Member Reviews

*thank you to NetGalley and Lake Union Publishing for a copy of this eARC in exchange for my review*

I didn’t know that historical fiction could feel like this. Amy Harmon’s storytelling ability is so seamless that it doesn’t even feel like reading. Is there anything better than a book that drenches you in the plot without making you feel lost? I was swept away by vivid characters and realistic settings that made me feel like I was really there.

Noble Salt. Butch Cassidy. Robert LeRoy Parker. What a man. He makes me think of that quote from Anne of the Island by L.M. Montgomery—“I wouldn't want to marry anybody who was wicked, but I think I'd like it if he could be wicked and wouldn’t.” Even with his checkered past as the outlaw leader of the Wild Bunch, here we see him as a man who truly wishes to be good, knowing that he can’t outrun his wrongdoings.

This beautiful fictionalization of Butch Cassidy’s love life is full of adventure and hope. I absolutely loved Jane Toussaint. In fact, I almost always love a prickly female protagonist because sometimes we (the prickly ones) need reminding that we can be loved in spite of and even because of our barbs.

Augustus Toussaint rounds out our little trio of main characters as the perfect little gentlemen. Too smart for his own good, he is a beacon of hope and joy in this story—his innocence and charm winning over everyone he meets.

This brilliant story had some incredible twists and turns. The timeline threw me off a little at first, but was overall really nice. One night when I was about halfway through, I suddenly realized how the book was going to end, and that was a little disappointing because I’m not the kind of person who guesses at the endings. But the ending itself was not disappointing—honestly, it was just very emotional. And I loved it.

What Harmon did here was weave us a story about two realistically unhappy people finding love in an unlikely way. This was my first Amy Harmon book, and I cannot wait to read more! Absolutely stunning. A new favorite.

Was this review helpful?

I could write that I am surprised how good this book is, how emotional, how extraordinary, exciting, and thrilling.
But I won't write all that :-) because when it comes to a book by Amy Harmon, it's always phenomenal.
I swear she can only write amazing books.
Her books leave such a lasting impression.
You always have to think about her stories long after you have finished her books.

If you are a fan of historical fiction, then this book, and all of Amy Harmon's books, is a must-read for you. I love all her books.

This book is a story about the Wild West and about the famous Butch Cassidy.

An incredible, fascinating and thickly real-fact-filled story about his life and his adventures.
It's also a fascinating story about the love of his life.
A very unique, exciting and emotional love story.

I seem to be going through a chaos of emotions with my books lately.
This book is a rollercoaster of brutal and heartbreaking, but also heartwarming feelings.
In other words, I cried like a baby again! 

This is such a beautiful book.
It's incredibly fascinating and uniquely written.
The story and the writing style will take you back to the times of The Wild Bunch and Butch Cassidy.
You will experience so many brutal, raw and authentic emotions.
You will experience so many mixed feelings while reading this book.
You will love and hate this story.

By the end, you will wish the beautiful book had never ended.

Was this review helpful?

This is my new favorite Amy Harmon book. I was absolutely obsessed with this book and I am always amazed at how well Amy researches her characters and time periods. She researched Butch Cassidy and all the legends surrounding his life and death and wove them expertly into her story. I always enjoy reading her author’s note and getting a little peek into her thought process and what drove her story-writing process.

I grew up in Southern Utah and grew up hearing the legends and tales of Butch Cassidy and the Sundance kid. This book absolutely renewed my interest in the outlaw and his history. I was researching Butch Cassidy and the Wild Bunch alongside reading this book. I was so fascinated with the American old west time period.

Amy wrote such a beautiful story about a morally gray man who was absolutely an outlaw, but also seemed to have a bit of a moral compass , albeit a bit shaky one. I loved how deeply he loved in this book. His love for Jane and Gus was so beautiful and heart-warming.

I loved this book so much and was crying by the end of it. So beautiful and complex and just so well-done!

Was this review helpful?

Prepare to be captivated by 'The Outlaw Noble Salt' – a riveting tale that seamlessly blends adventure, intrigue, and a dash of romance. Author Amy Harmon’s vivid prose transports readers to a richly imagined world filled with daring escapades and unforgettable characters. From the fearless outlaw navigating treacherous landscapes determined to defy tyranny, every page brims with excitement and suspense. But it's not just the action that makes this book shine – at its core, 'The Outlaw Noble Salt' is a story about friendship, loyalty, and the resilience of the human spirit. With its clever twists and turns, this novel is sure to keep readers on the edge of their seats until the very end. An absolute must-read for fans of epic adventures!

Was this review helpful?

Nicely written and engaging tale that was not what I expected. I almost passed this one by but I'm glad I didn't. Yes there's imagined history for Butch etc but it's nice to see a fleshed out character. Thanks to Netgalley for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Wow! This was my first Amy Harmon book and I really liked it. Lots of fiction intermingled with the historical side, and I’m not normally a historical fiction girlie but I really enjoyed it all. The characters were complex (even the side characters) and the storyline was interesting.

My only complaint is that the plot moved along pretty slow; I found I was skimming some portions. But overall, definitely worth reading.

Ending was so good! 👏🏼

Was this review helpful?

