Member Reviews
Glamorous, sticky and tense, this is the perfect summer read. I wasn’t expecting a mystery element to this book at all, however once that was introduced I wanted more from it. I found the book to be very slow paced which I didn’t think went with the mystery side of things. Had it just been a sort of literary drama, the slow more focused approach to the writing would’ve worked better. However I still very much enjoyed this book!
Teddy arrives in Rome newly married and a new life on the horizon. Her husband works in the American embassy. She starts working there cataloguing the artwork but then at a party his photographed kissing the ambassador. Can she recover? Can her marriage survive? I found it a bit too long and didn’t enjoy it that much
What a marvellous debut novel taking the reader to the glamour and sultry heat of Rome in 1969. We meet newly wed Teddy, ready to start a new life with her diplomat husband, but her past it turns out won’t stay hidden. Slowly everything begins to unravel, in this riveting tale of deception and lies. Stylish and suspenseful I love it. Thank you to Fourth Estate and Netgalley for letting me read this ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
I absolutely loved reading this book, the setting was so interesting and I love the storyline! The characters were interesting and I loved the time period it was set in! Definitely gave me the seven husbands of Evelyn Hugo vibes!!
I enjoyed Teddy, but it wasn’t quite what I expected. I thought it was going to be a sizzling summer read and while I loved so much of it - the gorgeous writing, the 1960s glamour, the backdrop of Cold War tension and descriptions of Rome itself, the hints at Hollywood corruption and the subsequent mysteries of Teddy’s past, it didn’t fully manage to win me over. The fact that the chapters are told in flashback and lead the reader up to present day revelations is effective in keeping you engaged in the story, but by the end I just felt sad for Teddy as she wades - not always successfully - through the misogyny of those around her, and I spent a lot of the book being angry on her behalf. In turn, I felt mixed emotions after the final chapter ended. I’m glad she was able to take back some autonomy, and hated what she had to go through to get there.
Overall Teddy was a thought provoking but frustrating read. A massive thank you to Netgalley and Fourth Estate for the e-ARC.
When reading “Teddy” I felt like I was transported into the romance and glamour of a 1950s Rome.
Teddy was a wonderfully complex character and the tension radiated throughout the novel. It was difficult to get into at first but stick at it!
Teddy is an intriguing and well told story set in 1960s Rome. I really enjoyed the Teddy’s character and was intrigued by her and her storyline. I was hoping for a bit more of a dramatic twist at the end although I did enjoy the plot development.
This book is well written and easy to read. I was intrigued and keen to read on to uncover the events Teddy has found herself wrapped up in.
Overall this was an enjoyable and fun read. I’m looking forward to reading more by this author in th future.
Teddy is an interesting read. The MC, whose name is given to this novel, is a person of high life. The story is set in 1969, and mainly in Texas and then Rome. Teddy's life is not what it seems.
Overall, I found the concept interesting.
Characterisation 3
Plot 3
Concept 3.5
Mood, atmosphere 4
Writing 4
Pacing 3
3.5 stars.
Emily Dunlay has written a great story set over a number of hot nights in 1960s Rome. I thought the writing was brilliant, and I felt invested in Teddy to keep reading to find out what had happened - the opening page hook (her dress covered in someone else's blood) was a great page turner. The only think I was disappointed with was [SPOILER] I expected it to have a bit more of a feminist twist that she'd been keeping something secret from everyone and that she would walk away the winner. There is a twist, but it's a bit tame, and predictable. I would have liked it to have been more linked with Teddy being an unreliable narrator and actually she was a spy - in reality she was the woman she'd been portrayed as all along.
Teddy is the story of a Texan woman from a well-connected family. It is 1969 and she makes a “late” marriage at 34, following a whirlwind courtship. Her husband, David tells her he is a minor diplomat, about to be posted to Rome. As a lover of art she envisages a life of high style and culture, but once in Rome she finds herself constrained, until the ambassador takes an interest and offers her a role in cataloguing the embassy’s collections. However this opportunity brings complications.
Teddy’s contradictions are powerfully portrayed. She is an heiress but she is always short of money. She is kept on a tight leash by her family and is prone to irrational extravagance whenever she has the opportunity. She tells us she is a beauty, but she is constantly ill at ease in her own body. She prepares excitedly for set-piece events, then feels she is all wrong - she has the shape and style of the fifties but the young women who surround her have an entirely different aesthetic. She is full of shame about her sexual history and terrified of her secrets coming out. There is also the alternating desire and disapproval she experiences from her husband and her own ambivalence to him.
That interesting duality in Teddy’s character is not seen in the secondary characters who feel more like types than rounded individuals. There’s a cold, distant mother, an aunt who went off the rails, a Reaganesque actor-turned-ambassador...I also felt there wasn’t enough plot to sustain the story so it was filled out with more wardrobe mishaps and self-sabotaging behaviour from Teddy. This became frustrating and led me to skim at times.
