Member Reviews

I read this so quickly and it is a fun YA fantasy fiction story. Does it have a few holes in the plot…maybe, or they’re a bit weak.the main premise is Mira wants to save her father and friend and to do that she believes she needs to follow coordinates in her mothers journal….it never really explains why and it would make more sense if this was coming off the back of her mothers death or even her fathers.
However, the literal and figurative journey Mira takes to get to these coordinates and back is thrilling, fun and full of adventure at such a fast pace. The twists and turns particularly in who to trust is what makes this book a real page turner!
You can definitely see how this will become a series and grow with its main character and her supporting cast.

I received this book as an ARC and provided and honest review

Was this review helpful?

I was really intrigued by this novel and I’m always interested in giving sea-based fantasies a read, although this isn’t as piratical as a lot of sea-faring novels. Although it didn’t quite hit that high note for me, it was still a good read and I’m happy I gave it a shot. Mira is a brave and strong female lead, determined to save her people by whatever means she can and it leads her on an adventure away from her isolated island home, introducing her to whole new worlds and people. She’s determined and fierce in her mission, but finding it hard to know who to trust when she knows those around her are lying, but not what they’re lying about. There’s plenty of action to be found in this story and some interesting characters - both friend and foe. I’m disappointed I didn’t feel any connection of chemistry between Mira and Seth, and I was frustrated by her behaviour with him, wanting Mira to be a little more cautious and really embody the strong, female adventurer rather than displaying so much naivete. So, that being said, rightly or wrongly, I wasn’t rooting for them as a couple and would have happily tossed Seth overboard early on to forget all about the seemingly magical connection between them. Though, Mira being Mira she’d probably have gone to save him, which I definitely admire her for. She’s brave and willing to risk herself for those she cares about and it was great to see her fierceness. With so many twists and turns, I want to see where this series goes next and what’s in store for Mira and her friends. It is bound to be a bumpy ride but one with lots of potential.

I received a free copy of this book. All views are my own.

Was this review helpful?

I'm not entirely sure on my feelings 100% with this one, I enjoyed it don't get me wrong but it also felt a little all over the place?

I couldn't understand why her mother's chest would help her father in the slightest, had a few plot holes I think. I didn't like how she kept going back to Seth either.

I was intriged by Elijah and would've liked to see more of him to be honest and the rest of the Phantom crew.

Would definitely read the sequel if one is made though.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to netgalley for the arc!
Piratey fantasy in a ya setting! Really enjoyable and I found Mira a great MC

Was this review helpful?

Mira, along with the rest of the people on her island, lure ships in to be wrecked and then pillage what they find in order to survive. But when her father is arrested, she must embark on a journey that takes her away from her island, where nobody she meets can be trusted ...

This is a good pirate-ish story with a hint of fantasy and a whole lot of twists. Some parts felt like they moved a bit fast, but overall it was a really enjoyable read!

I received a copy from the publisher in exchange for an honest review

Was this review helpful?

"Compass and Blade" is a ya romantasy written by Rachel Greenlaw.

I love fantasy with marine settings, so I jumped on this title with great enthusiasm! And what a wonderful read it turned out to be! "Compass and Blade" is a gripping, adventurous and magical book, filled with quaint islands, mysterious chests, secret maps, deceptive smugglers, ruthless guards, frantic chases, precipitous escapes, violent storms, intriguing magic, ravenous mermaids, ambiguous characters and much more. All enveloped by the enchanting, unfathomable and unpredictable charm of the sea! A fast, dynamic and highly atmospheric story featuring evocative, crisp and vivid prose that absorbed me completely! A tale in the wake of "Fable" by Adrienne Young and "Daughter of the Pirate King" by Tricia Levenseller, which I loved so much!

The story unfolds between a group of rather close islands, called Fortunate Isles, the open sea and the coast of the mainland. More precisely, the events start from the small Isle of Rosevear, the birthplace of the protagonist. A rocky island, where life is arduous and tough. The inhabitants of Rosevear survive by wrecking passing ships along the rocks surrounding the island, using deceptive light signals, then running into the water and retrieving the cargo from their holds. A choice dictated by survival, not by cruelty, which pushes them to try to rescue the survivors, whenever possible, keeping the truth from them. A well-tested system put at risk by guards sent from the mainland to root out any illegal activity. I loved the Isle of Rosevear, the strong sense of community that hovers among its inhabitants, the traditions that characterize it. The magical element is intriguing but marginal at the moment, mostly illustrated through stories and tales. There are witches, potions infused with magic, legendary creatures such as wyverns, narwhals and mermaids, and much more. Let's just say it's all very hinted at for now, with glimpses here and there that have me fairly intrigued! Overall it's a simple world building, not too thorough, giving the minimum amount of information needed to not get lost. I enjoyed it and found it extremely fascinating!

