Member Reviews
I would like to thank netgalley and Watkins Publishing for a free copy of the book in exchange for an honest review.
This was only a sample, but it was still a little disappointing.
I am one of the few people who wasn't aware of The Weird Walk journal of wanderings and wonderings before reading this book - but it sounded interesting. With books like these I always turn first to places I know well, in that way I know how good or useful the rest of the book will be.
This book takes you on a year of walks through ancient mythical Britain. The sites in the South West of England were well chosen with accurate details and an interesting write up with information that was new to me. This book is a great collection of sites to walk to from the well known - Stonehenge, to ones that would probably only be known to locals - the Green Man at Wootton Rivers. As a lover of history, I found this a great collection of walks.
Weird walk by the weird walk group might as well be a book of pagan holidays and Christian holidays because throughout the book we hear about traditions that are not only steeped in the occult but those whose origin story comes from the church but all is meant to be a great tourist attraction and A way to honor those who came before andcan even be used to teach the current generation about the old days. There are not only just places you can go but traditions you can participate in or at least watch I found this book to be very interesting but I will admit it was at times confusing as I am still not quite sure what the weird walkers are. In any event the things mentioned in the book are very interesting and right up my alley if you love the weird things that are off the beaten path then you will enjoy the events mentioned in this book. I want to thank Net Galley and the publisher for my free arc copy please forgive any mistakes as I am blind and dictate my review.
Firstly I wasn't aware of the "cultural phenomenon" Weird Walk, and I'm still not quite sure what it is either if I'm honest - so I was just expecting this to be a book of walks to "weird" places! On that front it isn't exactly what I expected, but I did still enjoy it.
This book basically gathers together a bunch of cool and unusual places and events within Britain that hark back to an older and more mysterious era. There isn't a great deal of emphasis on the walks involved to get to these places, and for several of them it's literally a walk from the car park and then plot your own route on an OS map if you want to go any further, but to be honest books of walks often don't work anyway since by the time you get chance to go and do them all, scattered over the British Isles as they are, at least some of the details of footpaths, pubs and public transport are invariably out of date.
The photos are great and I like the way that the descriptions are written in a chatty, witty style. There's a good variety of sites and events chosen so it doesn't get repetitive either. Overall I liked it a lot and would have been happy to read more than the sampler I had from Netgalley.
I don't normally bother with samplers on Netgalley, not least because they bring with them the quandary of how best to record them on Goodreads. Here, though, I did want to know ahead of the book's release whether it was worth getting for those of us who already have the parent 'zine. Short answer: yes. Obviously it won't be so easily popped in a pocket, and the lack of any sketch maps for walks feels like a shame (map references and OS suggestions are supplied instead). But the photographs look far better here, even in a supposedly low-res file, and the repetition of earlier content is minimal. As against the mag's sometimes baffling organisation - I still love that the first article in the first issue was a beginner's guide to dungeon synth - the scheme here is much clearer; walks are divided by suggested season, with the sampler containing spring (and Stewart Lee's excellent introduction. Of the authors: "No one knows who they are, or what they are doing. But their legacy remains. Are they bound together in blood by the call of the Way of the Weird Walk? Or are they just trying to escape mundane reality by adding an air of significance to what may essentially be extended rural pub crawls with ideas above their station?"). Some locations are familiar to anyone the least bit into this stuff - Cerne Abbas, Padstow - while others are more niche. Most of the entries go beyond their ostensible topic to some wider observation, maybe on a relevant book or film, perhaps on giant legends, or how even a folly can accrue a certain numinous quality with surprising speed. Importantly, they don't fall for some of the loopier anti-modernity which the revival of interest in folk culture can try to smuggle through: "It is easy to re-imagine pre-modern, rural lives in overly sentimental terms, as an arcadian time before the Industrial Revolution and the "dark satanic mills". The truth is life was often exceedingly harsh - toiling in the fields in savage British weather, scratching out subsistence, raising animals to sell and to slaughter, fending off disease." The project is about trying to recover things of value which have been lost, not a wholesale turning back of the clock. Their turn of phrase helps with this, able to be enchanted and irreverent within the same entry, avoiding earnestness without collapsing into a craven refusal to admit they're genuinely into their subject (the Cerne Abbas chapter is especially good for this, with the man himself looking "as though you have interrupted the colossal geoglyph in a particularly arousing, yet private, cudgel-wielding session.").