Member Reviews

Captivating Victorian-set fiction that tells of the evolving of the huge, park-like cemeteries and shows how women were little more than commodities to me. Bonnie escapes being married off for family profit to an old man only to fall into the clutches of a handsome con man who was considerably worse. It’s dark and twisted and a great read.

Was this review helpful?

4.5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️✨ The Burial Plot is an historical thriller that is absolutely absorbing. The gothic vibes are present throughout creating a scenic backdrop for an engaging plot. At times my heart was thumping when lies and manipulation start to unravel. Also the focus on burial grounds made for interesting reading as this was a problem Victorian England had to address. This book definitely transports you into the past and the characters are all so believable. Overall a brilliant read with darkness at its core. Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an ARC. This is a voluntary review of my own thoughts.

Was this review helpful?

The Burial Plot takes place in London in 1839. It’s a historical fiction novel that follows Bonnie as she navigates life with a trickster/scammer named Crawford. Bonnie often helps Crawford with the scams but one night everything goes wrong and Bonnie has to disappear. Crawford secures her a position as a lady’s maid in a grand house. Bonnie starts work and begins to understand Mr Moncrieff and his daughter Cissie. They are both strange in their own ways and Bonnie begins to question what secrets are hiding within the house especially as Crawford watches from the shadows.

The Burial Plot was an absolutely amazing novel. I loved the setting and I easily got the historical vibes. It actually reminded me of To Sir Phillip, With Love by Julia Quinn in the vibes of the house and the way it was isolated from everything. The writing was great and the story was very compelling. I read this in two settings and I loved the experience of it. Bonnie was an interesting character to follow especially seeing her dynamic with Crawford. I loved the gothic vibes of the house and the cemetery being built. There was a sweet bond built between Bonnie and Cissie and I loved seeing Mr Moncrieff develop as a character. I would definitely recommend this to historical fiction lovers as this is 5 stars and a new favourite. I’ll definitely read from this author again in the future.

Was this review helpful?

An absolutely fascinating delve into Victorian burial customs alongside a strong dose of Machiavellian goings-on! Elizabeth Macneal continues to conjure up fascinating characters and those at the centre of ‘The Burial Plot’ are desperate to escape the day-to-day drudgery and poverty of working class London, no matter how. As Bonnie, fleeing from a heinous crime to become a maid in Endellion, a grand house in Twickenham, imagines, ‘There, she might be a new girl again, fresh, unboxed, her shoes scoured clean of bold, the shaky feeling in her legs simply buffed away.’
Unfortunately for Bonnie, her real weakness is an attachment to the horribly alluring Crawford. There’s no doubt that Bonnie is a strong-minded, brave woman. Nevertheless, Crawford knows how to work on her insecurities and her desires. Whilst the reader can recognise his powers of manipulation better than Bonnie, it’s only towards the end of the novel that Macneal reveals just how clever and callous he really is.
Gothic would certainly be an accurate description of ‘The Burial Plot’ but it’s not the only adjective that comes to mind. Bonnie’s nurturing relationship with Cissie, the motherless daughter of Endellion’s owner is particularly moving and the novel’s conclusion reminds us that human nature is a force for good – mostly.
I would not be at all surprised if this story is optioned for the screen. Strong female characters (‘…a chain of women all reaching out a hand and feeling the graze of their fingertips’) and a wicked chameleon alongside the business of designing and building the perfect Victorian cemetery. Irresistible!
My thanks to NetGalley and Pan MacMillan for a copy of this book in exchange for a fair review.

Was this review helpful?

Loved this Gothic novel from the setting to the characters all of them, even the negative ones who made the story so complete. The writing style was really good, it made all feel more real. I recommend this book to anyone who likes a bit of mystery, a bit of love story and Gothic style stories.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed The Doll Factory back when I found this author. Unfortunately, this one wasn't my cup of tea in terms of the writing, language and execution and I DNF at 30%.

Was this review helpful?

Elizabeth Macneal once again wraps us up in the Victorian era in this twisted and unsettling gothic chiller, she creates the historical period with care, her rich descriptions of London and everyday ordinary details, the social norms and attitudes, for example towards women, the clothing, murk, grime and dirt, the poverty, preoccupations, and the inequalities. We have the fascinating Victorian focus on death and mourning, and the building of the large sprawling Highgate cemetery in 1839. The flawed protagonist is Bonnie, who has escaped her suffocating personal home circumstances, only to unwarily jump into the fire.

