While I appreciated the beautiful prose and the deep exploration of love and connection across different lifetimes, I found some parts a bit slow and drawn out. Many readers online praise Barker’s lyrical writing and the way she blends philosophical themes with engaging storytelling, and I can see why; there are moments of real depth that invite reflection.

However, I also noticed some criticism about the pacing, which I felt was warranted. At times, it seemed to drag, making it harder to stay fully engaged. That said, the characters are richly developed, and their journeys are poignant, capturing the complexity of human emotions.

This book was a creepy , disturbing read, and perfect for this time of year.. Not my usual genre but always good to go a little outside of my c9mfort zone every now and then. Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the advance copy

"Old soul" by Susan Barker is one of the reads that I was really struggling with. The premise was brilliant but for some reason I couldn't get into it fully.
It's definitely very well written and guides us through multiple characters that experienced evil. I would describe it as a mix of folklore tales, horror and general fiction. I finished it but I think I will give it another go in the next few months as for now I can't give it more than 2 stars and I believe in second chances. Thanks to Netgalley for giving me the opportunity to read an early copy in exchange for the honest review

3.5 stars

Firstly I’d like to say thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for giving me this ARC in exchange for an honest review.

I honestly don’t know where to begin with this review! This book was just so different from anything I’ve ever read before that I don’t know how to explain it!

I thought the writing had this eerily beautiful sense to it and the plot was very unique and equally eerie. There were many layers to this story and I found myself to have many varying emotions throughout as I grew to be connected to various characters and their storylines within the plot.

This book definitely had a unique style too and wasn’t at all how I expected it to be! I don’t think that’s a bad thing at all though as this book definitely intrigued me and led me through anxiously anticipating what was to follow for the majority of this book.

I was very close to rating this 4 stars, however, it took me a while to get into it and it did feel slower at some points. But overall, I did enjoy it and would recommend it!

Took me a while to instant what was going on, but that was worth it. The gradual disclosure of the plot keeps you motoring along through the pages, as you piece together the personalities that Jake, the chronicler-cum-narrator, finds and arranges. The antagonist is a horror but somehow is relatable as her love story takes shape.

Yes! I loved this book so much! This had all the feels to keep you awake at night! I don’t get scared easily but this made sleeping a little harder! I couldn’t love this more! I highly recommend this book… can’t wait to read more from this author! Brilliant!

I don't think I will ever be able to forget this novel. I will be haunted by it until my dying day.

Beautifully written, evocative descriptions and a plot to terrify the life out of you. Absolutely phenomenal.

I said in a recent review that horror’s back, and this is more evidence that the genre is enjoying an upswing. It’s a well written, multi-voiced account of a centuries old evil. There’s shades of Lovecraftian cosmic horror, a radically fresh take on vampire mythology, gore in the right places and tenderness in others, and a compulsive storyline that kept me reading and reading. Hands down the best horror novel I’ve read in ages, and one of my books of the year.

I don’t know how to feel about this one. I thought the writing was great and I thought the characters were well fleshed out, especially Jake. That being said I don’t think there were as many horror vibes as I would like and I found the book too slow. An interesting plot that I don’t think was executed to its full potential.

This novel takes an unusual approach to horror, blending a literary style with subtle but eerie moments that sneak up on you. The absence of a main character gives the story a unique structure, and the villain’s gradual appearances add a creeping tension. Themes like love and humanity are woven into the unsettling narrative, creating a haunting depth. Although the middle dragged a bit, the strong start and finish kept me hooked.

I don't know what to make of this book.
It's very well written & full of intricate stories but I just don't think it was for me. Some readers will adore this book but it was to slow for me.

I still have goosebumps.

Horror story. There is no happy endings, there are some mits, old stories that come to life to haunt us.
Promise, I would never look on Venus the same way.

I like the mystery here, the secrets, the temptation and the need to be something extraordinary.
I like the vibe, the way this book is structured and how we, as a readers, are entertained.
and following the path, page by page, was amazing experience even though I was genuinely scared sometimes.

Old Soul is a dark and gripping story that weaves together elements of mystery, gothic thriller, and supernatural horror. The book begins with a chance meeting between two grieving strangers at Osaka airport—Jake, who is haunted by the death of his best friend a decade earlier, and Mariko, mourning her twin brother’s recent brutal and unexplained death. Though their losses occurred 6,000 miles apart, both victims shared an eerie common thread: an encounter with a mysterious, dark-haired woman in the days leading up to their deaths.

