Member Reviews

I wanted to love this. It's not a bad book, but it doesn't really get started untill over half way through.

The beginning of the book can be summed up like a cheesy dance track, walk, talk, eat repeat.

So Gen is supposedly a master thief. He is taken from prison and sent on a quest to retrieve an ancient stone for the corrupt king. He travels a long way. And I mean a long was as this part of the story really drags on. Gen isn't a particularly likeable character at this point. He's more like a surly teen than a master thief. He basically moans about food the entire way and occasionally tells a mythological story.

The bit where he actually finds the temple and goes in for the stone is a bit better, but it lacked imagery at times. Then there's the ambush. Well personally what happened there was pretty obvious. It's all meant to be a big secret I thi k, but imo it was predictable and clear.

The ending was the best bit. Now I know that sounds rude, and it isn't meant to. Genuinely the ending is the clever bit. It ties everything together and adds a twist or two.

So overall not bad but not wow. The ending ties it all up which is clever, but the start was slow and arduous at times.

Was this review helpful?

Four stars for really well-written characters in a great world.

I liked the main character. It's been a long time since I've read a book with a male lead and it was very refreshing. I loved his wit and cunning and enjoyed how the story was interspersed with myths from the world. I liked the secondary characters too, although not so fleshed out they were still well written with intrinsic motivations.

The first half was very slow and not particularly exciting but the second half picked up big time - with some great reveals that more than made up for the first half. If it were me I would have placed some setups in the first half as some of the reveals came out of nowhere.

So much fun!

Thanks to netgalley and the publisher for sending me the arc in exchange for an honest, unbiased review.

Was this review helpful?

I had heard of Megan Whalen Turner's 'The Thief' in the past while looking for more books centred around rogues and thieves since my favourite books and games all revolve around them (Six of Crows, Thief: The Dark Project, Dishonored etc). However, I had never gotten the chance before to read 'The Thief' since copies of the book were hard to come by and it wasn't on Kindle yet.

I was happy to find an email from Hodder and Stoughton recently recommending 'The Thief' on Netgalley and jumped at the chance to read it now since the series is getting new updated covers and finally moving to Kindle format.

I enjoyed this book immensely despite it being aimed at middle grade or YA. I loved Gen as the main character and although half of the book involves a long travel sequence, he carried the story well and keep me reading. I enjoyed the mythology and stories of the Gods/Goddesses spread throughout the story and the world-building.

There is a plot twist at the end of the book I saw a mile off however, as I was spoiled by the series title so I do blame the publisher. Regardless, Gen does go back and mention some clues that should have hinted at the plot twist in the end - but I didn't feel they were clues that readers could have discovered on their own and gone 'Oh of course' when looking back.

There are a few more instances of Gen telling the story one way then going back later and adding more details, including the plot twist, which can be annoying. But I suppose it does reinforce that Gen is a tricksy character and to take his words with a pinch of salt.

My other slight gripe was dialogue - I sometimes could not tell who was talking at times, but this might have been down to messy formatting on the app.

Overall I'd happily recommend this book to others and will probably pick up the next book in my own time when the new covers come out.

Was this review helpful?

In the Thief we follow Gen, a young wayward sassy thief, who despite his best efforts is biding his time in prison. The world seems loosely based on the Roman conquest of Britain - with old and new Gods, an oppressive Empire where the rich grow richer and the power looks for more land to conquer.

Gen is surprising released from his imprisonment by the Kings head Magus - who enlists (read blackmails and strongarms ) Gens help in a quest. As we set off we know as little as Gen and the further we get we know less and less.

I feel like this book was just not for me. The world building felt a bit stilted and fairy tale like. It was really jarring moving between the story itself and these myths that were told by the characters alongside. The characters themselves felt very vague to me and I did not connect with them at all. The only dialog that took place really was one upmanship banter that though, while is entertaining get boring after awhile. Especially as Gen is supposedly the best thief ever, but he seems completely flummoxed by the people around him and acts like a sulky teenager.

