Member Reviews

Tell is made up entirely of one-sided interview transcripts with a lady who worked as a gardener for a wealthy businessman. As the woman tries to understand her boss and what happened to him, the reader begins to form their own impression of Curtis and the people in his life.

I couldn't resist the idea of a book made mostly of interview transcripts, and this one didn't let me down. Tell is a story about storytelling, featuring a plot that propels the book but also revolves around the title's topic. We don't know what questions are being asked of the narrator, and we only have a hazy picture of who is interrogating her and why. And we never get to hear anyone else's perspective. Tell takes the idea of the untrustworthy narrator - a theme I adore - to new heights, with its reflections on the inaccuracy of memory and how different individuals see the same things. This was one of those books where I found myself rereading particular words and sections because the author brilliantly captured something. And yet, I was completely absorbed in the author's imagined universe, nearly seeing and hearing the narrator thanks to the masterfully written writing style.

Tell is one of my new favorites in the metaliterary genre. Although this book does not claim to be based on true events, the characters and locations are so lifelike that I could easily think it is. Tell lacked that extra wow-factor that makes me want to give a book five stars, but it is a wonderfully intriguing, entertaining, and clever read. I already want to reread it.

Was this review helpful?

Fairly early on in this novel, which is made up of transcripts from a series of interviews with the female gardener who previously worked for a very wealthy businessman, the central figure says: "My mother, she always used to say that you can summarise a person with just one story". As its title suggests, Tell is made up of a whole number of stories, which fail and refuse to summarise its protagonists, not least Curtis, the businessman around which everything revolves. It's a subtle book and your response to it may depend on how patient you are with its subject matter - a depiction of the dysfunctional lives of the very rich. I found the writing more compelling than the subject matter, although it did make me want to seek out other books by Jonathan Buckley. We are gradually schooled to expect the openness of the ending - ends are not fully tied, which I quite liked - but on balance, I was a little underwhelmed by Tell,

Was this review helpful?

Tell is comprised entirely of a series of one-sided interview transcripts, with a woman who worked as a gardener for a wealthy businessman. As the woman tries to make sense of her employer, and of what happened to him, the reader begins to build up their own picture of Curtis and the people in his life.

I couldn't resist the premise of a book comprised of interview transcripts, and this one didn't disappoint. Tell is a story about telling stories, with a plot that drives the book but that also revolves around the theme of its title. We don't know what questions the narrator is asked, and we only have a vague idea of who is interviewing her and why. And we never get to hear anyone else's side of the story. Tell takes the idea of the unreliable narrator - a trope I love - somewhere new, with its musings on the unreliability of memory, and the way people see the same things differently. This was one of those books where I found myself rereading certain phrases and lines, because the author just captures something so perfectly. And yet, I was also fully immersed in the fictional world of the author creates, almost able to see and hear the narrator thanks to the beautifully crafted writing style.

I love a metaliterary book, and Tell is one of my new favourites. Although this one doesn't pretend to be a true story, the characters and settings in this book are so realistic that I could easily believe it is all based on the truth. Tell didn't quite have that extra wow-factor that makes me want to give a book those elusive five stars, but this is a really interesting, engaging, and smart read. I want to reread it already.

Was this review helpful?

Very disappointed, given the award winning nature of the book. Did not remotely engage my interest. DNF halfway through.

Was this review helpful?

This was really interesting, and now what I was really expecting. The thematic work was engaging to say the least.

Was this review helpful?