Member Reviews
This is a different, slightly quirky and eminently atmospheric story! Fascinating characters and I loved the whole premise and description of the train and the journey.
What a marvellous and unusual read this was. An eco-historical-fantasy novel which is set at the end of the 19th century epic train journey across the perilous Wastelands on the Trans-Siberian Express from Beijing to Moscow. The Wastelands are a vast area of growth and mutations which are considered dangerous, but maybe there is more danger from the controllers of the train company...
The novel expertly creates a sense of dread, wonder and building tension as we follow several characters on the train. The main character is Weiwei, a girl who was adopted by the train crew and whose discovery of a stowaway presages the strange events to come. Other characters include Henry Grey, a scientist and collector who is desperate to study the Wastelands, and Marya, who is investigating a mystery connected with her late father. There are a variety of nationalities on board, with Chinese and Russian predominating as the train connects the two Empires. The historical and geographical details of the alternative Victorian era were well thought-out and seemed very real. This is Sarah Brooks' debut novel. I am wary of trying authors I haven't read before as the writing style is very important to my enjoyment of the book. I liked the style and although there was over-use of some descriptions (people are always freezing and then moving in quick succession!) I was impressed and would read more of her work.
[Review will be shared on my blog, 11th June]
A brilliant historical fantasy set on the Trans Siberian Express. I was hooked immediately what with both the characters and the story. If I could give it more than five stars I would be happy to do so. Highly recommended.
The Cautious Traveller's Guide to the Wastelands answers the question 'What if the episode of Doctor Who called 'Midnight' was a historical fantasy horror novel?' and the answer is 'it would be absolutely amazing and everyone should read it.
Sarah Brooks absolutely knocked my socks off with this book, so much so that I am vibrating with excitement for everyone I know to read the book so that I can talk their ears off about it.
The concept of the armoured, enclosed train travelling through the wastelands while passengers and crew endeavour to piece together various mysteries and preserve their own secrets is masterfully written and handled with not only beautiful writing but perfect pacing so the book never feels slow and instead chugs along steadily (please excuse my train metaphors I cannot resist).
My favourite aspect of the book as a whole was definitely the atmosphere and the general sense of threat that permeates the story, which gets juxtaposed with the opulence of some of the passengers and the sense of 'first class travel'. It creates a book that feels incredibly vibrant and clear in the mind.
I adored this book and I truly cannot believe it is Sarah Brooks' debut - my mind is blown by her talent and I will be keeping an eagle eye out for whatever she writes next.
I received a free review copy of this book from the publisher via NetGalley all opinions are my own.
This story is told from the perspectives of: Weiwei the child of the train, a woman grieving her father, a scientist eager to prove his theory and the professor. The characters are compelling although the scientist Henry Grey seemed more religious than scientific and I couldn't find much sympathy for him. Each narrative added depth to the engaging, riveting story. I enjoyed the weirdness of this story and the mystery of what's in the wastelands and what it's doing.
It reminded me of the Southern reach books by Jeff Vandermeer as they were about something taking over sections of the world but it's own story (and not as weird). It's not really like anything I've read and I enjoyed every moment.
Although I did enjoy it I did think more would happen. It seemed like there wasn't really a mystery of the wastelands only a mystery of what happened on the last crossing. It was about the people and the train more than the wastelands but it's still a good, interesting story. Think I'd happily read more about other characters on the train and more weirdness of the Wastelands.
This was delightful. A steampunk fantasy about the Trans Siberian express set in an alternative Victorian world? Yes. Yes. Yes. Where do I sign up? I loved this. Twisty, strange, magical and surprisingly tender. I absolutely loved this book. Great characters, bonkers ideas and rendered so beautifully. There was a seamless charm to the Victorian world nestled alongside a darkly troubling magical world. Splendid stuff.
When I saw pics of the influencer pack for this title, I knew it was something special. And yep, it's superb. I'm utterly obsessed with this book, I've been telling everyone about it. Sarah Brooks has created something wholly unique –twisty, mysterious, with an incredibly well-crafted cast and a world that is familiar in some ways and completely alien and terrifying in others. So imaginative, atmospheric, and captivating. Think SNOWPIERCER meets Agatha Christie, by way of Susanna Clarke... but somehow twistier? This is undoubtedly one of the best books I'll read this year.
