Member Reviews

Padma's life is totally falling apart.
Her career is non existent, her relationship with her partner Wallace is on the skids as he is pressuring her into having kids.
Then on top of all this her younger sister Daisy needs help with her daughter Myra who is going off the rails and has ended up in hospital with alcohol poisoning.
In desperation Daisy asks Padma to basically "babysit" Myra for a few weeks at her godfather's, Hugo's house that he has been left by a relative in Harkness.
There she and Myra slowly clean up the house and bond and eventually find acceptance.
But in the throes of her dying relationship with Wallace, the situation is becoming complicated as Padma is staring to develop feelings for Hugo...
This was fantastic.
One of my fave novels I've been gifted an ARC of to review.
I adored the characters, they were flawed, were real and had true heart.
This was a novel of many social issues that get marginalised, addiction, depression, grief, loss, mental health yet also it had overtones of hope and new beginnings.
The complex and sensitive themes were addressed with delicacy, tact, empathy and were sensitively handled by the author who seemed to write with great depth and knowledge of her subject matter.
Will definitely be wanting a hard copy of this on its release.
Thank you for the complimentary ARC copy.

Was this review helpful?

What a beautiful story of family, love and self discovery. As a woman who suffers with depression and does NOT want children I really connected with the main character Padma. My nephew is my life, but no kids for me thanks!
It centres around Padma caring for her niece, but ends up as a wonderful story of her learning about herself and what she wants, no, deserves in life. A very well written book that left me thinking about how I treat myself!

Was this review helpful?

My first time reading this author, Poorna Bell, and it definitely won’t be my last.
A beautifully written novel dealing with a poignant rollercoaster of a journey for the different characters. This book was a departure from my normal genre but I loved it and would highly recommend reading it. I wanted to keep reading and not put this book down.

Was this review helpful?

Easily a 5 star read.

This year I’ve really started to enjoy books about family relationships. This book is definitely one of my favourites for the year so far. The stories were raw yet inspiring. It delays with difficult themes exceptionally well and demonstrated the different types of struggles that different family members face, yet how they can all relate to how they feel.

Depression, in its various forms, was a key part to this book. Each character struggled in their own ways but it was really heartwarming how their struggles brought them closer together as a family and they worked through it together.

I thought it was really wholesome how Padma helped Myra (her niece) to learn more about her culture. Their relationship was the best aspect of the book. I love how they connected and really built a trusting foundation with each other, especially after a rocky start.

I also loved that the book tackled starting over again. The Padma realises that the life she has isn’t what she wants and she gains the inner strength to cut off certain aspects of her life and start again. This felt truly empowering, as even though she was scared to start again, she did it anyway. She’s also quite a dry character, which helped to lift the story.

Overall, the book had a really positive outlook and it was incredibly inspiring. There are difficult themes in this book but the main message is a positive one and I 100% recommend that people give this book a read.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely loved 'This is Fine' - its a wonderfully nuanced story of sisters, mothers, nieces, daughters, wanting children, not wanting children, not knowing what you want from life or might deserve.

Padma's longterm partner Wallace wants children; Padma is fairly sure she doesn't but isn't sure how they can go forward as a couple with such a major disconnect. When Wallace suggests they have some time apart, it throws Padma's life into a spin - she lives in his house, she doesn't currently have a job, and she's not sure where her life is going.

Padma's 15 year old niece Myra is having her own issues with friendships and social pressures. When Myra's mum Daisy asks Padma to take her out of London for the summer and spend some time with her, Padma's not sure whether she's up to the job, but in the absence of any other options, she goes for it. What follows is a period of self-reflection and bonding for both of them, as Padma slowly reconnects with Myra, and through her, to her own sister Daisy.

The sisters had a hard childhood with their mother having her own issues and Padma covering for her, albeit unknowingly. They have become stuck in their ways with each other with Padma taking on a more maternal role and looking after her little sister.

I loved the emotional depths and layers to the story, it took its time to unravel the issues at the heart of the book, and gave the characters space and time to develop and grow.

Highly recommended.

Was this review helpful?

Such a beautiful, emotional story about mental health and different types of family relationships. I really love Poorna Bell's writing style--it's so thoughtful and evocative, and the descriptions made it easy to put myself in the characters' shoes. Looking forward to reading more from this author.

Was this review helpful?

This was such a relatable story. So many real issues covered in a sympathetic and understanding way.

