“There ain’t a lot of mercy in the world. And even fewer second chances.”

I am overwhelmed with emotions right now. This is not just a story, this an experience. It’s a journey of hope and love and repentance.

“We make our own hell, and we make hell for the people we love with our poor choices.”

Amy Harmon has a beautiful way of storytelling that draws you in, keeps hold of you, and holds you captive to the very end. Her characters are real and relatable, and you want to know them. Noble Salt is an outlaw. He seeks redemption and peace. He is loyal and honorable and protective, and he loves with his all. When he meets Jane and Augustus, his life is forever changed, and man is it beautiful.

“Sometimes…you fall in love with someone. And it doesn’t matter if it makes sense. It doesn’t matter what they look like or what they’ve done.”

This story is written beautifully and with such vivid detail that it plays out before your eyes. Watching Noble with Augustus melted my heart. They have such a beautiful bond. The way Noble cherishes and safeguards Jane and Augustus made my heart break wondering if there was ever going to be a way for them to be together. This is a story of contrition, of wanting to right past wrongs, of wanting to do good by others. It’s a story of sacrifice, of hope, and of an immense love you feel deep within. My heart ached, I swooned, I hoped, and I absolutely loved this story!

“Some people are just ours.”

I’m an Amy Harmon fan and I really enjoyed this one!
The infamous Butch Cassidy meets and becomes enamored with famous singer Jane Toussaint and her young son Augustus. He meets them again by chance years later. Jane hires him as her bodyguard as they travel from France back to the US for her tour. Things with Jane and Augustus aren’t entirely what they seem, and the job is bigger than he ever realized.

Amy Harmon’s books are always so beautifully written and well-researched. I did feel like this one was a bit slow for my taste, but the ending made it worth it.

Thank you to NetGalley and Lake Union Publishing for this e-ARC!

Butch Cassidy is at a point in his life that he is dissatisfied with running from the law and, instead, longs for a more honest living. He discovers Jane Toussant singing on stage and is instantly touched by her voice and her beauty. When she mistakes him for Dr. Noble Salt, who was called to care for her sick son, Butch plays along with the mistaken identity and manages to successfully help the boy due to his experience nursing his many siblings. A few years later, they meet by chance and Jane instantly proposes that he work as her bodyguard on her tour through America. He accepts.

This novel took the real-life, infamous Butch Cassidy and gave him an alternate history, showing a side of him that was admirable and honest. Most of this story was invented by Amy Harmon but everything felt plausible and I found myself drawn into Butch and Jane’s world. Harmon’s version of Cassidy was, deep down, a caring person who had been a big brother to so many siblings and regretted leaving home and never seeing his mother again. The loveable characters, some of whom were other famous outlaws, pulled me in. The historical aspects revealed in their tale were also engaging.

Harmon is an awesome author. I’ve read most of her novels. They are mostly very different from each other and display a variety of genres with a variety of settings and time periods. But they are all populated with terrific people who must rise above their circumstances. And they all include terrific love stories that warm my heart. This one is no different. I thought it was brave of Harmon to take on a legendary character and make him her own.

Thank you to NetGalley for giving me early access to this novel in exchange for an honest review. This novel will be released on April 9, 2024.

4.75 gunslinger stars

The Wild West has been romanticized along with the stories of Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid. But what if Butch Cassidy decided to walk away from his life of crime for the love of a woman?

A chance encounter in New York sets up Butch to hear noted singer Jane Touissant sing on the stage. The woman and her singing enchant him. Butch is mistaken backstage for a doctor, and so another alternate identity is created. This time, Dr. Noble Salt. Butch treats Jane’s ill son and departs again the next day.

As fate would have it, the pair meet again in Paris years later. Jane invites Butch to serve as her security for her upcoming tour. Butch does yearn to return to the US to see his parents again in Utah, but he’s a wanted man there. He gives in to the temptation and agrees to accompany Jane and her son Gus (a fantastic character in his own right) on an ocean liner to New York. This unlikely pairing eventually turns into a romantic situation.

As both Jane and Butch’s past catch up to them, we also get a glimpse of the Wild Bunch and what the times were like.

This author does a fantastic job of creating a historical time and place for her stories. I was completely drawn into this one, and I loved the story of a reformed Butch Cassidy. Plus, the ending was picture-perfect!