She acquires a lover in Crawford, and is soon engaged in fraud and stealing with him, only for it all to end in death, and the fear of being arrested hovering over her. A frightened Bonnie is persuaded by Crawford to become a maid for her own safety and security, a post in a big house by the river, where a grieving widower, Mr Moncrieff, lives with his troubled daughter, Cissie. Bonnie's life becomes ever more complicated, and she will need to become more courageous and develop greater resilience, as it soon becomes clear the ruthless manipulative Crawford was far from well intentioned. Crawford did not primarily have her well being in mind, his devious head is full of more nefarious plans. Will Bonnie be able to save herself and the vulnerable Moncrieffs?

Macneal writes a dark narrative where the pace quickens as the story develops, full of twists and turns, and a central character study of Bonnie, initially naive in her poor choices and putting her trust in a man, Crawford who little deserves it along with Rex. However, despite the pressure, stresses and nightmare fears she is heavily burdened by, we see her grow and become a much stronger woman. An intense Victorian historical read, meticulously plotted, a gothic period piece with themes that I think many fans of Victorian fiction are likely to enjoy. Many thanks to the publisher for an ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Give me a Victorian gothic novel set in an old grand house with a maid/governess and I'm sold. Reading this reminded me of Jane Eyre and Rebecca (two of my favourites!)

I figured out what was going to happen at the end around the halfway mark, but this didn't lessen my enjoyment of the novel. I really relished watching everything come to a climax.

This was my first Elizabeth Macneal novel and won't be my last. She's a superb storyteller, and her writing is exquisite.

Was this review helpful?

4+ 🌟

Very little happened in this book that I didn't predict YET Macneal writes so wonderfully well that I thoroughly enjoyed it.
She puts you into that place, that time. Makes you believe in characters.
I read the last few chapters desperate to know how things would end.
It was very well done.
Another winner for the author I think.

Was this review helpful?

This was my first Elizabeth Macneal novel and I will definitely be looking out for her other work. I love a good, Victorian gothic novel and this didn't disappoint.

Set in 1839, our main character, Bonnie, runs away from home to London and is 'rescued' by Crawford who begins and continues throughout to manipulate Bonnie to get her to help in his thieving and extortion activities in her belief that he loves her. An incident occurs and Bonnie fears being arrested by police. Crawford "helps her" by getting her a job in a fine gothic mansion outside London but what are his real motivations?

I foresaw most of the plot twists but that didn't affect my enjoyment. I was totally engrossed in it and finished it in just over a day. On occasions, some of the language used by one of the characters was a bit course which I didn't particularly like but given the setting of the slums of St. Giles in London, it was likely an accurate portrayal of the way they would have spoken.

Thank you to netgalley for the advanced copy.

Was this review helpful?

4.5-5 stars

Elizabeth MacNeal is proof, to me, why you don't give up on an author straight away. When I had The Doll Factory, it took two attempts for me to read it. Initially I felt it wasn't my thing so I shelved it. But a couple of months later I picked it up again and read it in a matter of hours and loved it. And then when Circus of Wonders came out, I once again devoured it in a day. And so her latest book was always on my wishlist, and I was so happy to receive an early digital copy of it. It sounded fabulous and the cover is gorgeous (and I definitely do judge books by their covers)!

Elizabeth is excellent at creating a sense of time and place. We immediately see ourselves in the space, we are familiar with the setting, the clothes, the smells, the sights; it feels as normal as our everyday life, even if we are almost 200 years apart.

I was initially lost as to who was whom and what they were to each other, but I think that might have been more to do with my attention span than the book itself. But I definitely got more into it once the scenes in the house started, which happen very quickly actually.

I have read a lot, a lot, of books set in Victorian England, where a young woman, usually running from something or someone, ends up as a maid or housekeeper in a large house that isn't all it appears to be. And you'd think I'd get bored of them, because surely how many different stories can you get frrom that, sand yet I haven't. This is as good as any I've read. Familiarity throughout, but with a little added extra to make it different. I think for me, the main thing that stood out was it's subplot about cemeteries. This isn't a topic normally covered in books like this, and that's what made it interesting for me.