It’s fairly clear that Teddy’s marriage isn’t all it seems from the start – not least because the story is framed as her account of events to sinister, anonymous men from the embassy. However, it takes a long time to get there. And I struggled with Teddy’s naivety, given her upbringing and the brutal political operators in her family.
Still, it’s a well written and atmospheric read and the chance to travel to Rome (and Capri, where Teddy and David honeymoon) will make it a popular choice for holiday read.
Set mainly in Italy during the 1950’s, this is a slow-burning story which I found difficult to get through at times, but it has left me pondering at the ending, and I really cannot decide if I found this a disturbing read or a disappointing one. The setting and fashion descriptions are gloriously described and I could vividly imagine each scene, particularly towards the end as the tension develops.
The book is cleverly structured to allow the eponymously named protagonist,Teddy, to tell her story over the course of an interview with the police who are investigating a crime. There are many hooks and suggestions to build the intrigue as to why she is being interviewed, and it definitely implies that she is guilty of something heinous.
I have to confess that I found Teddy a difficult female to warm to as she often comes across as vapid, vain and shallow; however, she was a victim of her time and I couldn’t help but quietly applaud her in the end for finally making a decision for herself - come hell or high water! Teddy seeks approval and security but consistently makes the wrong decisions. I found her indecision and indolence when her husband was away quite unforgivable and really wanted to shake some sense into her. I couldn’t quite grasp her desire to please David, her husband, as there did not seem to be much love between them. Eugene is a red herring and I never quite understood his role in the story, other than to show how deceptive Teddy could be?
Something in this story did not quite work for me. I was not invested enough in Teddy to follow the intricate plotting of lies on top of lies. Did I ever get to know the true character of Teddy? She clearly had been raised to expect little from life, yet her own family had more secrets to hide than those usually found in soap operas! I felt sorry for the predicament that she found herself in and the difficulties of her financial situation, though often she does not make the best of a situation but makes things even more difficult for herself.
This is probably a read that I need to revisit. I feel like I missed the point, but I’m sure the error is all mine. This is a dark, brooding story that’s layered like an onion and as each layer is removed it is clear that there is so much more to reveal from this gritty, sordid story that is probably inspired by more truth than I really want to know about!
Completely immersive 1960’s Rome, taking in both the fashionable glamour and abhorrent sleaze being the wife of an American diplomat. Fascinating read.
Emily Dunlay transported the readers to Rome in 1969. We saw the glitz, the glam and the ugly environment of Teddy’s life after she has married David, a diplomat. Growing up with wealth, Teddy knew she was going to be something. Whether that was rich with money or rich with beauty, she knew she was going to be important. We see the parties, the sparkles, the good times but also the bad times. Teddy’s depressive states where she felt lonely and sad and this made the whole story feel real. If you’re a fan of The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo, you will definitely enjoy this one!
This book was so good! The entire cast of characters were so complex and Emily portrayed all characters so well. I really felt the emotions of Teddy when she was lonely, and as she always wanted to be someone that stood out to others it must’ve been hard having the husband she did. I was hooked immediately and although I was unsure on Teddy at first, I understood her more and felt sorry for the way she was feeling.
A fabulous book and I can’t wait to read more from Emily in the future! Definitely recommend.
This is the sort of book I love to read in the summer , it's pure escapism and a perfect beach read (especially if you are in Europe!). There's glamour, intrigue , suspense, politics, romance, it's all in there ! It's a bit of a slow burn but once yu get into the story you will be invested. I think this would make a great screen adaptation , the backdrop would be amazing ! One for the tbr if you like a glitzy easy summer vacation read
The precis of Teddy piqued my interest, the glamour of US society and Rome in the 1960’s - the anticipation of a new life for Teddy, with a chance to leave her past behind and escape. I wasn’t disappointed, Emily Dunlay’s writing is beautiful, capturing the essence of the time and places, and as the story unfolds you fall deeper in to Teddy’s life and the people around her.
Thanks to NetGalley and the publishers for allowing me to read Teddy.
This book delivers everything it promises, it brings 1960s Hollywood glamour, it brings intrigue and mystery and the summer streets of Rome provide the perfect backdrop.
From the opening chapter I was hooked and I could not put this down. I was captivated by Teddy and her story; a story which is essentially her self discovery. At the start I felt as unsure about Teddy as she felt about her new life in Rome but as the novel progressed she captured my heart and I was rooting for her.
The story centres around the real historical and cultural events of the time, including details such as the current fashion tends, which made it feel authentic. It looks at what constituted a ‘scandal’ in the 1960s and it was interesting to compare this with modern day ‘scandals’.
For me the main theme was the role of women in the 1960s and the pressures and restraints they experienced from their families, their marriages and society. Emily Dunlay brilliantly captures the claustrophobia Teddy feels in her life as well as the inner turmoil she suffers always trying to do what is expected of her rather than what she wants to do.
A bright and glamorous read with a dark underside - I loved it!
