Member Reviews

I think I liked this one better than the first (The Coward)- Aryan balances his story a bit more this time. While following Kell on his adventure, he continues to follow events at home with wife Sigrid as well. Much like the first entry though, you are left wondering WHO is the Warrior of the story? Is it Kell (leaping a little too quickly at the opportunity to follow Willow)? Is it Willow for venturing out of her own world to start with? Is it Sigrid for staying home to fight things out with the Reverend Mother? Or Kell's guard(ian?)s for facing their own demons in their own ways?

Was this review helpful?

The Warrior es la continuación de The Coward y también el final de la historia de Kell. Tras los sucesos acontecidos en la primera entrega, Kell es rey de Algany, pero pronto alguien de su pasado volverá para reclamar deudas pendientes y lo cambiará todo.


No quiero entrar mucho en la trama porque inevitablemente llevaría a destrozar la experiencia de lectura del primer libro, así que he pensado que será mejor hablar de las sensaciones que me ha dejado The Warrior.

La última obra de Stephen Aryan es pausada y melancólica, dividida en dos narraciones que tienen distintas velocidades merced a un truco del escritor, pero que le sirve para ralentizar una de las tramas y acelerar la otra de una forma poco sutil para alcanzar un clímax unificado. Precisamente por el uso de este recurso, la impresión en la lectura es que la parte del león se la lleva la trama “ralentizada” mientras que de la trama “acelerada” solo veremos algunos atisbos.

Se trata de una novela eminentemente triste, de pérdida de oportunidades y derrotismo, del fin de una cultura que se encuentra con una amenaza interior a la que no es capaz de hacer frente, una sociedad en la que el pesimismo ha hecho tanta mella en las personas que ya casi ni viven, solo deambulan esperando el final. La pequeña chispa de rebeldía que suponían los actos de dos miembros de esta sociedad se consideran actos de locura imperdonables. Esta sensación de inevitabilidad está maravillosamente conseguida a lo largo de las páginas, pero también hace que la lectura sea morosa y lenta en demasía.

A algunos de los personajes que ya conocíamos de la primera entrega se une dos nuevos que tienen un papel muy desigual en la trama de la novela. Mientras que Odd y sus torturados orígenes gozan de gran importancia, la presencia de Yarra es casi testimonial. No digo que no cumpla su papel, pero parece mucho menos elaborada que Odd, a quien llegaremos a comprender en su ansia.

Como la primera novela, en esta ocasión también asistiremos a un viaje con un objetivo en mente, si bien esta vez no estará tan claro y las dificultades del camino serán mayores, no solo por la orografía del terreno en sí, si no por las luchas interiores que habrán de sobrellevar los miembros de la expedición.

He comentado que había dos puntos de vista en la novela, pero también es cierto que se le da poca importancia a la trama de Sigrid, a pesar de su relevancia en el aspecto político de los Cinco Reinos. Me hubiera gustado que se hubiera desarrollado en mayor profundidad, porque solo asistimos a pequeñas pinceladas del destino que le aguarda a la reina y podría haber sido más interesante centrarnos en ella.

El final, aunque satisfactorio, me parece un poco acelerado.

En definitiva, se trata de un libro de fantasía más lento y melancólico de lo habitual, que puede servir como contrapunto frente a otros autores que se vuelcan más en la acción y en la velocidad de la historia.

Was this review helpful?

I read the coward, i then listened to the coward and if it had come out in graphic novel form I would have bought that too, I was really hoping for a Netflix series or film! When I was kindly and gratefully offered an ARC courtesy of Netgalley I was putting it mildly somewhat happy, having read the book I am not so happy, I wanted more Kel and I didn’t get that, i found it difficult to engage with the story this time around and horror upon horror I actually skipped parts where I really didn’t care what was happening, maybe I just raised my expectations too high and was always going to be left unsatisfied, i will purchase this on Audible when it is eventually released and hope that the narrator can pique my interest again

Was this review helpful?

This was an enjoyable read that has some slight flaws. The work is a step up from book 1 but the depth is lacking. There is no fine detail and that battle scenes do not captivate me. There should be investment in these and Aryan makes the effort but the quest trope is done here in a way it doesnt add to other authors.

Was this review helpful?

This was a pleasant surprise!

Last year, I read The Coward, the first instalment in this series, and gave it four stars. I enjoyed my time reading The Coward, but some things were holding it back from being fantastic. Firstly, the book relied quite heavily on classical fantasy tropes, and the “quest trope” rarely works well for me. Moreover, some of the action scenes felt unnecessary and random in the first book. However, Aryan still was able to get me invested in Kell and his story, which made me want to continue with this series. So what did I think?

If you’ve read The Coward, you know that it reads like a standalone in many ways. Therefore, I was interested to see how Aryan would continue this story after the conclusion in The Coward. Let me start by saying that The Warrior is an improvement in nearly every way.

Firstly, Aryan introduces various new POVs, side characters, and locations to the story, adding another element of complexity. Moreover, I had a great time following all the new POVs. While The Coward is very much the story of Kell, The Warrior is much more a story about the kingdom and an existential threat threatening the lives of millions. Aryan takes time to flesh out the characters by giving the readers insights into their background, thoughts and struggles, making them feel more compelling and intriguing. I also loved seeing these characters grow and mature throughout the story!

Moreover, the plot in The Warrior is significantly more compelling, creative and captivating. Due to spoilers, I won’t get into details, but I would recommend readers who enjoyed The Coward to pick up this book. The Warrior is a considerable step-up in storytelling, characterisation and world-building!

However, this series does have some slight flaws. Although the characterisation is a step up from The Coward, most of the characters do not have much depth. If you are looking for a fantasy series that analyses characters in great detail, you won’t find it here. Moreover, Aryan’s battle scenes do, for some reason, not captivate me. Battle scenes rarely captivate me, but some authors, such as John Gwynne and R.F. Kuang, are able to get me invested in fight scenes. Unfortunately, Aryan wasn’t able to do that. Lastly, one of the plotlines in The Warrior has the “quest trope”. I know many readers do not enjoy quest stories, but Aryan does make an effort at putting some interesting twists on this trope in this story. I would encourage you not to let the “quest trope” put you off!

The Warrior is a compelling story with memorable characters and a riveting pace. Aryan has improved on everything that made The Coward great. The Warrior is an entertaining, complex and exciting story that most fantasy readers will enjoy! I had a great time reading this book and will keep an eye out for what Stephen Aryan will publish next!

4 / 5

Thanks to AngryRobots for an e-arc in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?