Gilmore girls meets practical magic! An absolute must read this fall season! I loved every character and the charming townsfolk. Such a fun and cozy read that should be on every fall lovers to read list!

Think pumpkin spice lattes + witches + beautiful autumn setting all in one book--you'd get this book. It was just as cliche and heartwarming as a starbucks PSL and I wasn't mad at it-you come in knowing what you want and you get it.

Impractical Magic is about 3 sisters in the enchanted town of Oak Haven, which is full of magic and witches. Main character and middle sister Scarlett is brought back to the town from San Francisco when the magic in the little town is going haywire. Scarlett had been gone for 10 years because of mistakes she made and has to face both the current problems and her own problems when she comes back.

The setting was so cute, lots of little magic bookstores, hardware stores, a magical inn, pumpkins, pretty leaves, etc etc. It made me super excited for fall to start and to do all the related activities. The magical inn that Scarlett's family owns was really entertaining as it brought in quirky guests and kept doing randomly funny things because of the haywire magic.

Unfortunately, the book felt super slow and the main character was really annoying. She spent the entire book going "its all my fault that ___ and I suck at magic!!" and the whining got very old very fast. She had almost no character development and was insufferable to read about. The other characters felt very flat and either pandered to her whining or yelled at her, making it worse. The plot progressed extremely slowly and was mostly Scarlett going around town to various magical businesses and talking to the owners.

Minor spoilers but it was quite funny when Scarlett was chasing this bad guy with her sister and they have an intermission mid-chase to eat at a Las Vegas buffet. It made no sense considering the situation and the gravity of catching up to the person but made me laugh.

So, is this book the best fall book this year? No. Is it a fun time and has all the fall vibes? Yes. Just don't go into it with a ton of expectations past context and you'll have a great time.

Thank you to NetGalley + Avon Books for this ARC!

Fun, whimsical and cozy - just what I needed to start the autumnal season! 🍂🍄🔮

Blurb:
When Scarlett Melrose receives a call from her estranged sisters, she immediately knows something is wrong. The magic at their mother’s inn – and in fact, the whole of Oak Haven – has gone awry, and they need her help to save it.

As the conflicted middle-child, returning home has given Scarlett the heebie jeebies. And to make matters worse, she’s just come face-to-face with charming old flame and handyman, Nate.

When her spell to fix the magic goes horribly wrong, all Scarlett wants to do is flee back to the peace and quiet of her San Francisco flat. But she can’t keep running away forever, and she’ll need all the help she can to solve this magical mess.

Sadly I didn’t love this. I found Scarlett hard to connect with and since the whole story centered around her it made it hard to enjoy the book! I didn’t get invested in the sisters and their family dynamic. The author did do a wonderful job of world building and describing the town of Oak Haven though. It delivered completely on the cozy fall vibes reminiscent of Gilmore Girls. Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for my ARC.

Thank you so much to Net Galley and the Impractical Magic team for the opportunity to read this ARC. I really thought I would love this book. I love Gilmore Girls, Charmed and the tropes advertised and really wanted to get those cozy Autumn vibes.

I think the book had potential, but it fell flat for me and I have had to DNF it at 45%. It takes me a lot to do that, but I just found the family dynamic really quite toxic, the miscommunication with Nate annoying and didn’t feel like I had enough to connect with the FMC. The constant pop culture references completely take you out of the world and story, particularly references to Harry Potter and “muggles”.

I really like the concept of the book and think the story has a lot of potential. But I just couldn’t connect with the characters and didn’t feel immersed enough in the world.


I am so sorry, but this just wasn’t a good fit for me on this occasion.

I enjoyed the vibes of this book… cozy, magical, and like a warm fall hug. However, I didn’t fall in love in with the characters as much as I hoped that I would. Definitely a solid fall read.

“Impractical Magic” is a charming, simply magical story great for the autumn season. Scarlett returns home to her small town to help save it from the magic that’s gone haywire. This story has many themes in common with Gilmore girls. It’s cute and easy to read, very light-hearted. The romance was friends-to-lovers and second chance, it felt under-developed without much of the backstory. The family dynamics were fun and I enjoyed the magical elements.

Many thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for the opportunity to read this ARC.

I enjoyed this! Very good for the forthcoming autumnal season. Very easy to digest, fun magical characters, and interesting twists and turns.

I love the family and how they all have these very distinct personalities and seeing how they all work with each other. Also love the town itself and how I could picture it so easily, and just evokes a proper cosy, hot chocolate in the fall, Connecticut town vibe. The romance was nice, a bit of will-they-won't-they, which is always good. My favourite detail was probably about all the Earls and their history as I thought that was very original and funny.

I'm only giving this 3.5 because although I enjoyed it, I don't think I'll remember it. A lot of it is very surface level - easy to digest which is nice, but also just fine, not amazing. Just a classic easy read.