I was going through a little bit of a rough time when I read this, and so it took me longer to read than it normally would, which did frustrate me but I actually think it was a good thing, as it made me concentrate and hone in on smaller details I might have missed if I'd read it at my normal speed. But by the time I got half way, I sped through it. The second half is far fuller than the first in terms of things actually happening, which meant the second half sped by.

It's a small cast of characters. Yes you've got secondary and background characters, and those already deceased. But for the main part, it's a small party, but that's given Elizabeth a chance to really delve into them and create marvellously layered characters.

Our main protagonist of Bonnie took a while to grow on me. Yes she is a young lady in a time where it wasn't easy for young ladies. But she felt a bit meek, juvenile, gullible, under the thumb of men. But I grew to like her and felt almost protective of her. She still had her moments where I felt her naïve and foolish, but it made her feel all the more natural.

You then have Mr Moncrieff and his daughter Cissie. A peculiar twosome. Full of secrets. But I felt them easier to warm to, even though I wasn't sure if they were completely good or not. But I thought them very intriguing.

And we have Bonnie's...lover, I suppose. Crawford. I didn't care for him. I won't go too much into him as I think a lot comes frrom the reading, but he felt slimy. Crawford. felt like a creepy crawly, and I wouldn't' trust him as far as I could throw him. And his friend Rex, desperate to match up. Despicable, the both of them, for reasons I won't go into. I felt almost embarrassment for them when they were on the page.

It isn't an obvious gothic thriller. There's no ghosts or ghouls or overly nefarious characters as such. It's subtle. It gets under your skin. For me, it's all about the character development and their conversations, rather than what's hiding in the shadows. I would say it's more gothic in terms of the setting rather than the goings on.

In hindsight I do think my favourite of hers so far has been Circus of Wonders, but that's not to poo-poo this one at all. It was highly interesting and entertaining, and I thoroughly recommend it to those who enjoy gothic thrillers.

I did read one early review that said the ending seemed a bit sudden for the complexities of what needed wrapping up, and so I was a little concerned about that. But I didn't find that. I thought everything ended in an appropriate way for the characters and where they were in their story.

I do love a gothic thriller. The position of Queen of the genre lies with Laura Purcell, but this is a wonderous contender.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley, Pan Macmillan and Elizabeth Macneal for giving me the opportunity to read this ahead of release. It was a pleasure!

This book felt as if I was transported back in time. The writing was beautiful and classic, effortlessly timeless. The cover art also drew me in - and after reading it, can see how it ties in perfectly with the book.

After escaping an arranged marriage, Bonnie finds herself alone in an inn. A grifter, Crawford, takes her under his wing and into his bed, moulding her into his muse. Together with Crawford's dogsbody Rex, they take on the task of relieving the wealthy of their riches by preying on them in the pubs and backstreets of London.

But when Bonnie is unknowingly coerced into applying for a lady's maid position at the impressive Moncrieff residence, Crawford isn't far behind with his dastardly notions.

This book was so unique, unlike anything I've ever read. It stirred up so many emotions.. Bonnie's character was impeccably written. I felt every emotion alongside her. Her bitterness, hatred, confusion, longing, lust, distrust, relief.. I felt like I held my breath throughout this whole book just praying she'd get her happy ever after!

Mr. Moncrieff was another favourite of mine, along with Cissie. Cissie's innocence and grief, her naivety and immature notions of romance, it was perfectly executed. And I loved the bond she built with Bonnie despite everything she'd been through and seen.

I can't wait to go and read more of Elizabeth Macneal's books!

Was this review helpful?