A vivid and hauntingly realistic story of the turbulent, tragic, and and at times violent life of Butch Cassidy as he navigates the final years of his life. It was so vivid and real that I desperate wanted it to all be true.
Noble Salt may have been a fake name, given to a woman and her young son at a time when he was leaving all of his past behind him, but it became something he could not escape. The singer entranced him from the very first moment she opened her mouth and sang, the way she loved her boy, and the heartbreaking way she seemed to expect pain and hurt from men, and not a simple kindness. When a chance encounter years later finds them bumping into again, fate seems to be whispering, but what he does not know. It sets them on a course that will change all of their lives in ways they never could have imagined.
Love blossoms in the most unlikely places and lasts a lifetime, even when we are apart.
It was a beautiful, heartbreaking story that stole my heart, broke it in pieces over and over again, and had me in tears.
I loved all of the characters, even the ones I probably shouldn't, and I wanted better for all of them. Why isn't it all true???!!!

I am an Amy Harmon fan. And I will forever be here for what she writes. (Still working on that backlist, though) The Outlaw Noble Salt was such a fun story about the infamous Butch Cassidy, his brother, and the Sundance Kid. This was such a fun twist on his story, and I was obsessed with what happened next for him. Amy Harmon made Butch a person that you could not help but root for, and who doesn't love an outlaw getting a love story? I was constantly googling real facts of the Wild Bunch while reading, and I absolutely love when books have me deep diving. If you're a historical fiction fan and want more of the Wild West get this on your TBR, stat. Thank you, thank you to Netgalley and Lake Union Publishing for the advanced digital copy!

This was such a unique historical fiction, as all of Amy Harmon's novels are. Although not my favorite of hers, it was a solid 4 star book. What brought it down slightly for me was the slow beginning. I didn't feel invested in the characters until at least the halfway point. For a character-driven book, I want to really love and feel for them, and I just didn't get there until the later part of the book. It was certainly fun learning more about Butch the outlaw!

Beautiful story about self-sacrificing love and redemption. It was emotional, endearing and hopeful. I loved how the story looked at an outlaw, or villain, and painted him into a real-life, relatable character that you ended up wanting to root for despite his past. It blended the original story of Butch Cassidy and the dichotomy that was underlying in history - villain, yes, massive flaws and bad choices, of course, but also with a compassionate and some Robin Hood-like behavior that made him more understandable. His emotion and Jane’s were very well conveyed and written.

I loved how Amy was able to translate so well that often our choices and reasoning and love are more grey than black and white. Good and bad are often less clear than we want them to be and people are complicated. It made Noble/Butch feel relatable and genuine. It allows for redemption and forgiveness instead of judgement and vengeance.

While a lot of the real Butch Cassidy remains a mystery, more and more sources are showing he likely didn’t die as one of the men in that shoot out, which allows for the what-ifs. In some ways, I wish the main chat in the book was a generic outlaw rather than a blending of fact and fiction so my brain didn’t keep warring with that, but the story Amy paints was beautiful nonetheless and I thoroughly enjoyed it.

Thanks to Netgalley for an advanced copy of this book. All opinions are mine.

I finished this book a few days ago but I am still not sure how to put my feelings into words. The story is beautiful, the characters captured my heart and I just loved it so much. I feel forever grateful to have read an ARC.

Outlaw Noble Salt tells a story of how American’s infamous outlaw Butch Cassidy fell in love. It’s a story of hope and redemption, it’s protecting those you love and taking risks, it’s about love. This is my first book by Amy Harmon and I am not sure why because I loved the story telling and writing style. I love Jane, Noble, and Gus with all my heart, Van and Harry too. And of course I loved the slow burn romance. I felt so many emotions while reading, I cried and I smiled. I highly recommend everyone reads this book.

As always, Amy Harmon is such a gifted writer. She out did herself on her descriptions, making the time period come alive vividly. I absolutely loved the alternative interpretation of Robert LeRoy (Butch Cassidy/Noble Salt) and enjoyed it overall.