Overall two stars as the end of the book did surprise me and I feel there is a lot of potential in this world

Was this review helpful?

I downloaded this book because YA fantasy is my new favourite thing and I loved the cover with its hint of Greek myths. I hadn't realised the book was originally published in the 1990s, but was intrigued to learn that the series had inspired several of my favourite authors.

Eugenides (Gen) boasts that he can steal anything without being caught, even the King's seal, but unfortunately it is his boasting that lands him in a prison that apparently even he cannot escape from. So his only chance to win back his freedom is when the King's Magus invites him on a quest to steal a legendary object. But while the Magus is working on an ambitious plan to benefit king and country, Gen has a cunning plan of his own...

At first glance, The Thief appears to be an uncomplicated 'road trip' story of Gen, the Magus, his two apprentices and a soldier, as they travel across three countries, hunting down this mythical object - but there are several large twists!

The characters have lots of adventures along the way and the balance of power switches around as they get to know each other and reluctantly begin to like each other. The characters are brilliantly drawn, particularly the whinging, complaining, failed thief and trickster Gen, but I also loved bookish Sophos, whose father wants him to be a soldier, and the long-suffering Magus, who has to put up with them all. The strength of the story is in the characters and the writing, which is so compelling I read most of the book in one go.

The Thief reminded me a little bit of C.S. Lewis's The Horse and His Boy, but looking ahead at the rest of the series (already published in the USA), I can see it will take a Game of Thrones turn. Although The Thief is a fantasy, the names of the characters, their Gods, and the descriptions of the countryside, have a definite Ancient Greece feel about them - but there is also mention of more modern inventions such as books and guns.

Conclusion? I loved The Thief! Five stars from me, a new favourite author discovered, and I really can't wait for the next book in the series!


Thank you to Megan Whalen Turner and Hodder & Stoughton for my copy of this book, which I requested via NetGalley and reviewed voluntarily.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to the publishers for reaching out and sending me this eARC in exchange for an honest review.

The Thief sets off slowly, our main character Gen is locked up in a prison and we learn his journey through him. Obviously he gets freed and the second half of the story is where the action takes place.

The writing and description in this novel is good and well placed however the first half did drag a little bit slowly for me. The second part of the story was interesting and more actioned out.

The Thief is part of a series and since this is the 1st novel I understand that world/character building is important so I would recommend readers stick it out.

Was this review helpful?

An adventure with a twist!
We follow Gen - a thief who can steal anything as he is taken on an adventure across the country to steal the impossible!
The journey is tough and perilous and Gen is pushed to his limits like never before. The twist at the end makes the book complete.
A great read with lots of action.
Thank you to the author, publisher and NetGalley for the arc of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

A huge thank you to netgalley and the publishers for a copy of this book.

The thief is a fantasy young adult novel by Megan Whalen Turner. I personally don’t normally enjoy fantasy novels but I found the adventure aspect of this book kept me hooked.

“I want you to steal something."
I smiled. "Do you want the king's seal? I can get it for you."
"If I were you," said the magus, "I'd stop bragging about that." His voice grated.
My smile grew. The gold ring with the engraved ruby had been in his safekeeping when I had stolen it away.”


The Thief follows the magus’ quest to find an ancient treasure. To do so he must employ a master thief. He selects Gen from the kings prison. Turner cleverly intertwines adventure, mystery and mythology in a novel that is a credit to the English language.

While reading I never felt massively loss, although I still felt a sense of mystery that kept my attention. Turner has a unique skill to keep the reader interested and her books are fascinating.

The ending was undeniably a plot twist, although it really wasn’t that hard to predict (I had already guessed due to clues not so quietly hidden). I enjoyed reading a book where I don’t feel the ending was pulled out of nowhere. Although would have liked if there was another element of surprise that was less easy to guess.

