Member Reviews

Thank you NetGalley for approving me for this book. I am so glad I was able to read this book as I really enjoyed this and will read more by this author.

Was this review helpful?

The fine art of uncanny prediction is a great novel. Wada is a brilliant, strong character who has unwittingly become a private investigator. This story kept me guessing with lots of twist and turns. I hadn't realised it was the second book in the series and I will definitely go back and read the first one.
Thank you to netgalley, the publisher and the author for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Umiko Wada never set out to be a private detective, but fate had other plans. Following the mysterious death of her former boss, Kazuto Kodaka, she becomes the one-woman operation behind the Kodaka Detective Agency. Wada is cautious about the cases she takes, keen to avoid a similar fate. When a businessman asks her to track down his estranged son, it seems like a straightforward assignment. However, as she delves deeper, she uncovers a labyrinthine conspiracy with links to a twenty-seven-year-old investigation by her late employer and the chaos of the dying days of WWII. Someone has gone to extraordinary lengths to keep the past buried, and Wada’s pursuit leads her into the orbit of one of Tokyo’s most powerful men. As she unravels connections between then and now, danger escalates, and those she loves are drawn into the web.

Spanning seventy years, the novel takes readers on a head-spinning journey of twists and counter-twists. Wada is a compelling character—intelligent, resourceful, and charismatic. The plot kept me guessing until the final pages. Recommended.

Was this review helpful?

With Umiko Wada, Robert Goddard has created one of his finest characters. Perfectly paced with plenty of twists and the odd double cross as you'd expect in his books.
Another fine novel from the master of labyrinthine crime novels.

Was this review helpful?

A second outing for Umiko Wada, and it's as complicated (more so?) as the first book in the series. Perhaps overly complex, the twists and turns slightly distracted me this time and I didn't fully engage, which is why it's only 4 stars. But Goddard is a great writer, and Wada such an unassuming joy, that this is another success in what may become a longer series. Don't fret the details, just enjoy the ride!

(With thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for an ARC of this title.)

Was this review helpful?

4.5 stars

Don’t be fooled by the quirky title and snazzy cover, this is not the light, cosy mystery it appears to be. A bit like a wolf in sheep’s clothing, it has fangs that bite. And you will need all your wits about you to deal with it.

The Fine Art of Uncanny Prediction is the second instalment in Goddard’s Kodaka Detective Agency series. Set in Tokyo, and spanning 70 years, it is a cunningly intricate tale of conspiracy, blackmail and murder. With its labyrinthine plotting, scintillating twists and enigmatic heroine, it’s a literary delight for the more cerebral reader.

Said heroine is Umaka Wada, who has inherited the Kodaka agency from her late boss. It’s not the career she planned, but it’s a job she’s surprisingly good at. When she takes on the case of a businessmen seeking to find his missing son, little does she know what complications lie in store.

This was quite a difficult book to get into, as it introduces multiple characters and bounces between two timelines (1995 and 2022) and two separate investigations; and this, after a tantalizing prologue set in 1945.

It’s a lot to digest, but Goddard’s writing is heavy on the kind of detail that makes you want to keep on reading, and your perseverance is rewarded as soon as the two strands start to merge. I found the complexity quite challenging but greatly appreciated the plot recaps that Goddard cleverly wove into the narrative, which helped keep me on track.

Wada is a formidable, if enigmatic, protagonist. Middle-aged and nondescript — qualities perfect for her role as detective — she is whip smart and frighteningly self-sufficient. But she’s very much a closed book. We know she was widowed when her husband was killed in the Tokyo subway sarin attack, that she has a difficult relationship with her family, and that her work is her life. What she keeps carefully hidden are her emotions. I hope to see her gradually soften in future instalments.

For me, the only downside of this novel was the vast cast. Although Goddard provides a useful glossary of principal characters (some 30 in total), I really struggled to differentiate and cement all the Japanese names in my head. This may be a quirk on my part, but I’d be interested to know how other readers fare.

This notwithstanding, I absolutely love this series and can’t wait to see what future adventures are in store for Wada.

Was this review helpful?