I love Amy Harmon’s writing. Her stories are always a rip-roaring adventure filled with heart, humor, and enough twists and turns to keep you hooked until the very end and Outlaw Noble Salt wasn’t any different and I ABSOLUTELY LOVED IT!

Now, we all know the legend of Butch Cassidy, the infamous outlaw who terrorized the West with his band of outlaws, the 'Wild Bunch.' But what if there's more to the story than meets the eye?

So in this rendition, Butch Cassidy isn't just a hardened criminal. He's a man trapped in a life of his chosen, struggling to find redemption in a world that's stacked against him. When he crosses paths with Jane Touissant, an opera singer with a very fierce spirit, he sees a kindred soul—a good woman caught in the web of unfortunate circumstances. What ensues is a romance sizzling with heat and chemistry and tender moments that made my heart swoon.

But as much as I loved Jane and Noble Salt, Jane's son, Gus is the heart of the story. Now that kid is something else. He's got this way of seeing the world that's both innocent and wise beyond his years. His curiosity knows no bounds, and his adorableness is off the charts. He just added a whole new dimension to Noble and Jane's adventures, turning them into a somewhat makeshift family on the run.

Overall, this was a story of redemption filled with depth and emotion. Amy Harmon really weaves a tale of longing and connection that'll leave you breathless, rooting for Butch, Jane and Gus’s adventures every step of the way.

Thank you to Lake Union Publishing and NetGalley for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

In The Outlaw Noble Salt, Amy Harmon whisks readers away on a thrilling journey through the American West and beyond, weaving a tale of risk, redemption, and love that grabs hold from the get-go.

Right off the bat, Harmon's storytelling hooks you in with its perfect mix of suspense and heart. We follow Butch Cassidy, the legendary outlaw, as he grapples with his past and tries to carve out a new future. When he crosses paths with Jane Touissant, a renowned singer, their lives become intertwined in ways they never imagined.

“I call you honey because that’s the way you make me feel. Soft and warm and golden.”

What really makes The Outlaw Noble Salt shine is Harmon's knack for creating characters you can't help but root for. Butch and Jane are compelling on their own, but the side characters add depth and richness to the story, making it all the more immersive.

As Butch and Jane's journey unfolds, there are twists and turns aplenty, keeping you guessing until the very end. And let me tell you, that ending? It's unexpected and bittersweet, hitting you right in the feels.

“I love you. Always have. From the moment I saw you, you owned me.”

In the end, The Outlaw Noble Salt is a gripping and beautifully crafted novel that seamlessly blends romance, adventure, and historical fiction. Amy Harmon once again proves she's a master storyteller, leaving readers captivated until the last page. Whether you're a fan of the Wild West or just love a good love story, this book is a must-read.

Was this review helpful?

Amy Harmon is a gem!!!!

This historical fiction of Butch Cassidy is thought provoking, emotionally charged, and adventurous. I love how as a reader I felt as if I was right there with the characters living this. The Outlaw Noble Salt is a must read !!

Was this review helpful?

Excellent as always! This story was a slow burn that pulled me in and chugged along. It was very well done. Thanks to the publisher for the review copy all opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

"Do you know my name? Perhaps you should forget it I'm a wanted man.".

"The Outlaw Noble Salt" was a step out of the normal romance books I choose to read. To say it was a pleasant surprise would be an understatement. Amy Harmon pulls you into the world of the wild west and a slow burning love story of the most famous of the outlaws, Butch Cassidy. You can feel the dust under your feet in the flat of Utah and smell the patisserie in the streets of Paris.

All Butch Cassidy wanted to do was turn away from the troubles his youth. The criminal world he lived in continued to pull him back as he tried to shake off the friends and family and escape that life.

"I'm tired. I want to be left alone, and I'd like to have a different life than the one I've lived. It's a new century. When I was a child, I spoke as a child, I understood as a child, I thought as a child. Now that I have become an adult, I have put away childish things."

Until, he had a chance encounter with a young mother and famous singer, Jane Toussaint. The encounter with Noble Salt (aka Butch Cassidy) was short but very memorable and one they would remember when reunited years later.

Their paths crossed once more six years later in the streets of Paris as the songbird was looking for security for her American tour. She knew Noble Salt -Butch Cassidy's past, but chose him regardless, knowing that despite what the world said he was a good man. The close quarters of travel to America and the longing that Butch felt for her from the time he heard her sing years ago brought a protectiveness for her that was leading to love. He had thought of her many times over the years.

"Tell me you love me. Even if it's not the truth. I'll cherish the lie."

This fictional story of "The Outlaw Noble Salt" was heartbreaking, full of hope and a beautiful story of find ourselves and each other right where we are. There are characters that you want to hate, but love. And, there are characters that you relate to at a core level. Amy Harmon has written some amazing books and this one now lands at the top of the list for me.

Was this review helpful?

A historical fiction based on what romantics would have hoped had happened to Butch Cassidy after he gave up his bad boy ways... Full of adventure, romance, loveable characters (yes, even the bad guys), and historical charm. I loved this one and couldn't put it down.

