Member Reviews

Who might enjoy their noir flavoured with a middle-east ambience?

Tel Aviv resident Erez Brown, a private detective more engaged in getting dirt on cheating spouses, never expects to encounter violence when trying to track down a girl who has gone missing. Neither does he expect to find her dead body when he goes to check her digs a second time. Yet her mother claims to have spoken to her after her death.

Brown does not paint himself as an entirely sympathetic character, but as we get to know his inner world, it becomes clearer that he is rather damaged, following an unlucky divorce. Things are no longer that black and white to him, it is in general less clear who the true villains are, if in fact there are any souls truly knowing the love of God.

All of this is probably what makes a quality noir, noir. Rosenberg evokes a. city of illusions and dreams in Tel Aviv, as he ventures into the demi monde of the less-than kosher World of S and M (he also gets to enjoy great food on his trips out, so despite the loss of illusions, the reader participates vicariously the measures of night life too.

The conclusion is therefore as messy as might be expected with Brown being the kind of man he is, though the ambivalence of the ending may well be frustrating for those who prefer a more clear-cut whodunnit..

This new anti-hero sleuth is still one to be watched in the future though. .

Was this review helpful?

I chose this book to review as I was going on holiday to Tel Aviv and it is fun to read about a place whilst there as a tourist.
I enjoyed the descriptions of the city and the melting pot of different cultures that is Israel. It probably helped that I know a fair amount about Judaism as aspects of this are a major theme of the plot.
Èrez Brown is a PI who is hired by a religious Jewish couple to find their daughter who has been missing for several years. Whilst investigating Lea Rubinstein’s disappearance, Erez gets involved with a murder and it is not clear at first if Lea is the perpetrator or the victim. When he is attacked and ends up in the hospital It becomes obvious that Lea has a lot to hide and Erez needs all his detective skills to find out what is going on.
Erez must also look after his young children as he has shared custody with his ex wife- from what is said during the book, he has a very negative view of marriage, maybe because he spends most of his time hunting down errant husbands or wives for their spouses!
Overall I enjoyed this book although there were a lot of characters to get my head around,- most were friends of Erez and I did get confused in places.
I liked Erez himself, he seemed to want to do the right thing and appeared to be following some sort of moral code.
The main star of the show was Tel Aviv itself which I felt was well described and recognisable. The author obviously is a resident or has visited many times.
I would definitely be intrigued to read a second book in the series.
Thanks to NetGalley and the publishers for my advance copy.

Was this review helpful?

I did not enjoy this book as I disliked the main character quite a bit. His only redeeming qualities seem to be that he cares about his secretary, he gets his job done and he is a consistent father though there is no strength to the relationship with his children. I was able to read this book as a preview via Net Galley and that is the only reason I finished it. Perhaps, if one were more familiar with the country and culture of Israel, it would be better but for me there were a lot of issues that just left me confused. Add that to the fact that the ending provides minimal resolution and it simply was not an enjoyable read.

Was this review helpful?

full teaser post to be published 19 February 2023 at https://wellreadpiratequeen.blogspot.com/2023/02/ISWIR-FarewellMyBabylon-Rosenfeld.html

****""""""""""""""""""**************""""""""""""""""******""

Dashiell Hammett gave us Sam Spade. Raymond Chandler gave us Philip Marlowe. Mickey Spillane gave us Mike Hammer. Now, Davidy Rosenfeld has given us Erez Brown. It reads like a classic noir but set in modern Tel Aviv, Israel.

All of Brown's cases kept me turning the pages to find out what was going to happen next. Will he find the missing daughter? Is the wife really cheating? Is the husband? Where's the ice cream money??? Rosenfeld really drew me in, though, with Brown and everyone he encountered -- his clients, staff, friends, and even the police who are sure he's leaving something out even when he's not. I could see them and hear them and, more than a few times, wanted to buy them a beer. My brain has already cast Eric Balfour as Erez and Inbar Lavi as his secretary Mazal, who could easily ranks right up there with Mike Hammer's Velda in terms of awesomeness.

The most fascinating character for me, though, was Tel Aviv:

"They say this city is a bubble. What it really is, is a broken mirror reflecting countless dreams. Tel Aviv is the capital of unfulfilled fantasies; the port Odysseus never reached; the grand lottery win missing only a single number; Pamela Anderson’s boobs…"

I've never been, but it feels like I have. Brown heard a song about Barcelona and though he had never been, he missed it. I'm going to feel the same about Tel Aviv until I get my hands on the next book and hopefully many more to come.

Was this review helpful?

Farewell My Babylon by Davidy Rosenfeld, an author unknown to me, tells the story of a private investigator in Israel who is engaged by an orthodox Jewish couple to find their daughter who disappeared some 3 years ago. The writing is somewhat mundane and most, if not all, of the characters are not very interesting. Despite those criticisms, I felt compelled to continue reading to find out how it all was resolved.

I thank NetGalley for the opportunity to read and review this book prior to publication.

Was this review helpful?