Thank you to Netgalley and Avon books for a free review eArc in exchange for an honest review.

As a lover of all things fall, witchy, and Gilmore Girls, I was absolutely thrilled when I received this eARC. And though this book certainly doesn’t disappoint in terms of its witchy, cozy vibes, it reads like an initial draft rather than a final product.

I really found myself struggling to connect with the FMC, Scarlett, who spent the majority of the book struggling with the guilt of her father’s death. When the time finally came to address/discuss said guilt, it felt very rushed and entirely unimportant.

In terms of the plot itself, it was a bit of slow start that picked up as the chaos in Oak Haven grew out of control. I was enamored with the concept of Oak Haven, the witches channeling their power from grove, and the infamous “forgetting spell.” I would have loved more world-building and a cleaner ending. I’m still confused as to who the “bosses” are.

That being said, overall, I enjoyed Scarlett’s growth both as a person and witch, as well as her romance with Nate. I also absolutely loved all the pop culture references sprinkled throughout the book.

A fun cosy small town romance read that is perfect for Autumn. I loved it. The chemistry between Scarlett and Nate was fantastic.
Thanks to the publishers and Netgalley for the eARC.

The description of Gilmore Girls meets Charmed was completely spot on for this book. The setting is enchanting; truly the town is described in the most endearing, idyllic way (despite everything going wrong in it!). Kudos also to the author who was super creative with the store names. The descriptions of places and events were solid - enough to give you a good visual picture but not enough to bog down any pacing (the pacing was pretty good). The magic system was both simple and unique, although that is an area where I would have welcomed more details on how it possibly varied (or not). I adored the MMC Nate and his unwavering love for the FMC Scarlet.

Despite some very strong things going for it, this book missed on a few fronts. The mystery was light and fun (which I can easily enjoy in novels), but everything in the town kept going wrong and wrong and wrong. Which is not my favorite trope. More importantly, the utter toxicity of the familial relationship between the mom and (also amongst) the siblings was hard to stomach. It was the toxic that appears in snipes and small morsels, that creeps up innocuously and permeates the entire situation. It frustrated me to no end; if that is what the author was going for - cementing in the reason for Scarlet’s self-hatred and complete lack of confidence - then she nailed it. It just was consistent, constant, and I did not enjoy that aspect. Scarlet believing every criticism down to her core and convincing herself that she did not deserve anything good was also not enjoyable. Her growth came a little abrupt. I do hope that readers suffering from the same toxic type of situation can read and objectively see how others’ words can affect someone’s self-esteem. For that would make this storyline arc worth it. But to me, unfortunately it kept me enjoying the book as much as I wanted.

Thank you to NetGalley and Avon Books UK for this ARC one change for my honest opinion

Thank you to Avon Books UK and NetGalley for the ARC of Impractical Magic in exchange for an honest and independent review.

While this book has all the feels and makings of the quintessential autumn read, there are also parts that I really struggled to make sense of or maybe went a bit too far in the context of what was necessary to the storyline.

To start, the idea of the town of Oak Haven itself is actually really interesting. The fact that it is run by witches and anyone passing through who is a non-witch will eventually forget about it's existence (even the men that live within its boundaries) was a unique plot twist that I haven't encountered before. This idea creates a very interesting dynamic when attempting to solve some of the mysteries currently plaguing Oak Haven. Emily also created a very interesting origin story when it came to how the town of Oak Haven came to be and filled that town full of very intriguing characters.

However, it was with the main character and her family where I took the most issue. This is obviously my own personal opinion, but I really could not stand the main character, Scarlett Melrose. You learn that Scarlett has been absent from Oak Haven for the last 10 years after she suffered a huge magical mix up, which she believes resulted in the loss of her father. Upon returning to town after 10 years at the request of her sister, Scarlett spends the entire book blaming herself for everything that is going wrong (now and in the past) and is continually playing the martyr. After the first 100 pages of "woe is me," I found it difficult to handle anymore of it. Eventually you just want to shake her and tell her to shut up, accept what happened, and grow from it. Unfortunately, she just ends up living in a pit of self-deprecation and pity for almost the entire book. The only thing potentially worse than the main character's outlook is the way her mother and two sisters openly treat her. Honestly, they are awful to her and talk down to her the entire time. Why ask her to return if you're just going to rip her apart the entire time? I immediately thought to myself, no wonder she's stayed away for 10 years with family like this to look forward to.

Lastly, her hot and cold relationship with her hometown love interest, Nate, also drove me over the edge. You're either in it or your not. I hated that one minute she was going to end it with him and the next she was considering a future with him. I was getting emotional whiplash by the end of the book and I just wanted to tell Nate to run in the opposite direction and cut his losses now.