Published 6 June 2024. Just had to pick up Elizabeth Macneal's newest novel and I wasn't disappointed. Once again a twist Gothic novel set, this time, around the Victorian obsession, almost, with death. There are not enough places to bury the dead and this is the time of the the grand cemeteries - Highgate Cemetery was established in 1839. Bonnie has fled from home and is now in London's underworld with her partner, Crawford, involved in a bit of fraud and a bit of theft. When something goes wrong and Bonnie fears that she will be arrested, Crawford convinces her to take up the position of a maid in a grand house on the banks of the Thames, a house owned by a widower, Mr Moncrieff, and who lives there with his daughter, Cissie. Moncrieff's primary occupation seems to be obsessively drawing mausoleums for his dead wife, Josephine, who had drowned. However, Bonnie soon finds that maybe Crawford did not merely have her safety at heart when he found her this position and that she is not as in control of her life as she had thought. This is a gorgeous story of manipulation. As a reader you fear not only for Bonnie, but the Moncrieffs. The feeling of unease grows as the book continues - as Bonnie is always looking over her shoulder for the arrest which she still fears, and then for whatever Crawford is planning. I loved reading about the building of the cemetery - as someone who enjoys a good wander around a graveyard - and although Bonnie didn't really get under my skin, I became engrossed in her situation. What was Crawford planning? I've now read three Elizabeth Macneal and hope she writes another one soon.

Was this review helpful?

A mysterious twisted gothic horror. But who is tricking who?

We all want to live in a fancy house, but Bonnie will do whatever it takes to makes that a reality.

A perfect weekend read with punchy chapters, that will keep you guessing.

Was this review helpful?

The writer’s craft is 5++ stars.
She transports you to this gothic world with her descriptions and interesting characters.
The plot was not my favourite - 4-4.5 stars, just out of personal taste, but overall, the mood, the setting and the characters are exquisite.
I will be reading Macneal’s other work and she is already one of my new favourite writers.

Was this review helpful?

A new book from Elizabeth Macneal always becomes one of my most anticipated books of a year. I loved The Doll Factory and enjoyed Circus of Wonders, and The Burial Plot sounded brilliant - Victorian cemeteries? Murder and manipulation? Yes, please!

This book is very dark; it might be even darker than The Doll Factory. Some descriptions of London and people are grimy, even unpleasant, and people are not very nice. Speaking of people, unfortunately I didn't like a single character in this book. I didn't click with anyone, didn't sympathise with them or root for them - neither for Bonnie, our protagonist, or Cissie, a young troubled girl in her care. Macneal's writing is superb, though, and I could read her vivid descriptions all day long, but overall the book lacked the gothic atmosphere. The twists and revelations were pretty predictable too. The Burial Plot has a fascinating premise (and a great title), but the execution wasn't great, in my opinion.

I'm still here for whatever Elizabeth Macneal writes next!

Was this review helpful?

First of all, I just want to truly appreciate the cover...it's absolutely stunning!

A gothic story of manipulation and mystery, immersive and visual in its setting and tone, and characters that didn't disappoint. A favourite genre of mine that I enjoyed from start to finish.

The characters were well developed and believable throughout, and the differences between the lives of the poor and the rich felt honest and real. The pace was well balanced and kept me fully engrossed right up until the last page. My first Elizabeth Macneal read, and most definitely not my last. Will be recommending this for fans of historical and gothic reader fans.

Thank you to NetGalley Galley and Pan Macmillan for a pre released digital copy ahead of publication....I may need to purchase the physical book to add to my home collection!

Was this review helpful?

This was my first Elizabeth Macneal novel but it won't be my last. I had a great time seeing how the plot came together overtime, unraveling all the ways in which Bonnie was manipulated, and seeing the characters grow despite the novel's heavy themes.
My only issue with this novel is one character in particular that I don't think was all that necessary. Maybe they were meant to be a loose end, something to always haunt Bonnie, but if that's the case I don't think it translated as well as I'd like into the story.
Still, I highly recommend this book for lovers of historical fiction set in Victorian times & all things Gothic.

Thank you NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Elizabeth Macneal's The Doll Factory made her a force to be reckoned with within the Historical Fiction genre, she followed it up with the Circus of Wonders which was also set within the Victorian period. With The Burial Plot she returns to the Victorians and this time she turns her eye to their fascination with death and burial, in particular the lack of burial plots within the cities . Enter Bonnie a young woman who has fallen in with an unsavoury man (Crawford) who coerces her into becoming a ladie's maid for a young girl whose father is obsessed with creating a mausoleum for his dead wife. Bonnie thought Crawford was protecting her however she soon discovers otherwise.

With our obsession with all things gothic this is bound to be popular.

Was this review helpful?

Elizabeth MacNeal knocks it out of the park again. She is a very good, and very interesting writer - this is a terrific novel, and well worth reading.

Was this review helpful?