Member Reviews

When Domino sees a piece of the moon fall from the sky, she experiences emotions she’s never known before. It was like “it contained a part of her somehow, like a shifting collection of her own dreams.” This connection is something she can’t ignore.

Domino is an orphan living in a Scientarium shut away from the rest of society. She struggles to be accepted by anyone at all. With no friends. no money and a mysterious alllergy to magic, there’s little happiness to be found. Instead, Domino looks for ways to harass the other children and fill the void she feels inside.

When there’s an opportunity to become an assistant to one of the science barons, Domino discovers a whole new life outside the Scientarium where magic and science are at war. Has Domino’s entire life been a lie? Who is she really? What is this power she possesses?

Struan Murray is master of fantasy world building. With complex social structures, ingenious characters and a feisty heroine who stands up to most threatening of creatures, this is a story you won’t want to put down.

Was this review helpful?

So many good things! Flying fortresses and dinosaurs and disasters, a hilarious heroine and a brilliant twist, all leading up to a compassionate finale.

If, like me, whenever you read a Middle Grade book you ask yourself, 'Is this a serious contender for Harry Potter's crown?' then the answer is yes. It's like HP combined with the darkly comic edginess of the Magisterium series. Domino, the heroine, is angry and self-absorbed, and this makes her growth feel nuanced and real: you root for her because of her flaws, not despite them.

Was this review helpful?

I was almost reluctant to read this book, thinking I'd be comparing it to Orphans of the Tide at every step. I was wrong and I should have known better; Struan Murray continues to demonstrate why he is a master of world building with this new book. We are immediately immersed in Domino's universe; an underdog in a world where magic is real and under threat from Science, Domino faces the kind of problems many children face (bullying, loneliness) and quite a few that they don't (spoilers!)

So many great characters, a tightly woven plot and Murray's trademark twists and turns make for a fantastic book that I will be buying for the library and pushing into the hands of every passing year 7.

Was this review helpful?

Struan Murray has done it again. A superbly crafted story in a fantastically created world. The Scientarium floats above the city, tormenting Domino, who dreams of visiting it one day, who has known nothing else but the bullying / prankster revenge and testing cycles her life consists of, thanks to the Science Barons who raise her there “to protect her from magic”. Does she really need protecting?

Once again, following the highly original and exciting Orphans of the Tide trilogy, the author has delivered with a variety of well defined characters, twists and turns, magic and mayhem, chases that have you on the edge your seat and even some dinosaurs.

Creating characters with depth and believability is a special skill and Murray has this down to a fine art. The ones that I’m particularly drawn to are those who bring indecision to my mind…which side will these characters fall on when push comes to shove? Abzalaymon, the spirit, is a deliciously contrasting character, which puts you, as the reader, on edge. Will they help Domino, Calvin and Raphael…or eat them?

A book map is always a bonus.

Thanks to NetGalley and Puffin for the eARC in exchange for this review. The book will be published on March 7th 2024

Was this review helpful?

It really doesn’t seem possible that a little under four years ago, Struan Murray’s debut title Orphans of the Tide hit the shelves. An astonishing read that went on to win the Branford Boase Award, its fantastical storyline and sublime characterisation and world building, which were repeated in the two further titles that completed the trilogy, firmly cemented the author’s reputation as an incredible writer of middle grade fiction.

When I discovered last year that there was to be a new, standalone title from him, I immediately added it to my must-read list and when it appeared on Net Galley shortly before Christmas, I requested it straight away, bumping it straight to the top of my reading pile when the New Year brought my much longed-for approval. A completely different story, it again has that amazing rich description that brings its characters and their world vividly to life and – as you would expect if you have read his other work – is packed with breathtaking twists and turns as the narrative plays out.

Floating high above the city of Abzalaymon, the roof of the enormous marble building of the Scientarium is the scene of just the latest unpleasantness between two of its inhabitants – Domino and Claudette – whose deep loathing of one another is hugely entertaining to the other children watching on. Dragged inside to face the music by Science Baron Garballous, orphan Domino is once again reminded of her place within the Scientarium and just how grateful she should be that they have taken her in not just to provide her with a home but to keep her safe.

Reminding her that she can never leave until a cure is discovered for her allergy to the city’s magic, Garballous tells Domino that she is to start work as assistant to a Science Baron who is returning from years spent abroad conducting research – a position she has earned in part by being so unpopular that she will have no friends with whom to share any news or gossip. Warning her that she is to be on her best behaviour, Garballous lets her go to attend her lessons – something that she finds horribly dull. When her teacher leaves the room for a moment to deal with something, the other children set on her and only stop their attack on her when a stranger enters the room: the newly returned Science Baron.

Before long, the new arrival creates mayhem within the Scientarium and seizing her chance to at last visit Abzalaymon, Domino flees from its stuffy laboratories and classrooms and heads to the surface below, with the Science Barons in hot pursuit. Suddenly finding herself in a city full of magic and wizards, Domino must question everything she has been taught to believe in her quest to find the truth about magic and herself. As she encounters automobiles, thunder lizards and spirits for the first time in her short life, it is clear that the Science Barons are up to something – something that involves her and something that she will need to put a stop to, to save not just herself but everything around her. Can Domino find out the secret of the mysterious Moonshard in time to prevent catastrophe and defeat her enemies before they catch up with her?

To say that Domino is a flawed character is a huge understatement. Lying comes as naturally to her as breathing and she has no hesitation in putting the most enormous effort into her elaborate schemes to seek revenge against nemesis Claudette at the start of the book. It is, however, impossible not to like her – she is quick-witted, brave and, as she gradually lets down her defences to allow in those with whom she slowly makes friends, fiercely loyal and I adored her for it.

Both the Scientarium and Abzalaymon are immaculately described, with every word that the author chooses to use done so to perfection. As we are drawn into Domino’s world, we experience it alongside her, with each discovery that she made causing my heart to race as I read on and involving me so deeply that even when I was not reading the book, it occupied an enormous number of my thoughts as I yearned to pick it back up to watch the plot unfold. With plenty of equally well-drawn secondary characters, all of whom have vital parts to play in the narrative, this is surely going to be on many readers’ best of 2024 lists, as it will be on mine.

A wonderful title for confident readers in Year 5 upwards, this will also make a brilliant read aloud, if used in class, and features some gorgeous illustrations by Vivienne To – an artist new to me, whose work I shall be keeping an eye out for in future. I absolutely loved it and cannot recommend it highly enough to those who enjoy science fiction, fantasy and stunning adventures.

As always, my enormous thanks go to Puffin books and to Net Galley for my advance, virtual read. The Secret of the Moonshard publishes 7th March and is most definitely a title to preorder.

Was this review helpful?

This is rather unique and really creative story about young girl called Domino, who has grown up in a floating laboratory called the Scientarium, run by the scientists who have been keeping her safe. Safe from what, you wonder?

Well, although wizardry has long been outlawed in Domino's world, there are known to be small pockets of magic that linger on the planet below, and Domino is so allergic to magic that she nearly died as a child. Which is why the scientists regularly take blood samples from her, ostensibly to find a cure for her affliction.

But is that really the reason why they are so interested in Domino? An unexpected encounter with a thunder lizard, a actual wizard, and young boy named Calvin is just the start of a huge adventure that has Domino questioning everything she has been told before...

This book has spectacular world-building, a unique set of very original, and in some cases lovable, characters, and more action than you can shake a stick at. Fantasy and magic story readers will love this one!

Was this review helpful?