Member Reviews
This is the Author's latest book featuring Nun Hildegard of the Cistercian Priory of Swine
When new novitiates start to spread malicious rumours within the Priory the Abbess tasks Hildegard to investigate . But before she can get to the root of the trouble a young man appears at their gate requesting aid , fearful for his life - he will not give any details or information - what are they to think?
Yet again before Hildegard can investigate further a young nun is found dead , who would kill her and with a storm on the horizon , the Abbey will soon be cut off by rising flood waters .
Can Hildegard discover the murderer and solve all the puzzles before she too becomes a victim ?
This is yet another enjoyable historical murder mystery by the Author , fast paced and full of twists and turns .The rich depiction of life in the 14th century brings the book to life .
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own
I believe I have already sent a review to the publisher and placed it on Amazon. It was an excellent novel. I loved the characterisation and as usual Cassandra Clarke does not disappoint as a writer. It presents a claustrophobic atmosphere and we are kept guessing as to whom the culprit is. High politics mixed with mystery.
Cassandra Clark continues the crime solving adventures of Hildegard at Swyne Priory in the floodtime of 1394.
Two unwilling novices are causing dissension in the priory; a court musician claims sanctuary from an assassin.
The nearby abbey has upsets. A serving maid is murdered. What is going on? Hildegard will figure it out. Excellent historical mystery.
In general, I'm a big fan of Severn House historical mysteries. Severn house publishes more such titles than any other publisher I'm aware of, and I've found many favorite series there that I continue to follow: Chris Nickson's Tom Harper series; Alys Clare's World's End Detective Bureau series: M.J. Trow's Chaucer series; Paul Doherty's Brother Athelstan series; Barbara Hambley's Benjamin January series; I could keep going.... Dark Water's Rising didn't work for me because too much of the dialog felt ananchronistic and the characters seemed more types than individuals. Nonetheless, thank you for bringing so many wonderful writers into my life. I'll continue to be a committed supporter of your historical mysteries.
I have greatly enjoyed over the last few years the dark and compelling world of Cassandra Clark's medieval mysteries set in and around Swyne Priory and featuring Hidelgard of Meaux and a brilliant cast of exquisitely drawn characters.
It's 1394 and while the political shenanigans of the House of Lancaster are threatening the fragile reign of Richard II, rising flood waters and a vicious killer are threatening the peace of the religious community.
A captivating whodunit full of greed, lust and death blessed with intricately realized characters and settings that give it a vivid, almost cinematic quality.
With its dark and violent plot that definitely echoes the harshness of England’s politics at the end of the 14th century, this smart and adrenaline-fueled medieval thriller was a marvellous read from start to finish!
Many thanks to Severn House and Netgalley for this terrific ARC.
1394 and the weather around Meaux is wet. Flood waters are encroaching on the arable land and it is predicted to only get worse. Hildegard is tasked with maintaining discipline over some unruly novices but her work is halted when in short succession a stranger arrives claiming to be chased by an assassin and then a member of the workforce from the priory is found murdered. As the weather closes in, can Hildegard get justice.
This appears to the be the final volume in what has been a solid and entertaining series. The research is excellent and generally the plots are strong enough in a crowded genre. I have to admit that the on/off state of Hildegard's 'love life' is somewhat annoying (should she even have one?) but it appears settled here. I did love the idea of the setting being a area that was dangerously flooded, a nice twist.
Medieval mystery at it’s best.
1394—the religious sector and the secular world have their problems. As Hildeguard puts forth, a “schism caused by two men claiming to be the true pope is a contagion. And even our own realm is riven in twain. At least two of our barons see themselves as king in place of their young nephew.” And it seems a catastrophic flood is about to engulf the area that includes Swyne Priory, Haltemprice Priory, and the Abbey of Meaux, or so Josiana the mathematically knowledgeable novice has decided. She’s done all her calculations.
Josiana goes to to Haltemprice to return an astrolabe she’s been using. She fails to return and Hildegard cannot find her, nor the serving girl who went with her. The girl will be discovered down in the salt marsh, the saltings, dead.
