Member Reviews

Thank you Netgalley and Pan Macmillan for this advanced copy!

Karen Swan is an author I constantly monitor for her latest work - I love her unique mixture of escapism, romance, thriller and jumps through time or narratives. I'd been a fan of her newer Wild Isle series, and was interested to see where her latest Christmas novel would take us.

Christmas by Candlelight felt at once different but the same as her other novels. Different in that it didn't bring us off on an adventure to a new destination, nor did it jump between characters from different eras. Instead we found ourselves in the UK, predominantly in one location for the 'present day' timeline - a college housemate's grand home for a Christmas reunion. We get flashbacks to the group's college narratives as well. In this sense, it felt like greater emphasis was placed on the relationships between the various characters, and our 'secondary' characters and their relationships with one another and the main characters also felt much more flushed out which was a joy to read.

I did feel a connection to some of the secondary characters more than our main lead. It may have been intentional (as our MC felt like an outsider looking in), or it may also have just been how she was written. Libby felt a bit like a Mary Sue - intelligent, driven, beautiful, and described on a variety of occasions by various characters as having a 'sexy body' (as if stripping away her baggy clothes suddenly opened up everyone's eyes to her worth). She was no nonsense as well and for quite a bit of the novel I couldn't see much more to build upon in her character, until some secondary character plot points continued to reveal themselves.

Nonetheless, the wit, banter, mystery and slow build romance that are characteristic in Karen Swan's other novels were still as plentiful here, and just as entertaining to read. I particularly enjoyed Teabag's moments, exploring Coco's character, and the general warmth of Em and Prock.

Overall, rating this one 4 out or 5.

Was this review helpful?

I love a Karen Swan Christmas story, and I loved this one.
Old University friends get together at Archie's Manor a few days before Christmas. Libby Pugh hasn't seen her uni friends in nine years. Her and boyfriend Max were only staying for dinner, but then it snowed heavily. There's a power cut, pylons crashing to the ground. There's no way out.
This is a dual timeline read with us going back to 2014, what happened with the friends, and why Libby didn't stay in contact.
This really picked up halfway through when there are shock revelations, not what I was expecting.
The atmosphere at the Manor during the power cut is eerie and scary.
The characters were well written and drawn.
A very good Christmas read
Thanks to Netgalley and Pan Macmillan for the ARC in return for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Karen Swan always writes excellent Christmas novels that aren’t all about happy families, cute traditions and joy. They leave food for thought and cover serious issues. This book was no different. I found the book throughly engaging. All is not what it seems secrets, lies and mysteries are scattered throughout.

“Candlelight at Christmas” begins in 2014 at Durham University Library where we meet Libby studying hard late into the night and meet some of her flatmates as they try to persuade her to leave so she doesn’t miss out on their housemate’s 21st birthday party.

The narrative then switches to the present day, 22nd December 2023. We see Libby, a high flying lawyer as she zooms down the M1M with her attractive colleague after being at a mutual friend’s wedding. Libby and Max are friends with benefits. This outing is the first time they have admitted to some form of relationship outside of work by being seen together socially. En route home they are stopping off for a meal with Libby’s University friends. Libby shared a house with 7 other people, at the time they were close but she has barely kept in touch with any of her friends. This year, due to her locality she has felt obliged to attend the reunion meal. She describes each of her friends to Max their backgrounds, current jobs and personalities. Despite being warned Max is still surprised by the size of the stunning stately home belonging to Archie.

Back together again, some more familiar with their glamorous surroundings than others, the friends reunite and the drinks flow. Meanwhile snow falls swiftly outside. They find themselves snowed in and the true merriment and Christie like locked room mysteries can begin…

The switch between University days and the present occurs throughout the book as we glimpse into the lives and loves of the housemates and hints as to why Libby in particular has moved on so far from the close knit student family she had. I think it worth noting that unfortunately one of the characters experiences a sexual assault as a student. This of course has massive implications to their future character development but it might be something that causes upset to a reader if they are not expecting such a sudden change from the jollity of the parties and quiet life of studying and scrounging to find bread, milk and other staples in a house full of disorganised, broke students.

I grew to care for all the characters, particularly as the key to each of their gruff or fake or serious personalities was revealed in the near past. As time moves on in the splendid isolation of a cold pile of a country house the question is will the aforementioned Christmas by Candlelight be a happy one?

Was this review helpful?

Christmas By Candlelight by Karen Swan grew on me as I read. To start with I wasn't sure about it but by halfway through I was completely hooked. I was rooting for Libby all the way through but the other characters also held my attention.

Was this review helpful?

Karen Swan is a great story teller and really this book is not about Christmas. A group of university friends meet up after 9 years. All of their insecurities, loves and lives are eventually drawn out, with the story yoyoing between the past and the present. OK, they were cut off from the world by a snowstorm but it could have been set at any time.
Thank you to NetGalley and Pan MacMillan for the advance copy of this book.

Was this review helpful?

Another very enjoyable read by Karen Swan, this time set around a group of friends who had been at university together, and catch up over the Christmas period years later at Archie's manor house.

The main character, Libby, arrives at the manor with her (sort of) partner Max, a flying visit to say hello to everyone at the reunion after being at a wedding in the area. But the weather goes downhill pretty quickly whilst they are there and they all end up stuck at the manor for a lot longer than planned due to the snow.

Whilst they are all stuck there they end up reminising about their time at uni, good times and bad times, some of which are still haunting them now. Secrets are slowly revealed by some of the people there, and past issues sorted out.

I really enjoyed all of the characters in this book, and it did seem very Christmassy because of the snow, and the power cut, so lots of candles and fires. There were some happy parts and some sad parts, but ultimately a very satisfying read. I would expect nothing less from Karen Swan though, she always delivers a wonderful story.