Umiko Wada is successfully running her private investigation business and is discrete and effective. However when engaged to find a missing man her assignment becomes much greater and encompasses national scandals. Meanwhile her rather difficult mother has opened her doors to disgraced former sumo wrestler and Wada has a whole other set of concerns.
Following Goddard's last book which introduced the world to Wada, he has unleashed this rather wonderful tale. The plot is labyrinthine, the parallel stories become a little confusing at times but are linked together brilliantly at the end and several strands of post-War Japanese history are addressed in a pertinent but low key manner. All in all a very satisfying read.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoy reading Robert Goddard's work and it seems like he is like good wine - with age he gets better.

The idea of a Japanese female sleuth is brilliant and Wada is an extraordinary character to say the least.

I thoroughly enjoyed this novel and hope he goes back for a further instalment sometime in the future.

Very much recommended.

Was this review helpful?

I have read several Japanese murder mysteries over the years, and I have to say Robert Goddard has somehow captured that same feeling in his book. Umiko Wada is an amazing character, and I can't wait to read more of her adventures.

The story threads between the past and the present, between Umiko's perspective and her late mentor's. It is extremely satisfying to see all the pieces come together towards the end. A truly delightful read.

[I did not realise this was the second book in a series when I picked it up. I will be ordering the first one immediately.]

Was this review helpful?

This is the first book i read by Robert Goddard and will surely read other in this fascinating series.
An intriguing novel featuring a strong character like Umiko Wada and it's a contemporary story with root in the past.
There's a lot of characters, thanks for the list at the beginning, and I was fascinated by the plot, the setting, and the style of writing.
Highly recommended.
Many thanks to the publisher for this ARC, all opinions are mine

Was this review helpful?

This is an excellent sequel to The Fine Art of Invisible Detection.
Fascinating and intelligent storytelling with a richly developed and distinct cast of characters.
Wada is thoroughly engaging and enigmatic as she unravels the case with determination and resourcefulness.
A multilayered tale covering two interconnected timelines which are clearly defined and easy to follow.
The plot is perfect in its pacing, with atmospheric settings and immaculate writing style.
Compulsive reading told perfectly with great humour, twists and red herrings.
Entertaining and captivating. Hopefully there is more to come from Wada.
Highly recommended. Many thanks to the author, publisher and NetGalley UK.

Was this review helpful?

The Fine Art of Uncanny Prediction is the second book in the Umiko Wada series by award-winning, best-selling British author, Robert Goddard. Three years after her boss at the Kodaka Detective Agency was murdered, Umiko Wada has earned herself a reputation as a confidential, low key, effective investigator. Fumito Nagata would prefer to deal with Kodaka, but will settle for Wada because of that. He wants her to find his estranged son, Manjiro Nagata, or at least, check that the man is alive and well.

While she initially fails to locate him, she quickly establishes that he is absent from his home rather than reclusive. But following up every tiny scrap of a lead, she learns that a civil servant who was making enquiries about Manjiro is also missing. And Daiju Endo’s story, once she learns the details, is even more enigmatic, involving an earthquake “sensitive” and a wealthy filmmaker with a dubious history that extends back to the final days of WW2. Wada is unaware that Kazuto Kodaka had cases involving the same people almost three decades earlier.

Back in 1995, Kodaka had been asked by construction industry heir, Teruki Jinno to discover the recipient of the twenty-five million yen paid out of his late father’s bank account annually for almost fifty years. Kodaka’s first instinct leans towards blackmail, but information from his carefully cultivated sources leads in a different direction. A Californian wine grower, the angry American owner of a bar for US servicemen and an earthquake research centre are all important parts of the plot.

In 2022, Wada is unwittingly stepping in Kodaka’s 1995 footsteps; each of them has to consider taking a case for a client they are reluctant to serve; each finds they have a tail they need to lose; they variously rely on the expertise or inside knowledge of a bank employee, a journalist, a sound technician, a lawyer, and a road transport bureau employee.

Two clients terminate Wada’s contract before she reaches her objective; twice she is rescued from mortal danger by an unexpected saviour; Wada travels to California, witnesses two murders, and the final body count is not inconsiderable.

