Member Reviews

From the opening of this book I felt it had big promise to be like Daisy And The Six or books with that feel, hints that a epic journey was about to become sadly as the book went on the promise wasn't to be and while there was a journey it was no where epic.

Having the read the authors previous novel "careless" I wasn't sure what to expect when reading this while the premise of the book is very different a lot of the themes about childhood trauma, bad parenting, the relationships between mothers and daughters which are presented in a very different type is story this wasn't a bad thing and the writer makes some really clear important social points about mental health, the class divide and neglect.
The flashbacks to the girls childhood were heartbreaking. The author takes real care with these parts and writes them with tenderness and respect.
While on the face of the synopsis the book sounds like a complete shift from the authors previous work they are in face very alike, dark, depressing and harrowing.

Told in the first person POV via Matilda and with interview transcripts we are told the story Ingrid and her two daughters moving back and forth though the past and present. The story itself is harrowing I found the pace, tone and characters all lacked. It was very slow in parts and dragged on, in particular the present day parts. I felt though out I was waiting for a big revelation or something to happen but nothing ever did.

The book is quite depressing and leaves you feeling cheated, while I liked how the ending was a happily ever one I felt the full book lacked any nuance it was very slow and heavy going.

Am sure this will be a big success but for me there was something I couldn't connect with, be it the characters, the writing style or the plot it just didn't hit the spot for me, perhaps I was expecting a different kind of book going on the synopsis and that's why it didn't work for me

Was this review helpful?

Girls is a touching story about two sisters, Matilda and Nora, and their difficult family life.. The book is full of ups and downs, making you laugh and cry along with the characters. It's a moving tale about love, loss, and the strength to overcome tough times. A heartfelt read

Was this review helpful?

Overall I loved reading this book, especially discovering the family dynamics that brought the girls close but also apart and how these experiences can define or change us.

Was this review helpful?

Girls in the first book I have read by Kirsty Capes and I enjoyed it so much I now need to go and read her previous novels!

Girls is a novel voiced by Matilda (the eldest daughter of artist Ingrid Olsen) who tells the story of her and her sister’s lives. Their mother, who was just as well known for falling out of bars and nightclubs as her art, left the girls to mostly fend for themselves as they grew up, Karolina, their aunt, was sometimes a presence in their lives, but their absent father was based in America with his new family, Whilst trying to look after herself and her sister, Matilda had a baby - Beanie - when she was seventeen with her childhood sweetheart, Gus, who is now a successful lawyer. The story starts around the anniversary of their mother’s death as a writer is writing a biography of Ingrid which coincides with their aunt’s plans to set up an exhibition of Ingrid’s work in America.

I found this to be propulsive and compelling reading, finishing it in a few sittings. The characters felt original and Matilda’s narration was a believable voice. The whole story felt authentic and unique and provides a great read. I recently read a book on Netgalley dealing with similar themes: sisters, family, death and grief, but this outshines it completely.

Was this review helpful?

Utterly compelling reading. Girls reads like a deeper, more literary version of Daisy Jones and the Six, one that takes an unashamedly honest look at the impact of trauma on mental health and how truly dis functional families can be. At the same time there are hopeful, funny moments that lift the narrative and make this a must-read. Loved it

Was this review helpful?

Kirsty Capes is an incredibly talented, versatile author. I have read her previous two novels… Careless and Love me, Love me not which in themselves had very distinct identities, and Girls is another change of direction. A joy to find an author that will keep you guessing what she’ll write next.
Girls tells the story of two sisters, Matilda and Nora, who are the daughters of a late celebrated, successful and notorious artist. A great artist, but not a great mother. After years of little contact, the sisters are brought back together in the aftermath of their mothers death, dealing with a biographer who seems to be getting far too close for comfort, and their Aunt who wants to bring together an exhibition of their mothers work. As childhood wounds are reopened, so the healing of their relationship could begin. But both are really scarred from their childhood where they were regularly abandoned by their parents, led to fend for themselves , and those scars might just be too deep.
I laughed and I cried. I adored this family. My heart soared and it crashed. It has all the emotions, and I loved it.

Was this review helpful?