A stranger turns up during the night looking for sanctuary and succour with wild tales of being pursued by an assassin. At first Hildegard wonders if he’s killed Lydia. His identity is unknown except he claims to be a minstrel for King Richard, and have witnessed something that had him fearing for his life.
Troublesome novices twin sisters, Bella and Rogella, beguile a young priest. One sister and the priest go missing. But which one? What’s going on here?
All throughout the flood waters threaten lives and property.
Add to this, Hubert is stricken by some sort of burden, refusing to see anyone. Hildegard confronts him and is treated coldly as though by a stranger. His men at arms and Hildegard’s are worried.
The Prioress has told Hildegard that she’s considering naming Hildegard her successor. What of the unspoken plans hinted at between Hildegard and Hubert, lord abbot of Meaux, not so long ago?
A wonderful medieval novel replete with intrigue and conflict, including in the ordinary lives of those within the church, still struggling with their humanity.
A Severn House ARC via NetGalley.
Many thanks to the author and publisher.
Please note: Quotes taken from an advanced reading copy maybe subject to change
In Clark’s twelfth and last mystery in the Hildegard of Meaux series, set in 1394 Yorkshire, tensions are nigh at breaking point. The novices at Swyne Priory, where Hildegard is a Cistercian nun, are unhappy, and Hildegard can’t settle them down. A young royal minstrel, Master Leonin, appears on the convent’s doorstep in a terrible state, alleging his life is threatened—and he refuses to say much more. Richard II has just lost his beloved queen, and the nuns worry his barons are agitating again. Even more troublesome is the unnatural death of a lay sister. Events in the natural world mirror the turmoil within: the rain is incessant, and the eccentric, bookish Sister Josiana predicts the Humber will break its banks, flooding the land. The priory is on high ground, but can they prepare in time, and will Hildegard solve the crimes?
It feels odd to describe a medieval mystery involving nuns as frenetic, but there’s so much physical movement that the plot gets muddled at times. Hildegard spends considerable time on the road, riding to and fro among Swyne, the monastery at Meaux, and nearby Haltemprice Priory during her investigations. The Prioress suggests she wants Hildegard to succeed her, but it’s unclear why, since Hildegard is rarely there; plus, there are unresolved romantic tensions between her and Hubert, lord abbot at Meaux. The story and characters hold interest, though, and it comes through clearly that with limited options for women, many found homes in convents regardless of vocation (or willingness). The sense of place is superb and appropriately eerie, with a full moon overhead as waters begin rising. Superstitions are rife, and many folks “trust portents more than facts,” but when Josiana’s measurements prove accurate—not really a spoiler—it’s a triumphant moment for all women of science.
Many thanks to NetGalley and Severn House for this Advanced Reader Copy and the opportunity to review “Dark Waters Rising.” All opinions and comments are my own.
The last Hildegard of Meaux book finds the abbess struggling in more ways than one, first to wiggle out the secrets of a young man who’s seeking refuge amongst the local religious communities and then to solve the various cases of disappearance and then death that are also happening around the abbey of Swyne. And if that wasn’t bad enough, the weather isn’t cooperating; the flooding from the heavy rains may find everything washed away. And what’s the deal with Abbot de Courcy? The spiritual crisis of the man she loves, forbidden as that love is, affects her greatly. There’s a lot going on in “Dark Waters Rising,” definitely.
The first death is a maid, who accompanied a sister who had left on a mission to a nearby abbey. The sister is still missing. She’s feared dead, too. In the meantime, Hildegard is trying to figure out who the young man -- Leonin -- really is and who he’s so afraid of. He finally confesses that “he knows something that the king’s enemies deem dangerous.” Well, this story will consume a great part of the book, involving Hildegarde, her priory, the abbey at Meaux, and especially, the abbot she loves.
And I haven’t even mentioned the two recalcitrant sisters -- twins -- she’s got at her priory. Angry, petulant, they would try the patient of a saint. Their story also contains disappearance and death, and Hildegard must use all her investigative skills to deal with their involvement.