I did feel like the story progressed rather slowly. About 60% in, they are just getting off the boat from Paris to the US. The pacing felt off, especially regarding the relationship between Jane and Noble. Jane's character felt like an extreme hyperbole of a cactus (literally is referred to as one in the text) and Noble felt very flat as a character overall. I didn't "believe" their relationship- but I feel like this was due to how I perceived the pacing of the story overall.

That being said, I would recommend this book to anyone. Three stars for me is that I liked it okay, but would recommend to others so they could form their own opinion. As always, if Harmon writes it, I will read it!

Thank you to #NetGalley for an ARC of this book!

The Outlaw Noble Salt by Amy Harmon

It was so easy to get caught up in this story of a real life outlaw with many names. Briefly, I couldn't help picturing the actors in the famous movie about Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid but it didn't take long for this story to overshadow my memories of that movie because this Butch Cassidy seems so real. Amy Harmon blends what is really known about Butch Cassidy, what is rumored about him and those he dealt with in his life, and her own creative variation she gives to his life that I can't help wishing played out more like this book.

In this story, Butch Cassidy becomes Noble Salt, he wants to be Noble Salt and not Robert LeRoy Parker (his real name) or any of the aliases he took throughout his career of crime. Although he first justified his crimes in a sort of Robin Hood-ish way, Butch Cassidy became very disillusioned with his criminal past and wanted to shed that life and follow a straight path into the future. Even though he hadn't killed anyone, too many lives had been lost at the hands of those he ran with and led, too many of those he rode with were dead or locked up, and he couldn't get away from some of the men who still wanted him to be the Butch Cassidy who could carry off a train robbery or fix things that went awry.

Being a wanted man was no way to live when Cassidy couldn't visit his beloved mother, his harsh father, or his many siblings. Not to mention his brother Van idolized all he did and wanted to emulate him without having the smarts to keep out of trouble or not make everything worse. Between Van and the Sundance Kid, Cassidy wasn't sure which one he hated more but he knew he didn't want to see either one of them again. Doing so would just keep him on a path of crime and never allow him to make amends.

Then Butch briefly meets beautiful songbird, Jane Touissant and her precocious son, Augustus, and Butch Cassidy becomes Noble Salt, a name he clings to for years, as he can't let go of his memories of Jane. Then he meets her again and Butch knows he'll do anything to keep Jane and he son safe. This story is like a fairy tale where you know the ending (if you know Butch Cassidy's story) but you can't help wanting things to end differently, they just have to end differently. Harmon does a wonderful job with the people inhabiting her story, and my heart broke for those who were dealt horrible hands but still had to get through each day. This is an insight into history, into an alternative reality, and into compassion and love despite a man who is on a path of destruction that had already been sown well before he meets Jane and her son.

So much is packed into this story that I'll be thinking of it for a long time to come. It's another one that has sent me researching many of the real life names mentioned and events associated with those people. I really like how Harmon intertwines rumors about Butch Cassidy into this story, as if maybe some of the things that happen in this story might have really happened. History can be fuzzy and we'll never know the truth but we can wonder when all the facts of so long ago aren't really known.

Thank you to Lake Union Publishing and NetGalley for this ARC.

It's no secret that I consider Amy Harmon to be one of my absolute favorite authors, and I've read and loved every single one of her books that have been published so far. I added The Outlaw Noble Salt even before I read the blurb, and then I discovered what it was about and I became even more excited to read this newest story. I loved the sound of the American West setting and the outlaw Butch Cassidy trying to go straight, and I've been dying to read it ever since it appeared on my kindle. I decided to save it for a special occasion though, as it has become a tradition to start a book by a favorite author on my birthday each year... And I couldn't have wished for a better story to celebrate. It's another fantastic piece of historical romance!

Butch Cassidy is probably one of the most famous Wild West legends, and there have been countless of stories and movies made about him and the rest of the gang. The Outlaw Noble Salt is not an exact representation of what is known about his life, but instead sprinkles some facts in with the fictional encounter between Butch (aka Noble Salt) and singer Jane Touissant. If you are trying to learn more about the outlaw himself, this might not be the book for you... But if you enjoy stories about second chances, trying to do better and a little romance and adventure thrown in, The Outlaw Noble Salt will most likely charm your socks off.

