Member Reviews

An interesting novel, written well. This book is set in 1970’s, I presume as the author was familiar with profiling back then, which provides the backdrop for this story.

The characters are well rounded and the “who dunnit” kept me guessing right to the reveal, which is always a bonus.

I give this more than a measly 3 stars, as the majority have done. I enjoyed it!

Was this review helpful?

I didn't really care for this book and it was really a struggle to make it to the end. It's a slow burning mystery but it was just a little too slow for me and I often found myself losing interest. The lack of likeable characters didn't help, either.
Thanks, NetGalley, for the ARC. I just wish that I would have enjoyed it more.

Was this review helpful?

A psychological thriller set in 190s Manchester. A well written story which had me thinking of that time and how much things have changed since then, either for better or worse. Highlights working in the NHS and the ethics within that at the time. I enjoyed reading this.
Thank you to the author, publisher and Netgalley for this ARC

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Netgalley, Allison & Busby Publishers and Martine Bailey for the eArc of Sharp Scratch.

This is a great mystery/ psychological thriller set in late 80s Manchester. Having loved the music in that era, I had plenty of music filtrating through my head as I read this one! There are a lot of characters and even though they were nicely fleshed out, it did take a while to make sure I had their voices straight in my head. The plot was well written and with a great pace. Reflects the NHS and work ethics in that time very well.

3.75 rounded up to 4 for Netgalley

Was this review helpful?

Loved this book. A mix of psychological thriller and throwback to the 1980's NHS, hospitals and work culture.

Was this review helpful?

I loved the premise here: 80s Manchester, murder, young women in the music scene. However, the story never quite grabbed me: it's quite slow-moving and complicated at the start, with a lot of characters and locations. I've love the author's historical mysteries, which all immediately swept me up in the world, with characters who leapt from the page, so getting bogged down so early was a disappointment.

Was this review helpful?

Martine Bailey is a new author for me, I definitely haven’t been disappointed and will be looking out for more from Bailey.

This is a book that had me intrigued from the very title. This is a book which is very well plotted. I have found the characters very mixed in this one. This is outside of my comfort zone but I have found this completely enjoyable.

I love how Bailey writes, it becomes easy to lose yourself in the pages of this book. I found I was transported and felt as though I was watching the events of this play out in front of me.

Sharp Scratch is slower paced than I usually prefer. I have enjoyed the psychological or personality bits at the start of each chapter. This is something I’ve not come across before.

This is a book I have devoured in just one sitting with no regrets. This has been everything I hoped it would be and more. Sharp Scratch is enjoyable and entertaining. I can’t wait to read more by this author.

I have no hesitation in recommending this book. Happy publication day @martinebaileywriter @allisonandbusby

Was this review helpful?

Set in an NHS hospital in 1980s Salford and Personnel officer and single mum Lorraine Quick is juggling a busy life. As well as trying to find a comfortable home for herself and her daughter and fitting in gigs with her punk band, she is also faced with a potential killer among the short list for the newly introduced general manager role. With a newly acquired skill in psychometric testing, she tries to use this knowledge to unveil the potential killer before she herself becomes their target. The descriptions of 1980’s NHS hospitals feels authentic and I enjoyed the psychometric “test questions” at the start of each chapter. My main criticism is that the title didn’t really do the book justice.

Thank you to NetGalley, the publisher and the author for the opportunity to read and review an advance copy.

Was this review helpful?

Five candidates. One job. A killer prepared to murder their way to the top.

Salford, 1983. Lorraine Quick is a single mother, a member of a band going nowhere fast, and personnel officer at the grim Memorial Hospital.

A new general manager position is being introduced, and Lorraine's recent training in the cutting-edge science of psychometric testing will be pivotal. As the profiles start to emerge, a chilling light is cast on the candidates.

When a lethal dose of anaesthetic is deliberately substituted for a flu vaccine, and a second suspicious death quickly follows, it's clear a killer is at work in the hospital. Can Lorraine's personality tests lead her to the murderer?

A dark, twisty thriller of murder, psychology/psychopath. Mysterious but rather slow storyline. Strong FMC role. Was quite an analytical read that kept you thinking right the way through, although there was no real direction to the storyline. I wanted to not finish this book but carried on just to see how it ended

Was this review helpful?

Have no idea whether I have had an off week but reading this book has been like wading through treacle! An interesting plot, which is why I requested it to read, but I am halfway through and have no clue as to what is going on. To take four days to read a fiction book is quite a long time for me but to take four days to read only half is unheard of. I am therefore moving on to something new.

Was this review helpful?

It's a good mystery but the blurb made me think of Kind Hearts and Coronets even if there's not a lot of humour and Alec Guiness.
It's dark, twisty and a good representation of how carreer dynamics can push someone to the border and lose any moral.
I enjoyed it as it''s well plotted and well written.
Recommended.
Many thanks to the publisher for this ARC, all opinions are mine

Was this review helpful?

This was a difficult one to read. I didn't like any of the characters, although I'm not sure you're supposed to. I found it hard going and finished it feeling underwhelmed.

Was this review helpful?