Goddard provides a useful (and quite necessary) character list at the start to help keep track of the many characters. He manages to convey his setting, both in Tokyo and California, with consummate ease. There’s plenty of excellent detective work, some dark humour, and not a few twists and red herrings. Fans can only hope that Goddard has more of this brave, smart and persistent protagonist and her support cast up his literary sleeve. An addictive series.
This unbiased review is from an uncorrected proof copy provided by NetGalley and Random House UK Transworld

Was this review helpful?

Normally a mystery plot with plenty of characters and a complicated story is kind of hard to follow and can make me feel impatient and disinterested in the book. But The Fine Art of Uncanny Prediction, though containing both a multitude of characters and an intricate plot, has a precise and intriguing narration that makes it hard not to get caught up in the whirlwind of action as Umiko Wada, the tenacious detective from Tokyo, tries to solve the latest case that has arrived at the Kodaka Detective Agency.

Although the book is the second installment in the Umiko Wada series, it can be read as a stand alone book. Umiko Wada is managing the Kodaka Detective Agency after the untimely death of her employer, Kazuto Kodaka. She is organized, immaculate, persistent and nothing but efficient in uncovering the truth when dealing with all her cases, which has made her more successful than perhaps Kodaka too. When a wealthy businessman comes to her seeking her help in locating his missing son, it leads her on a labyrinthine trail that takes her to California. Wada is after an ancient secret asset that many other parties are also seeking and they will stop at nothing until they lay their hands on it. The narration also follows a case that Kodaka was looking into in 1995, about a mystery woman who had predicted the disastrous earthquake in Kobe in January of 1995 and dubbed as 'Kobe Sensitive' by the media and public. The narration alternates between Wada's investigation in 2022 and Kodaka's endeavors to locate the 'Kobe Sensitive' and leads the reader on how both are linked by a common thread.

The writing is immaculate and fascinating and you cannot help but root for Wada, the steadfast detective with the quest for truth. A special mention for the character of Seiji Tago and hope that he gets a comeback in the next book because there were so many unresolved questions about him, primary being why did he get expelled from sumo? I have found another favorite series that I will be definitely following and another favorite detective to add in my list. Thanks to NetGalley and the publishers for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

The Fine Art of Uncanny Prediction is a second instalment in Robert Godard’s captivating series, featuring Umiko Wada, who is now a private detective. As we have come to expect from the author’s work, this book is well written, meticulously researched and full of twists and thrilling adventures. There’s an array of diverse characters, and the glossary at the beginning is very helpful in order to keep up. The storyline is multifaceted and quite complicated, occasionally posing challenges in tracking the myriad of events spanning both past and present. Nonetheless, the resolution clarifies any lingering confusion. Overall, I thoroughly enjoyed the book and eagerly anticipate the continuation of the series.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely loved the first book about Wada, the Japanese detective, running her late boss’s agency herself after his untimely death. This follow up novel contains more of the same although this time the majority of the story is set in Japan with a short trip to the US at the end.
There are many characters to contend with and an extremely complicated plot with two timelines but once I’d got my head around this and started reading the two different storylines , one about Kodaka , Wada’s old boss, set in 1995 and Wada’s investigation set in the present day, I was well and truly hooked.
There was also a lot of detailed research about Japanese customs such as Sumo and much written about the science of earthquakes which are a major hazard in the region. Both subjects were extremely interesting and fitted brilliantly into the plot.
I liked the relationship between Wada and her indomitable mother, Haha! This led to some lighter moments in the book, particularly as the older woman has decided to take a homeless sumo wrestler as a lodger!
There was a lot happening as the story progressed and much was revealed about both Wada’s and Kodaka’s past, all of which slotted in beautifully to the narrative. I thought the ending was really clever adding to the carefully constructed plot.
I’ll certainly be looking out for more stories about this wonderful and unusual detective and highly recommend both books as excellent reads.
Thanks to NetGalley and the publishers for my advance copy.

Was this review helpful?

Another excellent thriller featuring Wada. This s a complex storyline with a lot of characters to keep track of. There is a dual storyline which does eventually come together. To get full value you need to set aside quality time to fully appreciate the story . This is developing into an excellent series

Was this review helpful?

The Fine Art of Uncanny Prediction is the second brilliant book featuring no-nonsense middle-aged woman private detective Umiko Wada.

