Member Reviews
Fast-paced, surrealist and cruel at times, "Mysterious Setting" was a good start of Kazushige Abe's works for me.
I rooted for Shiori so much along the story. The characters were amazing and the story had the sort of irony I love.
Recommended.
This book is definitely up there as one of my new favourites! I loved the twists and turns and once I started reading it was hard to put down. Shiori doesn't have the best start to life with constantly being put down by the people around her. Still wanting to pursue her dreams she moves to Tokyo with the hope of a new start and to make new friends however her good nature and somewhat naivety leaves her in a similar position. Her positive outlook keeps her continually seeing the good in people which ultimately leaves her in an unexpected situation. Overall, I think Mysterious Setting is a great read and I will certainly be checking out more of Kazushige Abe's work in the future.
The main character of the story in this novel, Shiori, doesn't have an easy life. She is lonely and naïve and easily taken advantage of, which happens several times throughout the book. It's tough reading a character clearly struggling with social isolation get her hopes up when she thinks she has made new friends only to be beaten back again. Towards the end of the novel, there is a Schrodinger's Cat style action plot, and Shiori HAS to take action and make a choice on whether to believe or not to believe and here we finally see her start to take action.
The main bulk of this novel is a story being told by a narrator we meet at the beginning and re-join at the end of him telling Shiori's tale. I didn't feel this "story within a story" element added anything, it felt more like filler to add a few extra pages. Several Japanese novels I have read recently focus on the social isolation of young people and Mysterious Setting is another great portrayal of this.
I have given this book 3 stars because I enjoyed it but didn't feel like it was a stand out and there are other novels on similar themes which I would recommend instead of this.
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for the eBook ARC.
The story of a girl called Shiori told by an old man in a park to some mooching kids with little else to do. The majority of the story is about Shiori and her life. She’s got zero self awareness (plans to be a troubadour but is tone deaf, plans to be a lyricist but won’t write lyrics, thinks of herself as a poet yet never writes poetry….), she’s utterly gullible and ripped off left, right and centre and, asides from her sister, no-one is willing to take her to one side and knock some sense into her. She’s such a frustrating character. I trudged through the first two thirds before the arrival of The Suitcase. The final third is readable but Shiori is still her indecisive, clueless self. I assume that all this is build up is to establish Shiori as someone who is pure in heart, and untainted by the selfishness which marks just about every other character, ready for the set-piece ending. At the end, we learn why the old man is so determined to tell Shiori’s story.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
This is the perfect companion to All the Lovers in the Night by Mieko Kawakami. Which is kinda perfect, because Kazushige Abe is Mieko Kawakami’s husband (and I’m here, supporting my girlie’s partner). Both books follow women who ‘go with the flow,’ either because they lack drive or because they assume things of their surroundings, but in both cases, we see how lacking a voice leads to social alienation. Whereas Kawakami’s felt like a hug… Mysterious Setting is a bizarre, perplexing slap in the face with a chair.
I do want to put an emphasis on the bizarre here. Part of me felt as if Helen Oyeyemi had co-authored it. There were bits that had me doing the Jim from The Office thing and looking at the camera like ‘is this happening?’
Mysterious Setting is narrated by a storyteller who talks about Shiori, a troubadour who is so tone-deaf that when she things, beings die (animals and humans). So this curse and the harsh words of her peculiar sister Nozomi force her to drop her existence as a troubadour to pursue her dream of becoming a lyricist. Her social alienation and social awkwardness make her a target for people trying to take advantage of her. The story turns pretty dark when Shiori is gifted a very interesting suitcase.
Now, I have so many thoughts. This book is perfect for a book club because what the fuck. Shiori is batshit crazy, I don’t even want to talk about her. But Nozomi?? I adored Nozomi (even though she does something disgusting at some point). She was HARSH to Shiori. HARSH. And it was at times hilarious, at times horrifying. But throughout the book, I must say, Nozomi was the only person who cared for Shiori, even if that care was… just strange. There is a point in the book where Shiori starts talking to an object (I repeat: batshit crazy). And the object continues calling her ‘Shiori darling,’ which is what Nozomi calls her. This shows how important Nozomi was to Shiori even after Shiori leaves and goes to Tokyo.
The story was weird. The characters were weird. But the ending was super emotional. And the last 25% of the book really had me hooked, I kept wondering anxiously “is it real or is it fake” (because of something that’s happening). So, do I recommend it? Yeah. I thought it was a trip. So bizarre. But so cool and creative.
I think the concept of Mysterious Setting was included in the book but it made little sense. Yet you, as the reader, if you take a step back - this story is made of many details put together that seem to float to create a story, in a way. So I think it’s a good title for what came of it, but I don’t think it was utilized smartly in the book. (Mysterious Setting or Serti Mysterieux is a type of jewellery-making style in which little gemstones are put together very closely and in a way that they appear to be floating, but there is a little metal in the back keeping them together).
Regular readers of contemporary Japanese fiction will know that it needs to be approached with an open mind and a readiness for the inevitable "differentness" in store.
Mysterious Setting by Kazushige Abe is certainly no different.
Shiori is an outcast,she loves to sing but she's tone deaf and others hate her singing,this makes her cry,and those same "others" find her cries soothing and pleasurable. Tormented by her sociopathic sister ,Nozomi ,and with nothing in her life going right she reaches 18 and moves to Tokyo with dreams of becoming a lyricist. Once in the big city nothing changes ,the easy-going and placid Shiori is exploited and taken advantage of.
The book is frequently surreal,and sometimes quite disturbing, much of it is a litany of misery as once again the lost and lonely Shiori trusts the wrong person and mutely almost blames herself. When things do change for her it's in a totally unexpected way and the book takes on a totally new direction.
This book is often surreal,sometimes horrifying,frequently sad but ultimately will make readers rethink everything they thought they knew about its troubled heroine.
A quirky and fun tale that reads like a captivating movie. The author's vivid descriptions create an engaging ambience that pulled me in from the start. The characters and plot are intriguing, which kept me hooked for the most part. However, the book falls short in delivering profound takeaways, which left me feeling underwhelmed. Overall, while the book's setting sets an alluring stage, its failure to delve into deeper themes may leave readers craving more substance.
Everything I wanted and expected from this book and more was contained inside. Shiori had, overall, a miserable life. But it was never because of her lack of trying for better, or for hoping for the best at all times. Even in the face of everything bad happening to her she remained optimistic, or found the best out of a situation. It was the outside world that couldn't handle her and made her life a misery. Other people taking advantage of her goodness, her naivety. I found this to be so tender, heartbreaking, sometimes funny but overall deeply deeply sad. I loved it.
From what I can tell this isn’t a bad book. The writing flows quite nicely but it is quite slow paced. It just wasn’t holding my interest and I found I wasn’t wanting to pick it back up after putting it down, so I stopped trying to force it.
What a strange little book! Mysterious Setting read a bit like a fever dream and not for a minute did I know what was coming next. Darkly funny at times, and deeply sad the next, Kazushige Abe takes the reader on a surreal and thoroughly enjoyable journey.
I think this book was good. Kazushige Abe is starting to become one of my favorites with the books I've read from them recently. This book was one of my favorite and I can't wait to see more