with me as the storyline was something which really could have happened in earlier times, and really is quite shocking. This was the audio version, the narrator did a wonderful job in capturing Annie’s spirit.
The Dissent of Annie Lang
by Ros Franey
The Dissent of Annie Lang drew me in slowly but then had a firm hold on me until the very end.
Annie Lang’s story is told by a younger and an older version of herself as she reflects on a series of confusing and disturbing events from her past. With the aid of her childhood diary, the older Annie attempts to uncover the truth behind a number of mysterious happenings in her community. The author allows us to witness the seemingly arbitrary rules, harsh punishments and contradictory behavior of the adult world through the eyes and mind of a child. This is a coming of age story, one in which Annie will learn to question the ways of her authoritarian elders, correct injustices and make her world right again.
My sincerest thanks to NetGalley and Saga Egmont Aduio for the gift of this well produced and skillfully performed audio ARC. Don’t miss it! Pub Day: 04 November 2021
#TheDissentofAnnieLang
#RosFraney
#NetGalley
#SagaEgmont
#comingofage #historicalfiction #audiobooks #foryourlisteningpleasure #myreadinglife #booksofinstagram #modernmrsdarcy #mmdbookclub
The Dissent of Annie Lang by Ros Franey is the story about the precocious, naive, and insolated Annie who knows there is something not quite right with the grown ups in her life.
Annie's family are founding members of their church. Annie got mad at Jesus when her mom died and then her father married their very strict mean housekeeper. When her new mother wants the family dog out of the house Annie sneaks the dog back in late at night. Hiding in the basement she is confused when she sees from the window a pair of high heels next to her father's shoes. When she realizes who wears those shoes she knows she has stumbled on something wrong.
As Annie grows up she realizes the adults in her life are more about "do what I say not what I do." Told with the anxiousness of youth narrator Joanna Ruiz brings reality to Annie trying to understand the world around her. I would have liked more than Annie's point of view but after all it is her story.
I received free copies of these audiobooks from the publishers via #netgalley for fair and honest reviews. All opinions are my own.
I was pleasantly surprised by this little gem of a novel. Coming of age stories are one of my favorite books and this was no exception. I loved Annie, the main character! The story follows Annie through several timelines and when listening to it, I really needed to pay attention because it could be a little confusing. My only criticism of the novel was that Annie was pretty naive, even as an adult and it seemed a little unrealistic, but I loved and sympathized with Annie, so I forgave her for it. The narrator of this audiobook, Joanna Ruiz, was amazing! I never listened to a book that she narrated before, so it was a pleasant surprise. She was able to bring Annie alive as both a child and young adult. If my mind drifted at the beginning of a chapter and I missed the timeline date, I could often tell by the small changes in her voice and inflections between the young Annie and the adult Annie. I will certainly be on the lookout for this narrator and the author for other works.
Thank you to NetGalley and Saga Egmon Audio for an Arc of this audiobook.
Thank you Netgalley for this audiobook edition of The Dissent of Annie Lang by Ros Franey.
Annie Lang has lost her beloved mother at a young age, only to have her replaced by her cold stepmother. Her childhood was not a pleasant one, but after leaving for school, and then returning, she learns just how unpleasant it really was.
Forced to rely on her steel and determination, Annie has to advocate for several members of her family. She will also discover a betrayal by an unexpected member of her family. Through her diary entries, Annie works to uncover what lead to the demise of her brother's life, and who is to blame.
This was pretty good, perhaps I would have enjoyed it as a younger person, someone closer to Annie's age. There was a bit too much time spent on the family dog, and where the dog was sleeping. I also got a bit confused at the timelines. Otherwise, a pretty solid and interesting story.
The Dissent of Annie Lang was a fascinating visit to the interbellum years outside of London. Who is Annie Lang, and from what does she dissent? Interestingly, though Annie Lang is a fictional character living a century ago, raised in a Pentecostal type Christian sect, she’s not all that unlike many young people, especially women, brought up in conservative environments currently flourishing everywhere. Rules are strict, questions are muted, and pondering apparent contradictions gets you nowhere but in trouble. The story bounces back and forth between 1926 and 1932, and listening to the audio, I found the time jumps at times disconcerting, especially since the “older” Annie, who supposedly has been away from her family studying in France for a semester, sometimes seems no more astute than her younger self. Good doesn’t literally triumph over evil in this sensitively conveyed tale; the book ends in a draw, with both sides more or less acknowledging each other and agreeing to stand-down, at least for the time being. All of this sounds rather sterile, but I liked Annie. I came to care for her sister and her brother and the friend Annie wants so desperately to help, and even though I thought the ending a trifle abrupt, I believe the characters will stay in my mind for a while.
The Dissent of Annie Lang by Ros Franey, narrated by Joanna Ruiz
Right away, due to the excellent narration by Joanna Ruiz, I felt like I knew Annie Lang. Creative, precocious, smart, inquisitive, persistent, impulsive, and loyal, Annie Lang gives the impression of having been fueled by too much sugar and caffeine, such is her energy level, running thoughts and worries. She has so much to say that she can't get the words out fast enough, all the while having to restrain herself constantly because of the obvious displeasure of adults around her. Is it a wonder she bubbles over after an hour, day, week of trying to act the way that is expected of her?
Much of Annie's early life is clouded in mystery because she was too young to be told what was happening. Who is to blame her for wanting to know why her mother died when Annie was six? And who is to blame her for feeling like she has to hide her very self under covers because her new step mother seems to hate her with a vengeance? Annie tries so hard to not displease but she's always in trouble for saying and doing things that shouldn't even be considered wrong unless you belong to The Mission faith.
The family belongs to a very strict religious group that was founded by Annie's grandfather. What better way for her witch of a step mother to lord all things over her than to use the bible to browbeat and punish Annie. Yes, Annie may be rambunctious and curious but her step mother would like to stamp the life out of Annie, it seems. Step mother may have been able to keep Annie quiet (mostly) but she wasn't make Annie forget all what she saw and heard. Once Annie is able to go away to school, she is able to come home at sixteen and break through the barriers her step mother put in place, to find out some very dark secrets.
This story has a very slow buildup to the action at the end. The sense of repression is so real and strong, not just from the church and the step mother but also from the asylum where Annie's mad brother Fred has been sent. And Annie's sister Bea has changed. Once Bea was determined to be a missionary working in a needy country but now she seems to have lost that zeal. Both Fred and Bea know things they won't reveal to Annie and Annie is determined to find out those things.
Despite having questions about some things that happened in the past, I thought the ending fits this story so well. The psychological drama that infused this historical fiction had me on the edge of my seat. It's not a thriller and it's not fast moving but I wanted to know what had happened in the past and what was happening in the present, as much as Annie did. The story has us right inside of Annie's head, I never doubted this girl, and I was always on her side.
Thank you to Saga Egmont Audio and NetGalley for this ARC.
Fantastic narrating in this layered novel. You become more & more invested in Annie’s life & quest as the story progresses & the author keeps you on the edge of your seat till the final page. Well worth investing the time to listen to.
This seems like quite an easy, chick-lit type piece of historical fiction but turns into something much darker. I found Annie Lang's innocence a bit frustrating, even reminding myself that this was set in different times to ours where different things were expected within gender roles i still found it a bit annoying that she was so naïve.
In all a good novel. The audio book was well read and enjoyable.