Member Reviews

The Other Valley
By Scott Alexander Howard

A dystopian coming of age novel with a literary style that reminds me of Kazuo Ishiguro. It is set in a world where past, present and future exist in parallel. The concept is simple, and perhaps more interesting to those who read time travel, less for the science and more for the consequences of interference in time continuum, to the extent that I almost came to believe it possible that this world exists.

I really struggled to engage with this story however. I found the moral and ethical questions interesting, and how it reveals the complexity of human nature when faced with dilemmas where outcomes can eliminate this or that person's existence, but something about the slow pacing kept me at arm's length.

I listened to this in audio format, and while the narrator has a beautiful voice, very relaxing, she doesn't bring much by way of performance. Perhaps this was intentional, so as to not overwhelm the delicate narrative, but it resulted in complete underwhelm for me for the greater part of the story.

Fantastic premise which has impressed itself on my brain, but emotionally, this was a one night stand.

Publication date: 18th April 2024
Thanks to #NetGalley and #WFHowes for the ALC

Was this review helpful?

DNF. I have GOT to stop reading literary fiction written by men with female main characters because I just get let down every single time.

Was this review helpful?