The story proceeds fast and brisk, full of action, lies, secrets, deceptions, subterfuges, deals, betrayals and power plays. The captivating pace, coupled with the presence of short chapters, pushed me to devour the reading, without moments of boredom or heaviness. I admit I spotted the various plot twists in advance, but that did not prevent me from enjoying the book. The naval and marine scenes then are really wonderful, as are the various port scenes!

Mira, the protagonist with her only first person pov, convinced me! Mira is an 18-year-old girl born and raised on the Isle of Rosevear, one of the seven chosen to swim in the waters off the island and plunder the wrecked ships. Specializing in the rescue of any survivors, she inherited her position from her mother, who died during one of the pillages. A task she easily accomplishes, thanks to her excellent swimming skills, her ability to hold her breath longer than others, and the fact that for her, the waters never turn out cold, but warm and pleasant. Mira loves the island and its inhabitants, but at the same time she feels the call of the sea, the attraction to the abyss, the need to explore. A call she has always tried to ignore, because Rosevear and her dear father need her. That is, until the man is arrested by The Watch, setting in motion a series of events with unpredictable outcomes. Mira is a strongly empathetic, caring and kind girl with great courage and determination, used to extricating herself from difficult situations. A person who always tries to save others, hating the idea of leaving anyone behind. I found her to be fantastically portrayed, with incredible development! Her relationship with the island, its inhabitants, and her father involved me a lot, as did her connection to the sea!

The secondary characters seemed well portrayed to me! Some are quite gray, ambiguous and mysterious and obviously they captured me! I admit that I wasn't particularly hooked by the romance, at least in the beginning, but that's because I'm not a fan of instalove and I felt a strong instalove here. However, as I went on, I found myself changing my mind, thanks to the various plot developments and now I am very curious about it! Seriously, I can't wait to read the sequel to see how the whole story will evolve!

All in all, "Compass and Blade" is an excellent start to the series, which I recommend to lovers of fantasy with marine settings!

Thank you to the Publisher and NetGalley for giving me an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

A middle grade/YA adventure for those who loved a Pirates of the Caribbean, and Daughter of the Pirate King, following characters on a journey through the sea and storms, not knowing who to trust.

A truly lovely tale to sit down and read with ease. I would say this writing style is definitely more middle grade, however, the story tends to be more ya which is such a lovely mix because it means that you can sit down, read this book and enjoy it without it being too heavy to read. The perfect book for this time of year.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to publishers for the copy of Compass and Blade.

I really enjoyed the premise of this novel and I found myself drawn into the storyline. The way the plot played out was intriguing and I was eager to find out how it all ended.
I loved the character of Mira, she was strong willed and her fierce loyalty to her father was endearing. I really liked how she grew but I was frustrated by her lack of judgement of Seth. I liked Seth's character but I felt him predictable..
The whole story was great to read and the twists and turns made for a terrific read. I really enjoyed the ending and do wonder if there's going to be a book 2.
This YA debut is a fantastic read and I can't wait to get hold of my copy I have on pre-order.

Was this review helpful?

There was a lot of promise with the premise of this book but, for me, something just fell really short.

Mira, our female MC, is so incredibly niave, frustrating and blind. It was so hard to connect with her because all the way through I could tell what the outcome of her actions were going to be and she never seemed to learn from her actions.

I also do not get how this romance came about - it gave you no build up to how Mira and Seth "connected". When? How? It made no sense.

I'm gutted I didn't enjoy this.

Was this review helpful?

This book had me compulsively turning the pages, filled with adventure mon the seas, ship wrecks and smugglers and sirens, I was hooked and impatiently waiting book two.

If you love morally grey characters, adventures on the high seas and high stakes which ask the question what are you willing to do for family, this book is for you. If you loved To Kill a Kingdom or Daughter of the Pirate King, you'll love this. Filled with betrayal and non stop adventure, you'll be questioning everyone's motives.

Was this review helpful?

Emojis Out of Context - 🧭🗺️🪢🔪🗝️⛵

Compass & Blade is a fantastic entry to a unique new series. The introduction to the island of Rosevear and the Breakers was a brilliant hook and the visuals of them at work was awesome. I'd have been happy of just a novel of the Breakers at work!

Following Mira's journey to free her father across different islands introduces us to a variety of settings & plenty of great characters. The crew of the Phantom are standouts for sure. The world building is wonderful and I'm eager to see where Greenlaw takes us next. (Especially after that ending 👀)

Was this review helpful?

My first 5⭐️ read of the year 😍

Mira is a wrecker which means she and 6 of her friends and villagers swim out to ships wrecked on the rocks surrounding their village, plundering whatever goods they can find to survive.

I was immersed from the first chapter and finished the whole book in 1 sitting.
There is ALOT going on within the story but the writing flows beautifully and I was swept along with Mira on her journey and loved every minute!

The characters are interesting and the world building was beautifully done, no info dumping,
I was kept on my toes from beginning to end and I’m excited to see where book 2 takes us!

Was this review helpful?