This story starts out slower than expected, and I admit it took me a little while to get a proper feel for the plot. I think this had a lot to do with this slower pace and the fact that I simply had to get to know the characters better first... Because while a lot is happening along the way, there is a lot of focus on the character development and growth as well. And boy, does Amy Harmon create the most wonderful characters! Noble Salt is basically your perfect flawed anti-hero, and I simply loved spending time with him. Gus is likewise such a fantastic character, and both Noble and Gus are two of the main reasons this story works so well. They will win over your heart in record time! Jane made less of an impression on me, although I can't deny I did feel for her with everything she has been through in life... But Noble and Gus are the true stars of the show.

Like I said before, The Outlaw Noble Salt is only partly based on the life of the real Butch Cassidy, but I personally liked how the facts were incorporated with the fiction. It's definitely made me do a little research on his life, and it was fun to spot the similarities. The romance itself is really well done; proper slowburn with a realistic and growing connection along the way... Although I loved the connection between Gus and Noble even more. There is a lot of travel included in the plot, and I really enjoyed what the different scenes added to story as well. A little warning is in place for more serious topics including rape, murder, violence, miscarriage and bullying.

I might be a bit biased because I tend to adore everything Amy Harmon writes, but if you enjoy historical romance you simply can't miss The Outlaw Noble Salt. It might not have been my absolute favorite out of the 20! titles published so far, but it is still a beautifully rendered Wild West adventure slash historical romance.

Oh, my heart. Amy Harmon did it again. Creating a story that I just cannot put down, sucked in from the very first chapter. This is a work of fiction about Butch Cassidy, but has bits and pieces of his real life. It was so much fun to imagine a different path for him, or what could have been. The story of love and loss was so beautifully written. I absolutely loved. it.

I've been reading Amy Harmon's books for awhile and was excited to get my hands on her latest. Her style lately has been to take historical people, those known and not well known and give them a new life or a different ending than the one they have. While taking factual events or traits she weaves a tale that may change their fates or at least the road to them, and ends up with a satisfying ending.

That is no different than what we find in The Outlaw Noble Salt, where the famous bad outlaw, Butch Cassidy, is given a tale of a life if he were to go "good" and live an honest life after the crimes that he had committed in the wild west. A second chance if you will, and a love story at that, one under a new name of Noble. After seeing a young woman sing opera, Noble is enamored by her voice and the two of them go on an adventure far different than one that Butch had lead before.

Weaving historical references to crimes Butch really did do, along with his brother and partners, we are set on a love story while Butch is trying to outrun his past. It shed light on his life that I didn't know anything about before, and that there really was a mystery surrounding his death that still has questions about today, leaving an opportunity to craft a story for him. Another solid read if you're looking for an alternate ending for a historical person.

Thank you NetGalley and Lake Union Publishing for an opportunity to read an eARC of this book!

Butch Cassidy REIMAGINED with a love story! Now THAT's a great twist on an old classic! I love when I read a book that is based on a real person surrounded by actual events. It's my favorite way to get a little dose of history, and Amy Harmon is the QUEEN of this concept! She easily sweeps you into that time period, and writes so eloquently, that you can vividly picture the characters and scenery.

I absolutely fell in love with Butch Cassidy/Noble Salt, but calling him a book boyfriend does't do him justice. He felt so much more REAL. A man who made some bad choices, who was flawed, but never stopped trying to be the best person he could be. He was loyal and kind, smart and humble, loving and thoughtful. Jane Touissant is the lucky lady who is the recipient of all those amazing qualities. Jane is a very layered character who is a survivor and thriver as a famous singer. Her son, Augustus, is one of the best side characters with his innocence, big heart, and voracious appetite. Two other side characters are a little like Bert and Ernie. Contrary Harry and Rip Van Winkle. Both love Butch in their own way, but have a not-so-helpful way of showing it at times.

I thoroughly enjoyed this novel as I wrapped it up with tears in my eyes, and continue to think about it. Wisdom, love, heartbreak, and adventure. Yes, I think I will read it all over again.

I always take longer to write a review on Amy Harmon’s work because I feel she pours her heart into her words, and what kind of review of my words can do that any justice? So this time, my review is a hokku. Why? For the characters, of course. When you read The Outlaw Noble Salt, you’ll understand. I’ll also simply say, preorder this book. Pick up any Harmon book. You’ll fall in love.