This is my first read by Amy Harmon and I can't wait to check out her backlog... one of the perks of finding a new-to-you favorite when they've been writing hits for years!

Was this review helpful?

Growing up, I had heard the legend of Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid but I had never given much thought to their lives beyond the crimes they committed as outlaws in the Wild West. Amy Harmon humanizes the outlaws in this story and gives them purpose. Butch Cassidy, wanting to leave his outlaw reputation behind him, takes on the name Noble Salt and is hired to protect opera singer Jane Toussaint and her son Augustus. Butch/Noble is immediately enamored with Jane and Jane with Noble but in the end he realizes he cannot outrun his outlaw reputation and he must save Jane even if he cannot save himself.

Overall, this is another great read from Amy Harmon. I say that about all of her books but it is true. She is one of the most consistent authors for me. I know I can always count on a gripping and emotional story from her and she always delivers.

Was this review helpful?

Another beautiful book by Amy Harmon. I admit I'm not a big Western fan but this blew all my misgivings out of the water!
Jane is a perfect foil for Noble. "No, I call you honey because that's the way you make me feel. Soft and warm and golden." Sigh.
"You opened me up," he whispered to his sleeping wife. "And took my heart from my chest. Now how will I live?" Thank you for making Butch Cassidy a real person to me and not just a person in history books.
"Nobody really knew what was right or wrong in these matters. The wrestle between what was fair and what was lawful , what was merciful and what was good was a universal one. He couldn't unravel it himself half the time." I will definitely recommend this book to any historical fiction lover!! Thank you to netgalley for the book to read and review. I enjoyed every minute of it!!

Was this review helpful?

Amy Harmon never disappoints and I loved her latest, The Outlaw Noble Salt! It had me hooked from the first page until the last. It is well researched and very descriptive making me feel like I was inside the book. Definitely recommend for another classic Amy Harmon novel!

Thank you to netgalley for the arc in exchange of an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I first discovered Amy Harmon last year when I read Where the Lost Wander and she instantly became a repeat author for me. Im working my way through her backlist titles and was so pleased to be given a copy of Noble Salt! I love how Harmon weaves history with fiction, and this story was no different. I love her portrayal of Butch Cassidy, the writing was beautiful, and the love story was so expertly weaved in and laid out. I will forever look forward to any books by Harmon and recommend them to anyone that will listen.

Was this review helpful?

I really liked this! I didn’t know much about Butch Cassidy besides he was an outlaw and even though most of this is fiction I really loved the character Amy gave him. I loved that he found a love story and that he could change. I loved the little boy and their relationship. I loved their travels and the adventure of it all.

Was this review helpful?

I had never read an Amy Harmon book. I know she has a great fan base so I decided to give this one a try. I probably should have went with another of her books .
For some reason, the book did not capture my attention. It seemed to drag for the longest time. For a book about an outlaw that was rather puzzling to me.
My other main issue was the character of Jane. She was just overwhelmingly annoying to me. Definitely a cactus.
I think if you enjoy historical fiction that isn’t super fast paced this might be a good book for you.
I received an ARC of this book, all opinions are my own

Was this review helpful?

Such a fun read. I love the liberty that Amy harmon took with these characters and so much knowledge was included as well! You can tell that this novel was important to her as she stated in the acknowledgements some ways that it touched her life. Such a deep wonderful romance!

Was this review helpful?

Amy Harmon's latest novel, The Outlaw Noble Salt, offers readers a look at a well known wild west legend with a fictionalized twist. The book asks whether or not an outlaw can truly leave his past behind, even for love. The main characters all have something to escape, and form their own band of outsiders. The novel also questions the idea of identity and how the characters really see themselves versus how the world views them.

Robert LeRoy Parker claimed fame as outlaw Butch Cassidy. Cassidy never really took to criminal life and stole only as a means of survival. In the novel, while visiting New York City, Cassidy watches singer Jane Toussant perform an old Scotch ballad his mother sang to him. After going backstage to speak to her he is mistaken for the doctor sent to look at her ill son Augustus. Cassidy gives his name as Noble Salt. Years later Butch Cassidy, Jane Toussant, and Augustus meet each other again in Paris. Jane needs security guard and asks Noble Salt to accompany her and Gus to America.

Jane's her reputation as a diva belies her inner turmoil. She has terrible secret in her past, one that causes her tremendous shame. Jane longs to be a good mother to her son and protect him from a cruel world. Augustus bears the birthmark that leaves him open to harsh comments yet he is a bright, happy-go lucky kid. Both long for sense of normalcy - Jane wants to give a performing and Gus just wants to be a kid with family.

Butch Cassidy never truly saw himself as an outlaw, yet legend and western novels fixed that reputation to him. His alias Noble Salt evokes both aspiration and the truth - Cassidy wants to be noble and is salt of the earth, having come from a poor family. He yearns to leave his criminal pass behind him, to lead a normal quiet life. Amy Harmon imbues the real life legend Butch Cassidy with heart and soul. His past weighs heavy on his mind yet he knows he can't change the past. Instead he hopes for a future away from his outlaw life. He finds inner peace in protecting Gus and Jane. He becomes Noble Salt, maybe the man he was always meant to be.

Was this review helpful?