Was this review helpful?

Oh my word, this book, it's the best thing I've ever read! Christmas By Candlelight brings visions of a cosy Christmas but it's so much more than that, friends, lovers but also threat, violence and heart stopping moments that had me turning the pages fast, thrilling right until the end, Bravo!

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely loved this book and have to say, I think this is my favourite Karen Swan book so far. I could not put it down. The ending was not what I was expecting at all.

The start of the book seems to be an easy going story about friends doing life together at university, and then consequently, on the way back from a wedding, Lib comes back into their world for a reunion.

This goes so deep into friendship and history, regrets and dreams - along with some mystery and the sparkle of Christmas.

I would recommend anyone to read this book.

Was this review helpful?

I found this a very slow burner for me, it`s set over two timelines for a group of university friends.
They finally meet up a decade later, one of the friends has a family run down mansion and Libby is only calling in with her boyfriend after attending a wedding and before going home for Christmas unfortunately they get snowed in and the phone lines are down and no electricity as they all reminisce of the past and secrets are revealed.
A good story once it gets going.

Thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for the ARC and I give my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I like Karen Swan as an author but it took me quite a few chapters to reply get engrossed into this book. Once I got my teeth into it I couldn't put it down. Love the fact that friendship and love can survive and blossom over many years.

Was this review helpful?

Having read several of Karen Swan's novels was keen to obtain a copy of this, her latest book via Net Galley.
This is the tale of Libby and what happens when her and her boyfriend get snowed in on their way home from a reunion with university pals. I thoroughly enjoyed it

Was this review helpful?

Firstly I should say this is not a Christmas book in the usual style. There's lots of snow, but no candy cane sweetness!
The story tells of a group of uni housemates and friends, in two timelines - 2014 and 2023.
The main character is Libby who, in 2014, doesn't have the confidence or finances of her glamorous friends.
When Libby meets up with the others in 2023, their stories are all revealed. It's a risky book as the majority of the characters are unlikeable until we get to know their back stories.
Very well-written and plenty to keep you interested.

Was this review helpful?

Who doesn’t enjoy a Christmas novel in summer! I loved it and have enjoy the story it tells! Being snowed in and in close quarters secrets are bound to be revealed!

Was this review helpful?

Yet another excellent book by Karen Swan. I really liked the way that it moved from the past to the present, keeping me guessing about what was to happen. Interesting characters and a definite page turner.

Was this review helpful?

Another fantastic festive Christmas read from Karen Swan, I eagerly await her new books with such anticipation!
Based on a group of friends sharing a house at university, such a diverse group of friends from very different backgrounds with different aspirations and expectations.
Bonded by shared experiences and friends for life!
Libby who hasn’t seen her friends for many years attends a winter reunion with her new boyfriend in tow! Gathered together in Archies crumbling pile the old gang find themselves reminiscing, buried emotions surface and long held secrets come to the fore!
Told as a dual timeline and written in the tried and trusted style of previous Christmas books, this book is such an enjoyable, relatable read that illustrates so well the amazing role of friendships across the years, with a wonderfully happy ending!
Thank you NetGalley for this early read.

Was this review helpful?

"Christmas by Candlelight" by Karen Swan is a cosy and heart-warming holiday tale set against the backdrop of a snowed-in reunion with old friends. The story captures the magic of reconnecting with familiar faces and the warmth of shared memories. As the characters navigate unexpected challenges, Swan beautifully explores the complexities of relationships and the power of self-discovery. This novel is a delightful blend of nostalgia and the holiday spirit, making it a perfect read for the Christmas season.

Was this review helpful?

The book jumps from past to present and achieves the transitions beautifully. It’s a wonderful story of how the past has a way of catching up with us all combined with old friends and new romance. Fab book.

Was this review helpful?

Libby and her boyfriend Max are meeting up with Libby’s old University friends in an old faded manor house in Yorkshire. Theirs is meant to be a fleeting visit as Libby felt that she hadn’t fitted in with her friends, and doesn’t want to stay too long. Unfortunately, heavy snow falls result in them having to stay.
The story is told from two timeframes, Libby’s university days and present, which gives more depth to the story. I liked the varied mix of characters, they are well drawn and relatable. Karen Swan is expert at writing about relationships, she gets inside her characters bringing the story alive. Archie, the owner of the manor house, is a likeable laid back character, while Libby is driven to succeed in the business she is employed in. There are secrets from the past which are explored as the story unfolds.
Graphic descriptions of Archie’s mysterious, freezing cold manor house, with its ghostly noises and doors slamming shut, brings an added element of fear. Libby desperately wants to keep the past in the past, but is powerless when secrets are discovered. The hint of mystery and hidden secrets, along with twists and turns that make this story a winner.

Was this review helpful?

Christmas By Candlelight - Karen Swan

We get to meet a group of uni friends after a significant amount of time has passed and see how their old memories have affected them - bringing a lot of intrigue along the way. This book had me gripped from the first page, and I found myself trying to sneak a little reading time in here and there to just enjoy a little more of it, I found the relationships fascinating and also enjoyed some chemistry as well. This book can 100% be enjoyed all year around and even has a feel of a mystery book to it. So definetly something for all readers to enjoy.

Thanks so much Netgalley and Pan Macmillan for the e-arc in return for my honest thoughts and opinions.

Was this review helpful?

This was a lovely story. Libby and her boyfriend decide to stop off at a university reunion on their way back from a wedding. They are all having a wonderful time when the weather takes a turn for the worse and they a marooned for days. I really like the sledging story it sounded like a lot of fun. Everything was fine until the power went out and they chatted about their pasts which make things take an unfortunate turn and things are revealed that Libby would rather not revisit. A real page turner.

Was this review helpful?