Spoiler free review:
An American Legend
gets a second chance.

Gorgeous, lyrical.
Beautiful storytelling.
Noble characters.

How does she do it?
Another Harmon classic.
Never stop writing.

Reasons to read:
-incredibly written characters
- Complex themes
- Lyrical writing
- Romance with Depth
- heartbreaking and hopeful plot

My Thoughts:

Amy Harmon captures the tragic but thrilling spirit of the Wild West in her latest novel, The Outlaw Nobel Salt.

Famed outlaw, Butch Cassidy was a genuine historical figure. A legend born during a turbulent time in American history. I so loved the way that Amy Harmon chose to portray him in Noble Salt, as I will refer to him from this point on. He embodied the name he adopted in this story, a character that, while famous for his crimes, held high morals and abided by a set of principles he carried close. I thoroughly enjoyed the many uses of poetry, or haiku, throughout the story as it added insight into Noble’s character, expressing the emotions and revealing a complex story underneath the calm and collected personality he portrayed.

The side characters, and female lead, Jane, were memorable and influential on the plot. They were pinnacle to the growth of Noble, and wonderfully complex - done to the distable villain. I was invested in the outcomes of each character's life and was not disappointed. The romance between Noble Salt, and Jane developed quickly, yet held an intensity unique to them. They felt things deeply, yet hardened by life. I enjoyed the patience shown by Noble and the strong connection he developed with Jane and her young son, Gus.

There is no denying the quality of the writing found in Noble Salt. Harmon has a gift for weaving emotion into every word. Nothing is forgotten in the plot, and no scene is without meaning. I love finding the small connections she creates throughout the story, slowly lighting your mind, moment by moment for a breathtaking conclusion. I found myself loving and pitying characters who, in real life would be considered criminals and loathing others who were deemed “ good” based on their class. It was a brilliant reading experience and a reminder that not everyone is who they seem. I fell in love with those labeled as villains in history, yet loathed the others traditionally held in high esteem in society.

The Outlaw Noble Salt, for me, was more than the thrilling grit you come to expect from a Western, it was a novel with incredible depth, a love story between wounded souls, and the liberating tale of a man on the run who came to be known as Noble.

I recommend it.

****The following content guide may contain potential spoilers***

𝐂𝐨𝐧𝐭𝐞𝐧𝐭 :
Romance: Vague open door
Trigger warnings: Murder, death, strong language, rape, torture, miscarriage

*I received a complimentary copy of this book. The opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.

Thank you to netgalley and Lake Union Publishers for providing me a copy of The Outlaw Noble Salt by Amy Harmon. I have enjoyed reading Amy Harmons book and this one does not disappoint she it basically is a retelling of Butch Cassidy but with a romance twist.
I did not know anything about Butch Cassidy but the author explains about a character who wants to help others, even though he is an outlaw.

Amy Harmon always and consistently delivers fantastic stories that wrench at the heart. Her style is so captivating and she always manages to write multifaceted characters. Her writing is so good, and she's amazing at doing research. The Outlaw Noble Salt is no exception, and it leaves you wanting more stories that are so we'll-written. Highly recommend for all Amy Harmon fans, as well as anyone wanting to dig deeper into the wild west.

Thank you to NetGalley, the author, and the publisher for the eARC and for the opportunity to review this book. I am voluntarily leaving this review.

From the publisher: a sweepingly romantic tale of risk, redemption, and what happens when America’s most famous outlaw falls in love.

Where does one begin when reviewing an Amy Harmon novel? I always feel incredibly inadequate to put into words my feelings about her beautiful books, but I’ll do my best.

I’ll start by saying that these incredibly complex and well formed characters grabbed me and held on more than probably any other Harmon novel. They dug deep into my heart (even Van!!) with their struggles and striving for second chances.

The romance in this story is so tender, beautiful, and redemptive. It’s been a long time since I wanted two characters to get their happy ending as much as I wanted Noble and Jane (and Gus) to live happily ever after.

Harmon puts your heart through the wringer with this one, but… I wouldn’t want it any other way!

And in honor of these characters, here’s my haiku for this book (I hope I did it right):

Could not put it down,
a new five star Harmon book…
No one is surprised