Member Reviews

I enjoyed this book…I did. It’s a light, enjoyable read, and there were many funny moments. But I found Allie incredibly frustrating. And Margaret. And Hank too. And that made it difficult to relate to the characters. In the end, things are explained a bit and that helped…but still.

Thank you to NetGalley and Black Rose Writing for the ARC. Look for And Then There’s Margaret in bookstores now.

Was this review helpful?

I really don't know how Allie put up with her mother-in-law. Margaret was such a nasty character that I struggled to find any sympathy for her towards the end of the book. I felt Allie should have been supported more by her husband. That said, Allie could be incredibly childish at times. The pace is quick, and the tone light, so it's an easy read. With thanks to NetGalley for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

And Then There's Margaret is a gem. It made me frustrated on Allie's behalf, exasperated with Margaret, hopeful as the story progressed, and laughed so much!

It takes a strong person to have an in-law move in with the family but to add existential questions, careers, young adult children, poor Allie hasn't got a chance.

Or has she?

This book is so heartwarming and has me cheering for all the characters. I couldn't put it down and maybe took an extra long lunch one work day to finish it....

This is definitely a must read.

Was this review helpful?

I found myself gritting my teeth while reading this book, because Margaret is possibly the mother-in-law of your worst nightmares. Allison is already stressed and anxious about various aspects of her life (body, husband, kids, job, etc.) and when her beloved father-in-law passes away, Margaret moves in with Allison and her family. Despite all the friction, there is lots of humour and eventually, Allie and Margaret come to a sort of understanding.

Was this review helpful?

Allie’s mother in law Margaret doesn’t even hide the fact that she doesn’t like her. After the death of Margaret’s husband she moves in as she grieves. She makes Allie’s life even more miserable. Will they ever be able to form a closer bond and have appreciation for one another? This was a quick read and it would be great to take on a trip.

Was this review helpful?

And Then There's Margaret by Carolyn Clarke is a story centred on the volatile dynamic between a woman and her mother-in-law, and it will speak to anyone who has experienced what is a tricky and, in this case, sometimes toxic relationship.

Allie loves her husband Hank but is in a constant power struggle with his mother Margaret, who does not want to let go of her precious only child. The vitriole spewed by Margaret is shocking though mostly humourous, at least to those who do not find themselves on the receiving end.

I am always fascinated by the dynamics at play in any family unit, and very much enjoyed watching Allie and Margaret navigate their relationship with trepidation, tension, humour and heart.

Many thanks to NetGalley and Black Rose Writing for an ARC.

Was this review helpful?

This book is jawdroppingly crazy funny. Allie's tolerance of her mother-in-law is unbelievable. She has the strength of a warrior! She also has her flaws which makes her totally relatable yet admirable. Margaret is judgmental and crass. The dynamics between these two and knowing what is going on in Allie's head makes this book so enjoyable to read. I was hooked from the opening sentences of the book. This book makes me appreciate my mother-in-law a lot more! lol!

Was this review helpful?

The premise for this novel intrigued me as I have always been fascinated by the relationships between family, especially when marriage occurs. You are thrown together with people who you may or may not have chosen to be around.

Allie has always had a good relationship with her father-in-law, George but, when he passes away, her mother-in-law, Margaret moves into her home for a while.

It’s clear from the outset that these two women should not be sharing a space. Haha. Allie behaves in a way that I feel is totally relatable and I cheered when she stood up for herself. However, Margaret is also going through a bad time in her life so it was hard to just dismiss her as difficult. There is more to Margaret’s behaviour than Allie realises.

I liked the character and relationship development between Allie and Margaret that occurs throughout the book, as they possibly begin to understand each other. What happens is something I will leave you to find out.

Hank, Samantha and Cameron are great (I especially loved the bond Cameron and Allie shared,) and Val was also brilliant. I feel like there could be a story with her as a central character? I feel her story isn’t done yet.

This book successfully explores the family dynamic and how it can be wonderful one moment and bat crazy the next. That is life.

It also explores themes around mid-life crisis and how it is never too late to change the things in your life that are no longer working – the things that no longer give you joy.

The style of writing is effortless and I was immediately pulled into Allie’s story. I loved the fact that she was writing to George. It allowed him to still be a part of the story.

This book examines the life of a 40 something woman perfectly. It’s honest, has a great humour running throughout and has a lot of heart.

I loved it.

P.S: Thank you to my mother-in-law Sara for being nothing like Margaret. I got very lucky indeed.

(Thank you to Hannah Hargrave and Netgalley for the advanced reading copy in exchange for an honest review.)