Wada gets involved in another international adventure when she refuses to stop seeking the truth. There's a historical aspect to the mystery, going back to the second world war and overlapping with the 1990's investigation of Wada's former boss, Kodaka. There's also worry closer to home as Wada's elderly mother Haha gets involved with a disgraced former sumo wrestler

Highly recommended for lovers of detective fiction, but read The Fine Art of Invisible Detection first to get the full character arc for this remarkable woman.

Was this review helpful?

This is one of my favourite authors who I have been with for absolutely ages and who has never disappointed me. As I mentioned in my review for The Fine Art of Invisible Detection - the first in series - it is a return to the classic way of writing I fell for all those years ago. Oh and having mentioned that book, I do recommend you read that one first for better enjoyment of this.
So... Umiko Wada has really hit the ground running in her new guise as Private Detective. Having fully taken over her late boss Kazuut Kodaka's Detective Agency. He having died in mysterious circumstances, and her still being a bit green, she is very selective of the cases she takes on. But the one presented to her at the start of the book appears to fit that bill. A father wants her to find his missing son.
But, you know what, if it really was that simple it'd be a bit of a boring book! But I am not about to expand on that here, for obvious reasons. But what I will say is that there are links to an old case of her former boss and we then split to a dual timeline where we follow Kodaka in the past and Wada in the present as the two cases start to form links...
As with all his other books this one is very intelligently written and is interconnected and, on occasion, a tad convoluted. I would really recommend that you dedicate a fair chunk of your time to it rather than a page or so every so often. It does take a bit of concentration. Well, that's what I found. There is a cast list at the beginning but don't let that put you off. My jaw did drop when I saw it and I did screen shot and print it out for reference as flipping back and forwards is not easy with an eBook. That said, I never actually referred to it again! so don't let that overwhelm you! All the characters are well drawn and distinct and play their parts very well indeed.
Pacing is also good and matches the narrative all the way through. It does start off a tad slowly but there is quite a bit to build up before it really gets going. But all that really is necessary and, once it gets going, it will all have been worth it.
All in all, a brilliant follow up to what was already a cracking first in series. I am really excited for what he has next in store for Wada in book three. My thanks go to the Publisher and Netgalley for the chance to read this book.

Was this review helpful?

The good news is you don't need to have read the first one of this series to pick up who's who and what's going on because it's a completely different story.

This time Wada becomes embroiled in a mystery that, at first, seems quite simple - find a missing son. However when that starts getting more difficult and is followed with a other disappearance Wada is pointed in the direction of a case that her late boss, Kodaka, investigated in 1995.

It does get a bit complicated but, as usual, my advice is not to stress about all the characters just enjoy the story and it'll all work out in the end.

I find Wada a thoroughly engaging character probably because she's very organised and doesn't put up with any flannel from anyone (except perhaps her mother -- although how she hasn't sounded off at the brother who dispenses wisdom from thousands of miles away is anyone's guess).

Anyway, the two cases do dovetail and there's a satisfactory end. We get to learn more about Kodaka and Wada and there's quite a lot of racing about so the story clips along quite nicely.

I also enjoyed it a bit more because Goddard uses Japanese phrases (albeit in the romanised version) and since I'm trying to learn Japanese I was delighted to find I knew what everything meant without one single Google.

Thoroughly enjoyed this second outing for Wada and I look forward to a third perhaps? I'll keep my fingers crossed. No really gory buts, good plot, interesting characters, a bit of history thrown in. Almost perfect. I'd recommend this to anyone.

Thanks to Netgalley and Random House UK for the advance review copy.

Was this review helpful?

I’m extremely pleased that Robert Goddard has written another story about Wada and the Kodakka Private Investigation Agency.

This 2nd story set in Japan tells a tale of two timelines. One one set in the past and one more recent.

Complex, layered, complicated yet absolutely superb, Goddard writes mystery with the very best. It begins very gently paced as the story and world is built, but briskly picks up as the pages turn.

Wada is a glorious creation, and her investigations that really delve into the intricacies of Japanese Culture are a joy.

One of the best reads so far this year.

Was this review helpful?