In between all the crises, Hildegard does a lot of reflecting and remembering; as noted, this is the last book in the series. There is her past with the Abbot de Courcy, and how that aspect of her life has shaped her present. The warrior priests Egbert and Gregory have their place in the story. She even gets news of her old guardian, Lord Roger, and his new wife. Hildegard’s life, from before Swyne Priory and to present-day, is tided up for readers.
With the ending, secrets are revealed, a murder is prevented, and Hubert de Courcy and Hildegard of Meaux make decisions about their future. We are also told that the king got his revenge on his enemies, too. At least Hildegard and Hubert should be happier.
I'm sucker for historical mysteries featuring nuns or monks and Hildegard is part of these group of beloved sleuths.
This is a complex and dark story, full of secrets and twists. It's well plotted and gripping, the characters are fleshed out as usual
Highly recommended.
Many thanks to the publisher for this arc, all opinions are mine
Fans of historical mysteries should definitely give this one- which make terrific use of the politics and day to day life of the 14th century- a read. Hildegard, a nun, has noticed that the novices in the convent are unsettled and then a young man appears on their doorstep with a wild story. And then one of the young women is murdered. Hildegard, an estimable woman, has an intriguing mystery on her hands and no spoilers as to how she works through the possibilities. Thanks to Netgalley for the ARC. Fine as a standalone and sadly, it appears the last in the series.
Our favorite detective nun is back. Hildegard has to keep her wits about her for this latest mystery. She has been given the task of finding out why the young novices are so unsettled and why they are spreading rumors. But before she can even find out what is going on a young man arrives at the Priory but Hildegard isn't too sure if she believes his story. Why is he really hiding and who wants him dead?
Everything changes when one of their own is found murdered and no one knows why someone would want to hurt her? Hildegard needs to find out the truth but can she survive this deadly killer as they will stop at nothing to get their way.
Another great read in the series. I love Hildegard as she is so fearless and she will do anything to find out the truth. This is a read full of rich descriptions on life during the 14th century and we get to see through the eyes of the people that lived during that period. I am sad to see that this is the last book in the series.
Thank you Netgalley & the publisher for the ARC copy. This is my voluntary review.
Cassandra Clark’s latest (and apparently last!) Hildegard thriller is gripping from the first page. Hildegard of Meaux is a nun in the Cistercian priory of Swyne in 14th-century Yorkshire. One night a desperate young musician arrives at the nunnery door pleading for refuge. He claims to be fleeing an assassin, but will say nothing to explain who he is or why he is hunted – and his story is doubted. When a young novice nun is then murdered, Hildegard is determined to discover who he is and why the novice was killed. The story is told in a multitude of short chapters, with characters speaking a modern English sprinkled with archaisms (mayhap, perchance, sot-wit). There’s plenty of pleasing detail of the food, fashions and daily life of the time. In the background Cassandra Clark evokes a sinister atmosphere, the fear, deception and intrigue of the medieval world, its convoluted divisions, dangerous politics and the struggle for the English crown. Meanwhile, unprecedented rains are lashing down, and Hildegard’s perilous search for the truth takes place as floodwaters cover the land. A terrific read.
I must say I read this and was happy that it wasn't an overly long book. And again I must say that if I can go back and read the previous books I will revisit this one as I think there may be some back story in the previous books. But having said that it was a well written story and one that kept me reading. It is mystery, it is medieval/middle ages story and I love the setting.
I enjoyed it but now I have to go find all the other ones and start from the beginning!
A Perilous Puzzle..
The twelfth Abbess of Meaux mystery finds sleuthing nun Hildegard in the depths of a dangerous and perilous puzzle where absolutely nothing is as it seems. Soon enough, trapped with a killer and floodwaters rising, our intrepid protagonist will be fighting for her life. Another tantalising, colourful and cleverly woven plot with a well crafted cast of characters, a firm sense of time and place and a solid mystery to keep the reader guessing until the very end.