Member Reviews

Absolutely brilliant book!
I am a big fan of this author and love the writing style!
I cant wait to read more!

Was this review helpful?

The dark, suspenseful atmosphere of this thriller drew me in immediately. The tension never let up, and the twists were absolutely brilliant, a true gem of a thriller.

Was this review helpful?

This book. Was good. I enjoyed this.

Orianna was convicted of murder at 17 but claims she is innocent but can’t remember what happened . Annie Ledet a forensic psychologist is tasked with the job of finding who did do it if Orianna is innocent?

This is a mystery thriller with all the twists and turns you’d expect with this kind of story.. you’ll be pointing the finger at everyone reading this.

Was this review helpful?

The eponymous ‘Girl in Cell A’, otherwise known as Orianna Negi, was convicted of the murder of Gideon Wyclerc at the age of just 17. Gideon’s daughter Grace disappeared the same day and has never been found.

However, Orianna can’t remember what actually happened the day of the murder, but nevertheless maintains her innocence. And so it falls to Forensic psychologist Annie Ledet to unlock the truth, because if Orianna is telling the truth, then there’s a murderer walking free.

Orianna grew up in Eden Falls, ruled by the insular Wyclerc dynasty and its ruthless patriarch, Amos. This is a town of secrets, a town with its fair share of scandals, sex, power, alleged incest and murder - and it’s not the first murder either! 18 years later Orianna is released and returns to Eden Falls determined to find out just who killed Gideon, and discover what happened to Grace.

This was a clever, well written psychological thriller which explores memory, truth, and lies in a small American mining town. The finger of suspicion had a real workout here, pointing out several suspects, but it turns out my finger was way off, pointing totally in the wrong direction!

Was this review helpful?

Really enjoyed this book which get me on the edge on my seat

First time reading anything by this author

Would recommend

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely loved this book . The writing was extremely good and the story unravels slowly , enough to keep you guessing . I certainly didn’t expect that ending at all . I’ve looked at the previous books this author has done and this is something completely different . I definitely would love to read more in this genre from this author . I think this book will be very successful and I’d definitely recommend this book to my friends. 5 stars from me , can’t wait to see if this author does another in this genre

Was this review helpful?

I devoured 'The Girl In Cell A'. Utterly devoured it in one day. Couldn't put it down.
I'm a huge fan of Vaseem Khan's historical crime fiction series, set in 1950s India, starring the brilliant Persis, so I was a little wary of reading a stroy set in the US, in a contemporary timeframe. Could 'The Girl In Cell A' live upto my hopes?
Well, this multilayered tale, of psychology and murder is just brilliant, brilliant.
'The Girl In Cell A' has two interweaving timelines: First we hear from Forensic psychologist Annie Ledet, who is assigned the task of assessing Orianna (past) and then we meet Orianna in the present day, when she is trying to uncover the truth.
Orianna Negi is from a small town, where the Wyclerc family rule supreme. And at the age of 17, Orianna was found guilty of the murder of Gideon Wyclerc and the disappearance of his daughter Grace. She has always claimed her innocence and that she has no memory of the events of that terrible afternoon.
The plot moves along at a swift pace, keeping the reader intrigued but always careful never too move to quickly, and give away any of the (totally shocking) twists.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to the publishers and net galley for my advanced ecopy in exchange for a review. I really got into this book, it is on the lengthy side but I feel it adds to the story and character building. Loved the short sharp chapters and the writing flow. Orianna has been convicted of murder and has spent the last 18 years locked up and we follow her as she is released and travels back to Eden Falls a small town where she has grown up. The book flicks between her POV and also her prison therapists Annie as we gradually learn about her past and her investigation to find out what happened and also missing girl Grace. This book also had one of the biggest twists I didn’t see coming and was done really well. I will be recommending to others and looking out for more from this author . 4.5 stars

Was this review helpful?

Great writing! It kept me interested until the end, and the twists just kept coming! It's the type of book that you keep returning to because you need to know who killed whom!

I thought I knew who killed Gideon... then realized I was totally wrong... then the last few chapters just... what??? Mind-blowing twist!!!

Highly recommended, out on the 1st of May 2025! Thank you, @Netgalley, for the ARC ebook copy of this book. What a treat!

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this book. I felt the forensic side of the book had been very well researched and was an accurate account of the forensic mental health system.

The world building was great, I really felt that I was in the southern state.

The only downside for me was the length of the book. I felt this was a real slow burn up to say 350 pages. Then it picks up.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely loved this book! I couldn't put it down and read it in a day. If you're a fan of twisty thrillers this is for you. I love a good thriller that's unpredictable and keeps me guessing and this did the job for me. The twists totally took me off guard. Loved it and would love to read more from this author!