I wasn't familiar with Poornas work, but I'd definitely read another of her books. I felt sad when this book ended. Rooting for the main character Padma as i drew some similarities with her life and mine. You find yourself hoping for her the whole way. I could have read another 300 pages of this story and still feel a bit bereft when i was done.

One of these stories where not a lot happens physically, but you watch the characters developing, and I can honestly say i loved it.

I received this copy from @netgalley

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed witnessing various family members grow and develop throughout this story. I loved the south Asian representation, particularly the descriptions of various yummy foods. It was interesting to see how the characters navigated their issues and also support each other. This book was an easy read but deep issues were raised throughout.

Was this review helpful?

Another cracking story from Poorna Bell. I adored her first novel so had high expectations of this one. I’m happy to say they were more than met.

Poorna writes with such emotional intelligence and insight that I think I could have saved myself thousands in therapy just by reading this book.

That’s not to say that there is anything preachy or judgy in the language at all.

This is the story of Padma, who’s lost her job and it seems, her long term relationship with boyfriend Wallace.
Wallace wants children, Padma really doesn’t think she does.

When Padma’s teenage niece Myra lands herself in hospital after a binge-drinking session with her underage friends, her sister Daisy asks Padma to step in and babysit Myra in a friend’s house by the seaside for the summer holidays.

High-flying Daisy and her husband have a very different lifestyle to that of Padma and their relationship is a little distant to say the least.

Over the course of the story we understand Padma and Daisy’s situations and there is a gentle exploration of the way their childhood has shaped the women they are today.

But as well as the deep understanding of the impact parents can have on their children, this story gives us the joy of Padma making new friends, bonding with Myra and continuing her cooking journey.

Throw in a hint of romance, a little danger and some rescue dogs and all in all, this is an absolutely fabulous story.

I loved it.
It’s beautifully written and strikes the perfect balance.
Another bestseller for Poorna, I’m sure.

Was this review helpful?

3.5 stars rounded up.
Thanks to #NetGalley and #RandomHouseUK #Publishers for an #ARC of #ThisIsFine.
Padma isn't fine. She gets an ultimatum from her boyfriend about having children, her niece drinks herself into a hospital trip and she has lost her job. Her sister asks her to take her niece away from London for the summer, where this book takes place.

I enjoyed this book. Damaged families, damaged relationships, mental health and addiction. It wasn't exactly an easy read but it was an enjoyable one. Following Padma try to understand her relationships all around is frustrating and satisfying all together, and there is some positivity and self-belief we could all live by.
I haven't read anything by Poorna Bell before, however I will be looking for other books by this author.

Was this review helpful?

A joyful book that is full of emotions and amazing characters. The blossoming bond between Padma and her niece Maya was beautiful to read, as was the history between Padma and her sister Daisy and their tumultuous and traumatic childhood. Themes of depression, addiction, generational trauma, and guilt run throughout the book and yet it is full of hope, joy and so much humour too. Poorna Bell's writing is so good and I am still thinking about so much in this book.

Was this review helpful?

Just like Padma's recipes, this story was the perfect mixture of salty and sweet.

Padma is a 39 year old woman who has been living with her long term boyfriend Wallace while searching for a new job. When the topic of having children comes up between them, (Padma knows she doesn't want them but Wallace does ) they decide to take a break. Then, Padma's 15 year old niece ends up in hospital so she is tasked with going to a seaside cottage for the summer to help her niece find happiness.

I adored the descriptions of food in this novel, plus the character of Myra reminded me a lot of how difficult being a teenager is and how your friends can feel like the only important thing in the world. Poorna has as a really lovely way of explaining her culture and addressing daily micro aggressions that she and other minorities face without feeling like you are being told off. It also beautifully addressed the topics of mental health and addiction that taught us that it does get better.

If you want a story that brings you joy and can make you cry I would wholeheartedly recommend This is Fine.

Was this review helpful?

My first thoughts were here we go another lightweight read – rich people having money, access to second homes, being wonderful cooks etc. However buried in the text are some wonderful insights into some may emotional situations. A vivid description of depression, how hard it is to deal with an overbearing and successful mother, the trials of being a teenager on a privileged school….
The main protagonists all have journeys to make but I enjoyed following them and their thought processes.
Yes the ending is also twee but it’s the first time for a while I’ve read a book I didn’t want to put down and wanted to stay with the characters.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley and Random House UK, Cornerstone for an ARC.

I first became aware of Poorna Bell through In Case of Emergency, her first fiction book. I rated it very much so when NetGalley granted me a copy I was very excited and started reading immediately. That was about ten hours ago. I read it in one sitting and I think it's even better than her first novel.