As Jake delves deeper into Mariko's revelations, he uncovers a disturbing pattern. The same ageless woman, who vanishes just as quickly as she appears, has left a trail of death and devastation across continents and centuries. Those she leaves behind are left bewildered and disbelieved, but they are certain of what they saw. Jake becomes obsessed with understanding who—or what—this woman is and how she chooses her victims. The closer he gets to the truth, the more the book grips you with its chilling and suspenseful atmosphere.

One of the standout storylines involves Theo, a sculptor whose tragic connection to the enigmatic woman raises poignant questions about love and sacrifice. Can you truly love someone if you’re willing to destroy aspects of their future to preserve your own?

Old Soul unfolds with a slow, deliberate pace that might feel like a ghost story or gothic thriller, but if you allow yourself to immerse in its intricacies, you'll be rewarded with an unforgettable experience. The writing is atmospheric and haunting, and the climax will leave you wanting to scream into the void—in the best way possible for a book of this genre.

The epilogue, perhaps the creepiest part of the entire book, takes on an almost dark fantasy tone, leaving a lasting impression that feels distinct from the rest of the story. It's a perfect, unsettling close to a story filled with tension and foreboding.

For fans of haunting, slow-burn horror, Old Soul is an absolute gem.

Read more at The Secret Bookreview.

An unsettling and truly gothic-esque horror book that will leave you feeling creeped out.
It's a weird book, in a good way, and a fun read for horror fans.

Well, this was excellent.

A lovely, creepy, supernatural concept centred around a delicious female villain, spanning a wide time period.

The antagonist, who goes by many names, but I'll use "E" as it's the one that comes to mind, is central to the success of the story. She is a frightening character, and a conduit for something even more frightening, but she also has depth, and the reader understands her motivations, even if she is repulsive in many ways.

The story is told through a series of tales relating to E's victims across the decades, with some of these sections more stand-out than others. The author expertly drip-feeds more information about the mysterious E as the novel continues, and I was satisfied with the answers provided towards the end.

The ending wasn't quite what I wanted, but it didn't take away from the overall quality.

My main gripe with the book is the lack of speech marks around dialogue. I find this constantly frustrating in modern novels and as ever, it caused some confusion over who was speaking at various points.

But overall, I greatly enjoyed this; it was a cracking, creepy thriller.

Having just missed their flight from Japan, Jake and another passenger, Mariko, share dinner and a few drinks. With her guard down Mariko tells Jake about the last few weeks of her late bother’s life. It’s an unsettling and inexplicable tale which completely horrifies Jake, all the more so since it sounds exactly like the last few weeks of his friend Lena’s life, and seems to involve an appearance by the same, weirdly captivating, woman.

Determined to find out how such an aberration can be anything but singular, Jake starts to follow the few slender threads available to him.

And we’ll leave the plot there…

I must confess, I’m not generally a horror reader, and this book is certainly horror-adjacent, though it is a truly multifaceted novel.

Old Soul has a fascinating premise, one which is brilliantly utilised by Barker to explore the complexity of human nature, with its dichotomies of love and ambivalence, and its drive for self preservation.

The book is a masterclass in how to structure, pace, and maintain momentum within a rich multi-layered, multi-character story. Revelations are delivered across the split narrative and timelines with expert timing; you are always learning more, and there’s always more to learn. We rarely get ahead of the characters, which is a really effective way to keep us in a state of fear and trepidation: we share their dread and stupefaction.

When a book has such a high concept behind it, the cynic in me is always wondering when it will run out of steam, unable to sustain the idea beyond the first few chapters. No such worries here. Old Souls is so well written, so confidently executed, populated with memorable and convincing characters. Barker stokes the mood of malignancy throughout, delivering an affecting and consistent conclusion.

This book gave me nightmares, and I quickly added Barker’s previous novel The Incarnations to my wish-list. It sounds equally ambitious and compelling .

It’s giving Addie Larue vibes but with more of a horror aspect. This book was incredibly weird, not in a bad way but not necessarily good either. I will say the author is not afraid of a harsh ending.

OLD SOUL is a provocative and stunning novel, lush and atmospheric writing. It is transporting with gothic and horror undertones.

https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/6836285018

Could not put this down. Super creepy, atmospheric horror that genuinely left me slightly scared to switch off the light at night, and a cracking plot as well. A very solid 4.5 stars and would have been five were it not for a tiny bit of disappointment over the ending. But overall brilliant and thanks to the author, publisher and NetGalley for the ARC.

Despite my best intentions, I could not get into this book. Apologies for not finishing. Thank you for the opportunity though.