Member Reviews

A good story, compelling and with the right mix of adventure and fleshed out characters. Recommended. Many tnx for the arc

Was this review helpful?

Another great animal-centred story from Anna Fargher. I have never before read a story set around Pompeii and Mount Vesuvius and it was a fascinating and evocative choice. The animal story softens such an horrific historical event for the age group but doesn't shy away from the action and atmosphere of being caught up in it. This is a shorter but very pacy MG novel and the length was appealing. There was a lot of detail in the storytelling and it was clear that the author has done a huge amount of research. Narrating historical events through the eyes of loveable animal characters is a genius and effective move and this was both gripping, tense but also educational.

Was this review helpful?

In the shadow of Vesuvius, the wolf dog Delta has a race against time to save her family in 79 AD Pompeii.

It's 79AD and we are introduced to life in Pompeii through family politics.

Hememata is married to Marcus and expecting their first baby. Her new husband is ambitious and ruthless. He runs a construction business making concrete buildings (which prove to be substandard, with tragic consequences).

Hememata's father Lucius, on his deathbed, leaves his wealth to his daughter and her husband, and frees all his slaves. But when he dies the will goes missing.

The family dogs, Luna and her son Delta, are wary of the evil Marcus and try to thwart his plans but he imprisons his wife and sends the slaves Gaia and her son Neo to be sold on.

The story traces them all with Delta, helped by his eagle friend, Bellona, doing his part in bringing about all their freedoms. And all this as the earth rumbles and grumbles, warning of the terrible tragedy to come for the whole city.

This is a fabulous story which, though aimed at readers aged 9+, is rather grown up, I thought, in its description of the marriage between Hememata and Marcus particularly. The animals are powerful characters are by no means twee or cute. There's a great sense of pace and jeopardy. Loved it!

Was this review helpful?

Just not for me – the way the dogs speak to the eagle, the stodgy writing with overlong sentences about things we don't really care about, and the old-fashioned feel of it all. I felt the first sentence (dull, lecturing) had really failed to win me over to spending an evening with these pages, and nothing in the first three chapters changed my mind one jot.

Was this review helpful?

Perfect for children who love historical fiction full of action and heart, this is a fast paced and engaging read, filled with peril and adventure. A brilliant insight into slavery, class struggle and exploring the darker side of social history.

Was this review helpful?

This book is an edge-of-your-seat action adventure as a the loyal wolfdog races against time to save her loved ones in the midst of a volcano threatening to erupt. It also stands as a perfect way of introducing young readers to Roman rule in 79AD, including the darker elements of slavery and social hierarchies, without feeling overly educational or overbearing. A heartwarming story with real heart.

Was this review helpful?

Delta and the Lost City is an absolutely gripping historical adventure that took me on an unforgettable journey to AD79 where both humans and nature threaten the survival of a young wolfdog determined to protect her family from harm … poignant, heart-warming and hopeful … an epic adventure of courage, survival, hope and family.

Young wolfdog Delta enjoys her life inside the walls and grounds of her master, former army general Lucius’, luxurious countryside villa southeast of the coastal cities of Herculaneum and Pompeii. She spends her time play-fighting with her mother, Luna, her friend Bellona, the golden eagle, and her favourite slave, Gaia and her son, Neo … but she misses her mistress, Herminia.

Herminia, Lucius’ beloved daughter, no longer lives in the villa as she has married and moved to Rome with her cruel and controlling husband, Marcus. When they return for a night, before moving to Pompeii for the summer, Delta witnesses a terrible crime that culminates in the death of her master, providing a catalyst that changes her life …

Delta is accused of the death of her master and soon finds herself running for her life accompanied by her friend, Bellona, but she remains fiercely loyal to, and protective of, the family she loves and will never desert them. Delta is determined to stop Marcus’ tyranny and save her family from his cruelty. And, when further danger comes from the threat of Mount Vesuvius erupting, she finds herself in a race to locate and protect those she loves before it is too late. Can she save her family from both human cruelty and nature’s unstoppable might?