“That prison," I said with heartfelt sincerity, "Was absolutely the most awful thing that has happened to me in my entire life." I could tell by the way he looked at me that he thought my life had been filled with one awful thing after another.”


Gen (the thief) is certainly a likeable character. I found myself quickly becoming attached to Gen’s cheeky personality. The way he interacted with the other characters really made this novel in certain aspects for me.I enjoyed the other complex characters scattered throughout the novel and some characteristics that require some deeper reading.

I enjoyed the pacing of the novel towards the end and middle parts, however felt the first half was stressed out way to much. However you would argue you needed the long explanations for context. It may have been the authors way of clearly creating a setting to build the book on.

I did enjoy the mythological connotations throughout the book, although would have enjoyed it more if it was based on a set of particular myths. Due to the fact I have been left wanting to discover more. I am not normally a fan for Greek mythology either, so am in someways surprised why I liked this book so much.

I am excited to read the sequel, which I have high expectations for due to many other readers saying it is considerably better.

Overall I was pleasantly surprised by this novel, and the joy I got out of it. I am massively looking forward to reading its sequel, and would recommend it for anyone looking for an adventure-fantasy novel.

4/5

Was this review helpful?

So....maybe I overhyped myself for this? I'd been meaning to read it for years and I'd heard so many good things about the series, that I leapt at the chance of an arc. And it was a perfectly decent book. If you like straightforward, journey-based fantasy written in plain but beautiful prose, then this will probably be totally your bag.



I did enjoy large sections of it even as other parts left me underwhelmed. I think the problem is that if you don't click with the characters, you won't care about the minutiae of their very uneventful interactions. I'm sure that if I'd fallen in love with the characters, I would have relished every second and been happy to have more. As it was, I was only starting to warm to Gen and Sophos by about 70% of the way through. So that was a bit of a bust as far as I was concerned. My second issue, is that the author pulls a swift reversal in the last half a dozen pages. Now, I'm all for providing subtle clues so that the reader can look back after the big reveal and say 'omg of course!' But that isn't what happened here. We're literally excluded from the merest hint of what is really going on. This doesn't read as clever, it's simply annoying. And unfortunately compounds the sense that the book never really gets going because that reveal feels like the inciting incident we should have had at the 30 - 40% mark.



So in conclusion, this didn't entirely work for me. Lovely prose, interesting world building and just not enough happening.

Was this review helpful?

This book started off slow and I didn't think it started to pick up until I got to about 40%. While I love descriptive books I did find that a lot of it was filler, not an info dump as such, but a lot of details that didn't need to be included - the type of dirt under an olive tree, what shape an orange was etc. That being said, I did like the premise and the mythology and once Eugenides actually started his task it became intriguing.The plot twist was a surprise to me and I didn't guess how the book would end.

Overall, while I did struggle to begin with, I did enjoy it but I wouldn't continue with the rest of the books in this series.


*Thank you to @netgalley and the publishers @hodderbooks for providing this ARC in exchange for an honest review*

Was this review helpful?

This story follows Gen, a thief freed from prison by the King's magus on the condition of helping them find some long-lost treasure.

This story was quite slow at parts with a good chunk just dialogue between the characters whilst travelling - though that helped flesh out the main character, Gen who definitely grew on me throughout. It was interspersed with tales of God's told around the campfire and I would have personally liked to have seen more of that mythical side.

I'd say the last 30% of the book picks up the pace and there is a superb ending. As the first book in a series, it laid the groundwork well and I would definitely read the sequel.

Was this review helpful?

I will update the review with a link to our blog closer to publication date.
I'd like to thank the publisher and netgalley for providing me with an advance reader copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

OH MY GOSH I couldn't put this book down. It was absoluitely gripping with a fast pace that left me literally feeling like my kindle was going to start sparking flames. The writing was so good with a well executed storyline that was engaging and captivating, well developed charcaters that I loved and a great setting. The whole world building in this book was incredible honestly and I felt like I was there inbetween the pages. A really enjoyable read, I loved it.