There aren’t enough stars for this book. It is so unsettlingly strange and fantastical yet also believable and authentic, with great characters, brilliant descriptions and a story that just keeps giving. The writer is going to be huge I think. Brilliant
A wonderful, atmospheric Gothic tale.
It's the closing years of the 19th century and the Victorian world is bursting with new inventions. But in this alternate universe story, all is not what it seems. In eastern Europe there exists The Wastelands, a wilderness between Beijing and Moscow, broken only by a train line, used by the Great Trans-Siberian Express, built to carry cargo but which now transports anyone who dares to cross the Wastelands.
This is a story of dubious characters, old secrets and hidden conspiracies. And as the train makes its way across the country, the passengers find themselves fighting for survival. I'm not sure if I was expecting Murder on the Orient Express or an episode of Snowpiercer, but this book surprised me. In a good way. On the surface it's a Steampunk adventure, but below it's a commentary on Victorian hubris, Capitalism and avarice. It's a complex tale, somewhat dense in places but never less than mesmerising. There's an amount of commentary on first-world vs third-world, but not overtly preachy.
This is the author's debut novel - I'm already wondering where she goes from here. Definitely recommended for fans of Erin Morgenstern and Anna Mazzola.
Very strange and surreal but also a wonderful build-up, with every page I wanted to know more about the characters and the ‘Wastelands’
An interesting debut, with an intriguing premise and a cast of compelling characters. The plot sadly trails off a bit toward the end, but a promising new author.
Ok this was one strange book and I’m not sure how I feel. It has such a unique concept - an alternate history with a large swathe of Siberia being like a magical land and a train that risks travelling through it. We follow multiple POVs throughout the story and their travels through this mysterious land. This book was well written but I think the story was a bit too weird for me.
Stunning Immersion into another world. Steam Punk meets speculative fiction, and so very much more
I absolutely loved this, its wonderful cast of characters, its invention of a recognisable world from Victorian times, but one which also showed all the venal horrors of the vested interests of global capitalism, of greed run riot, of how we plunder the planet, and how, also some kind of hope might exist if we could only feel our connectivity to that planet, and to each other.
Beautifully written, it has just the right amount of satisfying weirdness, and a cast of characters all well delineated both recognisable and unique
I must say, closing the final page, I felt utterly bereft, and immediately would have liked to have been able to erase my memory of the book so that I could read it all again in the state of innocence and adventure a new book gives
We have a mythical Trans Siberian railway, linking Beijing and Moscow. The problem is though, that the landscape across which the train travels, back and forth, is by all accounts, dangerous, filled with odd lifeforms which might ‘infect us’ there are huge high walls/barriers/holding pens at start and end of journey ensure that nothing from ‘outside’ will contaminate those who live within the great connected cities. I thought of the horrible rhetoric of populism, of the Walls which get built to keep ‘them’ out of our place, whether these are actual physical structures or bureaucracy laced with horrible rhetoric and ideology behind it.
There is nothing heavy handed or over obvious in the way Brooks does this, she doesn’t smack you round the head with all of that. In fact, it is absolutely easy to read this as part of a sealed off adventure mystery – like a country house murder, or Murder on the Orient Express (those tropes are woven in) But I would say the ‘so much MORE than just that or this’ is in there for any reader who wants to find that.
I envy all future readers of this. I don’t think I’ve surrendered to a this kind of weird invented vibrant, real and coherent ‘new’ world since The Night Circus.
This is nothing like that, except in its glorious coherence in its own weird creation
Of course, the challenge is that inevitably the next book I read is likely to feel a little flat, as I’m still ‘infected’ by the seduction of this. Was there something from out the Wastelands somehow hidden in the pages?
Thank you, hugely, Sarah Brooks, for such glorious inventiveness. And the publisher. And Netgalley
Really interesting and sort of like Annihilation but on a train. The story was satisfyingly twisty and I really enjoyed the weirdness of the Wasteland.
This was a fantastic read, with the author building a fantastically whimsical world, with the ending becoming more chaotic and yet more beautiful. The prose was amazing, and the characters were all very developed, with their own motivations and feelings.