'Sharp Scratch' is the debut crime novel form Martine Bailey after her series of historical novels

Set in 1980s Salford, where Lorraine Quick is a working class single mother living in a condemned council flat in the middle of a rundown part of town with her young daughter Jasmine. Lorraine works as personnel officer in Memorial Hospital, a large city establishment, and also in a punk band in her spare time. She is keen to embrace new technologies of psychometric testing to help with her role. The results of the psychometric tests will be used by senior staff to find a new hospital manager to lead the hospital in a radical new direction so she is being rushed to pass her exams in order to help the hospital out. The five department heads are all being considered for this prestigious new role; Lorraine's insights into their personality style and management traits will be a key part of the decision making.

When a key member of the hospital staff is found murdered following a routine inoculation, all five candidates are potential suspects; can Lorraine use her knowledge from the psychometric tests to find out the killer.

Each chapter starts with a psychometric question at the outset, which I enjoyed thinking about, and as you learn more about each of the five candidates, you can guess what they might have put. Its interesting to think of a time when tests like these were seen as new fangled and unwelcome as they are so common now, but the sense of distrust and disgruntlement is palpable. 'Sharp Scratch' captures the clash of old world attitudes against new approaches, both in the NHS reform and with the varying approaches of the police officers investigating the murder.

There's a real sense of time and place, with the streets and rundown town centre of Salford being brilliantly described, as well as the hospital itself. It does feel like another world, with the characters using communal pay phones to contact their friends, cooking food on a fire inside a range, as well as the working styles so remote from what we take for granted now, with endless paper records for everything that are stored all over the country. I liked the background detail of the hospital redesign being as a result of Margaret Thatcher’s decision to review the NHS and how this was meant to move the service in a more modern direction..

The book does some concentration and I actually started again after 30 pages as I was losing my way: but I’m really glad that I did, it merits the effort and attention taken to read it and is well worth sticking with.

Was this review helpful?

An interesting debut with an unusual format. Each chapter starts with a psychometric testing question and result, then the content of the following chapter has some relationship to the question. Set in Salford in 1983 the main character is personnel officer and single Mum Lorraine Quick who works in Salford Memorial Hospital and in her spare time is member of a not very successful girl band. I was an HR manager myself in 1983 so am very aware of the psychometric tools in use at that time. However, I did find reading these, before each chapter, broke up the fluidity of the story and I stopped reading them about 20% in and it was so much smoother.

Briefly, it’s the Thatcher era and the hospital has a number of internal candidates in line for the new top job being created as part of Thatcher’s vision for change in the NHS. Lorraine is expected to facilitate and mark the tests but she hasn’t completed her training yet! However, before the testing date a member of staff is killed with a lethal injection and Lorraine is convinced that one of the candidates is responsible.

This was a bit confusing at the beginning but it’s definitely worth continuing with it. Detective Sergeant Diaz is investigating the murder and he is also interested in psychometric testing which is being used effectively in criminal investigations by the FBI. The twists and turns were excellent and I changed my mind about the killer a number of times and the big reveal was a complete shock. An enjoyable read.

Was this review helpful?

DNF at 20%. I struggled to follow the plot and get into the story. I loved the way each chapter started with a psychological or personality type question. Some real signs of promise but a little slower than your typical thriller

Was this review helpful?

I am afraid I did not enjoy reading this book. I was very confused by the beginning and the actions of the main character, Lorraine. I felt the plot lacked depth in order to become understandable. It was a difficult book to read in my opinion, or perhaps I just regretably didn't engage with the characters and the plot.

Was this review helpful?

The plot of this novel is cryptic, but moves very slowly, making it a dark and twisty thriller about a psychopathic murder. I appreciated that the main character was a powerful female. was a really analytical book that had you thinking the entire time, even if the plot had no clear direction.

Was this review helpful?

I loved this murder mystery. Set in 1980’s Salford, the author took you right there with plenty of appropriate references to set the scene. These were born either of good research or personal experience. The plot was suitably tortuous, with plenty of red herrings and twists and turns. The main characters were easy to identify with and realistic. There was a love interest, but there were no rose tinted lenses here, they liked each other but it wouldn’t work out. There was plenty here to describe the state of the nhs in an inner city hospital, an institution that needed modernising but with many dedicated staff. It was interesting to see the start of psychometric testing, something that we now take for granted in many parts of industry. All in all, an enjoyable read with much to take from it.

Was this review helpful?

Dnf @ 30%
This is a very boring story. I tried reading more and actually finishing the story because I received this as an ARC, but I can't bear the boredom. It has a psychometric question every chapter and the chapter revolves around that trait.
It is the 80s and they just found out about personality tests. So the head detective in the murder case has decided to ask a suspect of the case (she's the protagonist but that doesn't mean she's not an unreliable narrator) to give all suspects a personality test and find out the killer. She is just learning about the tests in college. She is not an expert. But somehow, she's qualified to find out the killer by handing out a bunch of questions. Smart detective (insert eye roll).
At this point, I had given up on the novel. It failed to draw my attention to it so far. I didn't have high hopes for the future.

Was this review helpful?

An enjoyable hospital based thriller,for me even better as was set in the 80’s
Good characters and plot and all in all am enjoyable thriller

Was this review helpful?