I think the overarching storyline had all the potential for a great book, but in all honesty, the main characters ruined it for me. There were points where I just didn't want to finish it, but it's almost against my religion to give up in the middle of a book. I had to see it through, and I'm glad that I did because I did find the end of the book very interesting, all be it rather rushed. There were some great high points in this one, but there were some big lows for me that I just couldn't get past, which is unfortunate. I think this book has all the potential to be really great, but I'd essentially want to overhaul the FMC and her family in order to do so. Am I wrong here? Let me know if you've read this one as well. Curious to hear your take on it.

I thought this book was a perfect book as we transition into autumn. However, there was something about Scarlett that really started to bug me. In addition, I feel like the romance aspect could be emphasized more, it felt kind of like a subplot? However the romance between Scarlett & Nate was cute for what I did see. 3 stars for me

If you’re a big fan of fall or seasonal romance, you’ll like this one! It has alllll the Gilmore girl, autumn cozy vibes. I think witchy, magical novels are hard to do. But this wasn’t a bad one!

Oh I LOVED this!

A must read if you love Practical Magic and Gilmore Girls.

It's the perfect Autumnal read.

Grumpy sunshine tropes, lots of magic, lots of autumn vibes.

I just completely got lost in the story and it was the pure escapism that I crave when reading.

THANK YOU to Netgalley and the Publishers for letting me read this before publication.

All you Autumn / Fall loving girlies, please read this asap!

Thank you Avon Books UK, NetGalley and Emily Grimoire for this eARC

I rated this 2.5 stars, the story was heartwarming and I enjoyed the last half much more than the first half.
I do have a few issues though.
1. I felt like the 28 year old FMC and her sisters all spoke like they were 15
2. The MMC was only given a few descriptive words, he seemed very one dimensional and only there to serve the purpose of awkward side character.
3. Without giving much away, a certain character at the end completely 180 degree personality turned, just for the purpose of a happy ending.


Things I did enjoy.
1. Night at the Museum type fun spell errors
2. I liked seeing the trans representation done nicely.

Impractical Magic was a sweet, lighthearted, cozy read that’s perfect for the fall! Our main character Scarlett returns to her magical hometown to help her family find and fix whatever is affecting the source of all their magical power. This is a perfect, inclusive read for lovers of Gilmore Girls and Halloweentown! Readers should pick this up when they’re looking for a sweet, fast paced story with a Luke Danes-esque love interest to snuggle up on the couch in a flannel and a mug of tea. Thank you for the opportunity to receive and read this ARC!

Ok so I really enjoyed this book. It was fun and lighthearted and a perfect cosy autumnal read.

Scarlett has come back to her home town after a self imposed exile for 10 years, when she is requested back by her sisters to help save the town after all the magic has turned into chaos. Scarlett plans to leave as soon as this mess is cleaned up, but in the process she has to face things from her past which have stopped her from returning for all this time.

This book includes a slow burn, second-chance romance that kinda felt like a side story to the main plot. I would have liked more of this romance story line as I was left wanting extra detail about this, especially their relationship before Scarlett left as it’s mentioned a lot but not delved into. Nate makes for a super interesting character and the storyline between them flowed really nicely, I just wanted to read more of it and to really explore their connection and what keeps drawing these two together, time after time.

Also, the town of Oak Haven was perfectly cosy and enchanting, I wished to be there along with the characters. The description and world building was something I really enjoyed about this book!! It’s just a lovely witchy super enjoyable read that I devoured super quickly!

Thank you NetGalley, the publisher, and the author for an advanced copy of Impractical Magic!

I had a lot of trouble getting into this book. Our main character, Scarlett returns home to Oak Haven after 10 years. The sister that asked her to come home spends basically the entire first part of the book making fun of Scarlett and berating her for leaving. The family dynamic really just confused and irritated me. There was little to no explanation as to why her family treated Scarlett the way they do throughout the whole book.

Also, the references to “muggles” really took me out of the book. The Harry Potter (and general pop culture) references made it hard to stay focused on the book. They didn’t really add a lot to the book and felt more like filler than anything. If you enjoy that type of writing/humor, this is definitely the book for you, but it definitely was not my cup of tea.

Overall, this book was “cozy” in the sense that it was set in autumn, but the plot felt like it was meandering in all directions. There was something was missing from this book that made it hard to enjoy and fully immerse yourself into.

This really is for fans of Gilmore Girls and Charmed and I couldn't put it down. It's the person returning-home cosy, witchy book for autumn and is a lot of fun.

I really enjoyed the explanations of different types of magic, as well as the family dynamics. The romance angle was a bit predictable and I think it could have had more fire to it but it was cute - any guy who waits 10 years for someone deserves a happy ending.

The magician aspect was interesting too and I hope that it's going to be looked into more in a sequel. I'd love a book for each of the sisters as they're all such strong but different characters.

If you enjoyed The Witches of Thistle Grove series, Hex Appeal and The Ex Hex, this should be your next read.