Thank you for the advanced copy of this book, I thoroughly enjoyed it! The train setting had an incredible atmosphere, it was grand, enchanting and mysterious. I loved getting to know the characters and their motivations for travelling on the train, and grew to care about a lot of them. My favourite thing about it was that the book is set long after the Trans-Siberian Express had been established, so it had an interesting history that was drip-fed throughout the book, which really added to the world-building.
I would recommend this book to readers who like atmospheric novels with casts of interesting characters, whether or not they are fantasy readers. The book was intelligent but accessible and I felt compelled to read on.
My one slight criticism is that there are two characters, The Professor and Henry Grey, who I thought were one person for a long time until a point in the narrative made me realise they were not. I don't think this is something that was deliberate (although I could be wrong) but it did confuse me a few times until I made the realisation. A colleague also had this issue so I think it would be helpful to have it made clear earlier as there are lots of characters to keep track of, the reader may need a little more help.
I'm grateful I got to read an advanced copy of this book and will be recommending it, I also want to say that I absolutely love the cover as well.
This is one of those titles it's really hard to review and rate, because it's not quite what I expected. I was expecting some kind of rollicking steam punk adventure/ homage to golden age detectives (and if anyone knows anything like this send it my way) but instead I read a slow book infused with magical realism with hints of steam punk, This doesn't mean I didn't enjoy it - I did - but I had to readjust my expectations throughout,
So, the premise. A wasteland full of mystery and horror across what used to be Siberia, walled in and forbidden, with only one way across, a gigantic train linking China and Russia, run by a rich and influential corporation. The train is the stuff of legends, each journey not without risk, not least because if it is ever breached then the train and all in it will be left sealed in the wasteland to avoid contaminating the rest of the world. And something did happen on the last journey, something that is only talked about in whispers and rumours, something that meant many people thought the train would never run again. But money always wins and there is too much at stake for the owners to simply shut their lucrative route down.
Beautifully written, uniquely plotted and incredibly descriptive - recommended.
loved the title of this novel and the first chapter instantly got my attention. It’s easy to imagine the luxury train carriages to look like the orient express. add this to fantasy and horrific occurrences on the journey, and the story seems set to be interesting.
I did find, however, that there is an awful lot of buiild up and explanation about what was potentially going to happen in the wasteland, but once we got up there the finale didn’t quite match the expectations that I had developed
There were some elements of the story in common with the Snowpiercer Netflix series where humanity is stuck on a constantly moving train overcoming the difficulties in the surrounding countryside in the case of the Netflix series. The issue was freezing cold, whereas in this novel there was a more supernatural difficulty with strange monstrous creatures and the ability to alter peoples brain activity in someway.
I have to admit this, I don’t usually read fantasy books and there were some elements to this story which were along these lines. For this reason, I enjoyed the more naturalistic parts of the story more than the monsters in the wastelands.
I think this book would make a great TV series which might be able to be extended with additional details about what is going on in the surrounding countryside in the wasteland. The book describes the train and its passengers so well that I can imagine the visual effect of seeing this bought to life.
I read an early copy of the book on NetGalley UK, the book is published in the UK on the 20th of June 2023 by Orion publishing group.
This review will appear on NetGalley, UK, Goodreads and my book blog bionicsarahsbooks.wordpress.con after publication it, will also appear on Amazon, UK
I absolutely loved The Cautious Traveler's Guide to The Wastelands!
It was so good and unique, It made me really struggle to put the book down as I wanted to keep going!
The writing style was beautiful so I'll definitely be checking out what the author writes next.
I loved the characters and thought they were all done really well.
I also loved how the book was a mix of genres with mystery, some steam punk elements and more!
I definitely highly recommend reading this book as it was amazing!
Thank you so much for giving me the opportunity to read this book in exchange for a review.
Thanks for the early ARC for which I will post an honest review. I was really looking forward to reading this one, it sounded interesting, complex and something completely different. Sadly it just wasn't for me. It was slow and for me never really got going, it was too bogged down in description with no real point or plot that made me want to care. I enjoyed the setting and the world created, the characters were also well thought out and developed. Others may enjoy this and I encourage you to make up your own mind, but sadly it just didn't do it for me.