And so begins an absolutely riveting, action-packed adventure as Delta faces danger, threat and a quaking earth as she fights to reach her family who have been separated from each other by the machinations of a merciless, manipulative master. The tension, danger and sense of urgency are palpable not only as Mount Vesuvius moves inexorably towards eruption, but as Marcus rips apart all Delta loves and holds dear. This is an epic adventure overflowing with heart-pounding, explosive action and with both heartbreaking and hopeful moments.

This is a story that reveals so much about the structure of Ancient Roman society which was patriarchal and hierarchical with a reliance on slaves. But it also reveals a lot about human nature, juxtaposing a master who shows kindness and respect towards those in his household, and one who is self-interested and cruel.

Delta is the most incredible young wolfdog – she has definitely found her way into my heart. She is fiercely loyal and protective of her family and is determined to save them, taking great risks and placing herself in terrifying danger to do so. She is attuned to the natural environment around her and shows empathy towards others which brings its own rewards. She has a courageous heart beating with hope and love for her family. I adored her friendship with Bellona, the golden eagle.

David Dean’s detailed black-and-white illustrations are absolutely stunning, and complement the storytelling perfectly as they really capture both the heart and action of this amazing adventure.

A truly epic, unforgettable historical adventure with an incredible young hero in wolfdog, Delta, who embodies courage, strength and love for family. A perfect adventure for readers of 9+.

Was this review helpful?

I am a huge fan of Fargher's work and this book was a delight to read, gripping and historically accurate with beautiful illustrations.
A great recommend for fans of Caroline Lawrence as well as those liking animal stories

Was this review helpful?

I loved the setting for this story – Naples area, shortly before (and during) the eruption of Vesuvius and the obliteration of Pompei and Heracleum. The author has clearly done a lot of research into the period, for the details given about the households and the street markets feel very authentic. I liked the storyline of Delta and her desperate search to find her mother, Luna, while the young slave boy, Neo, is equally distraught torn away from his mother, Gaia. All their lives are intertwined with Herminia (whose father owned the dogs and promised to free the slaves) and her evil husband Marcus, who is driven by greed and cruelty. Then there is Delta’s friendship with Bellona, an eagle very well versed in human affairs who knows Herminia’s father left a will which Marcus has stolen so he can seize Herminia’s inheritance and sell it, including the slaves.
The destruction of Pompei by a volcanic eruption is truly a horrific event, and well depicted in the story. While I thought it was dramatic enough that we didn’t need the plot of Marcus and the stolen will, perhaps this makes the story more palatable to younger readers. The idea of telling the story of the eruption through a dog’s eyes, and having her best friend, an eagle, playing a large part in the story is also an excellent idea which will appeal to children.
What didn’t work well for me was the depiction of the animals. I wish Delta and Bellona could have reviewed events and discussed things like animals, and from their specific species perspective. Instead their conversations were often info dumps, and told from a human perspective rather than an animal’s. Dogs have thousands of scent glands, so I was disappointed that Delta rarely used her nose, and in fact seemed overwhelmed by the smells when she entered Pompei. Delta was also tied up and left without food or water for something like six days in blistering August heat in Southern Italy, which made no sense to me as Marcus planned to sell her. If he did this in real life, Delta would be dead. I was also surprised that Delta didn’t go to any lengths to free herself during this time, which is very undoglike. While younger readers, especially those without dogs, may not pick up on these points, I think it was a shame that Delta and Bellona did not behave more like the creatures they were meant to be.
Overall I would say Delta and the Lost City is great idea with a good setting and time period and an exciting and terrifying real event, but let down a little by the execution.

Was this review helpful?

A book about one of the biggest natural disasters in the ancient world probably doesn't strike many as the sort to be a potentially sweet narrative, but Fargher's doggy heroine manages to bring a little light to Pompeii.

As is the trend with middle-grade at the moment, the Delta of the title is our protagonist, a wolf-dog living in a countryside villa in the shadows of Pompeii with her mother, Luna, eagle friend Bellona, and the human cast: enslaved woman Gaia, her son, Neo, Lucius, the master of the house, and Herminia, Lucius' daughter. Also present is Herminia's husband Marcus, but as we discover very early on, Marcus isn't exactly a pinnacle of niceness. When Delta witnesses a horrible crime in her home, she finds herself on the run with Bellona, evading beasts and thieves in the wilderness. But, as she sets about trying to right the wrong that has torn her family apart, Vesuvius begins to rumble, and another disaster is on its way.

