Member Reviews
Bitterthorn is brilliant! Powerful and emotional, near overwhelming, this is a book that left me broken and deeply affected. It's just gorgeous.
Bitterthorn is a fairy tale, and draws on elements from a large number of classic fairy tales, weaving them into its story so effectively that, while elements are familiar and recognisable, it's far from being a retelling of any particular story. The girl trapped in a castle with an uncaring monster, but left free to roam its halls feels very Beauty and the Beast, with some aspects of Bluebeard in the commands to avoid particular rooms and the dangerous curiosity about her predecessors. The negligent stepmother and the stepsisters taking priority once they move into the castle feels drawn from Cinderella, and there are definitely aspects of Sleeping Beauty and possibly Rumpelstiltskin in the weaving and some aspects of the magical curse. But all of these different story elements are taken and made into something that feels new and different, with just an edge of comfortable familiarity.
That's about all that's comfortable about it though. From the very beginning, Bitterthorn is a story that has its secrets, deadly secrets too, and it does its very best to create an air of unease, suspicion and fear. It's quite amazing how unsettling it all is as, like Mina, we have no idea what she's walking into, what she's there for or what fate will befall her. The castle she is forced to call home reflects that unease, with its winding, ever changing corridors and rooms and some quite incredible but really quite disturbing chambers. I particularly loved the room where it is always last Tuesday!
More than anything else though, Bitterthorn is a book about loneliness.
Sure, it's about how being all alone can change you, darken you, turn you bitter and spiky, but it's about more than that. It's about how being rejected, being made to feel unwanted, in the way, a problem can force you to retreat into loneliness. It's about how the despair of loneliness can be easier to bear than trying to make those connections and seeing them getting closed off. It's about that comfort of being alone, whether quietly reading in your room or walking out through the woods learning ab0ut the trees and the rocks, and not risking your heart in anybody else's hands. It's about losing the people you love, and coming to realise that you never really knew them after all and they never really took the time to know you. It's about the distance that can grow within families. And it's about what happens when you do take that risk, and open yourself up to the prospect and possibility of love and all of the potential pain it can cause.
I've never read anything that gets all of that and expresses it so clearly, so lyrically, so beautifully.
Bitterthorn is an exceptionally beautiful and moving modern fairy story.