Was this review helpful?

This book shares the story of Margaret and her pain in the ass mother-in-law who encroaches on her life and makes her feel inadequate especially after the death of her husband - George. Much of this novel will be very relatable to the reader showcasing the highs and lows of family life but in the end the tale of how Margaret’s mother-in-law came to be the way she is reveals itself and it turns out the two women have more in common than they initially thought.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this book. It was a semi tragic holiday. Margaret, the mother in law who steps over every line there, supported by her son and long suffering daughter in law. Funny, sad and a very easy read. Enjoyed and would recommend.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this book and finished it in one night. It is an easy read and deals with some complicated topics like family dynamics and death while still keeping humor and grace in the story. I liked how the author while making the MIL insufferable still gave moments of clarity that there was more to the story than her horrible behavior. Overall a very good book!!

Was this review helpful?

And Then There's Margaret is a story about an aging mother and her grown son and his family. The book mainly focuses on Margaret and her daughter-in-law, Allie. In no uncertain terms, Margaret does not like Allie. She is plain hateful, manipulative, and vial. Sadly, Allie does not handle Margaret well either.

Unfortunately this back and forth between the two women comprises 90% of the book. As a reader, I could have tolerated this storyline for some of the book but for it to be almost the entire story made the story depressing and I didn't even want to pick up the book. It was about a 1 star star up to this point mainly because of the length of the conflict.

The last 10% of the book was better with the women seeing the other's perspective and being kind to each other. Human decency. This part of the star would have earned a 4 star review if it would have composed more of the story.

Sadly, I would say don't waste your time unless you want a real downer for 90% of the book.

I received an ARC of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

And Then There's Margaret had me laughing from the first to the very last page.

Allie has the Mother in Law from Hell .

Her name is Margaret.

The quips that go back and forth, the innuendos and the out playing each other is something you can just picture.

Margaret sadly has just lost her husband George, whom everyone adored, specially Allie.

Margaret moves in with Allie and her family.

Is it forever Allie wonders.

My mother in law was a saint , my mother was in between but certainly had her Margaret moments ( she too was named Margaret)

I hated this book to end.

I will miss Allie and Margaret too.

So buying this for my sister.

Carolyn Lake has written a fantastic debut and I can't wait to read what she writes next.

Thanks to NetGalley and Black Rose Writing for making my day a better and happier one.

Was this review helpful?

I found this to be a light, enjoyable read. The relationship between Allie and Margaret seems a little far fetched at times, but also had very funny moments, this would be a good holiday read.

Was this review helpful?

I wanted to hate this book when I started reading about the things Margret had done, but I glad I read the whole story. I can not imagine having a mother in law acting like she did and not say anything. I did feel sorry for poor George but I’m glad Allie had a great relationship with him. Hank, he needed to grow a pair but I understand his situation.

Was this review helpful?

When Allie's mother in law moves in after the death of her father in law, things go down hill fast. This book had so much potential but fell flat.

Was this review helpful?

I would like to thank the author, the publisher and NetGalley for giving me the opportunity to read an ARC of this book. I read this book but I didn't really enjoy it, I had thought that it was going to be much funnier than it turned out to be.

Was this review helpful?

And Then There's Margaret is a joy of a book, I absolutely loved it. A few years ago I would have thought that Margaret was a bit (a lot!) exaggerated but having joined Mumsnet I am now fully aware that there really are mother's in law who do behave in this manner. How Allie didn't slap her down more often I don't understand.
The plot was believable and entertaining and the characters were relateable , a great book.

Was this review helpful?

The mother-in-law is the main character in this book....or is she? Is she all that bad? Is she? The protagonist can't get along with her mother-in-law at all...nothing she does is right (the protagonist). Her husband does not seem to be a strong character...this is a book about women...with the male figures in the background. Will the mother-in-law live with them after the dad dies? Where will they put her? How will they get along? Will she interfere continually? This is a quick read with quirky characters. The book was sent to me by Netgalley for review, and it is one I might want to read again...in case I missed something the first time.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this book ….. which for me centres around grief and how it affects people differently . Allison and husband Hank are themselves dealing with the loss of Hanks father George who Allison was very close to and in turn dealing with Margaret mother in law from hell….. or is she . Margaret seems to be getting on life without her beloved George in the only way she knows how focusing on Hank and his family and firmly gets her feet under the family table … Allison and Margaret have a very strained relationship and thinks seem to go from bad to worse . Grief - relationships - families and forgiveness this book has it all

Was this review helpful?