Was this review helpful?

A really great fantasy book. The plot was the first thing that caught my attention and I wasn’t left disappointed.
Also I love the new cover.
Would recommend!

Was this review helpful?

A fun, entertaining and light hearted fantasy heist story. Follow Gen the Thief as he is forcibly taken out of prison and made to accompany the King's magus and his disciples on a mountainous quest to find a lost treasure that holds the keys to the kingdom. There are some great characters and unexpected plot twists that make this a read that draws you in from the first page - I read the whole lot in one night and can't wait for part 2 to come out!

Was this review helpful?

DNF at 55%

I've been intrigued by this series for so long that I couldn't resist the chance to try it when I spotted it on NetGalley. I know this is a very popular series and it's one of those series I think I would have enjoyed if I'd read it when I was younger, but for the reader I am this book just isn't for me. It started out well, and it's a fairly quick read, but I'm very bored, and none of the characters are holding my interest.

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the eARC!

Was this review helpful?

I am at a crossroads with this book. In one sense, I did read this quickly but in another sense, I read it because I didn't want to DNF the book and wanted to see how it ended and if it could get better.
The story isn't the most memorable. The travelling is long and the characters sometimes fall quite flat. I think it would be a fine book for a quick read but definitely not something mind-blowing. Overall, it was alright.

Was this review helpful?

A big thank you to Netgalley for providing me with a copy of The Thief by Megan Whalen Turner.

This Is a book that I have read previously as it was originally published in 2005, however it was an absolute blast to revisit this world. The story does fall somewhere into a category of adventure between Middle Grade and Young Adult, with the plot following a boy named Gen who has been imprisoned for stealing the King's seal and bragging about it to the wrong person.

The story starts where Gen is taken from the prison by the king's scholar, the Magus, to tell him that he will be taken on a journey to steal something. The thing he will have to steal is highly secretive and the Magus does not tell anyone in the company where or what it is.

This is the first book in the series and it follows the group on their expedition and the twists and turns that this mission takes. There are quite a few surprises along the way, the best of which is saved for last and which also sets up the premise for the entire series to follow.

I really enjoyed this book and I cannot wait for it to be available in our stores again and to introduce more people to the lovable Gen and the imposing Magus (and maybe one or two other characters as well)!

Was this review helpful?

This is a charming fantasy for younger readers - and a fun, quick read for older ones as well - like an old Hollywood swashbuckler, and with some lovely twists and turns. The genre has come a fair way since the book first came out 25 years ago, but it mostly stands up, and must have stood out before. It's strange to think this is the first time it's out in the UK. A few things about the worldbuilding struck me, as an older reader used to more nuance, as odd, like the mix of ancient greeks names and architecture with a sprinkling of firearms that lead to a general anachronistic uncertainty - but I'm fairly sure younger readers won't be as picky, and will love the adventure and the snarky voice that was immediately captivating. I could hardly put it down in the day it took me to read it, and must say I enjoyed every minute.

Was this review helpful?

Gen is a thief, currently in prison for stealing from the royal court and then unwisely boasting about it in a tavern.

The king’s magus needs something found, a trinket from the gods, and he needs a master thief to help him find it. So he dregs Gen out of prison and onto a horse and the quest begins.

Like all good quests to find hidden treasure this is a journey through enemy territory, dangerous terrain and with travelling companions who can’t stand each other. It could be very boring, if it wasn’t for the stories of the old gods and goddesses they tell each other to while away the time on the road.

Although the stories might be inspired by the myths, stories and the countryside around the Mediterranean, this series is not a retelling of any myths, it is set in its own fantasy world and has its own unique voice and plot.

Some reviewers classify this novel and series as Young Adult. I’m not so sure about this. The protagonist might be on the younger side and is often described as a boy and not a grown man yet, though the story reads far more mature than your average YA fantasy. Probably because the usual tropes, like chosen one, love triangle, etc, are missing.

Was this review helpful?