Member Reviews

Miriam Halahmy’s "A Boy from Baghdad" is a gripping and heartfelt novel that explores themes of conflict, displacement, and hope through the eyes of a young refugee. The story follows a boy who flees war-torn Baghdad, seeking safety and a new life. Halahmy’s writing is both evocative and sensitive, offering a poignant portrayal of the challenges faced by refugees and the impact of war on innocent lives. The characters are vividly drawn, and the narrative is both compelling and emotionally resonant. "A Boy from Baghdad" is a powerful and thought-provoking read that highlights the resilience of the human spirit amidst adversity.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley and Green Bean Books for the ARC!

I was looking forward to reading this book, even though it was geared for young kids. However, it came out during the wrong time and I couldn't bring myself to keep reading. The part of the book that I did read, I could tell that Miriam Halahmy is a wonderful writer.

Was this review helpful?

I’ve always believed that books have a way of finding their readers. And I am delighted that Miriam Halahmy’s A Boy from Baghdad found me. Although it is a children’s book meant for 10–12-year-olds, I am confident even adults are going to enjoy this. At least, I certainly did!

Based partly on the author’s husband’s family, Halahmy’s storytelling transported me to the Baghdad and Israel in the 50s.

The narrative is skillfully driven by both character and plot. Salman and Latif’s optimism is infectious and it is impossible to not fall in love with these adorable boys. The secondary characters are equally well-sketched and play their roles to perfection.

This heartbreaking story portrays the prejudice, racism, genocide, and displacement faced by Iraqi Jews. For readers unfamiliar with this chapter of history, this book is a valuable resource. Kudos to the author for striking the right balance of honesty and sensitivity.

Despite these serious themes, the narration is filled with hope and empathy, encouraging readers to gain understanding and root for the people. This book can be a good resource for children and adults to discuss this chapter from history.

A Boy from Baghdad will remain a treasured and memorable read forever.
Wordsopedia Rating 4.75/5

Was this review helpful?

This is the story of Salman, a young Iraqi Jew who moves to Israel after the Iraqi government turns against its Jewish people and suggests that they emigrate. The Iraqi Jewish people would have a year to leave, could never return and were not permitted to take anything of value with them. Salman doesn't want to leave his comfortable life in Baghdad or his much loved River Tigris, where he loves to swim and dreams of being an Olympic medalist.

When Salman and his family have to move to Israel, the Promised Land, a land of milk and honey, they find that things are not what they were told they would be and life, in the camp they now call home, is hard. Israel was at war with several of the surrounding Arab countries and this led to tensions between the larger population of Ashkenazi Jews from Europe and the Arab Jewish people. Salman and his family face poor living conditions and abuse from others but he is determined to prove his and his people's worth.

I really enjoyed this book. I knew very little about the circumstances that provide the background to this story and am keen to learn more. I will be adding this book to our school library.

Was this review helpful?

I really love this little book, Salman/Shimon is a lovely boy who's dream is to win an Olympic medal. I did not know much about Iraqi Jews, nor did I know much about the first years of the state Israel. So this novel was not only entertaining because of the witty characters, but also because I got the opportunity to read about something new.
I hadn't expected this amount of prejudice. This story throws also a light on nowadays refugees. They all have a history and a reason for being where they are now and don't deserve living in camps like the ma'abara.

Was this review helpful?

It's the 1950s, and 12-year-old Salman is happy in his home in Iraq. He loves swimming and dreams of being an Olympic swimmer one day and representing his country. His dreams are shattered when his father tells him that they will be leaving for the Promised Land immediately, to start a new life, as Jews are no longer safe in Iraq.⁣

What was promised to them as The Land of Milk and Honey turns out to be a hellish experience, worse than they could have ever imagined, an they feel trapped and dejected that their own people have misled and lied to them.⁣

The family struggles, starting over from scratch, and all the while, Salman doesn't give up on his dream of becoming a swimmer, even though the odds seem to be stacked against him. His ride-or-die is his cousin Latif, who will do anything to help his cousin and make his dream come true. ⁣

It's sad that though every Jew should be united towards a common goal, the Iraqi Jews and all the Jews from the Arab lands are treated poorly and discriminated against by the Ashkenazi Jews, who think themselves better and superior to the rest. This prejudice exists even in the little kids and teenagers, who have undoubtedly learnt it from their parents.⁣

Salman and his family are sweet, simple people, and I felt sorry that they had to go through all those hardships, along with so many other families. However, they stick together as a family and help each other out till they can better their circumstances. ⁣

The characters of Salman and his cousin Latif are very relatable. They are trying to live as normal a life as possible, torn between their old and new identities, and they have the added responsibility of trying to hustle and arrange for food or earn a few extra bucks to help out their respective families, which is not something a kid should have to worry about at that age, but such are their circumstances. ⁣

Everything is not all gloom and doom, though. There are some Ashkenazi Jews that are good and helpful, and no matter what the family is going through, you can always see the silver lining running just below the surface of the story. ⁣

The book is meant for YA readers, but it's a heartwarming story that even adults will enjoy. I know I did!⁣

Thanks to NetGalley and the publishers for the digital ARC of this novel.