Padma is a 39 year old woman of Indian decent whose partner of ten years Wallace suddenly suggests a break from their relationship because she doesn't want to have kids and he does, like he could force her into it by doing so. She is also currently unemployed so when her sister Daisy and brother-in-law Henry ask her to look after their wayward 15 year old daughter Myra in a holiday cottage in Kent for six weeks during the summer holidays and get paid for it, she says yes. The cottage belongs to Hugo, a friend of the family. What follows is a lot of reflection on life while trying to get through to a depressed teenager. Padma herself also struggles with depression - it seems to lie in the family and stem from their alcoholic mother. Their childhood is frequently mentioned in her talks with her sister. The two of them struggle to connect as they remember things so differently, and Padma resents how Daisy tried to reinvent herself without acknowledging her Indian roots, even changing her name from Dharma. Padma's passion is cooking and she starts bringing her Indian dishes to the village where she makes friends quickly.

Bell's writing is so rich and so wise, I screen grabbed a few pages just for some quotes too good to forget. Padma's reluctance to have kids is brought up frequently but handled sensitively. It's really irritating how the decision to stay childfree is so often questioned in society.

Bell concentrates on the women in the story and there is very strong character development for everyone involved. The men aren't altogether too important although Wallace tries very hard to act like an arse. Thankfully even the love story isn't given great prominence and only happens at the end when Padma has regained her confidence.

What can I say, I loved the characters and the story, which is so effectively told. Myra is a typical but loveable teenager who opens up to her auntie and helps her gain followers on social media for her cooking videos.

I was sad when the book ended - I could have spent weeks with these characters as the love between the women was palpable.

Was this review helpful?

I was lucky to get this book from Netgalley.. not knowing too much about the genre or the author I started it with few expectations.
I really enjoyed it.. it’s filled with relationships, family, friendships and feelings.
A very enjoyable read.

Was this review helpful?

A wonderful book which gives a warm glow of female love and understanding.
At the start I was sceptical. It seemed a stretch that Padma was being entrusted with looking after a wayward 15 year old niece she hardly knew for the summer.
But the story developed beautifully. You could see the bond developing, in a natural and organic way, between Padma and her niece. There are several other sub plots. Padma doesn't get on very well with her ambitious and controlling sister Daisy, who seems to have turned her back on her Indian ancestry. Her boyfriend Wallace wants them to "take a break" because he's expecting Padma to conform to his wish to have children.
The topic of racism is handled sensitively. Small seaside towns like Harkness are not always the most welcoming.
I loved the friendship between Padma and Guyanese cafe owner Selina. The recipes and food were a joy and added so much to the book. I was inwardly cheering when both of them started to realise their dreams.

Was this review helpful?

Easy reading, sweet story, no big surprises but perfectly comforting nonetheless. I appreciated the opportunity to learn about south Asian culture, and the key issues of mental health, addiction and racism were handled with sensitivity. .

Was this review helpful?

Fantastic non traditional love story and tale of self discovery while dealing with mental health issues. Padma didn’t have the easiest childhood dealing with an alcoholic mother bad and absent father. On top of that she is a woman and a poc so she has to deal with all of this patriarchal society racism and sexism on top of just her own issues. It’s a story of self-descovery as she rediscovers herself and make some hard decisions for her own benefit but it also exposes a lot of issues that a lot of people have to navigate in their everyday lives. Over all, it’s a love story and I love that it is not at all traditional. Although there is romantic love and (spoiler alert) Padma does get her happy ending it is a story of all kinds of love, friendship, filial love and over all self-love. It was a fantastic tale, thank you for allowing me to read the ARC

Was this review helpful?

This was my first time reading anything by Poorna Bell and I really enjoyed it.

Padma has been in a relationship with Wallace for years, when he brings up the conversation about wanting a baby, Padma struggles with that as babies are not what she wants. Wallace asks for a break at the same time as her niece is taken into hospital. Circumstance means she is the one that looks after her over the summer.
Padma has struggled with mental health over the years and can see this happening with Myra, but they eventually get themselves into a groove.
I liked the characters and their interactions with one another.
Thank you to Poorna and Netgalley for the ARC.











This Is Fine, is certainly not what Padma's life is.
At a point in her life where things aren't going to plan, she's asked to look after her niece.

Was this review helpful?

Just an okay book! None of the story really grabbed on to me but I still enjoyed it. I’m sure this will have its own readers that will love it.

Was this review helpful?