‘Teddy’ by Emily Dunlay is a powerful and interesting novel in which Dallas debutante Theodora (Teddy) Carlyle tells the story of a dramatic period in Rome as a newlywed to her diplomat husband which culminated in a night of turmoil and violence, and slowly reveals her intriguing, tragic, darkly glamorous past along the way…
I loved the immersive 1960s setting of this book, with the descriptions of Italian streets and luxurious parties transporting me to the romanticism and excitement of a summer in Rome at the height of culture. The tale was strongly rooted in its time, with key historical events shaping the narrative and the shining stars of the moment being name-dropped throughout. I also lusted after some of the fashion mentioned in the novel which provided extra sophistication.
What surprised me the most was the depth of Teddy’s character and the emotional backstory laid bare across the chapters. Teddy herself was relatable, and the book asked very interesting questions about what scandal really means and whether layers of generational trauma can really be washed away. It was an eye-opening and often sad portrait of the pressures on women in 1950s and 60s society to behave in “the right way”, with said pressure often applied by older women caught in the cycle themselves.
The author skilfully built up tension and suspense throughout the pages, sowing the seeds of mystery and creating a swirl of potential theories as to what happened on that fateful early July night. I really struggled to put the book down, such was my determination to unravel the truth.
This gets five stars from me, and I’d highly recommend to fans of Taylor Jenkins Reid’s feminist historical fiction.
I received an advance Digital Review Copy of this book from the publisher 4th Estate via NetGalley. The opinions expressed in this review are my own.
I’m praying to the streaming/tv/film gods that this is picked up and made into a film or show immediately because Teddy deserves to be on screen!! 💄 💋
This was a joy to read from start to finish and I can’t wait to reread when it’s out! I’m obsessed with Old Hollywood stories because the vibes are unmatched, Teddy did not disappoint. While Teddy isn’t set in Hollywood, it’s Hollywood adjacent. It oozed the same ✨glamour and vibes✨of the 1960s that is synonymous with the time and I ate them all up! Dazzling 🤝🏻 deception 🤩✨
This book will be everywhere this summer, and with that cover it’s easy to see why. Teddy’s cover is one of my 2024 favourites and I can’t wait to add a copy to my shelf! 💅🏻🩷 A stunning debut from Emily Dunlay, I can’t wait to see what’s next! 👀
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me with this book for free in exchange for my review! All opinions are my own.
This was a fun book and a drama filled read perfect for the beach. If you are looking for a guilty pleasure book for the summer, this is a great book to add to your TBR. I am definitely going to look out for more books by Emily Dunlay in the future!
—
Many Thanks again to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me with this book in exchange for my honest review.
********
If you are interested in seeing more of my reviews and other content feel free to connect with me here <3:
https://linktr.ee/bookreviewsbyjules (links to my Instagram, Goodreads, TikTok, Storygraph, My blog and Substack newsletter, etc)
If you are a publisher or author who has questions about my reviews (as well as questions about my stats, reach or engagement), please free to email me. I am also open to requests for book reviews from authors or publishers. Thank you again for taking time to read my review, and I hope you have a wonderful day!
I was really excited to receive a proof of this novel. It sounded right up my street, and the cover is stunning! The book promises summer sun, glamour, sizzle, and scandal, and it certainly delivers on those fronts. However, it goes deeper and darker than I initially expected.
The novel deftly explores family secrets and shame, sexism and the abuse of power, and the societal expectations placed on women. It examines the versions of ourselves we present to the world to succeed and the strain this facade causes, as well as the determination needed to take charge of your own life.
The story moves back and forth in time, alternating between an intense interrogation in the present day and Teddy's story, which leads up to this. This structure builds tension slowly, culminating in an explosive event. While I found the pacing a bit slower than I’d have liked, it didn't ruin my overall enjoyment.
Teddy is a complex and multi-layered character. Raised in a privileged environment, she has the need for independence but no idea what to do with it when she gets it. At times naive, she is also ambitious and glamorous, yet slightly messy - which you know I love!! She is chaotic and never ready to calm down, leading to lots of questionable decisions. But she is also very open when it comes down to her vulnerabilities and concerns, allowing for a full all round view of her. However you can’t let it fool you, she only ever gives away as much as she wants.
The author's attention to detail in describing aspects such as clothing and decor was stunning. Some of the dress descriptions I particularly loved. The writing is very atmospheric, vividly capturing Rome’s rich cultural and luxury urbanscape.
In Teddy, the author has created an intriguing character, forever attempting to escape a past that continues to define her. Her journey takes place in a city teeming with heat, art, elegance, and luxury. Whilst sitting on a dark undercurrent of deception and manipulation, where appearances are often deceiving.
Overall, this novel is a compelling read with rich descriptions and a well-crafted, enigmatic protagonist. It is a thoughtful exploration of identity, power, and the cost of maintaining appearances. Highly recommended for those who enjoy stories with depth, complex characters, and a touch of glamour mixed with darkness.