Animal stories fit really nicely into the genre of childrens' historical fiction, and Delta is no different: it's not the first novel to tackle Pompeii for younger audiences (I say as an avid Roman Mysteries reader at the age of 9), but Delta's perspective brings new aspects to light that might otherwise be missed in a novel with a human protagonist. The Vesuvius scenes especially are very poignant in their detail and narration, and lots of the smaller historical details (such as the crowds tying pillows to their heads to cushion the falling rock from the volcano) are peppered in nicely, in a way that's subtly educational without being overbearing. While I'm not an artist myself, David Dean's illustrations work well with the tone throughout: it's characterful while also being stark monochrome.

Delta's relationships with her animal family members are also really refreshing to read. Her conversations and interactions with Bellona gives their relationship an almost big-sister feel, whereas it isn't often that parental relationships are explored in animal stories, so Delta's interactions with Luna, and her consequent desire to find her later in the novel, makes a really nice change to the standard Incredible Journey-esque canine character motivation to find human owners. It also creates more of an analogue between Delta and her readers, for whom close relationships with adult caregivers are presumed to be important.

It's always a complex manoeuvre to discuss slavery in ancient Greek and Roman stories for children in a way that accentuates how awful the institution of slavery is, while equally reinforcing the endemic use of slavery as an economic system within the ancient world. Fargher managed to strike a pretty good compromise in this regard by using Delta as a viewpoint character: her position as a dog places her in a liminal position to view this from a separate viewpoint. She isn't a free creature herself - she's a pet, and some of the events of the novel are tracked based on whichever collar she's wearing - but equally she isn't an enslaved human, meaning that she can view the system from a removed level while simultaneously empathising with the injustices we see. There is a scene in the first third where Gaia and her son Neo are separated in a slave market, which is particularly harrowing - while Delta's POV means this doesn't become completely upsetting to a child reader, it doesn't shy away from the trauma and injustice associated with the scene, and simultaneously places Delta on par with Neo due to both of them being separated from their mothers, a strong emotional core for childrens' fiction. However, the novel very nearly sidles into the trope of the 'good slave master', which it avoids purely by the skin of its teeth. Despite his friendship with Severinius, a wealthy Roman boy whom Neo and Delta rescue from bandits, and consequently the son of Neo's enslaver, Fargher is thorough in ensuring that Neo remains miserable the entire time he is separated from Gaia: Severinius has a sense of justice, but equally one where slavery is an endemic part of his life, and as such he treats it like this. Since Greeks and Romans are big parts of the Key Stage 2 curriculum, I imagine this would be an interesting classroom conversation to have.

As I implied earlier, Marcus, Herminia's husband, isn't the nicest of the cast of characters: as we learn pretty early on in the novel, the business he runs is a scam, he's a greedy criminal, and he doesn't treat Herminia well - not helped by the fact that she is pregnant with his child. There's a genuine sense of menace to his characterisation: he's obviously an abject villain given the numerous crimes and cruelties he inflicts, but his presence as an abusive husband towards Herminia makes him increasingly sinister in a way that's accessible to young readers. Fargher does a great job throughout of taking what might be deemed very adult themes and presenting them in a way that's emotionally-resonant while equally not traumatising. In terms of my qualms with this novel, most of them are line-level editorial issues which may just be an issue with the proof copy: while I imagine these have been rectified, I'll mention them here anyway since they were present in my reading. There are several lines which are clunky and don't read particularly well, and which would have benefitted from another read-through, but again, these are very easily rectified.

Overall, Delta and the Lost City is a fun little novel with a lot of heart at its centre, and a new canine hero to join the legions of dog protagonists in childrens' books: she's a joy to read, and I'm sure she'll resonate with a wide audience of children and adults alike.

Thank you to Macmillan Children's and Netgalley for an eArc in exchange for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed reading this book so much! I really like that Delta would not give up on finding her mum and her owners!
All of the characters were really brave but I think Delta was the bravest.

Was this review helpful?

We adored this instant classic book. It has history, excitement, friendship and a race against time. All of the children loved. Personally, I think that I might read it again soon by myself just for the joy of it.

