Sarah Dunnakey’s The Twelve Murders of Christmas offers an interesting concept with its tale-within-a-tale structure, blending a modern story with a classic holiday mystery. While the idea is engaging, the execution falls a bit short.

The dual narratives allow for some clever connections, and Dunnakey keeps readers guessing with her clues and twists. However, pacing issues and underdeveloped characters can make it hard to fully invest in the story. The characters are likable but often feel clichéd.

Dunnakey’s writing is light and fits the holiday mood, but the tension sometimes fades, leaving deeper themes unexplored. While the ending is satisfying, it doesn’t have the impact that could elevate the story.

Overall, The Twelve Murders of Christmas is a fun, cozy read for those looking for a festive mystery. It has its flaws, but it’s a decent seasonal distraction that won’t leave a lasting impression. If you enjoy light mysteries, it might be worth picking up!

Thank you to NetGalley for this ARC in exchange for an honest review.

This is a really fun book that's perfect for the Christmas holiday period. If you're dreading a tedious week of claustrophobia with your fractious family then this will ease the tension.

It's an atmospheric, traditional murder mystery story but with 'goose egg' puzzles in each chapter and puzzles at the end of the chapters. I found some of them utterly perplexing and entirely impossible whereas others were easier for me but still challenging and fun. It's a joyful book and an ideal gift or an emergency boredom break-glass for yourself.

I loved the concept of the puzzles coming together to give the final solution. The writing style works too and it's witty and sharp.