Was this review helpful?

The writing just felt boring and drawn out and I ultimately DNF'd cause I really didnt care what happened or why it happened.

Was this review helpful?

WHAT A READ!

The Girl in Cell A is an incredibly clever written psychological thriller, featuring multiple twists and turns that left me unable to from putting this book down.

As a convicted murder, 17 year old Orianna is 'the girl in cell A' and obtains some sort of 'celebrity status' of being a killer. Though, Orianna continues to argue that she is innocent, not having killed Gideon Wyclerc.

Working with Annie Ledet, a forensic psychologist, it is her task to find out what truly happened. Did Orianna kill Gideon? Or who is behind killing someone from the Wyclerc dynasty, who rules the small town Eden Falls? Going back and forth between what happened back then and revisiting the fact that Orianna is unable to remember what happened exactly when Gideon was killed, Annie continues to try and unlock Orianna's memory.

This book was absolutely gripping form the start until he very final page. With its twists and turns and psychological elements (something I particularly enjoy), I found myself coming up with multiple scenarios as to what happened. Being able to jump into the world of 'Eden Falls', this book was a brilliant yet rather chilling escape and would definitely recommend to anyone.

With the book being published in May 2025, I anticipate this to be THE summer psychological thriller you shouldn't be missing out on.

Was this review helpful?

A decidedly different and intriguing crime novel from Vaseem Khan, with bucketloads of atmosphere. I liked the dual narrative and the challenge of working out whose voice I could trust. I had to read the ending a second time and I'm keen to discuss it with other readers once it's published!

Was this review helpful?

I'm a short book person. I rarely read books over 400 pages so when I saw this was almost 600 pages I was a bit worried. However I enjoyed it so much I'm considering reading longer books more often!

Orianna was accused of murder when she was 17 and sent to prison. Orianna cannot remember anything from that afternoon but claims she didn't do it. This book follows her journey to try and recover her memory and prove her innocence. There is a dual timeline with a different POV from Annie a forensic psychotherapist as she tries to uncover Orianna’s memory.

I became so obsessed with this book! I loved Orianna and joining her in trying to figure out whether she killed Gideon Wyclerc or not. And the Wyclerc family, what a bunch! So many dark secrets, I am here for the drama!

More of a crime drama than a thriller, this story was engaging, interesting and the ending blew me away! Genuinely surprised me in such a good way!

I hope this book gets the love and attention it deserves when it comes out next year and I'll certainly be looking out for what Khan writes next

Was this review helpful?

I was really excited to read The Girl in Cell A, While the book did hold my interest and had moments of intrigue, I ultimately found it a bit of a letdown.

The pacing felt overly drawn out, with many sections that could have been tightened to maintain momentum. At times, the narrative veered into excessive detail and waffling, which slowed the story and diluted the tension. The ending, while a twist, wasn’t overly surprising and left me feeling disappointed—it made much of the earlier plot feel somewhat pointless, which dampened my overall enjoyment.

That said, Khan’s ability to weave a story is undeniable, and despite its flaws, the book kept me reading. For those who enjoy a slow-burn mystery, this might be a better fit, but for me, it lacked the punch I was hoping for.

Thank you for giving me the chance to read this ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Outstanding writing from Vaseem Khan, I was hooked right from the beginning. The characters were all really engaging and I found myself getting lost in their story. This is the first book I have read from this author but certainly wont be the last

Was this review helpful?

Vaseem Khan, author of the Malabar House series, has turned his hand to the psychological thriller, and has produced a most enjoyable read. He gets into the mind of the main character beautifully, and keeps us in suspense all the way through. A very competent piece of writing.

Was this review helpful?

4.5⭐️

(Spoilers)

I loved this book until the very end. The descriptions of people and places are exceptionally well written and drew me into the story.

I should have known something was afoot because throughout I couldn’t understand how she had got parole when she was convinced she was innocent and was not prepared to admit her guilt.

At the end, when she ‘finds’ Grace I was so disappointed to find that the whole story had been a false memory narrative.

The only saving grace (sorry!) is the very last chapter which links back to the beginning with its suggestion…

So for me, it was a 95% totally absorbing but ultimately disappointing read but, if this is a genre you like I think you will love it.

Was this review helpful?

This is a challenge: there are two (eventually three) narrators and I’m not sure why that was necessary. It seemed to make the story incredibly long. Imagine describing your day in great detail and then also having your partner or friend or parents describe the exact same day from their perspective, except only know what happened because of what you told them. So I just felt like I was reading the same thing over and over again.

There were twists and drama, which were well-executed but ultimately, I slogged through this because I owed Netgalley a review for allowing me the ARC.

Was this review helpful?