Was this review helpful?

Readers will love Salman from the start as well as his cousin Latif. While the world in A Boy from Baghdad, Iraq in 1951 and Israel, might be unfamiliar, the boys are entirely relatable. The author has done a wonderful job writing characters that both represent different reactions to their changing circumstances, Latif’s (Roni) willingness to embrace his new life and Salman’s initial reluctance to, and characters that feel real. The tension between the Ashkenazi community and the Mizrachi Jews is well balanced. The prejudice and deprivations that the Iraqi Jews faced is clear, but there still are Ashkenazi Jews that accept the newcomers as well. The complicated relationship between the new and the old, Ashkenazi and Mizrachi, Jew and Arab are present on the page, but presented in a way that still feels organic. Readers will find themselves rooting for Salman to succeed. While this book is perfect for MIddle Grade readers, it’s perfect for their parents too. Thank you to NetGalley for the advance electronic copy of this compelling novel.

Was this review helpful?

Iraqi Jews in the 1950's from a 12 year old perspective, emigration to Israel for middle grade readers (& adults too!)

Things in 1951 Iraq are dangerous for Jews like Salman and his family. He has to remember to speak Arabic in the street and fleeing to Israel is going to put a damper on his daily swims in the river.

They arrive in Israel to find themselves in a tent city. His family tries to make the best of it - his cousins have entrepreneurial ideas, his sister joins a Kibbutz and they find themselves feeling like outsiders once again.

Sal find a way to swim in Israel and find his way.

Beautiful story about the struggles of Iraqi Jews and their paths.

Was this review helpful?

You know a children's book is special when, as an adult, you both enjoy reading it and learn something new. I had no idea that the Iraqi Jews in Israel were treated this way. And it is a story that really must be told so that Israel can live up to its true potential and be a place more welcoming to those who don't fit the initial mold that the European Jews created. The author does an excellent job with this story and also avoids stereotyping any of the different groups that make up the story. It's readable and the storyline itself will appeal to anyone who loves to see the underdog win.

It's the kind of book that a 10-13 year old would easily get caught up in and reading it with an adult and then discussing it would make the experience even more valuable.

Highly recommended for children with an interest in the world and highly recommended for all synagogue and Jewish school libraries. It would also make a nice holiday gift!

Thank you to NetGalley for an advance copy of this book. We need more books like this!

Was this review helpful?

This is such an interesting and engaging book! It shows a side of Israel that many are not aware of - namely, the racism that some (mostly European) Jews can exhibit towards their fellow Jews. This is something that has most recently been seen in the Jewish State's treatment of the Falashas aka the Ethiopian Jews, but such attitudes go back much further than that.

For anyone familiar with Israeli society, the divide between the Northern Ashkenazi/European Jews and the darker-skinned Sephardic/Arab Jews is well-known. But others, who often see the Israeli population as fairly monolithic - in terms of rights and entitlements, if not diversity - are not aware of this very important distinction, which is reflected in the very different treatment meted out to those belonging to each of the groups.

Now to this book. It is 1951 and the Babylonian Jews of Iraq have been told in no uncertain terms that they are no longer welcome in their country of origin. Instead, they have one year in which to leave and relocate in the "Promised Land" of Israel.

However, 12 year old Salman Shasha is in denial. He loves speaking Arabic, living in his home city of Baghdad, and enjoying his secret swims in the river Tigris. Salman dreams of winning Olympic gold for Iraq by emulating his hero Johnny Weissmuller, hero of the Tarzan movies.

Instead, the entire Shasha family must move to Israel, where they end up living in unpleasant circumstances in a refugee camp that is very far from the land of milk and honey that they were promised by the Zionists.

Salman's cousin Latif adapts quickly and chooses to become "Roni". He is a wonderful character in the story, and epitomises the entrepreneurial spirit for which so many Jews have been reviled as much as they have been envied through the ages.

To make matters worse for him, Salman - who must adopt the Hebrew name of Shimon, as Roni does - soon finds out that the mostly professional Iraqi Jewish arrivals are seen as only fit to work as labourers in Israel, where the Ashkenazi Jews rule the roost...

The story is compelling, and readers will find themselves totally immersed in Salman's world from start to finish. What he must give up, and how he adapts to his changed circumstances, makes for a fascinating read.

The book also teaches some important lessons about the value of empathy through characters like Ilana, as well ah compassion towards others, as exemplified by concentration camp survivor Yizhak. Highly recommended.

Was this review helpful?