Was this review helpful?

A fantastic adventure!

In AD79, Mount Vesuvius erupted, burying the city of Pompeii and everything in its near proximity in molten lava. Pompeii became a lost city.

Told through the eyes of Delta, a faithful dog living in a villa in the countryside outside of Pompeii, this book would make the perfect accompaniment to studying the Romans. When her master is murdered by his son-in-law, Delta must find his mistress and save her from her dangerous husband. With the help of Bellona, the family's pet golden eagle, she heads into Pompeii to search for Herminia and whilst the people of the town prepare to celebrate, the animals sense imminent danger. Can Delta find Herminia before it is too late and will she survive?

The Book Clubbers age 9-11 loved Delta and Bellona and it was a fantastic, historical fictional novel that proved exceptionally popular with them and us.

Thank you to NetGalley and Macmillan Publishers for sending this eBook for review consideration. All opinions are our own.

Was this review helpful?

A great read for young Roman history fans!

Following the adventures of a loyal Roman dog across the streets of Pompei, this story gives us a different perspective on the famous historical events that unfolded in the ancient city.

The characters will appeal to young middle-grade readers and will introduce them to important topics, such as those related to freedom.

Thank you to Macmillan Children's Books and NetGalley for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

A cracking historical read perfect for confident readers to lose themselves in. This is going to be top of the list for all history fans to read as the perfect escape.

Was this review helpful?

History is a vast subject and while we are all interested in different parts of it – or none at all – there are some events from the past with which almost everyone is not only familiar but finds utterly fascinating. The eruption of Mt Vesuvius in AD 79 that buried the now world-famous towns of Pompeii and Herculaneum is one such event – one that has long inspired works of fiction and continues to do so.

When my attention was brought to this new middle grade title from the author of the gorgeous Umbrella Mouse being on Net Galley, I immediately requested it – despite being on a self-imposed ban from doing so – and was very excited when I was swiftly approved. Another story told through the eyes of an animal – in this case dog Delta – this is another tale of bravery under the most difficult of circumstances, and one that is destined to be a popular addition to young readers’ shelves.

Delta is lucky enough to live within the confines of a beautiful countryside villa when we meet her – a home she shares with her mother Luna, her master Lucius and Lucius’s pet golden eagle Bellona. Welcoming Herminia, Lucius’s heavily pregnant daughter, as she arrives en route to Pompeii with her unkind husband Marcus, Delta wishes that her mistress had not moved away and accompanies her as she heads to speak with her father. After briefly talking with him, Marcus banishes her from the room before he takes advantage of his father-in-law’s age and frailty to bring about his death.

Now able to wield power over the household, Marcus plans to sell Delta but before he is able to, she manages to escape together with Bellona and the pair of them vow to bring Marcus to justice. Aware that he and Herminia are to head to Pompeii, the two animals make their way there with the intention of helping Herminia break free of her unhappy marriage and they start to search for her.

But finding their mistress is not the only problem that they encounter within the town. As its residents prepare for an annual festival, it is increasingly hit by earth tremors. With the humans unaware of the significance of this, can Delta and Bellona find Herminia and help her to escape before the eruption of Vesuvius, or are they all destined to fall victim to its powers and – like so many – remain there forever more?

Young readers will adore Delta. Intelligent, brave and fiercely loyal to not just Herminia but also to the slaves who have served her well throughout her life, together with Bellona Delta does her utmost to free them all from Marcus’s tyranny, see that his wicked crime doesn’t go unpunished and – ultimately – bring about their escape from Pompeii.

The historical details of life within the town and the eruption that brought it to the world’s attention are rich and well-researched, bringing the action brilliantly to life – making this not just a wonderful adventure but also highly informative and a story that will appeal to those who are already young history fans and, hopefully, spark an interest in those who are not. With the text accompanied throughout by David Dean’s wonderful illustrations, this is a read that is perfect for Year 4 upwards, either as a solo read or one that is shared, and would make a great class reader to accompany a topic on the Romans.

My enormous thanks go to both publisher Macmillan Children’s Books and to Net Galley for my virtual advance read. Delta and the Lost City hits the shelves July 4th.

Was this review helpful?